TL;DR; Even though the dataset may be ready, you still need supporting consumer ready apps to use it.
(Originally posted this as a separate comment, but it is pretty relevant to this).
I agree that geocoding has been a problem for OSM, especially for building numbers, where the data often isn't there. But on the software side there seems to be progress recently, for instance, here are two open-source geocoders released in the last few months:
Photon, made by Komoot: https://github.com/komoot/photon, used in production at http://www.komoot.de/suggest/?&hl=en
Pelias, made by Mapzen: http://stateofthemap.us/session/pelias/, live demo at http://mapzen.com/pelias/
On building numbers, we need geocoders which can interpolate between sparse data, and then use that system to highlight where the gaps are. People tend to add data to OSM when they're confident that it's actually being used, to its full extent. If there are a hundred buildings along a road, in theory you don't need to add many of them before you can get a very good idea of where an address might be.
As you are saying, assistance from a mapping service need not be binary, just add some extra information and communicate cleanly the probability of result.
It's not perfect but it doesn't seem like a map based solely on map data is going to be able to compete with one that has all of the internet behind it.
Google can find me places of interest, without an exact name or address. That's my most common use case when using navigation on my mobile device.
That's a huge and under-appreciated advantage for Google's mobile apps and services.
Let's hope the increased use of the incredibly detailed and free OSM data will one day lead to better applications that make use of it. User experience comes first.
http://tools.geofabrik.de/mc/#14/52.5147/13.3899&num=4&mt0=m...
i really hope this changes soon and the UI/apps catch up to the greatness that is OSM.
edit: i have an iphone and although i live in canada i still use the german appstore (CC requirement).
that's why i can't comment on the app the original post was about as it's only available in the US store. it was more of a general remark about my frustration with the state of apps using the osm dataset. I want to get rid of google maps and I feel the maps part of osm would be ready for that. I can tolerate if the commercial store data is not as up2date. But if the general usuability suffers, i rather opt for gmaps.