News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by WoodenChair on Thursday May 08, 2014 @06:47PM (#7718196)
etoileos - last news update 2012 and wasn't even about the project

fluxbox - active and kind've interesting

awesome - more of just a WM than full DE

ratpoison - ditto

enlightenment - okay, kind've resembles Win 95 too... but more of a DE than the others you listed

windowmaker - been around forever; hasn't really "innovated" in forever; just a NeXT clone if I remember correctly for GNUStep

I think my point stands. I was talking about LXDE, Xfce, and RazorQT.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by scythe on Thursday May 08, 2014 @08:35PM (#7718637)
>windowmaker - been around forever; hasn't really "innovated" in forever; just a NeXT clone if I remember correctly for GNUStep

>enlightenment - okay, kind've resembles Win 95 too... but more of a DE than the others you listed

> etoileos - last news update 2012 and wasn't even about the project

What you seem to be missing is that these projects died because people thought they were weird, which is to say, innovation in the DE space pays negative rent, and that's no good, especially not from the perspective of an open-source project, which, the social dynamics of open-source dictate that projects need to acquire a large userbase to sustain an active development community for more than a couple years, that is to say, to make people keep working on it after the "new project smell" wears off.

In other words your observation is a direct consequence of the choices in DE that users have made and continue to make.

The recent trend has been towards modularity, and while you dismiss awesome and ratpoison, a major boon of LXDE et al is that, unlike Windows 95, you can replace the window manager with xmonad and still use all of the other components of LXDE. Modularity brings innovation to the people who want it while satisfying the large majority of users who apparently do not.

There's no reason for LXDE to ship anything but Openbox; LXDE could certainly switch to xmonad tomorrow, but their users wouldn't be happy. And who wants that?

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by dredmorbius on Thursday May 08, 2014 @09:06PM (#7718746)
these projects died because people thought they were weird

Actually, at least two of those (E and WindowMaker) remain alive. And WindowMaker's got its fervent fans (you're hearing from one here).

While Raster's continued to plink away at Enlightenment, among the reasons WindowMaker development's been so modest is that it accomplished its mission: provide an implementation of the NexTstep interface. I use wmaker without most of the rest of the GNUstep tools (I find them kind of funky and cumbersome), but the window manager itself is simple, straightforward, and rocks.

It's also very similar under the hood to Aqua as used now in OS X, which for the most part just skins it differently and removes a bunch of features I like -- so while I love wmaker, I really can't function on Macs.

As for userbase. Yeah. I'm aware that I'm in the minority. I'm totally OK with that.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by 2muchcoffeeman on Thursday May 08, 2014 @11:16PM (#7719131)
window maker was pretty great. I wish they kept going with it. It's still one of the best window managers I've ever used.
Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by ttflee on Friday May 09, 2014 @01:43AM (#7719551)
I love Window Maker and hope its development will go on, however, its lack of features really hurts, if you are an Asian language user and have an enthusiastic taste for typeface rendering. It is not a problem for Window Maker alone, but also problems in many other WMs that do not rely on a heavy and frequently maintained toolkit, i.e. GTK or Qt, as perfectly supporting font rendering and i18n has never been a simple job.

BTW, putting off window manager/desktop environment philosophy arguments, Input Method Engine is one of those constantly neglected aspects that really matter for East Asian users. It seems that the ones making plans for WM/DE and other infrastructure had little overlap with users, and their designing decisions were very likely to omit the requirements necessary to cooperate with IMEs.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by dredmorbius on Friday May 09, 2014 @06:28PM (#7723591)
I thought that font support was among the few changes which have been made in the past decade, though the most recent update affecting fonts was 11 May, 2005, adding gsfonts-x11.

I'm not enough of a dev to know what would be required, but pitching this to the developer(s) might be helpful.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by dredmorbius on Thursday May 08, 2014 @11:57PM (#7719262)
As I said: you can still get it. It's packages with most distros (I'm running it on Debian).

The only thing that's not happening is a whole lot of development. And I'm actually totally OK with that.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by astrobe_ on Friday May 09, 2014 @05:44AM (#7720074)
Funny, ScytheWM was one of those obscure and relatively innovative WM, with its single, larger than the screen virtual desktop. Related?
Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by girvo on Thursday May 08, 2014 @08:13PM (#7718560)
etioleos actually does have some stuff happening, if you go and look at the mailing list :)
Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by voltagex_ on Thursday May 08, 2014 @08:35PM (#7718635)
I really really think these projects need to have an automated notification to the devs to update their news page, or even automagically post a digest of mailing list activity. Lots of projects I've thought were dead have had lots of stuff going on behind the scenes.
Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by astrobe_ on Friday May 09, 2014 @05:47AM (#7720081)
> etioleos

dat Typo. "étiolé"= withered in French.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by panzi on Thursday May 08, 2014 @06:55PM (#7718237)
Well, Window Maker is basically a NeXTSTEP clone. If there is innovation it was done by NeXT in the late 80ies/early 90ies. So even an older concept than Windows 95.
Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by theGimp on Thursday May 08, 2014 @09:35PM (#7718837)
Funny, I've been looking for something like ratpoison for a while, and though the name seems familiar, I had never tried it before.

I'm using it now... I think my search is over :)

Thank you!

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by tomorokoshi on Friday May 09, 2014 @12:11AM (#7719312)
You might also like i3. I tried many tiling window managers, and i3 is my favorite. Its "manual tiling" works well with my brain.

Also see this comparison of tiling WMs: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Comparison_of_Tiling_Wi...

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by theGimp on Friday May 09, 2014 @02:47AM (#7719687)
Thank you very much for your suggestion. I will try i3 in a few days -- once I know what ratpoison's and StumpWM's annoyances and strengths are.

Update: I lied. i3 looked too good to wait for so I tried it, and it feels a lot more natural. I'm quite certain this will be it!

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by pyre on Thursday May 08, 2014 @09:48PM (#7718879)
Take a look at StumpWM. IIRC it's done by the author of ratpoison.

Bonus: If you're an Emacs user the interface/keyboard shortcuts should make you feel at home (or so I've heard).

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by 616c on Friday May 09, 2014 @03:10AM (#7719745)
Got into StumpWM about two months ago after living in tmux and emacsclient all day. Now I have a super minimalist desktop, all the key shortcuts I need (and mouse like I need, where as ratposion makes it a little too difficult), on the fly restart and command reload, Lisp, and oh my god so much flexibility.

Before that, I used XFCE. I have realized there is always another level of minimalism down from where you were before in Linux, until you hit the Linux console. But I love StumpWM. They might say it is not minimalist, but it is for me and it rocks my world.

I am going to hit submit and then hit a shortcut to open running term emulator and find my running mutt instance in tmux. Later full DE users.

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by theGimp on Thursday May 08, 2014 @11:12PM (#7719122)
I am overjoyed. Thank you :)

I've set a reminder to switch to StumpWM 2 days from now.

Emacs is something I've never tried though Lisp is amazing and that's reason enough to use it.

So many fun toys, so little time...

Re:LXQt – The next generation of the Lightweight Desktop Env... by andrewstuart on Thursday May 08, 2014 @09:43PM (#7718863)
They all look clunky and unrefined.