Also see this comparison of tiling WMs: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Comparison_of_Tiling_Wi...
Update: I lied. i3 looked too good to wait for so I tried it, and it feels a lot more natural. I'm quite certain this will be it!
Bonus: If you're an Emacs user the interface/keyboard shortcuts should make you feel at home (or so I've heard).
Before that, I used XFCE. I have realized there is always another level of minimalism down from where you were before in Linux, until you hit the Linux console. But I love StumpWM. They might say it is not minimalist, but it is for me and it rocks my world.
I am going to hit submit and then hit a shortcut to open running term emulator and find my running mutt instance in tmux. Later full DE users.
I've set a reminder to switch to StumpWM 2 days from now.
Emacs is something I've never tried though Lisp is amazing and that's reason enough to use it.
So many fun toys, so little time...
I'm using it now... I think my search is over :)
Thank you!