As a consumer, I don't like getting fucked by the spread on exchange rates on the buy AND sell sides when I try to pay in bitcoin. Want to buy some bitcoin? Unless you're doing it face-to-face you're going to get jacked a few percent. Want to spend them? Unless it's at a bitcoin-only merchant, jacked again.
Add in the fact that I'm not getting whatever points my credit card would have given me, that I've got absolutely no recourse against the merchant, and that I have to worry about hackers stealing my money... there's no reason for me to use it.
There is no easy way for me to transfer money to a friend other than handing them cash. You might suggest an awful centralized service like PayPal but there are plenty of problems with them too. What if I want to send money to a friend who lives in another country? Even harder. Bitcoin solves this problem.
In addition, if you are holding bitcoins with the expectation that they will actually appreciate (i.e. the currency will deflate rather than inflate) you are effectively losing money by spending it, further discouraging you from engaging in the transaction.
Krugman has enjoyed making this point a few times:
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/12/28/bitcoin-is-evil/
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/09/07/golden-cyberfett...
If someone gets access to your bitcoin wallet or whatever storage mechanism you are using fails, then that money is gone forever with no way to recover it.
If you are a regular user with no need to make a political statement with the use of a non-traditional currency, what exactly about the second scenario sounds safer?
Keep in mind that you're comparing two different markets in terms of maturity. One day, there may be a number I can call too when my bitcoin goes missing.
I'm sure people made similar arguments before e-commerce. Surely it had to seem easier to just buy a product in a physical store, with cash, with absolutely no risk of stolen credit card information on this new thing known as Internet. No issues with shipping and you can actually see the product in store. Things have changed and people are no longer as reluctant to shop online.
As interest in new areas grow, so do opportunities for business. You may not be an early adopter of Bitcoin in the way many weren't with e-commerce in the early days, but it doesn't mean it can't happen because one is easier today.
Why would I even need such infrastructure if I can already do that today with my bank?
Genuinely curious--how would this work?
There may also be bounty hunters who try to recover stolen BTC on contingency, but that doesn't sound like a good business.
You're arguing against cash, cash doesn't need defending.
Insert Mt.Gox joke here.
One would think businesses would really like this and promote it.
To me, this is one of the biggest problems with adoption--bitcoin doesn't offer much benefit to the typical consumer for mundane transactions.
I'm about to buy a coffee machine on Overstock.com. There's no practical reason that bitcoins are better than what I'm going to do which is put it on my mastercard. And there's a lot of reasons that getting my money into bitcoin in the first place is a giant pain in the ass.
Yeah, there are some potential situations that could change this, and if I lived in a country with massive inflation I might feel differently, but as it stands, I don't see any compelling reason to use bitcoin to make purchases.