News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by merrua on Thursday April 17, 2014 @08:25AM (#7603135)
Pretty fair that they blocked it. Its basically an unregulated taxi service. Also the name is terrible for Germany.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by travisp on Thursday April 17, 2014 @08:32AM (#7603158)
It's worth noting that in this context as far as I can tell, Uber's drivers and cars were regulated and licensed. They are allowed to drive limos for hire, but the law requires them to return to their place of business after a job (they aren't allowed to keep cars sitting around to pick up passengers). The google translation of the main complaint by the taxi association is "they keep taxe similar primarily in downtown ready to spontaneously pick up passengers." In other words, they don't wait to receive a call to get a car close and available to their passengers.

So, while it's true that this is probably against the laws of the city, it's hard to see it as anything other than protectionism for taxis: there's no evidence that Uber was causing harm for passengers (or else they'd be talking about this), and there's no reason to believe that making a limo service return its cars to its place of business after each job is inherently better for consumers.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by Xylakant on Thursday April 17, 2014 @08:49AM (#7603228)
In this context it's important to note that it's not a city law. Übers drivers violate the Personenbeförderungsgesetz which is a federal law. The injunction might have happened in all german cities, but this specific case seems to be about Berlin only.

Most specifically Uber violates §49 ("Verkehr mit Mietomnibussen und mit Mietwagen"), Satz (4) which makes a very clear and distinct case that rental limousines must avoid confusion with Taxis. " Annahme, Vermittlung und Ausführung von Beförderungsaufträgen, das Bereithalten des Mietwagens sowie Werbung für Mietwagenverkehr dürfen weder allein noch in ihrer Verbindung geeignet sein, zur Verwechslung mit dem Taxenverkehr zu führen."

The regulations concerning limos for hire are far lower than the regulations concerning cabs, most notably limos for hire are exempt from §21 (Betriebspflicht) and §22 (Beförderungspflicht). Basically cabs have to accept any customer and the law demands that they keep on providing (and even expanding) their service as deemed necessary by the city. It's like saying "oh, regular cars are regulated as well".

The cabs in germany are regulated as part of the public transport. Uber tries to skirt that regulation and reap the benefits, while undermining the system - and by doing that they create damage to the consumers. Even if you assume there's no damage to the consumer it's not Uber that gets to decide which law applies and which needs disruption. I could think of a couple of laws that I think need disruption in my line of work (tax law, for example) but I don't get to choose either.

http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/pbefg/__49.html

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by vvvv on Thursday April 17, 2014 @10:25AM (#7603725)
I completely agree with you. As Uber gets more popular, there's statistically more likelihood for assaults and rapes to happen (it does happen in some countries where taxi services are less regulated). What collateral would a distributed service like Uber have if one or more drivers turned out to be harmful to consumers?
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by smackfu on Thursday April 17, 2014 @09:15AM (#7603332)
It's interesting that Uber managed to get licensed drivers to ignore the rules of their license.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by Xylakant on Thursday April 17, 2014 @09:22AM (#7603364)
I just had a look at the uber registration page. I don't think you need any kind of license, at least not for UberPop. The only requirements listed are your own car, age 21, a drivers license and that you're out of the probation period for the license.

Cab and Limo drivers at least need a Personenbeförderungsschein, but I'm not certain that UberBlack requires that, the wording is unclear ("gewerbliche Zulassung" relates more to tax and business registration for which the Personenbeförderungsschein might be a requirement or not)

https://partners.uber.com/signup/berlin/

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by arrrg on Thursday April 17, 2014 @01:41PM (#7605047)
Yeah, seems like a pretty clear-cut violation of the law. You can’t do that. If you think the law sucks then you have to lobby for change, not just violate the law.

Also, it’s not like Uber (absolutely terrible name in Germany) offers any advantages over, say, mytaxi (ordering the car with an app, paying with an app), besides maybe price. (And since mytaxi works within the confines of the existing taxi system they can’t really change anything about the price.)

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @03:32PM (#7605790)
God forbid we have transportation services not beholden to arbitrary regulations built in favor of the existing taxi industry.

People use Über because it's better than any regulated taxi service. That is direct, incontrovertible proof that the existing taxi regulations are hurting innovation.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EpicEng on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:45PM (#7606200)
Regardless of whether or not you are correct in your assertion that these regulations are arbitrary and exist only to benefit existing taxi companies (which, of course, disagrees with your former claim...), you don't get to break the law because you disagree with it.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:06PM (#7606351)
> you don't get to break the law because you disagree with it.

So I guess MLK should have just accepted the current state of affairs, and Anne Frank should have just turned herself in?

The law is not some ultimate moral authority.

>these regulations are arbitrary and exist only to benefit existing taxi companies (which, of course, disagrees with your former claim...),

"Arbitrary" doesn't just mean "random". It also means "based on whim". There is no contradiction.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EpicEng on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:35PM (#7606565)
>So I guess MLK should have just accepted the current state of affairs, and Anne Frank should have just turned herself in?

Comparing the civil rights movement to taxi regulations is ridiculous. If that's the best you can do it should tell you a lot about the strength of your argument.

>"Arbitrary" doesn't just mean "random". It also means "based on whim". There is no contradiction.

It means: "based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system." If there is a reason it is not arbitrary.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:54PM (#7606690)
>Comparing the civil rights movement to taxi regulations is ridiculous.

In the context of this argument, they're logically isomorphic. The fact that the civil rights movement has more emotional significance is irrelevant.

You said "you don't get to break the law because you disagree with it". That's clearly bullshit if you believe that what MLK or any other law-breaking activist did was right.

>It means: "based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system." If there is a reason it is not arbitrary.

Emphasis mine. Your definition matched what I said exactly.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EpicEng on Friday April 18, 2014 @01:20AM (#7608046)
>In the context of this argument, they're logically isomorphic. The fact that the civil rights movement has more emotional significance is irrelevant.

No, they're not, and the significance of the civil rights movement is not "emotional." Drastic measures are required when people are being systematically oppressed and abused. Not so much when you want to start a taxi company.

>Emphasis mine. Your definition matched what I said exactly.

Right, except for you conveniently ignoring that last bit.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EliRivers on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:27PM (#7606081)
Arbitrary? While I can't speak for every taxi law in every country, I quite like knowing that the taxi I ride in has to maintain a standard of vehicle and that the driver isn't some chancer on day-release.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:08PM (#7606375)
That sounds pretty arbitrary to me. What is "a standard of vehicle"? Who defines that? What if I don't mind riding around in a shitty car if I have to pay less?

Über also avoids the need for regulation of vehicle quality by having a rating system. There are better, more efficient ways to solve problems like this than by legislating against them.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by VMG on Thursday April 17, 2014 @08:36AM (#7603175)
> Pretty fair that they blocked it.

Assuming taxi service regulation is fair of course. Taxis are insanely expensive in Germany.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by raverbashing on Thursday April 17, 2014 @09:25AM (#7603378)
" Taxis are insanely expensive in Germany."

What?

In Berlin from SXF to the "city center" it will run around 40€, from TXL, around 20€ to 30€ depending, and no tip. (Also both airports are served by public transport)

So, no, they are not insanely expensive compared to other places in Europe (and even elsewhere)

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by schneid on Thursday April 17, 2014 @02:09PM (#7605245)
Compared to Britain (not London; I have no experience there), I find taxis in Germany very expensive.

I would often take a taxi for £3 or £4 half way across a city in the UK, which would cost more like 15€ in Germany.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by Xylakant on Thursday April 17, 2014 @02:34PM (#7605410)
It's a bad argument to compare the prices for one service in two distinct countries and then imply that the price difference must be due to regulation. There are a lot of other factors going into the price difference - from fuel prices, car prices, repairs, to taxes and other differentiating factors. Prices also always relate to the average cost of living in the area.

The average earning per km in Berlin is somewhere around or below 1,50 EUR before costs (anecdotal evidences but from a credible source). Nobody really gets rich from that - not even the cab company.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by joeclark77 on Friday April 18, 2014 @01:41AM (#7608078)
I don't think you realize how small a kilometer is! Or how valuable a Euro is (in terms of real money like dollars). That sounds to me like an incredible rate of profit.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by schneid on Sunday April 20, 2014 @12:15PM (#7617304)
Fair enough, but I wasn't arguing any such thing.

Just giving my opinion that I find taxis far more expensive in Germany than I did when living in the UK.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EliRivers on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:30PM (#7606106)
These cities in the UK that cost three pounds to cross half of. Are they some kind of special, tiny city? Perhaps made out of lego? An awful lot of taxis charge a couple of quid as the minimum fare just to get in it, so where you're getting these taxis I don't know.

Here's a big list. Even allowing for the inherent unreliability of the internet (and some of those prices look a bit suspicious), just which city is it that costs three pounds to cross in a taxi?

http://www.numbeo.com/taxi-fare/country_result.jsp?country=U...

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by schneid on Sunday April 20, 2014 @12:14PM (#7617299)
Those prices look suspicious indeed. Most of my experience is from Glasgow around 2010.

I just entered a journey I made often (home in north-west Glasgow to the central station) and that website came up with £13.50. I clearly remember paying £5 with tip for that journey from a local taxi company.

Even with the dominant black cab company, I don't remember going home from the city centre late night for as much as that.

In Paisley, which is a bit smaller, I took taxis to the airport for £3 or £4.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by brightsize on Thursday April 17, 2014 @12:02PM (#7604404)
TXL=>Mitte (Rosenthaler Platz) cost me less than 20EUR a few months ago, with tip. Hardly "insanely expensive".
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by omnibrain on Thursday April 17, 2014 @09:51AM (#7603505)
SXF is not in Berlin. It's even in another german country (Brandenburg). So different regulations apply. TXL should be cheaper, but that depends on the target.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by Xylakant on Thursday April 17, 2014 @10:14AM (#7603650)
Actually, things are a little more complicated here. It's correct that SXF (and BER) are in another country (Landkreis Dahme-Spreewald, LDS) and don't belong to Berlin which would ordinarily imply that the SXF Airport is not part of the area where Taxis from Berlin have to drop you off and that Taxis from Berlin would not be allowed to pick up passengers at the SXF airport for the return trip to Berlin (and the other way round, Taxis from LDS could not pick up passengers in Berlin for the return trip). Since that is obviously an unacceptable situation the "Berlin" area was expanded to include the airport and that LDS-based taxis could pick up passengers in Berlin in return. It used to be that the fee was slightly different depending on where the taxi was based, but I haven't noticed any difference in the last years.

The reason TXL is cheaper is mainly because it's closer, SXF is pretty far out and BER is even further out. There's an extra airport upcharge for TXL though.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by raverbashing on Thursday April 17, 2014 @10:13AM (#7603641)
" It's even in another german country (Brandenburg)"

For someone who wants to nitpick you seem to have a funny definition of country...

And yes, taxis in SXF have a higher tariff http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxigewerbe_in_Berlin

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by dang on Thursday April 17, 2014 @02:11PM (#7605259)
> For someone who wants to nitpick you seem to have a funny definition of country

Please don't call people out for minor mistakes that the principle of charity (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity) can easily explain. Even when you're right, it usually adds more noise than signal.

It's easy to consider that omnibrain might be a non-native English speaker who isn't up on the distinctions between "country", "county", "state", "province", and the like. His or her meaning was clear, in any case.

If you do think something is important to correct, please edit out personalized language ("for someone...nitpick...you seem") from the correction. That too adds noise, plus detracts from civility.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by raverbashing on Thursday April 17, 2014 @03:45PM (#7605849)
This also applies to the parent's pointless observation and not providing a clarifying source (like I provided)

So if they're going to say I don't know what I'm saying while providing erroneous information (Brandenburg is a state, not a country) I'm going to prove them wrong

You could also avoid the noise by saying what people should or should not do

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by dang on Thursday April 17, 2014 @03:52PM (#7605892)
Please understand that when we post moderation comments like this, they're not intended personally. The intent is to send feedback into the HN system about what makes for a good thread. The hypothesis is that it will slowly adapt to the feedback. This may be working—some people feel the threads have gotten better—so, even though they're tedious both to write and to read, I'll keep posting them for now. Ideally, the system would eventually become self-correcting. We'll see.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by ErsatzVerkehr on Thursday April 17, 2014 @06:34PM (#7606930)
In German, the word "Land" is used for both states (as in the federal states of Germany, Bundesländer) and countries.

Berlin is a City-State in Germany, entirely surrounded by the state of Brandenburg. Thus it's not too surprising that Berlin's big airport is "in another state."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/States_of_Germany

This happens in the U.S. too - Cincinnati airport is actually in Kentucky, etc.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by zyx321 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @11:54AM (#7604366)
Well, Americans have a funny definition of state. I will however make no judgement whether one definition is more correct than the other.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by nymph on Thursday April 17, 2014 @12:38PM (#7604638)
Taxis are insanely expensive in Germany.

Like lots of other things in Europe, some things are cheaper, and some thing more expensive than in North American cities.

But to say that taxis are "insanely" expensive is not just overdrawn, but disconnected from reality.

And doesn't in the least detract from the main point: that just because Uber (or its fans on HN) perceive taxi fares as being higher in some locations than in others, doesn't give Uber the right to bust its way through local regulations. Period.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by aw3c2 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @09:05AM (#7603284)
Taxi drivers earn really little... I am not sure what price you would find fair?
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by swombat on Thursday April 17, 2014 @12:03PM (#7604413)
Depends on the country. As far as I know, at least back when I was a kid, taxi drivers in Geneva earned very well due to the monopoly and limit on numbers.

In London, black cab drivers still earn a very decent amount, able to take home £500 on a regular day afaik. http://www.reddit.com/r/london/comments/18oush/how_much_do_t...

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by aw3c2 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @12:06PM (#7604442)
Sorry, I was talking about Germany where I personally know the struggle.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by mseidl on Thursday April 17, 2014 @02:02PM (#7605198)
As a German this is news to me...