News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @03:32PM (#7605790)
God forbid we have transportation services not beholden to arbitrary regulations built in favor of the existing taxi industry.

People use Über because it's better than any regulated taxi service. That is direct, incontrovertible proof that the existing taxi regulations are hurting innovation.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EpicEng on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:45PM (#7606200)
Regardless of whether or not you are correct in your assertion that these regulations are arbitrary and exist only to benefit existing taxi companies (which, of course, disagrees with your former claim...), you don't get to break the law because you disagree with it.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:06PM (#7606351)
> you don't get to break the law because you disagree with it.

So I guess MLK should have just accepted the current state of affairs, and Anne Frank should have just turned herself in?

The law is not some ultimate moral authority.

>these regulations are arbitrary and exist only to benefit existing taxi companies (which, of course, disagrees with your former claim...),

"Arbitrary" doesn't just mean "random". It also means "based on whim". There is no contradiction.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EpicEng on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:35PM (#7606565)
>So I guess MLK should have just accepted the current state of affairs, and Anne Frank should have just turned herself in?

Comparing the civil rights movement to taxi regulations is ridiculous. If that's the best you can do it should tell you a lot about the strength of your argument.

>"Arbitrary" doesn't just mean "random". It also means "based on whim". There is no contradiction.

It means: "based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system." If there is a reason it is not arbitrary.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:54PM (#7606690)
>Comparing the civil rights movement to taxi regulations is ridiculous.

In the context of this argument, they're logically isomorphic. The fact that the civil rights movement has more emotional significance is irrelevant.

You said "you don't get to break the law because you disagree with it". That's clearly bullshit if you believe that what MLK or any other law-breaking activist did was right.

>It means: "based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system." If there is a reason it is not arbitrary.

Emphasis mine. Your definition matched what I said exactly.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EpicEng on Friday April 18, 2014 @01:20AM (#7608046)
>In the context of this argument, they're logically isomorphic. The fact that the civil rights movement has more emotional significance is irrelevant.

No, they're not, and the significance of the civil rights movement is not "emotional." Drastic measures are required when people are being systematically oppressed and abused. Not so much when you want to start a taxi company.

>Emphasis mine. Your definition matched what I said exactly.

Right, except for you conveniently ignoring that last bit.

Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by EliRivers on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:27PM (#7606081)
Arbitrary? While I can't speak for every taxi law in every country, I quite like knowing that the taxi I ride in has to maintain a standard of vehicle and that the driver isn't some chancer on day-release.
Re:Uber hit with preliminary injunction to stop service in B... by wyager on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:08PM (#7606375)
That sounds pretty arbitrary to me. What is "a standard of vehicle"? Who defines that? What if I don't mind riding around in a shitty car if I have to pay less?

Über also avoids the need for regulation of vehicle quality by having a rating system. There are better, more efficient ways to solve problems like this than by legislating against them.