Professional dan denotes past achievements, not playing strength. Young 1p is actually more likely to be about half a stone to a stone stronger than some older pros.
It's fairly hard to quantify how strong 9d KGS or AGA are, since there are too fews of them. But if 9d KGS is ~1 stones weaker than the pro, add on 3 more stones and Crazy Stone would be ~ 5d-6d KGS, which would be 95-98% percentile or more! That would make the computer about ~2100-2300 Elo for chess. Correct me if I'm wrong, but 10 years ago, no go program would have even come close to a mid rank kyu players.
Sorry, I know that the ranges given in the post are quite broad and might look silly, it's just hard to make any direct comparison between the system
Also, Crazy Stone is 6d on KGS.
The normal conversion I hear is a 3d on KGS is around a 1k on Eastern Servers. Or that's my experience for people who play on KGS and eastern servers. I'm a 4k on KGS, but I know my knowledge is a bit amateur or a South Korean 4k.
An above average amateur chess player around ELO 2000 should regularly beat the world champion with two extra bishops.
I think a more accurate analogy would be playing a game of chess without a pawn, or two, maybe, but the game is so heavily based on opening lines that some might argue if you have a pawn handicap, it shouldn't be called chess.
Also, I think some part of the difference in strength between Carlsen and I lies in his massive knowledge of the openings, which will be gone if I start the game with a two bishops handicap.
Either your rating is wrong, your are not actually playing the strongest computers, you're arguing from a too small sample size, or your definition of "crush" means "I win half of the games but those that I do win I do so convincingly".
4 stones is more like a pawn
This is completely and utterly wrong. The winning odds of having a 4 stone headstart are an order of magnitude higher than those of being up a pawn.
There is huge difference between a bishop and two pawns.
Yes. About 150 ELO - equivalent. More than being another pawn up.
>>Yes. About 150 ELO - equivalent. More than being another pawn up.
You can't quantify it like that. Strong chess player is going to win with bishop odds vs any entity on the other side: 2500GM, elite GM or Houdini on 32 cores. It's just a win starting from certain level and "150ELO" doesn't convey it. On the other hand there are a lot of entities which would beat me (and even some stronger players) with 2 or 3 pawn odds.
ELO, Material Difference and Winning percentage are directly correlated.
You can't quantify it like that
Of course you can. A material advantage increases the average winning probability, and does so in a way that corresponds reasonably close to the ELO formulas. No more and no less.
Strong chess player is going to win with bishop odds vs any entity on the other side: 2500GM, elite GM or Houdini on 32 cores. It's just a win starting from certain level and "150ELO" doesn't convey it.
You have no argument to support this, and there's evidence to the contrary. (See the above study). "Strong chess player" is totally meaningless, ELO is a relative scale. A 2500 player loses just as hard against a 2850 one as a 1600 does to an 1950. That's the definition of ELO.
I'm sorry but you're just not going to beat Magnus Carlsen in a long match even if he gives you bishop odds. That's exactly what him being 2880 ELO means. You would beat Karpov (!) though.
The main point is that Bishop odds are different from 3 pawn odds. It tilts the game too much in the favor of the odds taker taking away most of the advantages(positional considerations, openings, etc) that a 2850 player enjoys over a 2350 player.
What happens playing against a strong computer given a bishop odds, is that computer will slowly succumb to the negative eval.
Instead a better strategy for a computer would be to try something very speculative like in old Tarrasch games with odds against amateurs.
That is computer should be on the lookout for eval -20.00 with perfect play by opponent(me) but possibility of 0.00 or even +10 when I make a wrong move. That is computer would have to try hard to create high volatility situations and hope that the 2350 player would misplay them.
I suppose that Magnus would try something similar(especially given his penchant for grinding).
At any rate I'm also a decent amateur (2350 ELO) and it's absolutely unsurprising that a (2200+) player easily beats very strong computers with bishop odds.
For reference, you probably have to be at least 7-8 dan on KGS to be close to being professional.
Here is a rank comparison of various amateur systems:
http://senseis.xmp.net/?RankWorldwideComparison
All of those systems will be weaker than any professional system.
It's inaccurate to say that KGS is "very inflated" since it's measuring amateurs instead of professionals.
Ishida first: while he is certainly not top 100 in the world anymore, he is quite probably top 1000 (there are something like 1500 professionals out there, and he is probably above average for Japanese professionals, maybe above average for all the countries (see https://www.google.com/search?q=yoshio+site%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fi...). So he's closer to a grandmaster than a master. And in any case, other professionals have lost at four stones (see http://www.computer-go.info/h-c/index.html).
Second, regarding the handicap: I am not knowledge enough about chess to say, but it sounds high. In Go, I have beaten players who officially should give me three stones (though as you approach professional strength, it is true that players would be better at preserving that advantage and converting it into a win). I'd estimate the handicap as somewhere between 400 and 600 GoR points (which are similar in spirit to ELO ratings--http://senseis.xmp.net/?EGFRatingSystem). It is worth noting that the best European players take two to three stones from strong Asian professionals.
http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=ja&tl=en&u=ht...
That is, students striving to become professional.
tournament?
> To put in more westernized chess terms, this would be like beating a
> 2100 Elo master without bishops.
This sentence is not helpful. A handicap is useless without a basic idea of the skill level of both opponents. Who is playing the 2100 master? My mom who has no chess knowledge, the casual player who knows how the pieces move but has never devoted anytime to study, or someone ranked 1500? |------------+---------+------------------------+-----------|
| Underdog | Result | Favorite | Handicap |
|------------+---------+------------------------+-----------|
| CrazyStone | defeats | Ishida Yoshio | 4 Stones |
| ?????????? | defeats | 2100 ELO Ranked Player | 2 Bishops |
|------------+---------+------------------------+-----------|Crazy Stone computer Go program.
Having said that I suspect there are problems with the two bishops and the 2100 Elo. Reading other posts, maybe it is 2 pawns or so and maybe 2600 Elo.
Whereas the best chess engine is better than the best human, the best go engine can only beat a weak player with a big handicap. That's all valaraucal was trying to say.
I'm a chess expert but not a go expert - I don't know if valaraucal's right - but I suspect he is overstating both the weakness of the player and the size of the handicap.
Worrying about cores etc is overthinking it, they don't make that much difference (it's not a linear problem). Houdini is much stronger (or at least has a much higher rating) than Magnus Carlsen, even on a commodity laptop.
Incidentally, if you build a chess engine from scratch, it will take a bit of effort to get an engine that can beat a 2100 player with a 2 bishop handicap. I am about 2000, I spent a couple of weeks building a toy engine (available on triplehappy.com, my website). It is rated about 1500, but it will still beat me if I don't pay attention to the tactics. Illustrative of the fact that human ratings and machine ratings are not directly comparable. To get that far I had to give it some chess knowledge and some tactical ability. When you first get a chess engine playing legal chess it is going to be lamentably weak (less than 1000).
I did not mean to delete the comment you replied to. I have included it below:
It is terribly confusing analogy for me. Initially I thought the computer engine analogy was what was intended. But then I started thinking about someone rated 2100, down two bishops playing stockfish on a decent box with 3-4-5 EGTBs and a two bishop advantage. That seemed like a no brainer so I moved on to crafty, and then GNU chess and then what? I realized that I could not think of an engine that would consider a win with two bishops an accomplishment. As far as "maybe 2600 is a better target" goes you have to go all the way down to #88 on the CCRL in order to get to 2600.[^1] That is with even material and definitely not using 64 cores (the CCRL uses a AMD X2 4600+ at 2.4GHz benchmark).
I am sorry but thinking about a chess engine running on 64 cores with a two bishop advantage against a 2100 rated human is not reasonable. If I knew nothing about computers and Go I could reasonably read the 2-bishops/2100-ELO analogy and conclude that CrazyStone was laughable. I do not know much about computers and Go but I do know enough that I do not consider CrazyStone's performance laughable.
A 4 stone handicap between master's is massive. The difference between a 9d (dan) and 1d isn't actually 8 stones. With an 8 stone handicap a 1d will play a 9d off the board (provided both are profession dans not amateur). Source http://www.amazon.com/Kages-Secret-Chronicles-Handicap-Go/dp...
Generally I would say that this should put it around US 2-4d (for US Go Association, or KGS online). Maybe 2k-1d in professional amateur circles. I doubt it work warrant a 1-3p 'professional ranking'.