News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by nextstep on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:46AM (#7453272)
Not to mention, New York is relatively clean compared to San Francisco. San Francisco shuts down at 10pm; New York truly is the city that never sleeps, and many neighborhoods feel busy and alive at all hours of the night. The public transportation in SF (and the larger Bay Area) is a classist, unreliable nightmare. New York has probably the best public transit systems in the country. Owning a car in NY is unusual and unnecessary. In San Francisco, most people own a car, just like any other suburban area in the US. The number and quality of restaurants in NY is unrivaled. New York is unquestionably more diverse. The list goes on and on.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wyclif on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:01AM (#7453324)
The food culture and restaurants in NYC are on a completely different, higher level than SF. Having experienced both, I laugh whenever people in the Bay Area try to claim that SF has the best restaurants. It's not even a race; NY has SF whipped in that regard.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by kenjackson on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:27AM (#7453423)
Eh, I disagree. I've spent time in both and I prefer SF restaurants. I think it may have to do with the fact that local is generally better in California. Also there are some types of food where I just don't prefer the NY style -- in particular I don't like NY pizza. I've tried all the recommended spots and I think I just don't like the style as much.

EDIT: Someone mentioned elsewhere about the high quality of food in the Bay once you leave SF. A good example of this is Michael Warring's found in a strip mall in Vallejo (yes, a strip mall in Vallejo) -- just really good food: http://www.urbanspoon.com/r/6/1691241/restaurant/Michael-War...

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wdewind on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:03AM (#7453331)
> The number and quality of restaurants in NY is unrivaled.

NYC native and mostly SF-hater here. Hate to say it but SF has us beat for food. If you want to go have a 5 star meal you're going to pay about the same and get about the same food in both cities (NYC obviously has the edge here, but not hugely), but San Francisco has NYC (especially Manhattan) absolutely dominated at the everyday eating level (ie: burritos, sandwiches, cheaper restaurants). The general ingredient quality just blows NYC away - both meat and produce.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by jortiz81 on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:30AM (#7453440)
I'm a native New Yorker but lived in the SF Bay Area for 9 years. I agree with this assessment. The quality for the price in generally better in the Bay Area, since a lot of the food is local and super fresh. That said, the diversity of cuisines in NYC in much, much broader than SF. For example, in SF you can find Salvadorian and Mexican food quite easily, but New York has food from all parts of Latin America. The same can be said about other regional cuisines; the selection provides a "finer granularity" of choices for that region.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by bradleyjg on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:41AM (#7453700)
That really boils down to a critical mass of the relevant ethnicity. If you don't have enough Thai people in a given area than you aren't going to have Thai markets, which is going to make it very difficult to get the proper ingredients to make a great jungle curry. The sheer number of non-trivial ethnic sub-populations in Queens alone, much less all of NYC, makes it an unfair contest.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by jortiz81 on Sunday March 23, 2014 @04:38PM (#7455038)
I mean, none of these are truly fair comparisons. There's no question that there are many things Sf will be better at because of its size and there's other things New York can offer because of its size. But that's what this whole thread is about, comparing the two cities regardless of the root causes for their differences. For example, sf has better quality food in general, since the weather is more forgiving and farms and wineries are quite close. Still, there's no question that the food in sf is of higher quality on average.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by auntienomen on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:28AM (#7453427)
I've lived in both places and this strikes me as correct.

The day-to-day food in SF is just excellent, In part, I suspect, because they incorporate fresh vegetables of a kind that are just not available in NY for 8 months out of the year.

Also critical: The food in the greater NYC metro area is abysmal. The quality falls off very rapidly once you exit the city. Whereas if you walk into some random restaurant in some random town in the Bay Area, you're likely to get at least decent food.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wdewind on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:43AM (#7453498)
> The food in the greater NYC metro area is abysmal. The quality falls off very rapidly once you exit the city.

Oh man is that true :( Long Island is not known for it's cuisine...

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by chubot on Sunday March 23, 2014 @01:37PM (#7454187)
Really? I am an SF dweller, grew up in NJ, and an occasional NYC visitor, and always thought the opposite. In SF you seem to have to sit down and eat (i.e. with waiter) to get anything decent, especially vegetables.

The only places you can get burritos are really the Mission and Redwood City. That is one of the main "everyday eating" foods that is made well. They are certainly good, but not something you want to eat super often. There aren't any vegetables to speak of in burritos or tacos.

SOMA, where most startups are, mostly has terrible food (at the everyday eating level), although it has gotten better in the last 5 years now that more people live there.

In NYC you can reliably get good pizza and bagels -- and the pizza is way cheaper than anything in SF. In SF the pizza is generally horrible.

If you compare cheaper restaurants (i.e. with waiter), then it's possible that SF has NY beat (?). But if you are just talking about walking into a place and getting food by yourself, then I think the pizza and bagels of NY has SF easily beat. SF is really many neighborhoods, and the Mission is definitely better in terms of food, but compared with SOMA it seems like there is no contest.

The floor in SF also seems to be really low... if you just walk into a random pizza or (surprisingly) Chinese place, you are pretty likely to be disappointed.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by erddojo on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:06PM (#7454293)
You're speaking of SOMA like you're familiar with the restaurants here. I'm guessing you're not. Perhaps you live here but are too busy coding to make it past the Creamery?

At the "everyday eating level", try Darwin, Little Skillet, Garaje, American Grilled Cheese, Source, Butler and Chef, La Briciola, Coco500, Zuppa, Holy Grill etc.

Want to go a little more upscale? Saisan. Alexanders. 25 Lusk. Prospect. Town Hall. Benu.

C'mon, don't make such broad generalizations unless you can back them up.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by chubot on Sunday March 23, 2014 @03:36PM (#7454711)
Wow, wasn't expecting this level of venom for a harmless comment.

I lived in SOMA from 2002 to 2004, and from 2008 to 2010, so I know what I'm talking about... you do realize all the places you mentioned opened in the "last 5 years" (or have waiters and are not "every day food"), which I explicitly mentioned in my comment?

I'm guessing you don't because you just moved here, and those are the only places in SF you go to.

Now I know why pg wants to moderate comments. HN is really two forums: one for programmers, and one for industry gossip/lifestyle. The threads for programmers are still top notch, but once you venture into the non-technical parts you get randomly bitten by trolls.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by erddojo on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:02PM (#7456065)
Wasn't intended as venomous, just maybe a little bit of a reality check. And offering an opinion (with real examples) to counter your opinion isn't trollism. Plus your comment never said that any restaurants opened in the past 5 years weren't eligible for consideration (?).

I was on SOMA from '04-'06, then again from '08-present. There were some good places back then too. Some failed. Some are still here but aren't as good as they once were. If you haven't been here in 4 years, why are you spending your time claiming you know the SOMA foodie scene? And then getting all angst-y when countered?

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wting on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:11AM (#7453608)
I think the situation is reversed when considering Asian food. SF easily ranks behind other west coast cities I know extensively (Honolulu, LA, Seattle) when it comes to Chinese and Japanese food.

The Asian food situation is much better in south bay, but that's an hour from the city and thus limited to weekend excursions.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by davidw on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:14AM (#7453368)
To be honest, I ate better day to day when I lived in Portland, Oregon than when I lived in SF. Wouldn't know about NY - I've never been there. And I don't know about 'fine dining' options in either PDX or SF, having been in my early 20ies and not gone in for that sort of thing much.

These days, the best eating I do is when the in-laws have a big dinner, with stuff like hand-made tortellini!

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wdewind on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:16AM (#7453374)
Wouldn't shock me, my experience has been most of the food on the west coast is better. A lot of this has to do with how cheap it is to get quality produce compared to the east coast.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by leephillips on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:42AM (#7453706)
But do they have restaurants that serve "comidas Chinas y Latinas"?
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by raverbashing on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:17AM (#7453375)
" The general ingredient quality just blows NYC away - both meat and produce."

Well, west coast (meaning: access to Australia and some other selling markets), good climate, etc

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by mike_herrera on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:40AM (#7453487)
SF's neighbor to-the-east, The San Joaquin Valley, is "the nation's salad bowl." Which also happens to be home to many cattle and sheep operations.

Access for foreign imports are important for the gourmet scene, but not necessary.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by autodidakto on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:06PM (#7455666)
"Virtually all non-tropical crops are grown in the Central Valley, which is the primary source for a number of food products throughout the United States, including tomatoes, almonds, grapes, cotton, apricots, and asparagus." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Valley_(California)

Minor correction: The San Joaquin Valley in the south half of the Central Valley, and The Sacramento Valley is the north half. The dividing line is the Sacramento–San Joaquin River Delta

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by jfb on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:09AM (#7453602)
It's more that it's in California, which means easy, quick access to fresh produce all year round.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by raverbashing on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:37AM (#7453685)
Yes, that's what I meant by "good climate", it wouldn't help being in the WC but in Seattle for example

But the way I wrote it kind of hid the point.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by chrismonsanto on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:09AM (#7453350)
> The public transportation in SF (and the larger Bay Area) is a classist, unreliable nightmare.

I've never been to California, but used to live next to NYC. Could you expand on how the transit is 'classist' ? Is it too expensive? Does it not stop at places other than the suburbs?

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by cyclecount on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:28AM (#7453434)
My view is that in any place where public transportation is not ubiquitous, the ridership often comprises the poorest people in the city. Much of the public transportation system is used only by those who cannot afford better means of transportation. In NY, the norm is that everyone from the poorest classes to the upper-middle class use the Subway and buses for their daily commute, to go out at night, to grocery shop, to visit friends. The Subway is utilized by people from all backgrounds.

In SF, the buses are dirty and filled with homeless and mentally ill people. Taking a bus home late at night is the plight of the commoners, the poorest class that work in the service industry and can't afford an Uber or taxi. And this class divide is why a BART strike is possible. The worst affected were those who didn't have a car too fall back on, or who couldn't work from home for a few days.

If something so critical as the NYC Subway stops functioning for more than a few hours, the MTA provides alternative buses and advance notice. A multi-day complete system outage would impact everyone, not just the poorest people unfortunate enough not to have other options.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:34AM (#7453678)
In my experience, the rush hour commute on BART takes quite a bit of white collar people to/from the Market Street stops. Its just that when the BART strikes happened, a lot of people could work from home or drive or whatever. Imagine being a full time student at SFSU or something coming in from the East Bay.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by bane on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:33AM (#7453455)
Yes to all the above. Round-trip on the BART from Rockridge to Montgomery St. is almost $8. Let's say you need to drive to the station, now you're paying for parking also (additional $2/day).

So you're a minimum waged fry-cook or whatever in SF, you've blown 1/8th of your workday earnings just getting to-from work. You can get the monthly pass ($76.00/mo), but that's a bitter pill to swallow on those wages.

Oh, and you might not be able to take it home anyways since it shuts down at midnight, so don't get a job that does dinner service. Also, IIR, bus transfers to the Muni aren't free.

In the meanwhile the highly paid dotcommers might even get free company shuttles with wifi.

By comparison, a round trip Subway ride in NYC is what, $5? Goes pretty much everywhere, with good service even into lower income areas, transfers to buses are free. So while minimum wage is lower in NYC, it doesn't even kill 1/8th of your workday's pay to get from home to work and back.

Because coverage is so good, it's also unlikely that you'll even need a car, so you can save on all that expense: gas, taxes, registration, insurance, etc.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by paulbaumgart on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:07AM (#7453592)
FYI: BART doesn't have monthly passes outside of SF city limits, which actually makes your argument stronger.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by LeafyGreenbriar on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:02AM (#7453579)
Interesting, the per-ride fair on the subway is cheaper but the monthly pass is actually more expensive at (I think, I don't have one) $130/mo. However, the subway does truly feel like transportation for everyone, and it makes the city feel many times more accessible than SF.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by msrpotus on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:09AM (#7453599)
It's $112, which works out to roughly 45 rides or 1.5 rides a day. If you're someone working a M-F job and taking the subway there every day, a monthly pass is almost certainly cheaper than pay-per-ride.

If you can bike (which I do), though, the calculus quickly changes.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by mertd on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:37AM (#7453688)
Also many employers will let you buy it pre-tax. http://web.mta.info/mta/farebenefits.htm
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:33AM (#7453675)
In my experience, taking a bike on BART is a colossal PITA. Caltrain is years ahead.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by decktech on Sunday March 23, 2014 @12:02PM (#7453779)
Taking a bike on the subway is much harder, and usually seen as rude, because our cars are much smaller. Thankfully, our bridges have bike dedicated bike lanes, so taking them on the subway is not necessary.

I was astounded when I visited SF, usually seen as much more bike friendly than NY, and I saw that east bay riders still had to rely on the BART to get them into the city. The fare between West Oakland and Embarcadero alone is more than a subway ride.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by tzs on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:05PM (#7454289)
> Owning a car in NY is unusual and unnecessary

46% of NYC households own a car. I don't think that qualifies as "unusual". Or if it does, then some other things that are unusual in NYC are white people (44%) and males (47%). :-)

Even in Manhattan, which has the lowest car ownership within the five boroughs, 23% of households own a car, which is hard to describe as "unusual". Some things that are comparably rare in Manhattan: people who primarily speak Spanish at home (23%), and Black and Asian people (26%).

Car ownership in the other boroughs: 44% for Brooklyn, 46% for the Bronx, 64% for Queens, and 84% for Staten Island.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by nextstep on Sunday March 23, 2014 @08:53PM (#7456031)
New York City has the highest percent of households without a car for any US city: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_most_h...

I'd say that makes NY pretty unusual.

Your comparisons are intellectually dishonest.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by tzs on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:39PM (#7456200)
You didn't say that NY was unusual in car ownership. You said owning a car in NY was unusual. Try writing more carefully next time.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by eddieroger on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:26AM (#7453416)
Having spent time in both, but living in neither, I think that's fair. Specifically, good observation on the cleanliness of the city. New York is busy, but I never felt it was dirty in the way I immediately felt SF was. I think a large part of it was the uncontrolled panhandling and the fact that there are certain areas that those folks know will be busy, so they go there. I've never seen anyone openly urinate on the streets in New York, where I have twice on the same trip to San Francisco - an anecdotal fact that kind of blew my mind.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by bane on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:37AM (#7453479)
It also helps that it rains more in NYC. NYC is a wonder to behold a few hours after a rainstorm. I've noticed that places that don't get lots of rain just look perpetually more "dirty" and used.

NYC also has this weird way of turning filth into part of the set piece of the city that very few places can manage.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by eddieroger on Sunday March 23, 2014 @03:50PM (#7454782)
Yeah - the rain doesn't get enough credit. Contrast that with New Orleans where they literally hose Bourbon Street down every morning and it still feels gross. Crediting the rain starts to get close to blurring the lines between dirty and lived in - they're not necessarily the same.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by kenjackson on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:31AM (#7453446)
New York has probably the best public transit systems in the country.

NY has a very good public transit system. But I think I prefer D.C.'s. Cleaner and more comfortable. But both are quite good. I found London's quite good too.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by TheCoelacanth on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:51AM (#7453740)
DC's is a bit more pleasant, but in terms of actually transporting people NYC's is much better. NYC has a much better coverage of the area, longer hours of service and is much cheaper.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by evanb on Sunday March 23, 2014 @12:16PM (#7453839)
As a former DC and NYC resident who now lives in SF, I have quite a bit of experience riding the subway, Metro, and BART[0]. Here are my impressions:

The SF system is relatively nice, and regularly on time. Timed transfers are great. Shutting down so early, even on Friday and Saturday is a disaster for SF/East Bay interaction, and (on weeknights) people who work the night shift. The coverage is OK, but the fact that there's just one line on the SF side of things is a little crazy, especially given the challenge of walking long distances the hills present. Buses and MUNI are can't replace rail entirely. Finally, the variety of transit authorities makes it daunting to plan your trip or transfer services if (like a tourist might) you don't have a Clipper Card. 511 is pretty good as far as planning goes, but it'd be great to have a single map that showed BART and Muni, for example.

The DC system is far cleaner than NY, but coverage is very bad. Georgetown is devoid of Metro stops for snobby reasons, but the real desert is Northeast, which tends to be poorer and thus needs more public transit to begin with! Not being able to get to Dulles is terrible (although the silver line is nearing completion). SmarTrip works fine, but the lack of a monthly card really drove me crazy. Service is extended to 3 am on weekends, but DC is also far more walkable, and a cab ride isn't going to potentially set you back $80, even if you're in Virginia somewhere, like it would if you were trying to get across the Bay (yes, there are buses, they can get crowded to the point that they fill up and you have to wait for the next one, which can be an hour later). The Metro has peak fares, even if you are riding "the wrong way"---I commuted from DC out to College Park via the green line and paid more in the morning, even though I rode trains where everyone could find a seat. This makes no sense to me. The fare was $3.35 (the base fare of $2.65 for that trip is more than a NYC fare)---it was actually cheaper for me to drive, but the extra 40 minutes to read, do the crossword, etc., was worth the difference. If you're going to have me swipe in and swipe out and charge me based on distance, then I think you can figure out that I didn't add to the rush.

The NYC system is by far the best with respect to the problems the other two systems have, although coverage in eastern Queens and Brooklyn leave much to be desired, and Staten Island has its own set of problems, and the lack of direct airport service is a serious shortcoming. However, you can always catch a train at any time of night if you are willing to wait 20 minutes. You can buy an unlimited daily, weekly, or monthly metrocard. A fare otherwise costs a flat, time- and distance-traveled-independent $2.50. Coverage is phenomenal, in terms of the number of stations, neighborhoods serviced, express trains, and comparative resilience to service disruptions when there is construction. Finally the scale and usage are incomparable. The Lexington Avenue Line alone (ie. the 4, 5, and 6 trains) carries 1.9 million people a day[1], whereas the entire BART system carries 400,000 and DC Metro 850,000 daily[2]. My point is that the NYC subway is simply massive in a way that those other systems aren't.

I understand why NYC's system is so good: age, lack of NIMBY strength and fierce competition between different subway companies when it was first constructed, scale of the city itself, only having to deal with a single authority (now, anyway) and political jurisdiction (again, now, anyway---if the 7 ever gets extended to Hoboken, we'll see what happens). Finally, a flat fare makes sense for a city where the poor tend live far away from "important" areas (like Midtown Manhattan), and this enables logistically simpler unlimited ridership cards, whereas in DC the wealthier people tend to live in the suburbs and the poorer people in the city, so it is less regressive to charge by distance. Not sure if/how SF fits into this idea.

[0] I just noticed that the commonly used name for each of these is capitalized differently!

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IRT_Lexington_Avenue_Line

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_rapid_tra...

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by yeukhon on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:13AM (#7453365)
Not to mention, New York is relatively clean compared to San Francisco.

I am a NY resident but I was in SF this past summer. Regarding cleanness it depends on which neighbors you live in. If you live in Richmond or Outer Sunset like I was the neighborhoods should be pretty clean. Where I live now in NY is considered one of the safest neighborhood but with the ever increasing population the neighborhood is getting dirtier.

San Francisco shuts down at 10pm; New York truly is the city that never sleeps, and many neighborhoods feel busy and alive at all hours of the night.

True. Most local restaurants close around 10. Even those in the city closes early too. Usually I have to drive to Daly City to look for better and bigger restaurant.

But that's fine. I wouldn't want to dine too late. Now if you are looking for late night entertainment....

New York has probably the best public transit systems in the country

Also one of the dirtiest too. The problem with SF transit (subway) is that it runs on the street so they compete with cars and buses. Also SF subway trains are smaller and shorter so it can't take that many at once. So it's unfair to say SF doesn't have a good transit system.

SF's buses are quite on time, unlike NYC. I could check nextbus.com to confirm the next arrival and usually the bus can come within 2 minutes within the estimated arrival time.

The only pet peeve I have is there is very few bus sign. Looking for yellow paint mark can be tricky. When I was new to SF I was constantly asking people and looking outside the window to check whether I was approaching my destination. The only clue I had was to look at the street sign (X ave X street) and guess. Or I have to stare nextbus.com to watch for the next bus stop.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by sandipc on Sunday March 23, 2014 @01:15PM (#7454095)
NextBus (or NextMuni, specifically) tracks buses and light rail by GPS... so what you're looking at isn't the actual bus schedule, but the estimated arrival time. Bus schedules are published on the Muni website and I doubt that mang of them are followed strictly.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:56AM (#7453304)
A good part of SF not seeming to be a 24 hour city, is that public transit in SF doesn't run 24 hours-at least not BART, and I don't think MUNI Metro does either. The last SB Caltrain leaves at midnight, I think? EDIT: I'll give you being clean, SF can stand to be cleaned up a bit.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by derwiki on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:13AM (#7453366)
Buses are the only public transit that run all night, but those are limited/different than day routes. Plus many people I know who live here have an unreasonable dislike of the buses, so many just don't consider it an option. I think they're great, except for some passengers who get on in the Tenderloin.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wdewind on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:18AM (#7453379)
I don't live in SF but the few times I've been the bus system has been a complete joke. It's like a stereotype of a bad bus system: dirty, unreliable, slow, filled with junkies, loud, doesn't really go anywhere you'd like...there's a reason Uber was founded in SF.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by rayiner on Sunday March 23, 2014 @12:00PM (#7453768)
What is truly amazing to me about New York is that you can live in the suburbs and still not have a car. I used to live in Westchester, 20 miles north of midtown, and drove maybe once a month. My commute was amazing, 35 min straight to midtown on trains that ran often and on time. Nothing else in the US comes close.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by joshmlewis on Monday March 24, 2014 @02:11AM (#7456982)
I wouldn't say nothing in the US comes close..there are plenty of mid-sized cities that you can have a less than 5 minute commute in and be in the middle of the cool parts for under $1000 a month for a big apartment.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:57AM (#7453306)
And yes, if we're talking about SF proper, (not the Bay Area as a whole) MUNI can stand to be massively improved.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by michaelochurch on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:11AM (#7453352)
The issue is this. San Francisco used to be weird, beautiful, edgy, and affordable outside of known rich neighborhoods (Pac Heights) that, like the UES, aren't very interesting places to be, anyway, unless you live there. San Francisco used to have a lot of unique character to recommend it. It still does, to a lesser extent, but it also has douches wearing Glass and paying huge sums of money for crappy apartments, not even because they want to live there, but because they enjoy bullying the poors.

When MBA culture infected the Valley, it turned it into a shitty New York: the worst of both worlds between a sleepy, semisuburban (but still beautiful and interesting in its own right) California city and the hypercompetitive pressure-cooker of Manhattan.

In 2002 it was still conceivable that a normal person would want to live in San Francisco, just because it was still an interesting place: a genuine big city on the West Coast, with less rain than Seattle and far more character than L.A. Now, all the people I like hate what's happening to Northern California.

Even tech workers are marginalized in this brave new world. How many software engineers are there that could buy a house in San Francisco at the market rate? Seven? Twelve? At typical house-buying, setting-down ages the are... zero, plus or minus one engineer who got in early on a ridiculously lucky startup, negotiated well, and over whom the founders are still kicking themselves.

It's ridiculous. Of course, that's also the fault of the NIMBYs, who should be squashed with extreme prejudice. They deserve far more hatred than anyone on Sand Hill Road. It'd be better if the insane anger were directed at NIMBYs instead of innocent Google engineers (who are also getting ass-raped by rent, thus victims of the same thing).

I don't know what the permanent identity of San Francisco is. I hope the crash will take out the nonsense and flush the entitled, Harvard-MBA culture back into the Stygian reaches from which it came. Let's have the NIMBYs thrown under that bus as well. They're certainly trying to turn San Francisco into a shitty New York knock-off, but they haven't irreversibly won yet.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by sltkr on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:41AM (#7453491)
> [..] douches [..] paying huge sums of money for crappy apartments, not even because they want to live there, but because they enjoy bullying the poors.

I find this very hard to believe.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by crusso on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:50AM (#7453528)
that's also the fault of the NIMBYs, who should be squashed with extreme prejudice

I don't have a dog in the fight, but I respect the right of people to help determine the kind of city they want to have. Enough people who already live in SF are saying that they don't want to be New York. What's wrong with that?

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by cynicalkane on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:01AM (#7453576)
They exercise privilege that they haven't paid into but simply possess on being there first, nor do they have economic incentive to see development that is beneficial for others. NIMBYs are the economic version of "finders keepers" together with not caring about anyone's well-being. This is suboptimal, even in lassiez-faire, to say nothing of an actual egalitarian society.

Then there's the additional problem of the most ornery and stubborn NIMBYs commanding the greatest political influence. This is also suboptimal in any economic model.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by chimeracoder on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:26AM (#7453652)
> They exercise privilege that they haven't paid into but simply possess on being there first, nor do they have economic incentive to see development that is beneficial for others.

It's amusing, because this is almost the exact opposite of the typical argument I see against gentrification of lower-class neighborhoods in Brooklyn or Upper Manhattan in which most of the longtime residents are not property owners (ie, "They were here first").

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by crusso on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:46AM (#7453724)
simply possess on being there first

Being there first is a really strong reason to respect someone's wishes. The ones who have been there have formed the place into much of what it is that makes it so desirable.

If being there first doesn't carry much weight, being a johnny-come-lately carries even less.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by natrius on Sunday March 23, 2014 @12:54PM (#7454003)
What you've described would be desirable were it not for a widespread flaw in human reasoning. When people invest time and/or money into a place, they want to make sure it doesn't change for the worse. The default strategy to achieve that goal is to fight any change at all, which doesn't work in growing cities. You can try to keep the buildings the same as they are, but the people will change, as will the transportation problems.

A growing city requires more housing to slow the rise of housing prices. A growing city requires more housing near its transportation investments (especially where capacity can easily be increased) so more people can get to where they need to go quickly. NIMBYism prevents both of those, and is the cause of many problems in the modern American city.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by bane on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:44AM (#7453505)
SF is like the Hippy movement writ large. Weird and experimental and funky a long time ago, got older and realized money is better and now wears turtlenecks and wireframe glasses that are too small and protects their property investment by artificially limiting availability and keeping public transport away (so the riff raff can't get around as easy). A few folks burned out early and couldn't get in on a good investment vehicle, but the weather is too nice to do anything about it and nobody seems to mind when you take a pee in the middle of the street. Plus, it's not too hard to bum a ride every month or two and head north to score some great bud.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by gruseom on Sunday March 23, 2014 @01:19PM (#7454108)
> San Francisco used to be weird, beautiful, edgy

> the fault of the NIMBYs, who [...] deserve far more hatred

When I lived in SF, the "weird, beautiful, and edgy" older culture was very much also the anti-development and NIMBY culture. I'd be surprised if that were no longer true.