News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by buro9 on Sunday March 16, 2014 @05:18AM (#7408738)
> Nebulous semi-employee with unspecified responsibilities related to a founder?

This is the point that stands out for me. That the wife is not an employee of Github but claims to be able to access private company chat records, and also is able to "work" from within the office and interact with the staff.

Even with allowances that company property remains company property and private chat rooms are in fact non-private to the company... there is no scenario in which a non-employee should have access to those chat rooms.

The wife, and the husband (founder), have displayed an incredible lack of professionalism here. There may even be a question about whether those acts are illegal if they are substantiated.

And for companies that use Github to host private repositories, the question should be asked very loud and clear... "Who can access private company data, why, and for what reason?".

If a non-employee can access information that is presumed (even by their own employees) to be private, then our (external companies) assumptions about what is private and secure at Github are weakened and demand very clear statements backed up with clear processes to reassure.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by keithpeter on Sunday March 16, 2014 @06:38AM (#7408935)
"Who can access private company data, why, and for what reason?"

This seems to me to be the major takeaway for organisations outside github from this sorry affair. I'm sort of surprised you are the only person to raise this so far.

In the UK, the employee who resigned could have a successful day in an employment tribunal. And one aspect of the hearing would be privacy and the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act provisions.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by icco on Sunday March 16, 2014 @02:45PM (#7410624)
I am not a Lawyer, but I'm pretty sure in the US, she could sue as well.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by agapos on Monday March 17, 2014 @09:04AM (#7414761)
One could sue for pretty much anything in the US.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mendicantB on Monday March 17, 2014 @01:37AM (#7413301)
So spot on. Considering recent privacy issues, Github needs to be careful to respond on this. It has potential to explode into an entirely separate shitstorm.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by wahsd on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:01PM (#7410169)
But you live in the UK, which is still part of Europe, where people are still people that have rights. Your only right in the USA is the right to leave.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mwfunk on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:11PM (#7410219)
The fact that you were able to post this means that your statement is false. Using hyperbole to make a point only serves to invalidate your point, unless your audience is composed of complete idiots (not hyperbole, that's actually what I mean). I would hope that the HN readership isn't a bunch of idiots, although you obviously think they are.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by jrockway on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:25PM (#7410288)
you live in the UK where people are still people that have rights

The right to be sued for libel whenever they write something that someone else doesn't like?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by keithpeter on Sunday March 16, 2014 @02:16PM (#7410500)
Actually, we have no written Constitution, and very little in the way of actual rights in the sense that if a Constable asks us to move or go home or to search our bags, we have to let them.

Employment rights however are slightly better. The employee interviewed in the OA would have recourse to an employment tribunal for what used to be called 'constructive dismissal' - the terminology may have changed recently. The monetary compensation would be quite basic by Valley standards, but the public exposure of the employers, subject to cross-examination, would be most satisfying I imagine.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by gaius on Sunday March 16, 2014 @02:24PM (#7410538)
You do have certain rights for stop and search: https://www.gov.uk/police-powers-to-stop-and-search-your-rig...

Get all their details, and complain if you think you were treated unfairly.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by Intermernet on Monday March 17, 2014 @07:02AM (#7414315)
And the right to win in court: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BCA_v._Singh

Unfortunately, this doesn't invalidate the fact that you're correct in a way. If Simon Singh hadn't been able to afford the time and money to defend this case, the libel suit would probably have stood.

Still, it's a step in the right direction, and an important legal precedent.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by officemonkey on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:30PM (#7410828)
It seems to me she has made a pretty good case for sex discrimination, harassment, and hostile work environment.

If this happened in my company, lawyers would be crafting a settlement right now.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by glibgil on Sunday March 16, 2014 @12:37PM (#7410048)
I love github, but toxic cultures can happen anywhere. Github employees have been involved in commit abuse since the beginning https://web.archive.org/web/20130117043748/http://sheddingbi...
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by quotemstr on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:56PM (#7410414)
Yet people wonder, mouth agape, why I prefer staying up in Seattle.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by aspleenic on Monday March 17, 2014 @10:28AM (#7415170)
Location really has little to do with. While SF is a bit of a hipster enclave, so are a lot of places with plenty of tech companies.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by drawkbox on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:54PM (#7412617)
You've gotta love Zed A. Shaw, he is an entertaining truth cannon (and a great programmer).
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by krick on Sunday March 16, 2014 @11:10PM (#7412687)
Somehow I cannot find a single part of him I could love.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by drawkbox on Monday March 17, 2014 @12:02AM (#7412958)
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by rrouse on Sunday March 16, 2014 @04:10PM (#7411026)
I think it was just a user of Github and not an employee that did that nonsense
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by Bahamut on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:18PM (#7410767)
Wow...I hope that toxic github employee was fired for that.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by rrouse on Sunday March 16, 2014 @04:11PM (#7411035)
I believe it was just a user of Github and not an employee that did that nonsense.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by Bahamut on Sunday March 16, 2014 @05:22PM (#7411356)
This quote suggests more than one GitHub employee was in on it at the least:

'They purposefully allow this glaringly obvious mechanism for insulting and annoying their members and are actually involved in the joke. Until I broke their server they were all laughing at my "testing", then they were pissed when they had to fix the bug I found. If you don't believe me, look at the HackerNewsTips twitter account, which I know is astroturfed by a github employee.'

In one of the first few paragraphs, there's this block:

"The other piece of information you need to understand is that there's a sort of running hidden gag among the Ruby Iluminati (aka Rubynati) within San Francisco. Employees from Engine Yard, PowerSet, and ... github love this joke where they create code that generates ASCII art penis pictures and then force other people onto their project without permission. Here's another one called dicks by Martin Emde."

It's a shame that companies doing some useful things have to encourage a culture of brutish behavior.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by maxcan on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:23PM (#7410790)
> The wife, and the husband (founder), have displayed an incredible lack of professionalism here.

That assumes that the story, as told in the accusation, is completely accurate. One could envision a scenario where the founder felt his wife may be able to relate to the situation better and could actually assist the accuser. However, in spite of best intentions, its possible that the wife's actions were misinterpreted by the accuser. Until Github or the wife gives their side of the story, perhaps withholding judgement is the optimal strategy.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by grifpete on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:52PM (#7410942)
I don't pretend to have any info on what truly happened. But the story doesn't have to be 'completely accurate' for it to be disturbing. A company can't have family members browse around company offices and imposing themselves on employees with whom they have no professional or personal relationship. I find it very hard to understand how the wife's repeated presence can be favorably interpreted if it did indeed upset Horvath.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by maxcan on Sunday March 16, 2014 @09:13PM (#7412298)
it could have been well intentioned. bringing in an pseudo-outsider may not be the smartest move but its also not necessarily evil at all. the founder may have felt that his wife could relate in some way. until more evidence is given, we should withhold judgement.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by locusm on Monday March 17, 2014 @12:19AM (#7413028)
Things like this should be formalised though. Its very unusual for a spouse to prance around any organisation handing out directives/advice. Maybe its a sign that the founder in question doesn't have the people skills to handle her possibly dominant personality.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by maxcan on Monday March 17, 2014 @12:31PM (#7416072)
> should be

Yes, but its the difference between malice and an innocent error in judgement.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by alttab on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:30PM (#7412537)
In what scenario is having an undocumented employee ok?
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by Bluestrike2 on Monday March 17, 2014 @12:33AM (#7413073)
In these types of situations, it's usually pretty difficult to come to solid conclusions about the chain of events this early. My initial take?

It's not uncommon for business owners to rely heavily on non-employees for advice, even in the day-to-day operations. Spouses are especially common. What confuses me is that the wife, as portrayed, seems a bit irrational--if not delusional. There's a big difference between even vocal trusted advisors, and the sort of power the wife described herself as having.

So much so that I think there's a third possible interpretation: the quotes are accurate, given by a wife that genuinely believes her statements even though they have no basis in reality. This sort of delusion, in varying degrees, is quite common across the population. We convince ourselves of something--in this case, the wife that she has power in the Github organization--and then attempt to reduce the cognitive dissonance that arrises from the belief and the evidence to the contrary. As time goes on, we try harder and harder to justify those irrational beliefs.

It's entirely possible that there's no truth whatsoever to the wife's words, but that the wife genuinely believed them in spite of it. And that Julie Horvath is entirely accurate in detailing the conversation and the implied hostility she felt from the founder and his wife. So now, not only do you have to determine whether the conversation took place, but also whether the power the wife alleged existed in the first place. Unfortunately for Github, even if the wife never had that power, the wife was still able to contribute to a hostile work environment and that can have significant legal ramifications even though she wasn't an employee.

Friends you go out for drinks with to talk about life and work slowly transform into "spies" who keep you informed of what's happening in the office under the guise of gossip. Curiously taking a peek at an open chat tab on the husband's laptop becomes "access." Commenting on whether you liked a potential hire you met earlier becomes "responsibility over hires." Love for your husband and concern for his work becomes an overprotective desire to shield him from harm.

Given how rapidly Github has grown, the idea that any trusted non-employee, wife or not, would have that sort of power and influence described seems absurd. Hell, for a while it seemed as though they announced a new hire daily. Far too many for one non-employee, no matter how often she went into the office, to have that sort of power. Especially when most were technical positions.

Time will tell, but for now, more information is needed. Anyhow, I suppose I took issue with the phrase "undocumented employee" and ran off on a tangent :). The wife needn't have been an employee at all to have helped cause a shitstorm.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by alttab on Friday March 21, 2014 @02:56AM (#7441007)
So common business owners need day-to-day advice from people outside the company to run their business? I somehow doubt that.

If someone was not on payroll and interacting with my employees on a personal level and on a daily or weekly basis I would have reasons to be concerned.

Being a "start-up" doesn't make you impervious to these problems. It simply means you haven't run into them... yet.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by kaitai on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:35PM (#7412558)
Professionalism would dictate that the wife not be involved even if this is the case. I don't go tell my husband's nurses that ... well, anything!

What business do I have with my husband's colleagues other than being polite at the summer barbecue and the holiday party?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by krick on Sunday March 16, 2014 @11:03PM (#7412654)
It may be arguable, but for me non-company member being somehow related to company business is not only acceptable, but actually very nice. Being family member of the founder is reason enough to care about company, and I'd prefer informal atmosphere where people can help with business just because they care to that formal bureaucratic atmosphere that is common in banks. That's were wives come to pretty boring holidays parties and politely chuckle about boring jokes. Ugh.

Of course that doesn't include "accessing private chats of company members", but for that reason the more I read about that story the less I believe "the victim".

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by calibraxis on Monday March 17, 2014 @03:45AM (#7413681)
Combining work and marriage structures is fraught with all sorts of problematic outcomes. Consider even the differing processes to enter each institution. Or the differing standards for being successful at each.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by puppetmaster3 on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @04:23PM (#7424739)
No it does not. Management 101 is that you fire all 3 ASAP.

Also looking at her github account, she is a designer, not a developer A bit different education.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by sizzle on Sunday March 16, 2014 @08:58PM (#7412235)
from reading the article, I got the vibe that the wife may have felt innately (territorially?) threatened by the thought of a (pretty) female in the company getting close with her founder husband in a more intimate, rather than professional, type of way. Thoughts?
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by maxcan on Sunday March 16, 2014 @09:11PM (#7412292)
That raising "threatened wife" motif is actually quite sexist. Its entirely possible that the founder may have felt that his wife could relate better to the accuser but that their meeting may not have went well and the wife felt that the accuser was behaving as inappropriately as the accuser felt about the wife. Furthermore, accusing someone of "sitting near me to intimidate me" is quite vague and bizarre.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by pekk on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:08PM (#7410710)
> This is the point that stands out for me. That the wife is not an employee of Github but claims to be able to access private company chat records, and also is able to "work" from within the office and interact with the staff.

Completely ridiculous and unprofessional.

But, not sexist. Just terrible.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by PhasmaFelis on Sunday March 16, 2014 @06:23PM (#7411674)
However, the guy who declared his love for her despite knowing that she had a boyfriend, and then started sabotaging all her code when she shot him down, is very much sexist bullshit.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by MarkTee on Sunday March 16, 2014 @06:35PM (#7411714)
That's not sexism; he was acting maliciously because she turned down his advances, not because she was a woman.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by makomk on Sunday March 16, 2014 @08:14PM (#7412085)
The fact he expected to get away with it and thought it was a reasonable thing to do has, alas, quite a lot to do with both his gender and her gender.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by alttab on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:32PM (#7412543)
No, it has to do with his clear immaturity. His behavior merely justifies why he was turned down.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by krick on Sunday March 16, 2014 @11:25PM (#7412766)
Again, we should remember that it's how she perceives situation. Removing somebody's code is completely normal if you rewrite something for reason (changing interfaces, fixing properly something in other place so that piece of code becomes unused, implementing some complex mechanism which doesn't play well with that feature so that's easier to rewrite it — there are many such situations). We all like our code, but caring about it too much is unprofessional. I removed my colleagues' code hundreds of times, they removed mine. Solution seemed nice few months ago turns out to be horrible in today's light. It's just how the life goes.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by alttab on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @12:29AM (#7426815)
So if she perceives she is victimized because of her sex that qualifies it as sexism? On whose part?
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by MartinCron on Sunday March 16, 2014 @08:32PM (#7412135)
It's de-facto sexist not to be aware that sexual harassment is wrong.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by sizzle on Sunday March 16, 2014 @06:58PM (#7411780)
I've worked with brilliant engineers that lack a lot of real world social skills and this doesn't surprise me one bit. A pretty girl really can mess with the logical types of people that have little experience with the opposite sex.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by djKianoosh on Sunday March 16, 2014 @08:37PM (#7412159)
your comment is also dripping with stereotypes unfortunately
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by sizzle on Sunday March 16, 2014 @09:15PM (#7412304)
well I've witnessed this phenomenon in the real world, so I can't discount the existence of this, stereotype label aside.

I've met the opposite as well, charming, well dressed, and physically fit engineer types who can hold a conversation with the opposite sex without any awkward vibes at all.

The awkward types seem to lack some dating experience and thus cannot discern positive/negative social cues or read body language as well.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by ahomescu1 on Monday March 17, 2014 @05:38AM (#7414006)
> I've met the opposite as well, charming, well dressed, and physically fit engineer types who can hold a conversation with the opposite sex without any awkward vibes at all.

> The awkward types seem to lack some dating experience and thus cannot discern positive/negative social cues or read body language as well.

I hate replying to this, but here it goes: have you even given positive social cues to guys who weren't "charming, well dressed and physically fit engineer types"? Also, if you're only getting "awkward vibes" from unattractive guys, that might not be a problem with their social skills (at least not in the way you're putting it; charm is a social skill).

Not to mention, what does "well dressed and physically fit" even have to do with "awkward"?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by nailer on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @01:10PM (#7423273)
Dressing well and taking care of your body are social cues, that you meet the dress 'standards' of the group (whatever they are) and that you are capable of managing your own body.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mason240 on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:06PM (#7412468)
I think everyone has witnessed that phenomenon, regardless of what industry they work in.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by PhasmaFelis on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:36PM (#7412564)
...The advances that he would not have made if she were not a woman. So you're saying a man sexually harassing a woman isn't sexist?
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by MarkTee on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:44PM (#7412593)
Seeing as we don't know his sexual orientation, you don't know whether he would have made those advances if she were not a woman.

And no, a man sexually harassing a woman isn't always sexist (even though I'd imagine that in the large majority of cases sexism plays a role).

Sexual harassment ≠ Sexism

What's important to discern is the reason behind the harassment. If a man is harassing a woman because he views his gender as superior to hers, or that she's nothing more than a sexual object, then that's a pretty clear-cut case of sexism. But if a man acts inappropriately towards someone because he lacks self control/tact, has poor social skills, etc. and is only targeting that person because he's attracted to them, then it's sexual harassment.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by nodelessness on Monday March 17, 2014 @04:41AM (#7413846)
That's not sexist. Sexism is when you act out the belief that the person of other gender is inferior to yours. Singling her out for rejecting his advances is not sexist.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by countrybama24 on Monday March 17, 2014 @02:57PM (#7417233)
The idea that she's obligated to respond favorably to his advances or be punished is most definitely sexist.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by nodelessness on Monday March 17, 2014 @03:23PM (#7417431)
But that is not what happened here.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by antihero on Monday March 17, 2014 @04:17AM (#7413756)
That is the sort of thing that you should be able to fire people on the spot for, no severance, just get out you misogynistic entitled scum you deserve nothing from anyone.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by yarrel on Sunday March 16, 2014 @06:11PM (#7411615)
Agreed. There's some (alleged) sexism in the full story though.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 16, 2014 @12:38PM (#7410049)
> the question should be asked very loud and clear... "Who can access private company data, why, and for what reason?"

I am against using private github repos simply because: it's safe to assume that the NSA can access them via hardware backdoors on github's premises (as per many US ISPs), or by compromising crypto keys that github holds (as per lavabit).

It's also safe to assume that github will be legally compelled to either remain silent on this topic or lie and deny it.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by couchand on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:26PM (#7410294)
Doesn't that apply equally to any shared hosting?
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:29PM (#7410303)
It applies to any shared hosting with servers in in the US that operates above a certain scale; yes. What that certain scale is who knows, but github the most visible hosting service so is certain to be above it.

Github is great for my open source work. Everyone's allowed to see that code, even the NSA. However you can find source to LOIC on github. I'm sure that who put that there and who worked on it when would be of interest to them and form a suitable pretext for a dragnet.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by dobbsbob on Sunday March 16, 2014 @05:52PM (#7411537)
That's why evil github exists, GitTor where all your low orbit ion cannon dev trees can be uploaded without metadata.

You can also use Tor to sync small github projects through ssh. Employee internal communications should all be done away from Github and encrypted if you're working on something like p2p software and worried your flippant piracy jokes might be held up in a court room one day as "proof" your project is criminal. I would always assume all comms are stored forever and available to anybody who requests them, like lawyers looking to sue you and would like all your HipChat logs.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 16, 2014 @05:55PM (#7411552)
What is "evil github" ?
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by dobbsbob on Sunday March 16, 2014 @06:22PM (#7411667)
https://wzrtr6gpencksu3d.tor2web.org/

It's just a .onion github clone to pseudoanon share booters/LOIC and other "evil" code. It was called GitTor but I guess they recently changed the name.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by danielweber on Sunday March 16, 2014 @02:05PM (#7410459)
Yeah, because the NSA can't do anything about the service run by 2 guys in Germany. </s>
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by ef4 on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:24PM (#7410794)
It's not a question of "can't", it's a question of economics.

People keep confusing targeted attacks with bulk data collection. Nobody doubts the NSA can successfully launch a targeted attack against nearly any organization.

But that's not economical to do against everyone all the time. Whereas bulk collection of unencrypted or poorly-encrypted data from the handful of biggest cloud providers and network operators is cheap and easy.

So yes -- leaving the big providers in favor of competently-managed small-scale, lesser-known providers is probably a step up in privacy.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mpyne on Sunday March 16, 2014 @09:00PM (#7412240)
Except that legally speaking bulk collection is even easier for NSA overseas where the Fourth Amendment doesn't apply. Given the way cloud computing works all they'd have to do is "target" the top 3 or 4 cloud-based source code hosts and get everything, and there'd be no legal defense against it.

For U.S.-based cloud infrastructure it's at least possible to take it to court (as Levison did).

So it's a pick your poison thing unfortunately. If you think you can outwit targeted surveillance then by all means use an overseas hosting provider but if they would be targeting you either way then it might actually be safer doing what The Guardian does, and using U.S. law as a shield.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday March 17, 2014 @05:12AM (#7413937)
> Except that legally speaking bulk collection is even easier for NSA overseas where the Fourth Amendment doesn't apply

Treating notionally allied countries as free-fire zones is a curious definition of "easy". You run this kind of risk: http://en.alalam.ir/news/1528560

And for that reason, anyone with regard to the long term would deploy that kind of thing cautiously, if at all. But I have no idea if that applies to the NSA.

It's curious, I have seen this kind of comment on HN before, essentialy saying "US law doesn't apply in other countries therefore the NSA can do anything that they want there" ignoring that other countries have their own laws, often stricter in terms of privacy. My suspicion is that this is a particularly USAian myopia, which does not bode well for the NSA. Clearly they have gotten away with for a decade or more; but it relies on goodwill and secrecy; and those reservoirs are looking very low lately.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mpyne on Monday March 17, 2014 @01:41PM (#7416635)
> My suspicion is that this is a particularly USAian myopia, which does not bode well for the NSA.

I am telling you literally like it is. Whether or not you want the Fourth Amendment to apply outside of the U.S. (keeping in mind that amendment is the only part of U.S. constitutional law restricting electronic surveillance by the U.S. government anywhere in the world), the fact is that legally speaking it doesn't. I'm not telling you how the world should be here, I'm telling you how it actually is.

This is not specific to the U.S. though. Does Germany have constitutional laws forbidding them to collect intelligence from networks in France?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Monday March 17, 2014 @01:58PM (#7416778)
> Whether or not you want the Fourth Amendment to apply outside

Now you have changed the subject. The original assertion was that it was "easier" for the NSA to collect bulk data outside of the USA. If the 4th amendment was the only factor then it might be so. My point was that the 4th is not the only factor.

For another example of this, how seriously would someone like Lavabit take a US court order to hand over keys and shut up if they were based in Reykjavík?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mpyne on Monday March 17, 2014 @08:03PM (#7419009)
> Except that legally speaking bulk collection is even easier

Did you miss the "legally speaking" in my original sentence before you accused me of changing the subject?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @05:12AM (#7420890)
I did actually miss that, and the purely legal aspect of it is not the whole and interesting picture. But I don't think that it makes a difference.

TAO (I.e computer network exploitation) may be easier if you possess a legal/ethical framework whereby allied counties are free-fire zones; at least up to the point when they're no longer allied.

But bulk data collection is not TAO. As far as I can see, it relies on firstly on physical access to network infrastructure, so you can put a secret room at the Phone company or copy off the network traffic off the undersea cable as it lands. This is legally easier in your own country.

Secondly it relies on legal authority over companies. US agents arrived at lavabit with a US court order to hand over the crypto keys and tell no-one. How would that play for a company based in Reykjavik? I expect that after the laughter and blog posts, a bit like this: http://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/view/30559/iceland-expe...

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by mpyne on Tuesday March 18, 2014 @06:14PM (#7425421)
> But bulk data collection is not TAO.

Except, of course, when TAO allows you access to data in bulk. That was my whole point, and if you guys keep conflating legal jurisdiction, technical capabilities, and scope of effect with each other then you'll have only yourself to blame when you get outwitted and your data ends up in a database with ALLCAPS naming conventions. :P

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @04:59AM (#7427413)
> when TAO allows you access to data in bulk

You should write an article about that, I do like to learn more. So long as it doesn't consist of "lol you got outwitted :P" style taunting.

Interesting how your loyalties are expressed in that comment. BTW, based on your other comments, what exactly do you do "in the military" ?

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:45PM (#7410894)
Quite right. Even better is hosting your git yourself so that the data never leaves the premises. it is more work; but from a security point of view it's even better.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by cbsmith on Sunday March 16, 2014 @03:59PM (#7410970)
Actually, it applies equally to private hosting too.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 16, 2014 @05:56PM (#7411556)
But no so much to on-premises self-hosting. I am talking about the danger of bulk data collection here, as per https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7410794
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by rmc on Monday March 17, 2014 @08:18AM (#7414580)
Eh, any US based hosting is potentially vulnerble to that. Even non-US based hosting is vulnerble to you being hacked by the NSA. But a company allowing non-employees access is a very different situtation.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by cwilson on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:23AM (#7409490)
It's as easy as the wife grabbing the husbands laptop and scanning the Hipchat logs.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by rmc on Monday March 17, 2014 @08:19AM (#7414585)
The article claims GitHub said that the wife would "work from home". Why would a company say that a non-employee would "work from home". Why would a company allow a non-employee to get into the office that much?

This sounds a lot worse and blatant than just shoulder surfing at home.

Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by skyebook on Sunday March 16, 2014 @10:47AM (#7409563)
GitHub uses campfire, but HipChat does not give any way for a account owners/admins to read personal 1-1 chat logs.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:13PM (#7410226)
Hipchat user/admin; agreed. I don't have access to 1 on 1 chat logs and I prefer it that way.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by skyebook on Sunday March 16, 2014 @11:27PM (#7412779)
Same exact situation for me, definitely don't want to be reading anyone else's chats or for there to be any concern that someone might be listening in.
Re:Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behin... by api on Sunday March 16, 2014 @01:56PM (#7410411)
"Who can access private company data, why, and for what reason?".

But the cloud. The cloud!