News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by danielweber on Thursday March 13, 2014 @11:42AM (#7392516)
I'd love this. If American public transportation fans would stop fantasizing about trains and instead do what really works for most people -- buses -- then we could have things a lot better.

I've been waiting for years for a service that dispatches a nice bus to ride in on my way to work without me having to walk/drive to a bus stop and hope the schedule is right.

I'd accept a modest increase in the commute time if I could read/sleep/play/watch TV for the duration of the commute.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by untog on Thursday March 13, 2014 @11:54AM (#7392614)
If American public transportation fans would stop fantasizing about trains and instead do what really works for most people -- buses

Trains really work for large numbers of people. A single NYC subway train can carry something like 2,400 people. A bus can carry something like 1/10 of that at best. Once you factor in the subway and local train services to New Jersey, CT, Long Island and Upstate New York you really, really don't want to think of buses as the future of mass transit in dense urban areas.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by willyt on Thursday March 13, 2014 @01:16PM (#7393162)
The trouble is, trains require a certain density to be economic and to run a frequent enough service to be convenient. The ideal city density for an efficient metro service is roughly equivalent to streets of 4 or 5 storey apartment blocks. If you've ever been to Barcelona then you'll have an idea of the ideal density. Very few urbanised areas of the US meet this requirement and most of the areas that do fit the bill date back to before the 1920's and already have mass transit. Buses can operate in cities of lower density, but still require a certain critical mass. I don't have the figures to hand but there has to be a certain number of households within 5 minutes walk of a bus stop to make it viable and many suburbs aren't dense enough for this. See the book 'Cities for a small planet'. Also the Reith lectures on this topic: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00gxns8
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by benesch on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:01PM (#7392666)
Oh god. Even a bi-articulated bus with 240 people on it is emphatically not a bus I would want to be on.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by anologwintermut on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:09PM (#7394122)
The story that trains are superior for high density is not necessarily true. Buses with dedicated lanes appear to have high throughputs and lower infrastructure costs ( not to mention can continue to run into lower density areas or have routes more easily changed as the population density shifts).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_rapid_transit#Comparison_wi...

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by tacticus on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:57PM (#7394962)
But significantly greater operational costs. Those comparisons are with light rail not heavy rail like the new york subway.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by soperj on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:52PM (#7393003)
Helsinki has a subway though. This is on top of that.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by tricolon on Friday March 14, 2014 @03:37AM (#7397388)
Helsinki has a tram system (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_tram) and bus system. The metro is mostly for getting to/from East Helsinki (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_metro).
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by tuukkah on Friday March 14, 2014 @05:14AM (#7397618)
The single metro/subway line is nothing compared to bigger cities, but don't forget the three urban railways and the hugely popular bus rapid transit (line 550)! These form the basis for a network of high-service trunk lines in this wide urban area of only 1.4 million inhabitants.

Here's a nice schematic of what the system will look like in 2016 when the subway extension west of Ruoholahti is complete, the lines 560 and 500 have started, and the M and I trains have expanded to become the airport trains V and P: http://www.flickr.com/photos/29682104@N04/9711135644/

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by maxerickson on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:03PM (#7392681)
Sure. Trains work great where you already have them and lots of people that want to ride them. They also work pretty well if you have a massive budget and the political will and power to build out sensible routes.

So they don't work for a whole bunch of the U.S.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by mikeash on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:08PM (#7392710)
Budget, political will, and power are three sides of the same coin (you heard me), and one person's "fantasizing about trains" is another person's "trying to convince the public that it's worth spending the money".
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by danielweber on Thursday March 13, 2014 @01:54PM (#7393444)
Yes, keep the trains where you have them. But to reduce car ridership, work on making buses good enough that professionals want to take them to get to work.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by adambard on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:53PM (#7394941)
You might be interested to learn about the successful bus rapid transit system in Curitiba, Brazil:

"Buses running in the dedicated lanes stop at cylindrical, clear-walled tube stations with turnstiles, steps, and wheelchair lifts. Passengers pay their fares as they enter the stations, and wait for buses on raised platforms. Instead of steps, buses have extra wide doors and ramps that extend out to the station platform when the doors open. The tube stations serve the dual purpose of providing shelter from the elements, and facilitating the simultaneous loading and unloading of passengers, including wheelchairs, efficiently. This system of same-level bus boarding, plus the pre-boarding fare payment, results in a typical dwell time of no more than 15 to 19 seconds at a stop."[1]

[1] http://www.urbanhabitat.org/node/344

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by jasondemeuse on Thursday March 13, 2014 @11:57AM (#7392638)
>do what really works for most people -- buses

Do buses really work better for most people? I live in Chicago and it seems like most people I know (including me) ride the trains unless it can be avoided.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by mikeash on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:13PM (#7392744)
It seems to be universal. I've seen it in places from SF to DC to small-town France to Beijing: the bus a second choice that you only take when the train doesn't go where you need it to go.

I'm still trying to figure out why, though. Despite sharing that opinion myself, I still can't quite figure out what the concrete reasons are. It seems to come down to: subway routes are much easier to figure out, stops are much better labeled, and the ride is much more comfortable. However, those first two don't seem like inherent problems with buses, merely how they happen to be built, but it seems like they're that way everywhere.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by cameldrv on Thursday March 13, 2014 @02:26PM (#7393743)
Trains are faster if they're grade separated because they don't have to wait for traffic. Not waiting for traffic also makes them more reliable, especially during rush hour. If you can't rely on the schedule, you have to put padding into your schedule, which makes them effectively even slower. Trains are also faster because they have lots of doors and the passengers are waiting at the same level as the doors, and you're not waiting for people to buy tickets, so the stops are quicker. Since they move faster, you can also run a more frequent service with the same number of vehicles (driver cost is a very large component of operating costs of a public transit system) They're also smoother and so more pleasant to ride. You're usually also waiting for them out of the elements.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by peeters on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:17PM (#7395134)
The grade separation is a big thing. When I compare taking the bus in Toronto to taking the bus in Ottawa, which has (some) dedicated transitways for buses, complete with dedicated overpasses and bridges, there's a world of difference.

For an example, follow the roads in this satellite imagery: https://www.google.ca/maps/@45.4116853,-75.6640352,489m/data...

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by kgermino on Thursday March 13, 2014 @02:56PM (#7393993)
The thing is "They're also smoother and so more pleasant to ride. " is the only thing on that list that's even remotely inherent to trains over buses. Yet you rarely see people arguing to improve the buses so the other things you mentioned aren't an issue.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by cameldrv on Thursday March 13, 2014 @08:51PM (#7396267)
Ok, but if you take a bus and do all of the things I mentioned to it, you end up with a "rubber tire metro", which does exist, and is used in Paris and Mexico city, at least. These are basically indistinguishable from a passenger perspective to a train. The smoothness of trains is really out of necessity. If the tracks weren't smooth, the train would derail.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by tacticus on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:01PM (#7394995)
Capacity is significantly higher and stop frequency significantly lower allowing a high speed high volume route.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by Fishkins on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:24PM (#7392810)
I'd say the biggest reason is they aren't subject to traffic or (usually) weather, which makes them much faster and more consistent in urban areas. All the other factors are just little perks IMO. Although I personally like that I can read on a train without getting motion sickness, but not on a bus.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by mradamh on Thursday March 13, 2014 @02:17PM (#7393660)
I'm sure I am in the minority, but avoid bus trips wherever possible because I get horribly motion sick on them. I few years ago I had a job with a 20 minute bus commute and it was torture. I'd break out in a cold sweat every time and stagger off the bus feeling light headed and dizzy.

This does seem to be an inherent problem for me with road vehicles. I experience a similar problem riding in the back of a car. I'm not immune from motion sickness on trains, but it is an order of magnitude better.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by andrewf on Thursday March 13, 2014 @06:36PM (#7395633)
Have you tried medication? (Took me years to realize that feeling sick on an hours-long coach ride need not be inevitable)
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:23PM (#7392803)
> I'm still trying to figure out why, though.

I'm in Chicago, same as OP. The elevated train has exclusive access to the tracks, whereas busses have to compete with private vehicles on the road. I'd rather be on the El.

Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by TillE on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:16PM (#7392767)
I agree with all three of your reasons, and I'll add another big one: speed. Trains are faster, both inherently and because they make fewer stops.
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by ForHackernews on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:55PM (#7395387)
Re:Helsinki’s personalized bus service is like Uber for publ... by galago on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:35PM (#7392879)
The reason light rail makes sense, at least in Portland, Oregon is that its cheaper per ride to operate. Personally, I would rather ride MAX than a bus. http://trimet.org/about/dashboard.htm#efficiency