News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by Eliezer on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:56PM (#7336028)
I'm amazed that anything this obviously correct is entering the Overton Window. Next we'll hear someone advocating land value taxes.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:42PM (#7336305)
Could you explain why this is obviously correct? It's not obvious to me. To me, the Fed's current process of bidding on very liquid, publicly sold assets seems to be the most neutral way of injecting dollars into the world.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by nostromo on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:48PM (#7336341)
But that benefits the rich disproportionately.

Rather than injecting new money into the financial and government sectors and hoping for a trickle down effect, it seems much more fair to just cut checks to all citizens.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:52PM (#7336361)
How does it benefit the rich?

Suppose I'm rich. The Fed creates a dollar. The Fed offers me a dollar for my treasury bill worth $1. I accept. As a result, I am now a dollar richer but a $1 treasury bill poorer. Have I gained? I have $1 more in money, but $1 less in assets. So I'd say no, I haven't gained. The only way I gain is if the Fed pays me more than the treasury bill is worth. And since the Fed pays market price, this is difficult to do.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by jellicle on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:19PM (#7336555)
If the Fed instead decided to hire poor citizens to dig ditches and build roads at a flat rate of $12/hour, the effect would be obvious to everyone - "they're distorting the minimum wage labor market! driving honest Walmarts out of business! businesses won't be able to find anyone for $7.25/hour, they'll have to pay more!"

Every right-wing commenter in the world would immediately see that this is wealth redistributing socialism and needs to be stopped instantly.

It's the same if you decide to pay rich people for their bonds. Only, you know, it helps rich people instead. You bought a million dollars of bonds last year, this year you can sell them for $1.1 million. The profit goes straight into the pockets of... people who can afford to buy a million dollars of bonds.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by yummyfajitas on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:02PM (#7336433)
To be completely fair, the fed will move the market a little bit and will have to cross the spread.

I.e. if the bid/ask is $100/$100.5, the fed will have to buy at $100.5, even if the next market trade might have happened at $100.25. So the rich owners of treasuries do reap a small reward, something on the order of the size of the spread.

That said, your point is generally correct. Buying treasuries results in $100 of money injected into the economy, while redistributing only $0.25 of wealth.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by notahacker on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:46PM (#7336728)
Focusing on what happens at the margin also excludes the bigger picture, which is that the act of carrying out monetary expansion through the issue of bonds paying risk-free real interest (as opposed to helicopter dropping printed money or channeling it through fiscal policy) is a big subsidy for fractional reserve banks and cautious holders of liquid wealth.

That's not to say there aren't massive gains to society from a policy mechanism that both provides a relatively efficient and reversible means to manage inflation and helps stabilise the banking system, but the fact is it favours the wealthy much more than the alternatives.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by nerfhammer on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:45PM (#7336722)
In principle increase on the demand side will raise the price of a commodity short term.

Meanwhile raising the market price of bonds makes debt servicing less expensive, saving taxpayers' money. Unless the market expects inflation, lowering bond prices again.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:53PM (#7337139)
I'm not convinced it really injects the full $100. It's swapping something that's basically cash for something that is cash.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by code4life on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:18PM (#7336548)
In many ways, I'll describe two.

The newly created money is worth more when it's new. When the average person finally receives the money, the value is worth less through inflation.

Secondly, the rich can borrow money from the fed at 0%. Then they can buy bonds from the government and receive interest on that. How does the average person do that?

Re:Free Money for Everyone by scotty79 on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:34PM (#7337035)
> How does it benefit the rich?

I guess you are vastly more likely to own a treasury bill if you are rich.

If you are poor Fed buying treasury bills does nothing for you.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by pedrocr on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:08PM (#7336478)
>The only way I gain is if the Fed pays me more than the treasury bill is worth. And since the Fed pays market price, this is difficult to do.

The Fed is a large enough new buyer that it will move the market price.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by natrius on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:46PM (#7336330)
Only the wealthiest Americans (and foreigners for that matter) own the assets the Fed is bidding on. It is not neutral.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by nerfhammer on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:35PM (#7336667)
Who owns treasury bonds?

* Foreign - $5.724 trillion (national breakdown: http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/ti... or http://www.gao.gov/special.pubs/longterm/images/countries_la...)

* Social Security (Social Security Trust Fund and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Fund) - $2.764 trillion

* Federal Reserve - $1.794 trillion

* Other (individuals, government-sponsored enterprises, brokers and dealers, bank personal trusts and estates, corporate and non-corporate businesses, and other investors) - $1.497 trillion.

* Mutual Funds - $946.4 billion

* Office of Personnel Management (Federal Employees Retirement, Life Insurance, Hospital Insurance Trust Funds, Postal Service Retiree Contributions) - $826.8 billion

* State and Local Government, including their pension funds - $703.5 billion

* Private Pension Funds - $457.7 billion

* Military Retirement Fund - $419.5 billion

* Banks - $341.4 billion

* Insurance Companies - $263.3 billion

* Dept. of Health and Human Services (Federal Hospital Insurance Trust Fund, Federal Supplementary Medical Insurance Trust Fund) - $260 billion

* Other Federal Programs and Funds - $260 billion

* Uniformed Services Retiree Health Care Fund - $189 billion

* U.S. Savings Bonds - $181.7 billion

* Department of Energy - $54.8 billion.

* Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation - $33 billion

* Department of Labor (Unemployment Trust Fund) - $30 billion

* Department of the Treasury (Exchange Stabilization Fund) - $26 billion

Re:Free Money for Everyone by natrius on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:57PM (#7336804)
This doesn't refute my claim that buying treasuries disproportionately benefits the wealthy.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by nerfhammer on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:27PM (#7336994)
if you add up all of the taxpayer funded entities and pension funds and savings bonds I get about 48%
Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:36PM (#7338086)
If 48% is distributed over 100% of the population, and 52% is distributed over 1% of the population, that sounds pretty disproportionate to me.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by nerfhammer on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:14PM (#7338211)
If A then q does not imply if !A then !q
Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:31PM (#7338274)
Logically true, of course, but I really don't see how you can assign A and q in any way that makes that relevant. My statement was in support of "This doesn't refute my claim that buying treasuries disproportionately benefits the wealthy.". If there's a plausible situation that's consistent with the data, for which the claim is clearly true, the data does not refute the claim (it may still be some evidence against the claim, if alternate claims are more strongly supported, but "refute" reads substantially stronger).

Note that this is quite distinct from my supporting "buying treasuries disproportionately benefits the wealthy" - I am not convinced enough to hold a real opinion on that either way. Reading back further, I see the original claim was in fact "Only the wealthiest Americans (and foreigners for that matter) own the assets the Fed is bidding on", which claim the data certainly contradicts.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by nerfhammer on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @12:48AM (#7338722)
A = 48% of the debt

!A = 52% of the debt

q = not owned by the wealthy or foreigners

!q = owned by wealthy or foreigners

I believe the data shows A && q, but !A && !q is much less clear and A && q is larger than many people might expect, that's all. A && q does not mean !(!A && !q) as you point out.

Around half of !q is owned by foreigners, mostly foreign central banks, so there's that. The distribution of the remainder of !q is unclear.

Also, note the difference between "benefits" vs. "own" which are not the same. Buying bonds has a variety of effects. Buying a bond from someone benefits the former owner immediately but raising the price of bonds lowers bond yields making buying all new bonds less profitable. It also lowers the cost of financing all government debt, benefiting all taxpayers. But reducing bond yields tends to increase the demand for other assets, such as stocks, increasing the paper value of stocks. Similar story for pushing dollars abroad to foreign bond holders, sending dollars abroad makes the dollar cheaper, boosting exports and hurting imports but reducing market bond yields should do the opposite. But if the market expects inflation from quantitative easing it should reduce the future value of money, increasing bond yields again, but tends to depress stocks but not value stocks as much...

Simply put, the claim that buying bonds helps the wealthy is an idea that needs a lot more support than thoughtless one-liners that twang the emotional strings of power and betrayal.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @12:55AM (#7338741)
"A = 48% of the debt

!A = 52% of the debt

q = not owned by the wealthy or foreigners

!q = owned by wealthy or foreigners"

None of those is really logical negation (it's set complement), hence my confusion.

"I believe the data shows A && q, but !A && !q is much less clear."

I agree. I don't believe the data shows the claim you label "!A && !q" - I do believe it admits it.

Your later point - that effects outside bonds probably dominate effects confined to bond prices - I think is correct.

"Simply put, the claim that buying bonds helps the wealthy is an idea that needs a lot more support than thoughtless one-liners that twang the emotional strings of power and betrayal."

Certainly the case.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:42PM (#7336702)
Thanks for bringing some facts into the discussion.

One thing I'd like to point out from your list above is that Social Security is the largest owner of treasury bonds. If the Fed buys treasury bonds from Social Security, that is essentially distributing money to lots of people directly - exactly the suggestion of this thread's article! :)

(Though it's not really the same, since they buy treasury bonds in an open market, not directly from Social Security. The amount of bond-buying has nothing to do with the amount of Social Security checks going out, which is a good thing, in my opinion.)

Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:50PM (#7336347)
Could you please explain why the money going to wealthy people is a problem?

I think it's fine for $100 million to go wealthy people if the wealthy people lose $100 million of treasuries at the same time. It only becomes a problem if the Fed overpays for the assets. Which is why it's so important to pick giant liquid asset markets like US treasuries. Giant liquid markets are the least likely to be distorted by Fed action.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by sheetjs on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:22PM (#7336568)
> It only becomes a problem if the Fed overpays for the assets.

Which is precisely what happened. Many of the toxic assets that are now on the fed balance sheet would have been close to worthless (if not completely worthless)

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dredmorbius on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:17PM (#7338228)
I actually had the opportunity to ask this question of a regional FR Bank president a year or so back. Specifically: how does the Fed assess the value of the assets its buying?

The answer was: they don't. They're bidding at auction, so to that extent, the value is market-based (banks with assets they think are valued over what the Fed is paying will withhold those assets), but to the extent that it's pretty much the Fed creating this market of and by itself, there's not much competition.

The interest of the Fed isn't in buying valuable assets. It's in injecting liquidity, that is, cash, dollars, into the financial system.

I've kicked myself for not having asked another question (how is the banking system supposed to work and lend when real returns on financial capital are negative), but the one I did ask and the answer I got were informative and illuminating to me.

The question I didn't ask, it turns out, has been asked by others (though I need to track down specific instances). The declining real returns of investment is something that's been specifically noted, see Deloitte's Shift Index:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2012/01/25/shift-in...

http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1y3z3n/the_shif...

Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:46PM (#7337688)
Could you please clarify which assets you're talking about? Is it the Fed's MBS portfolio?

So far your worry has not borne out. The Fed has been earning about $80 billion per year, and its MBS portfolio is worth about $1 trillion.

http://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21570753...

Re:Free Money for Everyone by natrius on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:00PM (#7336412)
I don't think it's a problem per se, but it's not neutral. When the Fed purchases $100 million of treasuries with new money, it makes wealthy people as a class $100 million richer.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:14PM (#7336529)
Could you please explain how it makes them $100 million richer?

They have $100 million more in money, but $100 million less in assets. Their net worth is unchanged. They are not richer, even when considered as a class.

(I think your comments could be improved if you made some of your thinking more explicit. I have difficulty following your lines of reasoning. Brevity has value, but also cost.)

Re:Free Money for Everyone by natrius on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:38PM (#7336680)
"$100 million richer" is wrong, but increasing the demand for treasuries makes them worth more, which makes their holders more wealthy.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:03PM (#7336844)
Consider the following. I am the Fed.

(1) I announce that my general policy will be to buy treasuries when I want to spur inflation

(2) I announce that next week I am going to buy $100 million of treasuries.

(3) I actually buy the treasuries.

A very interesting question is: At which point (1, 2, or 3) was demand increased?

(I would argue that if Fed purchases are expected, they do not change the price and treasury owners do not benefit.)

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:49PM (#7338127)
Assuming they don't execute in sufficient quantity for there to be liquidity issues, at each point the price will change to incorporate the market's guess as to how much they'll be buying relative to how much various parties want to sell - which will be entirely accurate after (3), and fairly accurate after (2). Whether it goes up or down for 2 and 3 depends on whether the market has over- or underestimated just prior, but it will certainly be up at each point over the Fed holding a different policy. Since the Fed's policy is what we're discussing (rather than whether we should be long or short T-bills just prior to each event), the distinctions you're making aren't terribly important.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by warfangle on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:24PM (#7336593)
The difference is, distributing $100 million to the already-wealthy does not incur increases in aggregate demand (it might, in fact, decrease it), as the wealthy tend to lock up their funds in financial instruments (from bonds to stocks). And invest in a company (stocks) all you want, if there's no demand for what it's selling.... why are you investing?
Re:Free Money for Everyone by tedsanders on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:56PM (#7336797)
I think your answer is a bit self-contradictory.

The only way for the $100 million not to enter the money supply is for the wealthy to hold $100 million more in cash. If they invest it in bonds and stocks, then now the previous holders of those bonds and stocks hold the cash.

The point of distributing the money is so that money is worth less and prices become effectively lower, causing people to buy more stuff and businesses to make more stuff (i.e., monetary stimulus of aggregate demand).

Here is a blog post on the hot potato effect: http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=23314

Re:Free Money for Everyone by warfangle on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:56PM (#7337155)
Yet the previous owners of those bonds and stocks who now hold the cash are likely members of the same elite investment class, and immediately ... reinvest it in bonds and stocks, instead of spending it on goods and services. (unless they are the recipients of, say, social security -- the biggest single investor in government bonds)

edit: replied without reading the HPE post. My point, I guess, is that this helicopter drop of cash, if evenly distributed (e.g., every US citizen received 3.19488818e-9 of it), would disproportionally be distributed to those who would spend it immediately, increasing aggregate demand - compared to those few percent who would just add it to their investment portfolio.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by NateDad on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:11PM (#7336502)
By definition, anything you're selling is something you value less than the money you're getting paid for it. Otherwise you wouldn't sell it, right?

Also, things like land and real estate tend to be bought at steep discounts and then sold for huge profits.

Finally, having a $3m house is not the same as having $3m in cash.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by kaonashi on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:09PM (#7336486)
Except it doesn't do anything to change net incomes, only composition of financial assets/cash (which are very similar to begin with).
Re:Free Money for Everyone by toomuchtodo on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:38PM (#7336280)
> land value taxes

What is the value of a land value tax? (ELI5)

Re:Free Money for Everyone by 3825 on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:50PM (#7336346)
In the most basic sense, land value tax would mean that the tax would be the same whether your land was just sitting there empty or you had a hundred-story skyscraper on it.

I don't know what that effects it would have. I assume the first and most direct effect would be budget shortfalls in local governments which would probably try to create more fines[0] and sin taxes (assuming they are still legal).

[0] LA has an almost $200 fine for jaywalking. I'd argue that fines and confiscated money from drugs should never go into general treasury much less directly used to fund the department collecting such fines and confiscations. Our government should run on taxes alone and not on fines and fees. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/26/us/in-a-car-culture-clash-...

Re:Free Money for Everyone by notahacker on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:52PM (#7336772)
Land which is worth enough to put a hundred story skyscraper on it usually doesn't stay empty for long, especially if the landowner is paying the same tax rates as the owners of the surrounding city centre lots.

There's no a priori reason to assume that land value taxes would either fully replace other tax systems or not be revenue neutral. If collected locally, they might even favour well-managed local governments who should see their investment in better services reflected in higher land prices.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:39PM (#7338298)
Interestingly, it would be a huge blow to cars in cities, as parking would need to get substantially more expensive.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:47PM (#7336734)
"I don't know what that effects it would have. I assume the first and most direct effect would be budget shortfalls in local governments which would probably try to create more fines[0] and sin taxes (assuming they are still legal)."

In principle you could have a revenue neutral transition to a land-value tax. In practice, it might very well lead to crazy numbers.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by praptak on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:00PM (#7336421)
I cannot ELY5 because I don't find that simple nor obvious and it would also require explaining the distinction of "unimproved" land value, but: "Ground-rents are a still more proper subject of taxation than the rent of houses. A tax upon ground-rents would not raise the rents of houses. It would fall altogether upon the owner of the ground-rent, who acts always as a monopolist, and exacts the greatest rent which can be got for the use of his ground." - Adam Smith
Re:Free Money for Everyone by toomuchtodo on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:06PM (#7336457)
Thank you!
Re:Free Money for Everyone by Antiquarian on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:28PM (#7336219)
Be still my heart.