Which is precisely what happened. Many of the toxic assets that are now on the fed balance sheet would have been close to worthless (if not completely worthless)
The answer was: they don't. They're bidding at auction, so to that extent, the value is market-based (banks with assets they think are valued over what the Fed is paying will withhold those assets), but to the extent that it's pretty much the Fed creating this market of and by itself, there's not much competition.
The interest of the Fed isn't in buying valuable assets. It's in injecting liquidity, that is, cash, dollars, into the financial system.
I've kicked myself for not having asked another question (how is the banking system supposed to work and lend when real returns on financial capital are negative), but the one I did ask and the answer I got were informative and illuminating to me.
The question I didn't ask, it turns out, has been asked by others (though I need to track down specific instances). The declining real returns of investment is something that's been specifically noted, see Deloitte's Shift Index:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2012/01/25/shift-in...
http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1y3z3n/the_shif...
So far your worry has not borne out. The Fed has been earning about $80 billion per year, and its MBS portfolio is worth about $1 trillion.
http://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21570753...
They have $100 million more in money, but $100 million less in assets. Their net worth is unchanged. They are not richer, even when considered as a class.
(I think your comments could be improved if you made some of your thinking more explicit. I have difficulty following your lines of reasoning. Brevity has value, but also cost.)
(1) I announce that my general policy will be to buy treasuries when I want to spur inflation
(2) I announce that next week I am going to buy $100 million of treasuries.
(3) I actually buy the treasuries.
A very interesting question is: At which point (1, 2, or 3) was demand increased?
(I would argue that if Fed purchases are expected, they do not change the price and treasury owners do not benefit.)
The only way for the $100 million not to enter the money supply is for the wealthy to hold $100 million more in cash. If they invest it in bonds and stocks, then now the previous holders of those bonds and stocks hold the cash.
The point of distributing the money is so that money is worth less and prices become effectively lower, causing people to buy more stuff and businesses to make more stuff (i.e., monetary stimulus of aggregate demand).
Here is a blog post on the hot potato effect: http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=23314
edit: replied without reading the HPE post. My point, I guess, is that this helicopter drop of cash, if evenly distributed (e.g., every US citizen received 3.19488818e-9 of it), would disproportionally be distributed to those who would spend it immediately, increasing aggregate demand - compared to those few percent who would just add it to their investment portfolio.
Also, things like land and real estate tend to be bought at steep discounts and then sold for huge profits.
Finally, having a $3m house is not the same as having $3m in cash.
I think it's fine for $100 million to go wealthy people if the wealthy people lose $100 million of treasuries at the same time. It only becomes a problem if the Fed overpays for the assets. Which is why it's so important to pick giant liquid asset markets like US treasuries. Giant liquid markets are the least likely to be distorted by Fed action.