News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Girls and Software by timr on Sunday February 09, 2014 @02:50PM (#7206846)
I'm torn. I think she makes some really good points -- particularly about discouraging young girls and the futility of shoving adult humans into foreign social situations -- but I also think she might be rather narrowly defining the personality type of a "hacker", and dismissing behaviors that she doesn't find valuable (in her words: "ephemera -- popularity, beauty and fitting in").

Maybe it's possible that there are plenty of people out there who care about "ephemera", and yet are also capable of programming a computer or soldering things together? I think it's possible. And when I read stuff like this:

"Sometimes I want to shout 'you're not a programmer, what are you doing here?!'"

it makes me think: this might be a problem. Is it harder to be a hacker if you also have an interest in social media and graphic design and popularity and friendships? Are we defining "hacker" to include only people with bad social skills and no interest outside of technology? I hope not.

Re:Girls and Software by bitwize on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:18PM (#7207006)
For the longest time I harbored the biggest crush on a girl from my high school. The thing that made me fall in love with her (and it was love -- as much love as a 14-year-old could feel) wasn't that she was pretty or cute or popular -- though she was all these things. (Head cheerleader. Literally. Dated a football player and everything.)

It was that I had the good fortune to peek over her shoulder at some BASIC code she'd written in our completely noddy, intro-to-computers class. She wasn't going to put Grace Hopper to shame, but it was surprisingly well-structured and showed she knew how to reason about causes and effects within the machine. Which is, like, the first skill that you need to be a decent programmer.

But the thing about pretty girls is that they often find it is more immediately profitable to be pretty than to be bright. And staying pretty and popular -- keeping that limelight on you -- is a lot of work. It's a full-time job with potentially ruinous consequences without some sort of balance (look at Miley Cyrus). So she eventually forgot about coding and went on to become a television personality.

My point here is that you become what you invest time in becoming. If you want to ascend to elite-level hackerdom, then you almost have to put things like attractiveness and popularity on the back burner. You don't have to have poor social skills to be a hacker. But the people who are best at being popular and fitting in are the people who invested time and effort into doing just that, just like the best programmers are the ones who invested time and effort into programming. And we only have so much time to give, so yes, you kinda gotta pick and choose.

Re:Girls and Software by timr on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:39PM (#7207112)
"My point here is that you become what you invest time in becoming. If you want to ascend to elite-level hackerdom, then you almost have to put things like attractiveness and popularity on the back burner."

No, you really don't. You believe this because it's what you've seen around you, but that's a selection bias. Someone else on this thread pointed out that Von Neumann was an exceptionally stylish guy, but he's far from the only example. Only in the peculiar little world of computer programming do we seem to equate slovenly behavior with competence.

One of the great qualities of smart, capable people is that smart, capable people tend to have a lot of different interests. There's no reason that you can't be attractive and smart.

"Specialization is for insects." -- Heinlein

Re:Girls and Software by gwern on Sunday February 09, 2014 @04:12PM (#7207258)
> Someone else on this thread pointed out that Von Neumann was an exceptionally stylish guy, but he's far from the only example.

So your solution is to suggest everyone be as smart as John von Neumann so they can master subjects while still being a snappy dresser? Does this seem like something people can do?

The proverbial 10k hours of practice have to come from somewhere. Time is limited, activities are zero-sum.

Re:Girls and Software by arrrg on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:19PM (#7207912)
I don’t think anyone was suggesting that.

Many hackers I know do have other hobbies besides hacking and they devote lots of time to those hobbies. Beer brewing, coffee making, writing poetry, music, languages, …

What if one of those hobbies is dressing fashionably? Or makeup? Or whatever?

Beyond a certain point activities are zero sum but do you seriously suggest that to be a proper hacker you have no time at all for anything beside that?

I don’t think anyone should ever feel obligated to be into dressing fashionably or makeup or even just feel obligated to dress a certain way. That’s awful. (I especially hate gender policing.) But telling someone they can only be part of the group if they aren’t into makeup isn’t all that much better than telling someone they should wear makeup to represent women better.

It’s a heuristic for identifying in-group people that makes no sense and to me seems highly destructive.

Re:Girls and Software by nitrogen on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:30PM (#7208266)
It’s a heuristic for identifying in-group people that makes no sense and to me seems highly destructive.

I suspect this heuristic started out as a way for the outcast, socially unwelcome hackers to finally find a group to which they could belong, an activity that didn't judge them for their intellect or their appearance.

I further suspect that some of the pushback against lifting this heuristic comes from those same people, who feel that they will lose the only thing that gave them a reason to feel good about themselves in the face of total rejection by their peers. It would be just as tragic to force these people out of programming as it is tragic to prevent others from coming into programming.

Re:Girls and Software by arrrg on Sunday February 09, 2014 @08:07PM (#7208438)
Oh man, even more zero sum thinking.

Outcasts making others outcasts, bullied becoming bullies. Nice.

The general point is this: rejection because of the way you dress (no matter how) or look (no matter how) is not cool. The direction doesn’t really matter. But this groupthink is pretty disgustingly exclusionary.

Re:Girls and Software by nitrogen on Sunday February 09, 2014 @09:41PM (#7208774)
From the article:

Most of all, I'm disappointed. I had a haven, a place where no one cared what I looked like, what my body was like or about any ephemera—they cared about what I could do—and this culture shift has robbed me of my haven. At least I had that haven. The girls who follow me missed out on it.

You know what's disgusting? People getting disgusted over issues that don't warrant disgust.

Re:Girls and Software by arrrg on Sunday February 09, 2014 @10:07PM (#7208862)
I’m not sure how exclusionary rhetoric follows from that. It just doesn’t make any sense to me.

Also, I think that statement is just outright wrong and misleading.

Re:Girls and Software by nitrogen on Sunday February 09, 2014 @10:20PM (#7208910)
I wrote my first comment before reading the article, and later found that paragraph in which the article's author seemed to share my sentiments.

In my first comment I may have been speculating on the motivations of others, but I did so by drawing in part on my own experiences. Programming, computers, BBSes/online services/Internet, etc. gave me something I could do as a grade school child that didn't depend on other people's approval of my social identity. My point was and is that it would be just as tragic to drive off the social misfits as it would be tragic to exclude the socially adept.

Sadly, sometimes it seems the mainstream have seen how much money can be made by former and present misfits as hackers and want to take ownership of it for themselves.

Edited to add: After rereading the thread, it seems you may have been commenting specifically on the sentence that I quoted. I don't intend to justify the heuristic that leads some to assume non-social-outcasts are non-hackers, only to explain it, and perhaps find a way of bridging the gap between those who use that heuristic, and those who are harmed by it.

Re:Girls and Software by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday February 09, 2014 @10:30PM (#7208942)
I think a lot of programmers and such have bought into a dress code that involves ratty old tshirts and jeans and that kind of thing, c.f. scorn at people who show up to technical interviews in a suit
Re:Girls and Software by jiggy2011 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:41PM (#7208328)
When you are younger the scarcity is money, not time. When I was younger I would have liked to dress fashionably or go out and do more sociable activities , but it was either that or buy computer parts and software etc. I couldn't have afforded both.

By the time you get a job that lets you afford both you don't necessarily want to learn fashion from scratch.

Re:Girls and Software by arrrg on Sunday February 09, 2014 @08:15PM (#7208474)
That seems mostly like a class issue (which is also pretty awful, no doubt, though not something everyone faces). Also: As I said, I know hackers tend to have hobbies. And not cheap ones.

Also, computers have dropped massively in price during the last twenty years. I don’t think becoming a hacker was ever super-expensive compared to many other activities, at least not during the last two decades, but now it’s quite affordable. Always depending on what you want to do, but – just as a point of comparison – I think being serious about PC gaming would likely be much more costly (well, I guess equally as costly if you are really into game development or something of that nature).

Luckily computing has never been as affordable and accessible as today.

Re:Girls and Software by picomancer on Sunday February 09, 2014 @09:45PM (#7208796)
> I don’t think becoming a hacker was ever super-expensive compared to many other activities

I disagree. In middle school I had a textbook on assembly language; the first chapters used DEBUG (a 16-bit debugger which came with DOS) but later chapters switched to programming in Microsoft MASM which was $180.

I remember thinking, "There's no way my hacking budget can take that. It'll take me years to save up that kind of money, and when/if I do, I'm definitely gonna blow it on video games."

I learned a lot by writing a QBASIC script which added label functionality to DEBUG to make it more usable assembling large programs.

Also, the only C compiler I had was Turbo C++ Lite for DOS, which came with another textbook I picked up for cheap (I recall $20). It was crippled: You could only run programs from within the IDE. If you used the "compile to EXE" option, it would work but the resulting executable would do nothing, just spitting out an error message along the lines of "Only the full version of the compiler can produce working executables".

But because different programs produced different-sized executables, I figured that meant the EXE file wasn't just a placeholder, it actually contained the compiled code but it was disabled somehow.

I figured out through tracing and in-memory patching (with DEBUG of course!) that there was a conditional branch within the first couple hundred instructions. Replacing it fixed the problem!

Kids these days have it so easy. All of the tools you need have excellent FOSS versions you can instantly download. Online resources are more comprehensive and up-to-date than any textbook. Modern languages have garbage collection and array bounds checking, eliminating entire classes of bugs.

Re:Girls and Software by jiggy2011 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @08:35PM (#7208548)
When I was learning PC gaming and interest in programming tended to go hand in hand, people wanted to program because they wanted to build games or mod games. Though I guess now it might be social media, iphone apps or something.

As a teenager I didn't exactly grow up poor but my income was restricted to what I could earn by working around my studies, so at most 12 hours a week at minimum wage which for a teenager was something like £3 an hour.

At that sort of income doing things like renting servers , iphone SDKs, decent computers etc start to look more expensive.

Re:Girls and Software by spikels on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:05PM (#7207837)
Specialization is almost entirely responsible for all the gains in our standard of living since the stone age. This includes almost every technological advance.

Heinlein is wrong on this and a specialist himself: a writer who requires other specialists to meet his every basic need (water, food, shelter...).

Don't dismiss specialization as it is the key to both past and future success.

Re:Girls and Software by d4rti on Monday February 10, 2014 @03:35AM (#7209810)
Additionally the line is spoken by a character who lives for over 2000 years.[1]

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lazarus_Long

Re:Girls and Software by sjy on Monday February 10, 2014 @09:11PM (#7215255)
Maybe the quote would make a bit more sense in context.

"A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects."

Re:Girls and Software by guard-of-terra on Sunday February 09, 2014 @04:03PM (#7207217)
- Hackers tend to do things sequentially. First get really good at something, look around, become good at something else. Compare that to people who just try to be "good enough" at (a limited scope of) everything.

- Hackers tend to have their own path in doing things.

A teenager hacker might look stange and alien to his peers because they do everything in the same way, extremelly conformist. Same thing for beauty: teenagers care less for beauty, more for copying things they understand.

This means that even social and stylish hacker might seem a freak in their teens.

Re:Girls and Software by theorique on Monday February 10, 2014 @06:31AM (#7210404)
If anecdotes count as evidence, we can point at Erdos for a counterexample (dedicated only to mathematics, could barely dress himself, lived homeless and traveled from friend's house to friend's house to work on mathematics).

So much of this depends on individual interest and temperament.

Re:Girls and Software by leoedin on Monday February 10, 2014 @07:02AM (#7210512)
I agree that it's not a binary situation - I know many people who are capable programmers and have an acceptable sense of style, social skills and other interests. However, time is limited and unless you're exceedingly capable you have to make tradeoffs. It takes an extraordinarily large amount of time to become a truly competent programmer, and if you're spending that time in front a computer you're not actively working at building friendships, thinking about fashion, thinking about music or working on any of the other things that might be equated with being attractive or popular in the vicious world of teenage social structures.
Re:Girls and Software by epsylon on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:30AM (#7211523)
> Von Neumann

You couldn't have picked a more outlying outlier. Von Neumann was one of the most brilliant minds of the century.

Re:Girls and Software by Crake on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:26PM (#7208250)
>But the thing about pretty girls is that they often find it is more immediately profitable to be pretty than to be bright.

100% agree with you. I also think a lot of the difference in the gender ratio can be attributed to the fact that women simply have far more options.

Re:Girls and Software by neona on Monday February 10, 2014 @04:29PM (#7213990)
I wouldn't say more options so much as societally-encouraged options. It's a lot more conforming to expectations to be attractive than it is to be a hacker, so it's easy to leave the less-accepted things by the wayside in a pressuring society.
Re:Girls and Software by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday February 09, 2014 @10:27PM (#7208928)
This is the kind of story that reveals a lot more about the teller than the subject.
Re:Girls and Software by HedgeMage on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:03PM (#7207831)
> it makes me think: this might be a problem. Is it harder to be a hacker if you > also have an interest in social media and graphic design and popularity and > friendships? Are we defining "hacker" to include only people with bad social > skills and no interest outside of technology? I hope not.

I never said any such thing. I didn't say "you are pretty, what are you doing here?". I said:

>> you're not a programmer, what are you doing here?!

I am a highly social hacker, and a polymath to boot. I have a vibrant love life, good friends from all walks of life, and plenty of non-coding interests: writing, reading, psychology, music, crafts (I do leatherwork, weave rugs, sew, do native american loomed seed beadwork, etc), backpacking, martial arts, and more.

What I don't do is walk into a room and tell a woman who's good at something I'm not -- a dancer, for example -- that she's being graded not on her ability to dance, but on whether she looks like my idea of what a dancer should be. I don't demand that her math skills (something just as orthogonal to dance as fashion is to coding) be evaluated instead of her dancing.

In my not-so-humble opinion, if you can't code, you don't get a vote on how it is or isn't okay to be a female (or any other) coder, period. Wave that "feminist" flag all you want, I'm not buying it. Women in generations before me didn't burn their bras so I could be judged on my fashion sense instead of my work.

Re:Girls and Software by arrrg on Sunday February 09, 2014 @08:23PM (#7208498)
Which feminist told you to dress or look a certain way? No doubt, there are feminists in the margins who think that way, but the vast majority of feminists I’ve ever met or talked to would be absolutely abhorred and disgusted by someone telling you how to dress or look. That’s certainly what I think. Gender policing is disgusting.

I’ve real trouble integrating what you are saying with what I’ve heard feminists say about the issues you are talking about.

Re:Girls and Software by Crake on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:36AM (#7211557)
>Which feminist told you to dress or look a certain way?

In my experience, feminists are more obsessed with making sure other women are dressed "correctly" than just about any other demographic outside of conservative christian republicans. Have you never read an article by a feminist about X or Y movie character is demeaning to women because she dressed too sexy, or wore something that the feminist herself would never wear?

Re:Girls and Software by alecdbrooks on Monday February 10, 2014 @11:37AM (#7211935)
Criticizing how fictional women are dressed is not the same as criticizing how real-life women are dressed. When a man draws or designs a female character with "sexy" clothing, it's likely sexualizing that character for male viewers to ogle. When a woman decides to dress that way, it's personal expression.

When I see feminist criticisms of how female characters are dressed, they're not criticizing three dimensional autonomous characters that happen to wear revealing clothes. They're criticizing usually stock characters that perpetuate stereotypes about women and objectify.

That being said, some feminists (or should that be "feminists"?) absolutely do police women's clothing choices, and that's just as wrong from them as it is from anyone else.

Re:Girls and Software by Crake on Monday February 10, 2014 @04:33PM (#7214030)
>Criticizing how fictional women are dressed is not the same as criticizing how real-life women are dressed.

Who do you think portrays them on tv and in movies? Fake women? Give me a break.

>When a man draws or designs a female character with "sexy" clothing, it's likely sexualizing that character for male viewers to ogle. When a woman decides to dress that way, it's personal expression.

I like how if a man does it, it's sexist, but if a woman does it, it's "empowerment." I guess men aren't allowed to write empowered female characters. And yet, if they don't write them--that makes them misogynists, too.

>They're criticizing usually stock characters that perpetuate stereotypes about women and objectify.

In my experience, this is just very elaborate justification for plain old jealousy of another woman's looks.

Re:Girls and Software by alecdbrooks on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @12:00AM (#7215878)
> Who do you think portrays them on tv and in movies? Fake women? Give me a break.

Oh, I had forgotten actresses write their own roles and pick their own wardrobes. And since most producers are women [0], most directors are women, most writers are women[1] and most people behind the scenes are women [2], I don't know what I was thinking. You're absolutely right: Men really have no influence on the process at all.

/sarcasm

>>When a man draws or designs a female character with "sexy" clothing, it's likely sexualizing that character for male viewers to ogle. When a woman decides to dress that way, it's personal expression.

>I like how if a man does it, it's sexist, but if a woman does it, it's "empowerment." I guess men aren't allowed to write empowered female characters. And yet, if they don't write them--that makes them misogynists, too.

I'm comparing a woman's personal choice to a man's choice of how women are portrayed. Men can dress as they wish. What they shouldn't do is objectify women.

[0]: http://www.screendaily.com/news/production/percentage-of-wom...

[1]: http://www.thewrap.com/tv/article/tv-writing-remains-white-m...

[2]: http://entertainment.time.com/2014/01/15/report-women-are-st...

Re:Girls and Software by aeturnum on Monday February 10, 2014 @07:59PM (#7214952)
It's very common for readers / viewers to feel that elements of a story represent a world view that is much wider than the specific bounds of that particular story. If you read 1984 without reading Orwell's goals, how would you characterize his goals? Is he trying to say something about all societies, or is his book concerned only with _that_ society? The more superficial the interaction with a work, the easier it is to mistake an author's perspective.

I think these sorts of differences in perspective are common to people in general. Some of it is jealously, but a lot of it is simply a failure to understand or take into consideration the viewpoint of the piece.

Re:Girls and Software by king_jester on Monday February 10, 2014 @01:20PM (#7212656)
> In my experience, feminists are more obsessed with making sure other women are dressed "correctly" than just about any other demographic outside of conservative christian republicans.

Dress and body policing of women is a reflection of misogyny, of which women and men both participate. However, it is definitely wrong to do so whether one considers themselves feminist or not.

> Have you never read an article by a feminist about X or Y movie character is demeaning to women because she dressed too sexy, or wore something that the feminist herself would never wear?

Media representation criticism != body policing of actual people.

Re:Girls and Software by Crake on Monday February 10, 2014 @04:30PM (#7214002)
>Media representation criticism != body policing of actual people.

Except that in many cases, it's actual women being criticized.

Re:Girls and Software by jejones3141 on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:58PM (#7214418)
True, however there are examples of the latter, vide how Nixie Pixel was treated at OSCON 2012.
Re:Girls and Software by overgryphon on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:23PM (#7214264)
Why did fashion come up in this article at all? There is no reason to believe that a woman who wears heels and makeup can program any less well than a woman who doesn't. Or that girls that read fashion magazines aren't interested in computers. Fashion and dress are irrelevant.
Re:Girls and Software by cheald on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:57PM (#7207194)
> I also think she might be rather narrowly defining the personality type of a "hacker", and dismissing behaviors that she doesn't find valuable (in her words: "ephemera -- popularity, beauty and fitting in").

I read that more as "where do your passions lie?" People have many interests, but few passions, and passions demand sacrifices. When push comes to shove, hackers will give up popularity and fitting in for the sake of hacking - not because they don't care about those things, but because they'd rather be hacking. Girls who are told that the most important thing for them is to be beautiful and popular are deprived of the opportunity to develop a passion for hacking, because their passion for popularity chokes out other competitors.

I don't think it's harder to be a hacker if you're interested in social media or graphic design, but if you'd rather be tweeting about your latest logo design than figuring out how to fix a bug, you might not be a hacker.

Re:Girls and Software by sillysaurus2 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:03PM (#7206927)
Maybe it's possible that there are plenty of people out there who care about "ephemera", and yet are also capable of programming a computer or soldering things together? I think it's possible.

Sure, Jobs did. On the other hand, Woz was the tech genius, not Jobs.

I've never heard of a tech genius who also cared much about the qualities you mention. This seems more than a coincidence. If it were, then there'd probably be at least one counterexample. Is there someone who is at the level of Woz or Blackwell who also cares about popularity, beauty, and fitting in?

Re:Girls and Software by llimllib on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:18PM (#7207014)
> I've never heard of a tech genius who also cared much about the qualities you mention.

How about von Neumann, famous for always being in an impeccably tailored suit? I hope he's genius enough for you.

You don't even have to go past the very first hackers to find ones that care about those qualities. There are many, many other examples.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann#Personal_life

> Von Neumann took great care over his clothing, and would always wear formal suits, once riding down the Grand Canyon astride a mule in a three-piece pin-stripe. Mathematician David Hilbert is reported to have asked at von Neumann's 1926 doctoral exam: "Pray, who is the candidate's tailor?" as he had never seen such beautiful evening clothes.

Re:Girls and Software by Crake on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:26PM (#7208248)
Wearing a nice suit != being obsessed with popularity, beauty, and fashion.
Re:Girls and Software by sillysaurus2 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:21PM (#7207028)
Indeed! This is a great example, thanks.
Re:Girls and Software by timr on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:30PM (#7207070)
You should also stop and consider, for just a moment, that if the only stories that can convince you need to be famous, you're working in a very narrow space of human experience.

It's a big world out there, and there are a lot of smart people who will defy your expectations.

Re:Girls and Software by sillysaurus2 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @05:52PM (#7207757)
Actually, it's not inherently about fame. It has to do with whether the hackers are skilled. Pg goes into why it's difficult to compare hacker skill in one of his essays, though I forget which. But the summary is that nobody knows who the most talented hackers are, because you have to work with them to know how talented they are. Therefore fame is the only metric that makes sense in this case to derive hard evidence. Fame is a proxy for many people having recognized their talent, and the original question was about talent.
Re:Girls and Software by timr on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:41PM (#7208325)
Fame is orthogonal to skill.
Re:Girls and Software by timr on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:11PM (#7206972)
"Woz was the tech genius, not Jobs....I've never heard of a tech genius who also cared much about the qualities you mention."

I hope you've considered that your worldly experience may not be comprehensive.

I've known plenty of good programmers who care about all the things I mentioned. They just don't self-select with the Linux user groups of the world, so you're unlikely to come upon them if that's where you hang out.

Re:Girls and Software by sillysaurus2 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:18PM (#7207011)
To clarify, I asked for an example, not touted myself as the arbiter of worldly experiences.

I also asked for an example of a programmer on the level of Woz. This is an important distinguishing quality, because otherwise there's no way to know how good a hacker actually is. Every story would be anecdotal instead of resembling factual.

Re:Girls and Software by woah on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:47PM (#7208056)
So it's a binary choice between being Richard Stallman and not programming at all? Your worldview is narrow.
Re:Girls and Software by herokusaki on Sunday February 09, 2014 @08:13PM (#7208467)
By the same token your comment would suggest a binary choice between having a narrow worldview and not acknowledging very real trends (that hackers care less about dress and appearance than other professionals). That's an uncharitable interpretation.
Re:Girls and Software by Crake on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:09PM (#7206960)
>Maybe it's possible that there are plenty of people out there who care about "ephemera", and yet are also capable of programming a computer or soldering things together?

Did you even read the article? The point she made is that feminists are trying to "fix" the gender ratio in tech by expanding the definition of hacker to people who have no idea what solder even is and have never printed a hello world in their life.

>dismissing behaviors that she doesn't find valuable (in her words: "ephemera -- popularity, beauty and fitting in").

These things are in no way relevant to producing good code. They're completely orthogonal.

>Are we defining "hacker" to include only people with bad social skills and no interest outside of technology?

The only person putting forth that argument here is you.

Re:Girls and Software by superuser2 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:05PM (#7206936)
>you also have an interest in social media and graphic design

You added an "also." The criticism was of "women-in-tech" advocates who are solely "women-in-tech" advocates/PR people/designers and who are not programmers.

Re:Girls and Software by krstck on Sunday February 09, 2014 @04:25PM (#7207324)
I hate to include designers in that maligned category, because their work is actually extremely valuable.

The existence of "women-in-tech" advocates who want other people to program (but not themselves) is baffling to me. Why do we need such people?

Re:Girls and Software by timr on Sunday February 09, 2014 @03:25PM (#7207044)
Yes, that's fair. She does say "women who can't code", so perhaps I'm interpreting that particular sentence too broadly.

That said, she does make more than one disparaging remark about "ephemera"...I think it's safe to read between the lines here and have a conversation about culture, given that a lot of capable people (men and women) are turned off by the traditional societal definition of "hackers".

Re:Girls and Software by einhverfr on Monday February 10, 2014 @01:05AM (#7209417)
> I think she makes some really good points -- particularly about discouraging young girls and the futility of shoving adult humans into foreign social situations -- but I also think she might be rather narrowly defining the personality type of a "hacker", and dismissing behaviors that she doesn't find valuable (in her words: "ephemera -- popularity, beauty and fitting in").

Also the ephemera are gateways to something less ephemeral: social contacts and human capital. I don't think this can be understated. Most women are social to a degree that most men will never be, and this is ok because being social is being powerful in every way that matters in day to day life.

The thing is, I am not sure one can really be technical and social in the same moment. These are very different thought processes. Social context is fluid and changing, and it can't be directly measured. So these are different.

It's funny. I suspect that my grandmother (who introduced me to computers and punchcards(!) would agree with everything in this article. Of course she mostly programmed in Fortran relating to her work in astrophysics (a field she entered in 1964).

> it makes me think: this might be a problem. Is it harder to be a hacker if you also have an interest in social media and graphic design and popularity and friendships?

I do think that brain cycles are finite, and while I am male I tend to find that if the very things that make me good at solving certain sets of technical problems can make me socially out of touch at times.