News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by manmal on Saturday February 08, 2014 @02:51PM (#7202347)
This very recent tweet from Dong seems to explain his motivation: https://twitter.com/dongatory/statuses/432096186313355264

other guy: "No problem, but you hate the success of Flappy Bird?"

Dong: "Not because of them but because how people use my game. They are overusing it."

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Aqueous on Saturday February 08, 2014 @03:11PM (#7202455)
And in about a month or two Flappy Bird fever will wear off and folks will move onto something else.

Don't turn down millions of dollars because people are doing what people do! Someone remind him of all the folks who have downloaded his game and stopped playing nearly immediately...,

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by pikachu_is_cool on Saturday February 08, 2014 @03:33PM (#7202560)
This might come as a shocker to many people on HN, but many people do not like money.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Aqueous on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:05PM (#7202985)
It's not noble to waste opportunity like that. If he doesn't like money, he should take the money then give it away. A lot of poor people would kill to have that money to feed themselves and their families, or send their kid to school - if he feels so inclined he should take it and give it to them. If not, he's wasting a huge opportunity to either be very rich or very charitable out of some poorly thought-through righteousness.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by awakeasleep on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:57PM (#7203228)
So you advocate doing things you find morally objectionable while telling yourself that it is the right thing to do because you can give the money away afterwards? That sounds insane to me.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Aqueous on Saturday February 08, 2014 @06:22PM (#7203326)
I think it's morally objectionable to waste a rare opportunity when one could just as easily channel that opportunity towards the benefits of others.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Varcht on Saturday February 08, 2014 @07:46PM (#7203636)
This really does not compute for me, so it's bad to stop ruining people's lives if in ruining their lives you could help other people's lives? What if the people addicted and raging over Flappy Bird are the same ones that you think should be helped?
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by derefr on Saturday February 08, 2014 @08:47PM (#7203840)
You're conflating two acts: he has produced a game, and being addicted to games ruins some people's lives. But if he withdraws his game, their lives don't suddenly get un-ruined. They just switch to some other game.

Basically, you're suggesting that an equilibrium of (1 person-hour stolen by addiction : 1 person-hour of ad impressions given to charity) should be replaced with (1 person-hour stolen by addiction [just to some other game] : 0 person-hours of ad impressions given to charity). Note that there is no "0 person-hours stolen by addiction" option.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Aqueous on Saturday February 08, 2014 @11:53PM (#7204424)
I mean let's just think about it here. Is Flappy Bird really ruining people's lives? Flappy Bird? Really?
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by 97s on Saturday February 08, 2014 @07:37PM (#7203610)
Yeah this is basically like drug dealers saying I give all the money to charity.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by derefr on Saturday February 08, 2014 @08:44PM (#7203823)
Actually yes: a casino run by a cult of effective altruists would probably do more for the world than most charities.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by scotty79 on Saturday February 08, 2014 @06:01PM (#7203247)
He doesn't produce the money. He just takes money from people. Giving it away is not the same as not taking it in the first place.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by kordless on Saturday February 08, 2014 @06:15PM (#7203301)
No, it's not noble, but being noble isn't such a great thing either. It's being true to one's self and following the path you choose. Nothing more, nothing less.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by yogo on Saturday February 08, 2014 @03:41PM (#7202602)
Yep they either have it already or they are fucking idiots. It's a fundamental lack of appreciation for good luck.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by ChrisNorstrom on Saturday February 08, 2014 @03:53PM (#7202667)
Dude common. You have to see it from his point of view. His money and fame aren't coming from a prestigious accomplishment. He probably doesn't want to be known for a flappy bird game for the rest of his life. Imagine being the guy who invented the turd scrubber brush next to the toilet. Everyone owns that brush but would you want to be known for it? Associated with it?
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by throwaway092834 on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:08PM (#7202726)
I have to say yes, I would have no problem with being known for inventing a toilet brush, or flappy bird. I'd be proud, even.

I know that people can have strangely fragile egos but the idea of being upset for being known for something, no matter how benign, is completely foreign to me.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by ChrisNorstrom on Saturday February 08, 2014 @08:39PM (#7203804)
? Then why is your account username "throwaway092834".
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by throwaway092834 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @01:56AM (#7204691)
Because I have found the internet in general to be at times crude, ignorant and destructive. I don't want to concern myself with considering self-censorship to ensure self-preservation. Instead I chose to contribute anonymously so that I may challenge the status quo or speak truth to power without personal concern.

I assure you it has nothing to do with embarrassment. It's unfortunate, but speech often has very serious consequences.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by ChrisNorstrom on Sunday February 09, 2014 @04:46AM (#7205003)
I'm sure our friend the flappy bird developer feels the same way. With insults thrown his way constantly over the game and a massive popularity he wasn't ready for, I'm sure he wishes he was anonymous as well.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by throwaway092834 on Sunday February 09, 2014 @11:24AM (#7205936)
We're discussing different things. You're talking about fame and internet comments which have no real impact, at least, not to me. I don't have a problem with people insulting the code I publish under my real name.

I'm talking about the potential for real life harassment (folks calling my employer, showing up at my house, swatting, etc) if I were to say something controversial. I am specifically concerned with being doxxed and criminal harassment.

There's a vast world of difference between people making comments in poor taste over a game and the level people sometimes go to if they engage in an argument and lose in an embarrassing way. I would not recommend that anyone freely engage in internet debates in a non-anonymous fashion.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by adventured on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:14PM (#7202761)
Flappy bird can make it possible for him to fund his next adventure (or next 10), whatever he chooses that to be. He should think forward a bit more. It's extraordinarily rare to be in the position to take advantage of opportunities like that. What he'd be effectively doing is just handing the money off to Clumsy Bird instead. If he has any dreams for the future, he should view it as funding those dreams; which could be anything from a future game, to charity. Just my opinion obviously.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by bigje54 on Saturday February 08, 2014 @06:01PM (#7203250)
The disappointing part is that he apparently has such poor self-esteem, he thinks that he will not be able to create anything more popular than this game, even with all the money he's generating.

Regardless of what he builds, what industry he is in, there will always be people there to criticize. Why throw away opportunity that most people wish they had due to something that will occur regardless of the revenue?

Being a martyr only works in certain circumstances. This is not one of them.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by eropple on Saturday February 08, 2014 @08:16PM (#7203747)
> The disappointing part is that he apparently has such poor self-esteem, he thinks that he will not be able to create anything more popular than this game, even with all the money he's generating.

If you look at mobile game development, it's not a bad bet to guess that he won't. It's a big ol' dart board.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by AznHisoka on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:47PM (#7202903)
I agree. There's a subtle difference between being sincere and being intelligent.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by megablast on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:41PM (#7203151)
> Flappy bird can make it possible for him to fund his next adventure (or next 10)

If he lives in Vietnam, one day would set him up for the rest of his life.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by pikachu_is_cool on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:25PM (#7202817)
Actually, it's more like he's going to have to deal with fake people for the rest of his life.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by forgottenpass on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:08PM (#7202725)
There's nothing more to life than profit. Except maybe regretting your priorities on your deathbed, but whatevs, you won't be worried about it for long.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by unethical_ban on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:06PM (#7202988)
You and pikachu_is_cool are boggling my mind right now. The guy is having a moderately high amount of money coming in for him now, based on something he did out of passion. There is nothing wrong with money for stability. If you don't like it, give it to charity... or save for health issues, because we all now realize just how pricey a scrape can be in America.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by pikachu_is_cool on Sunday February 09, 2014 @12:33AM (#7204518)
It's not the money itself. It's what comes with the money. Once people know you are capable of making the money, they will never stop stalking you, following you, pretending to be your friend, fervently hating you (this happens SO OFTEN), stalking you, harassing you, etc. No amount of charity donation, hell, even burning all of your money won't fix it.

There is literally nothing coming back from it other than waiting for the hype to die out. And that's what Nguyen is trying to do. Trust me, I'm talking from experience here.

I guess I might be in the minority here, since most people on HN are trying to become the next Mark Zuckerberg with their startups. Maybe they like that kind of attention. However, I, Dong Nguyen, and many people like us do not like that kind of attention. You don't know who your real friends are, and as he put it, it "interrupts my quiet life".

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by krallja on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:54PM (#7203212)
Dong Nguyen lives in Vietnam.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by catshirt on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:11PM (#7202744)
even if you actually hated money, it seems strange to turn your back on your passion because it came with a shit ton of money.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by pikachu_is_cool on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:23PM (#7202803)
Oh yeah, becoming rich is so great. You can buy whatever you want for people you are not entirely sure are your real friends.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Dylan16807 on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:32PM (#7203101)
If you literally don't want the money, give it to charity.

Problem solved, get back to your passion.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by catshirt on Saturday February 08, 2014 @06:29PM (#7203369)
give it to charity, use it to sustain more development on your games, use it to build a company that can just focus on making your games, use it to fund or invest or donate to other gaming projects... etc.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by pikachu_is_cool on Sunday February 09, 2014 @12:25AM (#7204498)
It's not the money. That doesn't matter. It's that people find out about the money. Once people know you are capable of making the money, they will never stop stalking you, following you, pretending to be your friend, etc. No amount of charity donation, hell, even burning all of your money won't fix it.

There is literally nothing coming back from it other than waiting for the hype to die out. And that's what Nguyen is trying to do. Trust me, I'm talking from experience here.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by catshirt on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:41PM (#7202884)
you're missing the point.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by forgottenpass on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:28PM (#7203078)
I don't buy the premise of either of those hypotheticals.

Where is he turning his back on his passion? It doesn't sound like the way people are responding to Flappy Bird are the embodiment of his passion he wants. And his passion is in game dev, not an oddly specific passion for riding only the Flappy Bird app to success. Taking it down doesn't mean he can't build different games.

I also reject the idea that it was because of the money alone that he is taking the app down. Money wasn't the only byproduct of the success. Far be it for me to make assumptions, but it may be the "ruins my simple life" levels of baggage that came with the success of Flappy Bird.

My post was attempting to point out that he may have priorities in addition to profit, not that he is anti-money. If you meant to respond to the guy that is actually saying that the money alone could be the problem, perhaps you should move your post.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by derefr on Saturday February 08, 2014 @08:50PM (#7203848)
> And his passion is in game dev, not an oddly specific passion for riding only the Flappy Bird app to success.

I think people here were assuming that his passion was entrepreneurship through game-dev. Because, you know, HN, entrepreneurs, etc. (But also because he did both things in order to ship this game, so it's just as probable he liked doing both of them. He could have given the game away for free, if he thought entrepreneurship was a hassle or something.)

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by catshirt on Saturday February 08, 2014 @06:26PM (#7203346)
>> Where is he turning his back on his passion?

one passion of many. he was passionate about Flappy Bird, and he is now removing it from the app store all together.

>> I also reject the idea that it was because of the money alone that he is taking the app down.

fair enough and i agree. i really just mean that generally, there are not very many good reasons to outright reject this kind of money.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by jusben1369 on Saturday February 08, 2014 @09:32PM (#7204012)
His Dave Chappelle moment.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by ryanSrich on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:33PM (#7202847)
I never understood this mentality. Why not give it away? You know how awesome it would be to just walk up to a homeless person and hand them $100 bill? What about stopping by an orphanage and donating a couple grand? Use your skills to better the world.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by SurfScore on Saturday February 08, 2014 @03:32PM (#7202555)
I think it's about more than money for this guy
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by Houshalter on Saturday February 08, 2014 @04:15PM (#7202765)
I respect his morals but the people over using the game are just going to move on to some other game and get addicted to it. If he feels bad about profiting from the game, he should donate it to a charity. That amount of money can do a lot of good.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by jonny_eh on Saturday February 08, 2014 @05:19PM (#7203045)
And if a drug dealer decides to stop selling meth, you'd discourage him since addicts can just buy it down the block?

Note: I'm not saying Flappy Bird is like meth, but just pointing out your logic.

Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by derefr on Saturday February 08, 2014 @08:41PM (#7203814)
If meth were a liquid market with dealers lining up on every single street corner in the city to sell (and probably stocking it in grocery and convenience stores besides), then yeah, his stopping wouldn't really change the situation. His monetary loss from stopping sales will far outweigh whatever infinitesimal decrease there will be in the convenience of finding an addictive game on the iTunes app store.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by jusben1369 on Saturday February 08, 2014 @09:28PM (#7203998)
This only holds if meth and playing flappy are on par in terms of damaging your life.
Re:Flappy Bird creator, Dong Nguyen, taking down game; "I ca... by AnthonBerg on Saturday February 08, 2014 @07:27PM (#7203584)
A good reason to turn down the money is that this is an unusual event, and may get people thinking. And we also have an unavoidable mechanism that is our conscience. I'm fairly sure that his decision will make him happier and more at peace with himself in the long run.