I don't understand your comment. What Iceland did - allow its banks to default on their debts - is completely different from what eg. Ireland did, ie. nationalise the debt.
That it then nationalised the bankrupt banks is a different matter. It nationalised them, sure, after they defaulted on the debt.
The consensus of mainstream economics at the time was "holy shit are you fucking nuts?", and I don't think it looks any more sane with the benefit of time.
[1] http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2011/03/michael-...
Iceland banks didn't collapse, the government nationalized them to prevent their collapse. (Edit: as another poster mentions a portion of the debt was paid down by other states too. Again, that's a detail, not a fundamental difference).
Some foreign-deposit operations did collapse but the bulk of the banks, their shares and national operations, were protected by the state.
"The Financial Supervisory Authority (FME) has acted to "ring-fence" the Icelandic operations of Landsbanki and Glitnir, stating its aim of "continued banking operations for Icelandic families and businesses."[126] NBI (originally known as Nýi Landsbanki) was set up on 9 October with 200 billion krónur in equity and 2,300 billion krónur of assets.[127] Nýi Glitnir was set up on 15 October with 110 billion krónur in equity and 1,200 billion krónur of assets.[128]
Talks with Icelandic pension funds to sell Kaupthing as a going concern broke down on 17 October,[129] and Nýja Kaupþing was set up on 22 October with 75 billion krónur in equity and 700 billion krónur of assets.[130]
The equity in all three new banks was supplied by the Icelandic government, and amounted to 30% of Iceland's GDP...."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9311_Icelandic_finan...
> Iceland banks didn't collapse, the government nationalized them to prevent their collapse. (Edit: as another poster mentions a portion of the debt was paid down by other states too. Again, that's a detail, not a fundamental difference).
It is a fundamental difference. When Iceland took over its banks, it basically said: your deposits are insured if you are a tax-payer. Customers living elsewhere, share holders and (non-Icelandic?) bond holders were wiped out; they were owed something one day, zero the next, and it matters little to Icelanders who may have generously picked up the tab -- they didn't. The banks were recapitalized when needed, and a few bank execs got thrown in jail for good measure.
I beg to ask how this is in any way similar to what happened in the US, the UK or Ireland. Or Greece, for that matter.
Here, for example, in english it says: "Credit agricole and Keytrade save Kauphting's client" and explains how the 21 000 belgians who had accounts at Kauphting didn't lose a dime.
That's far from being "wiped out".
http://www.express.be/sectors/fr/ict/le-crdit-agricole-et-ke...
Or by "elsewhere" did you mean "Outside the EU"?
(honest question...)
The non-tax paying, non-residents? Yes.
They were subsequently bailed out by foreign governments and/or entities, but from Iceland's standpoint — which is the important one when it comes to their taxpayers' finances — they were wiped out.
That is why the UK and Holland, in particular, were so pissed at Iceland and threatened to block EU-entry negotiations at one point. They spectacularly footed the bill, and I presume so did other countries. They then sent it to Iceland.
Iceland, on its end, raised its middle finger. Slowly.
Not just once, either.
The politicians tried to sneak the debt back in to be accommodating. And twice, a popular vote was organized and the referendum yielded a big fat no by a massive landslide.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icesave_dispute
Credit Agricole, btw, was bailed out using US-funds funneled by Bernanke's largess through AIG, rather than by France:
http://money.cnn.com/2009/03/07/news/companies/aig.fortune/i...
Icelanders, Americans and Greek have all experienced a sharp reduction in their standard of living (Icelanders, like Greeks, experienced this through a large currency devaluation). Both Icelanders and Americans live more or less under the same system that existed before the crisis.
Also, Bernie Madoff went to jail...
All the devils are here has a nice history of this financial crisis, I thought, and no-one who was involved in the fraud which caused the collapse of AIG, for example, was convicted, though there have been some investigations, AFAIK.
Also Iceland defaulted on its external debt and only protected national interests - the UK and US didn't really do anything similar, they have chosen to inflate their way out of debt instead.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis/3225213/A...
http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405274870420140...
[Edit: He also describes the right of passage for new bond salesmen - when you bankrupt your first client....]
That's not fraud. It's probably unethical, but businesses selling customers products they know are shit is more or less legal, or at most the subject of a civil action by the purchaser. I mean, look at the software industry. How many software companies sell products that are buggy crap, that they know are buggy crap? And when it comes to investments, that basic dynamic is at the heart of a lot of sales. If I think this investment is a great deal that's going to just go up and up, why would I sell it to you?
I'm willing to entertain the idea that what GS did crossed the line in terms of the standard of ethics people expect of investment professionals, which maybe should be higher than for businesses generally. Maybe we should put such standards in place and make them enforceable,[1] but it wouldn't be fair to throw people in jail for what they did before those standards were in place.
[1] For example, it would be punishable ethical breach for a lawyer to represent a client then take a financial position adverse to the client's interests.
The only thing missing from a fraud case in the "selling shit products" story is "knowingly making false statements", right?
GS knowingly sold AIG junk CDOs days before the collapse
GS didn't sell CDOs to AIG. GS didn't actually sell anything to AIG. GS bought insurance (in the form of credit default swaps) on the CDOs from AIG and apparently sold at least some of those swaps on to other banks for a profit.
If Goldman had done something to accelerate the deterioration of the value of the CDOs (something like insuring a house and then burning it down), then you could probably claim GS was in the wrong. AIG would have known it was insuring subprime mortgage CDOs. There also isn't anything in the article asserting that GS misrepresented the quality of the loans or anything like that.
It's hard to get from that WSJ article to fraud.
http://wheredoesallmymoneygo.com/goldman-sachs-fined-550-mil...
They're potentially using insider information on deals and risk in order to profit; I'm not sure they should even be allowed to bet against their clients, because it gives them all sorts of perverse incentives. But it's a complex area, and I'm no expert in it...
I agree it would be hard for that to end in a fraud conviction, and as you say perhaps more regulation would be required for that to even be possible, but perhaps more regulation of this area is required.
You have to consider that when an investment bank sells you a structured product it then naturally has the opposite position. If you want something that pays off if interest rates rise, an investment bank can sell you something like that in the form of an interest rate swap. You are now long interest rates and the bank is short them, but there wasn't anything malicious there. The bank just sold you the product you wanted. Now the bank has to hedge somehow or sell the swap on to someone who wants to be short interest rates. It may have clients that are interested in that sort of exposure.
I'm not trying to defend Goldman here, but when people say things like "banks are betting against their clients" it usually shows a misunderstanding of the business.
That was the fraud. It told its clients the portfolio had been created by someone who was trying to put together a reasonable-ish CDO when in fact it had been put together with the exact opposite in mind. I will also point out that there are no claims by the SEC that Goldman itself was short the CDO.
Iceland never claimed any kind of insurance of foreign deposits, so was not in any way obliged to pay them up.
The UK's position (AIUI) was that membership of the European Economic Area means that Iceland can not treat its own citizens' savings differently than those of other EEA member states' citizens. Hence the whole squabbling about repayment and such, which is still ongoing.
It's clear for instance that UK public money went to UK depositors. The UK is entitled (though maybe unwise) to do this and it sets up a framework for explicit guarantees. In Ireland's case, god knows who really got bailed out. The EU loaned Ireland money to loan to their banks to pay back depositors who were other banks..etc. There was pressure from Germany as both the source of much of the financing and the destination of much of it (Irish banks owed money to German banks). No one went bankrupt, for a normal definition of the term.
It amounts (in my limited understanding) to a few important difference that leave the system far more robust. (1) there is some transparency. It is knowable who is getting bailed out and where the money is coming from. (2) Some long tail risk is put onto depositors, especially foreign/large depositors so it can be priced in. A Hayekian sort of systemic risk reduction. (3) It appears to have reduced the flow of money from poorer future people to current rich people. (4) It clearly defines depositor bailouts as depositor bailouts. Money goes from the public purse to Ms Gunnarsdotter's. In other bailouts (Ireland) the public was driven to fear that banks would collapse and their savings wiped out unless some unknown quantity of money was put into an unknown funnel from where it would flow (among other places) back into their deposit accounts.
IMO we need to come to a long term setup that is simple enough for a first year economics student to understand and first year finance student to price. A guarantee is fine, if we can set it to an affordable level (say, deposits up to €25k) payable directly from the government to qualifying depositors with potential recovery by a bankruptcy court.
A lot of people who borrowed from the Irish banks were forced to go bankrupt - apparently mostly those who had borrowed relatively small sums (less than 20 million or so).
Those who borrowed from the banks and went bankrupt were the cause, rather than the result, of the banking crisis (speaking purely from an accounting perspective -- no moral or policy judgement.)
If Iceland had more than 300,000 people, you can be damn sure the debt wouldn't have been forgiven, and there would be tariffs on cod and aluminium until it was paid back.
If you go to a foreign bank for tax, interest or other benefits you are exercising a high degree of financial autonomy, choosing a banking system to be a part of. It's not a default decision by someone who needed somewhere to deposit their £438 per week salary. I really don't think you can make the same argument about guaranteeing deposits in these cases, especially without a (low) cap of £10,000 or so.
The Bank of England bailout transferred money from future middle class workers in the UK to wealthy and upper-middle class people, maybe 2 generations apart. I think it was immoral.
As part of the EU scheme I think the intention was for local compensation schemes to pay out to consumers and reclaim from the bank's home countries if the bank failed. Obviously this part didn't happen (and possibly could never have happened) but if the FSCS did not list Icesave I would not have invested.
My due diligence was checking the bank was properly covered by the UK scheme and that I did not have more money in it than was covered by the UK's compensation scheme.
A case can be made that those investing more than the scheme should have lost money (not necessarily just for Icelandic banks but also for the UK banks that were bailed out) or that FSCS should not have committed to compensate but they did so they really did need to pay out.
(I too had an Icesave account at the time, it was a fearful couple weeks)
What's also important to remember is that only retail investors were bailed out. Council's and the like lost everything.
It may have been a £50K limit, the precise number wasn't an issue for me at the time as I wasn't near either figure.
Did the Icelandic government ever agree to this liability? Was their ability to meet it ever looked in to?
I believe it was part of some European agreement for open access to financial markets but I don't know the details. So I think that the answer is probably: Yes.
Edit: I've upvoted a sibling post with the judgment on the case. I haven't read it all but it seems clear to me that the rules were complicated and there were good reasons to believe that Iceland had such a liability.
>Was their ability to meet it ever looked in to?
Obviously not sufficiently. It may be that it was looked into initially when it was small and manageable but no-one said stop when the Icelandic banks grew beyond the ability of their government to rescue. Of course if you withdraw cover you can trigger the bank run that brings down the system. With hindsight you know that you should have stepped in to restrict opening of accounts before the risky position was reached.
Edit2 to add: Agree that FSA were at fault. My post was to explain the extent to which it was not an exotic foreign investment but a normal option available to regular customers and with the normal bank compensation scheme in place.
See the EFTA court ruling at http://www.eftacourt.int/uploads/tx_nvcases/16_11_Judgment_E...
they were supposedly also beholden to the EU depositor protection scheme, if they weren't then most depositors wouldn't have touched icesave.
on the eve of the crisis the Icelandic politicians told the UK that they would pay out to UK depositors, then after the UK had paid out they changed their mind.
no one could have predicted that the day before the collapse the Icelandic parliament would withdraw their promise
If someone is daft enough to deposit their cash abroad to get higher returns without doing enough due diligence as to where they are depositing their money that's their problem - not mine or any other taxpayers.
So if a UK scammer tricked your parents or grand parents out of say 50% of their life savings you'd tell them you where stupid and deserved it?
The 3rd option is nonsensical. At some point banks will fail. The market works better when the decision maker has skin in the game but there will still be failures and we (nations and individuals including pensioners cannot be shielded from reality completely.
Notice as they keep comparing the Icelandic unemployment rate to the EU average unemployment rate ?
Comparing its unemployment rate with that of the US would seem as bizarre as comparing Ohio's with that of the EU.
But the biggest point is that Iceland has taken a very different path from Ireland, Spain or Greece with very different outcomes.
(of course, the situations were not exactly similar at the beginning but comparable enough to draw those comparisions)
IANAL but I understand that what Iceland did would not have been permissible under EU law. That is part of the reason why Ireland, for example, took the path it did, in relation to the bank bail-outs.
However, what Iceland did was still unilateral. They didn't ask for anybody's permission and didn't expect their decision to be accepted.
Laws and treaties still need to be enforced and those countries are still sovereign. What happens if a country does something that is against EU law ? At worst, they may be expelled from the EU.
So it's really a matter of comparing the advantages of EU membership to the cost of the path of action that was taken.
It's still a political decision.
That detail is anything but trivial. It's the difference between giving the assets of a company to creditors during bankrupcy, or just clearing the debts, and keeping the assets as company possessions (and keeping the company owners).
To tell you the truth, I still can not understand how the US (out of all countries, the one where people do not trust the State) accepted that bank bailout.
Like the US, Iceland provided financial support for its ailing bank system when the crisis appeared. That Iceland officially nationalized banks and the US left the banks officially in private hands is really a trivial detail. Iceland supported their banks and ultimately returned them to the control of their previous owners, the same effective strategy as the US.
And some unsecured creditors lost in Iceland and in the US, depending on the circumstances. Again, a detail, not the main picture, which wasn't really that different than here.
Just stop with the "Iceland's different" baloney, just stop.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9311_Icelandic_finan...