Here, for example, in english it says: "Credit agricole and Keytrade save Kauphting's client" and explains how the 21 000 belgians who had accounts at Kauphting didn't lose a dime.
That's far from being "wiped out".
http://www.express.be/sectors/fr/ict/le-crdit-agricole-et-ke...
Or by "elsewhere" did you mean "Outside the EU"?
(honest question...)
The non-tax paying, non-residents? Yes.
They were subsequently bailed out by foreign governments and/or entities, but from Iceland's standpoint — which is the important one when it comes to their taxpayers' finances — they were wiped out.
That is why the UK and Holland, in particular, were so pissed at Iceland and threatened to block EU-entry negotiations at one point. They spectacularly footed the bill, and I presume so did other countries. They then sent it to Iceland.
Iceland, on its end, raised its middle finger. Slowly.
Not just once, either.
The politicians tried to sneak the debt back in to be accommodating. And twice, a popular vote was organized and the referendum yielded a big fat no by a massive landslide.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icesave_dispute
Credit Agricole, btw, was bailed out using US-funds funneled by Bernanke's largess through AIG, rather than by France:
http://money.cnn.com/2009/03/07/news/companies/aig.fortune/i...
Icelanders, Americans and Greek have all experienced a sharp reduction in their standard of living (Icelanders, like Greeks, experienced this through a large currency devaluation). Both Icelanders and Americans live more or less under the same system that existed before the crisis.
Also, Bernie Madoff went to jail...
All the devils are here has a nice history of this financial crisis, I thought, and no-one who was involved in the fraud which caused the collapse of AIG, for example, was convicted, though there have been some investigations, AFAIK.
Also Iceland defaulted on its external debt and only protected national interests - the UK and US didn't really do anything similar, they have chosen to inflate their way out of debt instead.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis/3225213/A...
http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405274870420140...
[Edit: He also describes the right of passage for new bond salesmen - when you bankrupt your first client....]
That's not fraud. It's probably unethical, but businesses selling customers products they know are shit is more or less legal, or at most the subject of a civil action by the purchaser. I mean, look at the software industry. How many software companies sell products that are buggy crap, that they know are buggy crap? And when it comes to investments, that basic dynamic is at the heart of a lot of sales. If I think this investment is a great deal that's going to just go up and up, why would I sell it to you?
I'm willing to entertain the idea that what GS did crossed the line in terms of the standard of ethics people expect of investment professionals, which maybe should be higher than for businesses generally. Maybe we should put such standards in place and make them enforceable,[1] but it wouldn't be fair to throw people in jail for what they did before those standards were in place.
[1] For example, it would be punishable ethical breach for a lawyer to represent a client then take a financial position adverse to the client's interests.
The only thing missing from a fraud case in the "selling shit products" story is "knowingly making false statements", right?
GS knowingly sold AIG junk CDOs days before the collapse
GS didn't sell CDOs to AIG. GS didn't actually sell anything to AIG. GS bought insurance (in the form of credit default swaps) on the CDOs from AIG and apparently sold at least some of those swaps on to other banks for a profit.
If Goldman had done something to accelerate the deterioration of the value of the CDOs (something like insuring a house and then burning it down), then you could probably claim GS was in the wrong. AIG would have known it was insuring subprime mortgage CDOs. There also isn't anything in the article asserting that GS misrepresented the quality of the loans or anything like that.
It's hard to get from that WSJ article to fraud.
http://wheredoesallmymoneygo.com/goldman-sachs-fined-550-mil...
They're potentially using insider information on deals and risk in order to profit; I'm not sure they should even be allowed to bet against their clients, because it gives them all sorts of perverse incentives. But it's a complex area, and I'm no expert in it...
I agree it would be hard for that to end in a fraud conviction, and as you say perhaps more regulation would be required for that to even be possible, but perhaps more regulation of this area is required.
You have to consider that when an investment bank sells you a structured product it then naturally has the opposite position. If you want something that pays off if interest rates rise, an investment bank can sell you something like that in the form of an interest rate swap. You are now long interest rates and the bank is short them, but there wasn't anything malicious there. The bank just sold you the product you wanted. Now the bank has to hedge somehow or sell the swap on to someone who wants to be short interest rates. It may have clients that are interested in that sort of exposure.
I'm not trying to defend Goldman here, but when people say things like "banks are betting against their clients" it usually shows a misunderstanding of the business.
That was the fraud. It told its clients the portfolio had been created by someone who was trying to put together a reasonable-ish CDO when in fact it had been put together with the exact opposite in mind. I will also point out that there are no claims by the SEC that Goldman itself was short the CDO.
> Iceland banks didn't collapse, the government nationalized them to prevent their collapse. (Edit: as another poster mentions a portion of the debt was paid down by other states too. Again, that's a detail, not a fundamental difference).
It is a fundamental difference. When Iceland took over its banks, it basically said: your deposits are insured if you are a tax-payer. Customers living elsewhere, share holders and (non-Icelandic?) bond holders were wiped out; they were owed something one day, zero the next, and it matters little to Icelanders who may have generously picked up the tab -- they didn't. The banks were recapitalized when needed, and a few bank execs got thrown in jail for good measure.
I beg to ask how this is in any way similar to what happened in the US, the UK or Ireland. Or Greece, for that matter.