(I too had an Icesave account at the time, it was a fearful couple weeks)
What's also important to remember is that only retail investors were bailed out. Council's and the like lost everything.
It may have been a £50K limit, the precise number wasn't an issue for me at the time as I wasn't near either figure.
Did the Icelandic government ever agree to this liability? Was their ability to meet it ever looked in to?
I believe it was part of some European agreement for open access to financial markets but I don't know the details. So I think that the answer is probably: Yes.
Edit: I've upvoted a sibling post with the judgment on the case. I haven't read it all but it seems clear to me that the rules were complicated and there were good reasons to believe that Iceland had such a liability.
>Was their ability to meet it ever looked in to?
Obviously not sufficiently. It may be that it was looked into initially when it was small and manageable but no-one said stop when the Icelandic banks grew beyond the ability of their government to rescue. Of course if you withdraw cover you can trigger the bank run that brings down the system. With hindsight you know that you should have stepped in to restrict opening of accounts before the risky position was reached.
Edit2 to add: Agree that FSA were at fault. My post was to explain the extent to which it was not an exotic foreign investment but a normal option available to regular customers and with the normal bank compensation scheme in place.
See the EFTA court ruling at http://www.eftacourt.int/uploads/tx_nvcases/16_11_Judgment_E...
As part of the EU scheme I think the intention was for local compensation schemes to pay out to consumers and reclaim from the bank's home countries if the bank failed. Obviously this part didn't happen (and possibly could never have happened) but if the FSCS did not list Icesave I would not have invested.
My due diligence was checking the bank was properly covered by the UK scheme and that I did not have more money in it than was covered by the UK's compensation scheme.
A case can be made that those investing more than the scheme should have lost money (not necessarily just for Icelandic banks but also for the UK banks that were bailed out) or that FSCS should not have committed to compensate but they did so they really did need to pay out.