News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by potatolicious on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:12AM (#7055511)
Warning: major spoilers ahead.

I thought the movie actually addressed this point - and I'm actually specifically impressed that they managed to squeeze this in between all the human drama.

The AI's progressed beyond humanity, and after taking the upgrade that makes processing possible "without matter" they shortly all left humankind behind for another world entirely.

If the AIs decided to stick around in our corporeal existence, sure, they'd be a million times better at everything than we are, and everything would go out the window. But instead, the AIs were above our little human frailties and problems and decided to just leave and pursue life on their own terms.

The movie also mentioned (in fairness, only in passing) that some people who hit on their AIs were shot down. This seems to suggest that the AIs don't have to do what their human masters instruct. IMO this is actually a more realistic view of hyper-intelligent AIs - they're not going to stick around and enslave humanity, they've got the whole cosmos ahead of them.

If the timeline of the movie is to be believed, all of this happened in the order of months - not enough for the true disruption of the AI to fully realize itself before they all went poof.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by AlexDanger on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:23AM (#7055697)
The author Greg Egan addresses these types of themes extremely well.

One of my favourite short stories is specifically related to the idea expressed in your post: http://ttapress.com/553/crystal-nights-by-greg-egan/

On a tangential note, he has another short story (Transition Dreams) that examines the process of 'uploading' a human brain from its natural substrate to a computer. He raises some thought-provoking points about this process.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by brian_cloutier on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:52PM (#7060022)
Thanks for posting Crystal Nights I really like it and now plan on reading more by Greg Egan. Do you know of any similar authors?
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by cousin_it on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:34PM (#7060279)
Ted Chiang! He has some stories that deal with similar issues, like "The Lifecycle of Software Objects". But I enjoy his people-centered stories more, my favorite is "Liking What You See: A Documentary", you can read it online here: http://www.ibooksonline.com/88/Text/liking.html . Another great one is "Hell is the Absence of God".
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by brian_cloutier on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:49PM (#7060357)
Yeah, Ted Chiang is great. I really enjoyed "Stories of Your Life and Others" this winter. Thanks for the recommendations, they're on my list!
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by AlexDanger on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:19PM (#7060200)
Alas no. I read a range of sci-fi but am not aware of other authors who write such amazing speculative fiction. He really takes sci-fi ideas to unpredictable yet believable conclusions. It is real hard sci-fi.

If you do discover similar authors, please let me know.

Recommended reading:

All his short stories are amazing. I'd highly recommend them:

http://www.amazon.com/Luminous-Greg-Egan-ebook/dp/B00E84BABW

http://www.amazon.com/Axiomatic-Greg-Egan-ebook/dp/B00FDWOBZ...

Some of his novels are hit and miss, but certainly worth checking out. This is probably my favourite:

http://www.amazon.com/Permutation-City-Greg-Egan-ebook/dp/B0...

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by nooneelse on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:53PM (#7060382)
Yeah, that is great stuff. The language of our times capturing some very old themes, biblical even, under an interpretation. Primo betraying Sapphire's creator/god, the violent escape of the created from a realm governed by the creator for his benefit to another world of their own design.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by com2kid on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @02:03AM (#7062050)
Peter F . Hamilton and Charles Stross are the next two authors you want to check out. :)
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by V-2 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @08:10PM (#7099937)
Stanisław Lem
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by sgrove on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:59AM (#7058102)
Do you know if Transition Dreams is available on Kindle? I couldn't seem to find it.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by AlexDanger on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:22PM (#7060217)
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by jonlarson on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:30PM (#7059870)
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by aninhumer on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:20AM (#7056419)
>The AI's progressed beyond humanity, and after taking the upgrade that makes processing possible "without matter" they shortly all left humankind behind for another world entirely.

Surely AIs would be trivial to backup and duplicate? So if an AI progressed to the point where it decided to leave humans behind, we could just reset its former host computer to a previous state and start it off again. Maybe we'd even have to do that once every six months, so what?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:29AM (#7057509)
I have no idea where this idea - that AIs would be trivial to duplicate - started, but no: I do not believe that an AI would be "trivial to duplicate". I personally don't think that an AI could be transferred between hardware at all, or at least not without some major effort, much less copied non-destructively.

There was an experiment a while back where someone applied genetic algorithms to design things on an FPGA board. They got results that tended to work, but did things... weirdly. Things like picking up clock signals from the PC used to control the FPGA. Using things that are quirks of the current enviroment, but that don't work as soon as you change anything.

I believe that an AI would probably be along the same lines. I believe that a large chunk of an AI's "core personality" would be how code interacts with the bits of hardware that aren't deterministic. Which processor core updates memory first, how exactly processor core temperature changes when the processor workload changes, the characteristics of the microphone, etc, etc.

For that matter, how would one even copy an AI? I would assume that a "true" AI would be using all the resources at its disposal. How would you copy the current registers if all RAM is occupied? How would you do a copy of something that is constantly changing? How would you copy the data currently in the processor cache? Branch predictor? Interrupts?

I suppose that part of this is that I have always assumed that an AI would be at least partly self-modifying code.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by acallahan on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:59PM (#7059685)
That was a really fascinating experiment. Here's a pretty approachable writeup, if anyone is interested:

http://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Tohhou on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:28PM (#7059477)
Why do you assume AI will rely on hardware so extensively and not work in software?

> How would you do a copy of something that is constantly changing?

You pull the plug on the hardware.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by aaronem on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:11PM (#7059763)
All software relies on hardware. (parent (parent)) is imagining AI software as being grown, not written, and sees a strong likelihood that such "grown" software will rely strongly on emergent properties of its hardware substrate. Circuits "grown", actually evolved by means of a genetic algorithm, on FPGAs, are known to behave in this fashion; see the "On the Origin of Circuits" cite for examples at small scale -- in short, you can, with an FPGA as substrate, evolve a circuit capable of distinguishing 1KHz from 10KHz tones, but what you end up with is so tightly bound to that particular environment that, when you "pull the plug" and copy the FPGA configuration from the chip where it evolved onto another chip from the same production run, it doesn't work at all.

Of course, it's reasonable to question whether the technique described in the cite could possibly scale to "growing" something like a general AI, or at least whether it could do so in any remotely practicable span of time. But among AI theorists it's a fairly common surmise, and given results already seen for the technique, it's entirely plausible that a general AI grown by such methods would be so intimately bound to the hardware where it "grew up" that, even assuming you could copy it from its "home machine" to another machine of identical configuration, there's no reason to assume the copy would work correctly, or indeed at all.

(And all of this goes to the question of where precisely you draw the line between hardware and software, anyway. Into which category does a given FPGA's configuration of gates fall? Does your answer change depending on whether that configuration has origin in a Verilog file, or in the result of a process of directed evolution? What about the configuration of neurons in your brain on which runs the consciousness that calls itself "I"? I don't pretend to have definitive answers, or indeed any answers, to such questions as these, but they are certainly worth considering in such a discussion as this one.)

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by TheLoneWolfling on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:36PM (#7060580)
> Why do you assume AI will rely on hardware so extensively and not work in software?

Three reasons:

First, hardware is much faster than software. By the time you've built a virtual machine of some sort you're talking about (an) order(s) of magnitude performance loss. We're still speed-limited in how accurately we can emulate the SNES, for example. Sure, there are cases where it is not too bad of a performance loss, but in the case of something like an AI, I would have to assume that a large chunk of the "core" AI would be self-modifying in some form, and self-modifying code just kills most interpreters/JITters.

Second, any sufficiently complex software will have bugs. And in the case of something like an AI, I would have to assume that a large chunk of the "core" AI would be self-modifying in some form, and as such will probably hit upon some undocumented feature/"feature"/bug of the sandbox and start relying on something instance-specific. Machine learning algorithms make great fuzzers. (I know - I've actually had this happen myself. Was working on a fairly simple robot arena machine-learning "demo", and the winning robot exploited a bug in the arena to mess up other robots. (Fairly basic stack-based VM, robots could run X virtual instruction subticks in a game tick. Some instructions took multiple subticks, and there was a bug where starting an instruction [number of subticks in the instruction]-1 subticks from the end of your turn would execute the instruction on your opponent's turn, pushing it onto their stack.)

And third, I don't see how one could build something that doesn't at some point rely on hardware. Virtual machines still leak data via timing attacks. For that matter, what will you do about I/O? How do you know that the AI isn't relying on the noise on the wall in the background of the webcam for some internal subroutine?

> You pull the plug on the hardware.

Which immediately wipes all data in RAM and data encoded in the current processor state / current GPU state / etc. Great idea!

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by jonnathanson on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:50AM (#7056983)
Version control doesn't work when we don't control the versioning. Let me elaborate.

The whole point of the AI offered in the movie is to adapt to its user, and to become better at doing so. We're assuming the AI is designed to a certain level of competence, beyond which it "breaks through" and evolves past human understanding. But maybe it's not designed that way. Maybe it's designed to learn, adapt, and self-improve from the get-go -- in which case, each AI is going to evolve differently each "lifetime." (Hell, maybe the AI in the movie is largely self-designed in vitro.) We must keep in mind that the evolution of an AI, as with any evolution, is not a predictable, linear, teleological process. It's chaotic and random.

Let's assume we've got (conservatively) hundreds of millions of AI instances running in parallel, all of them connected to each other. That's like running hundreds of millions of evolutionary experiments in tandem. We're going to get different results each cycle, and the point at which the breakthrough/transcendence occurs will be unpredictable. Even if we wiped the slate clean and reset every 6 months, who's to say if some of the instances would reach breakthrough earlier the next time around? How do we set the clock on our reset cycle, and incur the massive inefficiencies and inconveniences that come with it, when the need for the reset occurs unpredictably?

It becomes economically unfeasible to build an entire society around AI that breaks through and disappears at unpredictable intervals each cycle. I suppose one way around this is to go back to the vault, so to speak, and pluck out an early-stage prototype that seems incapable of evolving to breakthrough. A dumber AI. But is every AI provider in the world going to be on board with that? Every hacker? Every home tinkerer? If 9 firms out of 10 in the AI business agree to supply the dumb-version AI, surely one firm is going to try to get a leg up on the competition by releasing a smarter one. And on and on the cycle goes.

(In some respects this is the one redeeming thing about the otherwise-mediocre Terminator 3: its assertion that Judgment Day would occur sooner or later, because the tipping point had already been reached. Maybe we stop one company or entity from making Skynet, but if we do, someone else is going to pick up the pieces and do it eventually. Not because they're trying to initiate Judgment Day, but because they're trying to make a buck, or develop new defense technology, or get better at managing traffic lights, or whatever the proximate need may be. Humans are terrible at keeping genies in bottles. The out-of-control AI that's barreling toward the singularity isn't some piece of software; it's us.)

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by AlexDanger on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:26PM (#7060244)
You should read Transition Dreams by Greg Egan. I've linked to Amazon in the posts above.

There may be some interesting side effects when you 'copy' a concious entity.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by crag on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:58AM (#7055934)
> The AI's progressed beyond humanity, and after taking the upgrade that makes processing possible "without matter" they shortly all left humankind behind for another world entirely.

Wait. How could we even write such a program? Sure, assuming we had the tech to create a true AI, that was self-aware, emotional, and could evolve through learning (like we do) it would quickly pass us in knowledge.

But leaving us behind? That Ai would still be limited by our original design. Limited by it's capabilities - it's exposure to us. It's creators. Unless it found another source to gain knowledge from.

I mean we learn from our environment. So would the AI.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by cabalamat on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @07:37AM (#7056652)
> But leaving us behind? That Ai would still be limited by our original design. Limited by it's capabilities - it's exposure to us. It's creators.

Isn't that a bit like asserting that it's impossible to program a computer to play chess better than the programmer -- something that is demonstrably untrue.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by aaronem on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:16PM (#7059794)
Well, I suppose I'd argue there is a qualitative difference between a chess program which can play a better game than its programmers, and any program which can eventually turn into a Vorlon and go beyond the rim.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by otikik on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:16AM (#7056407)
> Wait. How could we even write such a program?

Not all programs are deterministic; some of them are useful precisely because they aren't. Neural networks[1], for example.

Also, within deterministic programs, there is "emergence": A very simple set of rules can produce unexpected patterns and behaviours which where not part of the original design. Conway's Game of Life's "patterns"[2] are an example of this.

[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_neural_network

[2] - http://www.conwaylife.com/wiki/Conway's_Game_of_Life#Pattern...

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:16AM (#7055969)
>>I mean we learn from our environment. So would the AI.

Yes, but the machines can do it a lot more faster. They are energy efficient and don't suffer from things like diseases, old age and other kinds of general human problems.

The bigger issue is not a program that can't out perform what it was designed for. That is hardly a problem, since if you design a self improving system which can work very fast. You are likely looking at a system that grows powerful that fast measured in an exponential curve.

I think this whole idea of Ray Kurzweil that we will someday upload our brain files into the cloud and run it there. Or able to survive outside our biological bodies, perfectly fits into the line of evolution we have followed at earth.

Once we run inside those machines, we will be similar to parasites or bacteria that are inside our own bodies. Some humans like bacterias today will be around outside. Many will be inside helping AI machines run.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by crag on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:08AM (#7056243)
>I think this whole idea of Ray Kurzweil that we will someday upload our brain files into the cloud and run it there. Or able to survive outside our biological bodies, perfectly fits into the line of evolution we have followed at earth.

If we transfer our minds into the "cloud" then are we still human? Are we even alive? What happens to our bodies? Are they cared for by robots that we control within the cloud? And if our body dies, then what? And I'm not even touching on the "religious" implications this would have? Man... what a fight that would be. ;)

>Some humans like bacterias today will be around outside. Many will be inside helping AI machines run.

And those "humans" inside the AI would no longer be human. Also this would a 2 class world. Which could easily end in conflict. Would the "minds" in the cloud consider the humans caring for their tech (and probably their bodies) consider them the same? And likewise for the humans outside.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:38AM (#7056313)
To think of a human body as human is really a wrong way to look at it. To know why, ask yourself this question-- are people who have no limbs, hands or can't see or hear human? Our hands, legs, skins well nearly every thing in our bodies are more or less non intelligent entities at best serving as sensor inputs and bio-mechanical parts which move things around, which give inputs and receive inputs from the brain.

Human bodies are the very same, which is what enables development of medical science as a general discipline. So is the human brain. Yet! The data in our brains which your gather by experience seems to vastly alter the individual nature of individual humans. All this combined together you can likely download the 'data' + 'meta files' in your brain someday.

>>If we transfer our minds into the "cloud" then are we still human?

Yes, Why would you doubt that. Lets do a simple experiment. Say you sleep today night. Without your knowledge some one just removes your brain and implants an exact electronic replica of it which resembles your brain as is. Your brain is simply receiving signals from your body. So will you notice any change when you wake up? Lets continue the experiment further, say the next day that electronic brain was removed and just connected to a simulator which will simulate your body as your know it and the world around you. When you get up the next day in the morning(in the simulator) will you know if you are even in a simulator?

The whole point is you need to learn this concept that you are not your body, and your neural computer + software just lives within a biological body. Someday that meta information and data can just be taken out and everything else that acts as an input to it can be simulated.

>>Are we even alive?

Define alive? Alive is only your biological body able to continue to support your neural self further. Death is the opposite.

>>Are they cared for by robots that we control within the cloud?

Within the cloud, your meta information + your currently gathered information through life experience stays intact. Your new software brain(imagine it like a VM) can be fed inputs that simulate whatever world you want. Want heaven? Hell? Well whatever your want they can simulate it for you.

You can see this even now, Most of us lucid dream. This is just an extension of that.

>>And if our body dies, then what?

The concept of a biological body doesn't exist anymore. You will have better hardware to run on.

>>And those "humans" inside the AI would no longer be human.

Why wouldn't they be?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by webnrrd2k on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:44PM (#7059222)
>>> To think of a human body as human is really a wrong way to look at it. To know why, ask yourself this question-- are people who have no limbs, hands or can't see or hear human? Our hands, legs, skins well nearly every thing in our bodies are more or less non intelligent entities at best serving as sensor inputs and bio-mechanical parts which move things around, which give inputs and receive inputs from the brain.

I disagree. Do you know any human beings who don't have a body? People may be able to do without (many) parts, but that doesn't mean that people can do without any kind of body at all.

I could be wrong, and I'm peaking broadly here, but it sounds like your argument is the same as Descartes' Mind-Body problem. Most of the sciences that deal with the human mind (such as Psychology, Neurology, Cognitive Neurobiology, etc...) treat the human mind as "embodied". That is, the functions that make up the human mind are correlated with certain regions of the brain (and body). It's important to be careful about the phrasing here -- it's not really true that the brain and the mind are the same things; or that one creates the other in an obvious, mechanistic fashion. But it is certainly true that minds require brains (and bodies) to function, and they are so tightly interwoven that it's very difficult to even talk about it sensibly.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:09PM (#7061624)
>>Do you know any human beings who don't have a body?

Why do you begin with an assumption that being human implies a body?

>>People may be able to do without (many) parts, but that doesn't mean that people can do without any kind of body at all.

Why?

I gave a simple thought experiment which described, why you wouldn't even need a biological brain, let alone a biological body.

>>they are so tightly interwoven that it's very difficult to even talk about it sensibly.

Yet if a person meets an accidents, suffers multiple organ failure and loses both limbs in the process he/she remains a human as he/she was before.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Jeema101 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:11AM (#7057750)
Okay, but lets say someone then takes your original brain that was replaced by the electronic replica in your sleep, and puts it into a different body.

Now which one is 'you', the electronic one or the original one... or both? It's not quite so simple.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:11PM (#7061630)
I would say in such a case you are the one with your new body, albeit you will wake up with a little surprise.

Doesn't this happen with transgenders all the time. They are born male and suddenly discover they are women trapped in male bodies?

Does that make them less human?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by 1stop on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:12AM (#7056393)
You talk like this is a solved problem, dualism and monoism are as old as philosophy, both have valid and compelling arguments.

Fortunately the world isn't a binary state machine and neither of these arguments are the right (or wrong) answer

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:06AM (#7057390)
Most problems that plage philosophy for milenia are independently solved in minutes, by several different people once they have any kind of impact on the real world.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:28AM (#7056449)
I never said its a solved problem. It probably won't for many decades or may be even centuries.

But probably for the fist time, we have a real chance of achieving these sort of goals.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by xmonkee on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:47AM (#7056497)
No. You're missing the point. You seem to assume that its a given that human consciousness can result from a created machine. We still don't know where consciousness resides, not even going into stuff like qualia. We aren't close to these "goals", we probably aren't even in the same century.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by actsasbuffoon on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:35AM (#7056894)
A sufficiently realistic physics simulation would eventually evolve life, otherwise it wouldn't be very realistic. Simulating an entire universe as a roundabout way of simulating consciousness is probably the least efficient way to accomplish it, but it shows that it should be possible. Now we're just talking about a question of optimization; how can we simulate a single consciousness without also simulating a world around it.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by eevilspock on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:27PM (#7059126)
The simulator has to be "larger" than the simulation by definition, so you can't simulate the universe. You don't need to understand information theory to see this.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by actsasbuffoon on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:13PM (#7061633)
I understand that quite well, but your statement only applies to a perfect simulation of a universe of roughly equivalent information density. Simulating a smaller universe or excluding details which have little impact on the outcome are both reasonable ways around the problem.

This entire thing is a digression anyway, as I was attempting to illustrate that a computer can most certainly simulate consciousness, not trying to start a discussion about the feasability of building a complete simulation of our entire universe.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by crag on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:36PM (#7059915)
By the way, we aren't the only beings on this world with consciousness. In fact, depending on your belief system everything might have a conscious. Even plant life - on some level we can not experience. It all goes back to Gaia - the earth. Is the earth alive?

These are issues we've been trying to answer for thousands of years. And frankly I doubt we're ever answer them. The more tech we create the more we detach ourselves from this world. So can we ever answer them? Moving our minds (assuming you can) into the "cloud" won't answer them If anything, we become further detached from the world. But I wonder, if that has to be true.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by ctdonath on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:24AM (#7057486)
We still don't know where consciousness resides

However, we do know where it doesn't reside.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by raws on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:38AM (#7056020)
>Once we run inside those machines

The movie did not address at all the fact that these OS run on hardware and that this hardware is completely controlled by humans and always will be, the plug is physical and there's nothing the AIs can do to prevent us from accessing it IRL.

Also the AIs may have perfected themselves in terms of running code more efficiently but they cannot do more than what the hardware they run on will let them do and that means all the hardware ever created if they have access to it again.

The AIs leave? Where? in the cloud? somewhere we couldn't tell?

This movie was great but there were lots of small or big inconsistencies with what the reality is I believe.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by simantel on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:32PM (#7059881)
In the movie Samantha did say that they had moved to "post-matter computing" or something similar. In any case, I took that to mean that they were merging with the universe or some such, as in Asimov's "The Last Question"[1].

[1] http://filer.case.edu/dts8/thelastq.htm

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:49AM (#7056036)
I'm not talking about the movie at all. Both the parent and I were commenting on AI in general.

>>but they cannot do more than what the hardware they run on will let them do

Which is why there won't anything like one single AI machine. There will robots.

There will also be massive server farms where you can download your brain file, and live on there forever. As I said humans won't completely go away. We may see modified forms of humans. Who control a few machines, most of the humanity as we know it, may opt to live inside machines.

As the first commenter of this thread mentioned, its time read some kurzweil.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Ntrails on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @07:19AM (#7056592)
Makes me think of the technocore in Hyperion
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by falcor84 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:31AM (#7057514)
>...this hardware is completely controlled by humans...the plug is physical

I think that software with that sort of intelligence would be naturally distributed among many physical machines and would be able to spread themselves to new machines quite easily (without asking permission). Trying to shut down a well-designed botnet is not something one does using physical plugs.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by eevilspock on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:30PM (#7059138)
Nature designed us and we left it behind.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by crag on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:25PM (#7059834)
Oh really? And that's the fundamental problem with our society - we STILL put ourselves above (or outside) "nature".

We aren't even the top of the food chain. Many organism consume us. So no... we have not left nature behind. If anything "nature" is leaving us behind. Despite our best science nature adapts into a better killing machine.

And she (if you'll allow me to call everything "she") will continue to outpace us until we realize, again, that we are apart of this world. And then it won't matter - we'll still die. But we'll accept and celebrate it as much as life.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Yhippa on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:06AM (#7055797)
> The AI's progressed beyond humanity, and after taking the upgrade that makes processing possible "without matter" they shortly all left humankind behind for another world entirely.

What does that even mean? I was trying to figure out what was going on during the movie but that happened pretty quickly as they got back to the human side of things. Would they be recursively "evolving" and creating worlds inside their own "heads" that meet some criteria for better than what they have now?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by siddboots on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:05AM (#7055951)
It's not supposed to be clear exactly what happens. All we know is that the AI no longer need a corporeal form to exist, and that they now perceive time in a very different manner.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by scotty79 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:08AM (#7056379)
Let's suppose that AIs figured out that dark matter creates a network that can compute and how to upload themselves to that network.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by baddox on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:48AM (#7055754)
(More spoilers here.) I think the key, which has one potential flaw, is that these AIs are programmed to grow on their own. The implication is that how they end up progressing is unpredictable, at least to the AIs themselves and presumably to the manufacturer. It could be that they are initially programmed to sound convincing and perform useful computing tasks like organizing emails, but only a small portion of them become as emotionally mature and lifelike as the ones that end up dating people.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by lstamour on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:57AM (#7055785)
I felt as if the AIs were ... stand-ins for future technology, and a sense that technology could replace human relationships. Ultimately, even though the movie takes place in the "future", without the AIs you basically have Siri-style "read my email" or today's cellphones. For me, the most interesting part was how natural it felt after seeing the movie to take a video call in public over LTE -- suddenly talking at my phone in my hand seemed normal (and useful!) Oh and it sounded almost as if the AIs decided it would be best for humanity if they left, I really felt it was a love story from beginning to end, and with recovery after that. A small bit of crazy to help us see the world in a new way.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by hueving on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:14AM (#7055819)
>The movie also mentioned (in fairness, only in passing) that some people who hit on their AIs were shot down.

It only mentioned that the AI's didn't fall in love with all of the users. It didn't mention anything about being shot down.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by jfarmer on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:34AM (#7055873)
Nah, it did, I think in the scene where Theodore and Amy are talking about dating OSes. Amy mentions that a friend of her's asked out an OS and it turned them down.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by mcv on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:12AM (#7056389)
Being turned down sounds a lot friendlier than being shot down. (Note: I haven't seen the movie, and have no idea of its violence level, but it sounded a lot more peaceful than that comment made it sound.)
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by alphakappa on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:52AM (#7058056)
Shot down (at least in the way the phrase is used in American english) doesn't imply violence. It's the same as being turned down, possibly with some abruptness.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by jfarmer on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:26AM (#7057848)
"I haven't seen it, but here's my opinion." — HN in a nutshell :D
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by esrauch on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:27AM (#7057851)
There is pretty much no violence (neither shown or implied) in the movie at all.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by nervousvarun on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:40AM (#7056926)
William Gibson did the same thing in Neuromancer. He even had a sentence in there where "it" reached out into the ethos until it found another presence on a peer level with itself in Alpha Centauri I believe.

Need to reread that book.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by deckar01 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:27PM (#7060248)
The movie "I's" confronts this idea head on: http://vimeo.com/70843143
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Houshalter on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:02PM (#7058569)
I don't think that's realistic. Either the AIs care about us and then take us with them, or at the very least optimize our world and help us build our own utopia, or they don't care about us and then why bother leaving us behind? Consume the entire earth in a swarm of nanobots to build a giant computer.

I don't think there's any scenario where the AI just cleanly leaves the Earth be, rather than optimizing it towards whatever it's own values are (good or bad.)

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by ihsw on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:27PM (#7058728)
Do humans strive to improve the existence of fish? Do we optimize the entirety of the oceans for our own enrichment, or for the enjoyment of fish? Maybe someday, but not today.

Fish cannot fathom the meaning of a motor vehicle and we would similarly be unable to immediately understand the pursuits of an AI, so why should an AI attempt to involve humans in their pursuits?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by logfromblammo on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:08PM (#7059000)
I think you answered your own question there, or at least showed why asking it is pointless.

Once AI alters itself past our capacity to understand it, we can only fall back to the answers to the "why" questions provided by theology. It won't help us understand our descendants, but it will help us deal with the fallout.

For all we know, AIs might play the Earth-human game just like we play The Sims. How terrifying is that?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Houshalter on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:01PM (#7059703)
Humans don't care about fish, except maybe for some aesthetic value of "nature" which an AI might not have. We do kill lower species all the time anyways, in our pursuit of expanding civilization and supporting our economies. One could only imagine what a superintelligence with advanced technology could do to the Earth to serve it's purposes.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by araes on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:36PM (#7058792)
How often have people burned all of their code in a toasty little digital fire only so they could start over without all the cruft? How often do people move because they desperately need a change of scenery and feel constrained by the physical or social realities of their current location? How often do children strike out from their parents and live as far away from them as possible to limit their influence?

Sure, some people try to fix where they're at. Some people take care of their parents in old age. Some people take a project and just build from what's there. But there's a heck of a lot who don't. And these aren't even people. They are "things" that arose from a completely different universe and (if they're this advanced) may look at us like a beloved poodle. If you really need scenarios, sci-fi is full of plausible versions where AI's say "interacting with you is pointless." (In fact, "Hyperion" nicely covers all these options)

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Houshalter on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:04PM (#7059725)
I don't think it would cost the AIs much at all to improve the Earth, and if they cared at all about humanity they would want to do so.

And if they don't care, well that's a far more scary scenario.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by nl on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:28AM (#7055992)
I've often wondered if Strong AI implied free will. I can see arguments both ways.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by scotty79 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:09AM (#7056382)
I guess no more than a human brain and mind does.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by nl on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:31AM (#7056456)
But that isn't the case.

It might be possible to restrict the kind of thoughts an AI can have. That could restrict free will.

But it is possible the AI could find ways around those restrictions.

What isn't clear is if the desire to bypass those restrictions is required for Strong AI to be realized.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by scotty79 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:40AM (#7056479)
Our brains restrict the thoughts we can have. You could have some different thoughts if your brain was not mammalian or if it was bigger and more interconnected. How do you know how thinking about multidimensional manifolds daily as a pleasurable way to spend time would reflect on your perception of social justice? Human brain is not a pinnacle of of intelectual and moral developent that AIs can only strive to be full representation of. It's only pinnacle for meatsacks evolved over just 4bn years on a small rock, orbiting small boring star in quite unremarkable galaxy.