News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:38AM (#7056313)
To think of a human body as human is really a wrong way to look at it. To know why, ask yourself this question-- are people who have no limbs, hands or can't see or hear human? Our hands, legs, skins well nearly every thing in our bodies are more or less non intelligent entities at best serving as sensor inputs and bio-mechanical parts which move things around, which give inputs and receive inputs from the brain.

Human bodies are the very same, which is what enables development of medical science as a general discipline. So is the human brain. Yet! The data in our brains which your gather by experience seems to vastly alter the individual nature of individual humans. All this combined together you can likely download the 'data' + 'meta files' in your brain someday.

>>If we transfer our minds into the "cloud" then are we still human?

Yes, Why would you doubt that. Lets do a simple experiment. Say you sleep today night. Without your knowledge some one just removes your brain and implants an exact electronic replica of it which resembles your brain as is. Your brain is simply receiving signals from your body. So will you notice any change when you wake up? Lets continue the experiment further, say the next day that electronic brain was removed and just connected to a simulator which will simulate your body as your know it and the world around you. When you get up the next day in the morning(in the simulator) will you know if you are even in a simulator?

The whole point is you need to learn this concept that you are not your body, and your neural computer + software just lives within a biological body. Someday that meta information and data can just be taken out and everything else that acts as an input to it can be simulated.

>>Are we even alive?

Define alive? Alive is only your biological body able to continue to support your neural self further. Death is the opposite.

>>Are they cared for by robots that we control within the cloud?

Within the cloud, your meta information + your currently gathered information through life experience stays intact. Your new software brain(imagine it like a VM) can be fed inputs that simulate whatever world you want. Want heaven? Hell? Well whatever your want they can simulate it for you.

You can see this even now, Most of us lucid dream. This is just an extension of that.

>>And if our body dies, then what?

The concept of a biological body doesn't exist anymore. You will have better hardware to run on.

>>And those "humans" inside the AI would no longer be human.

Why wouldn't they be?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by webnrrd2k on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:44PM (#7059222)
>>> To think of a human body as human is really a wrong way to look at it. To know why, ask yourself this question-- are people who have no limbs, hands or can't see or hear human? Our hands, legs, skins well nearly every thing in our bodies are more or less non intelligent entities at best serving as sensor inputs and bio-mechanical parts which move things around, which give inputs and receive inputs from the brain.

I disagree. Do you know any human beings who don't have a body? People may be able to do without (many) parts, but that doesn't mean that people can do without any kind of body at all.

I could be wrong, and I'm peaking broadly here, but it sounds like your argument is the same as Descartes' Mind-Body problem. Most of the sciences that deal with the human mind (such as Psychology, Neurology, Cognitive Neurobiology, etc...) treat the human mind as "embodied". That is, the functions that make up the human mind are correlated with certain regions of the brain (and body). It's important to be careful about the phrasing here -- it's not really true that the brain and the mind are the same things; or that one creates the other in an obvious, mechanistic fashion. But it is certainly true that minds require brains (and bodies) to function, and they are so tightly interwoven that it's very difficult to even talk about it sensibly.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:09PM (#7061624)
>>Do you know any human beings who don't have a body?

Why do you begin with an assumption that being human implies a body?

>>People may be able to do without (many) parts, but that doesn't mean that people can do without any kind of body at all.

Why?

I gave a simple thought experiment which described, why you wouldn't even need a biological brain, let alone a biological body.

>>they are so tightly interwoven that it's very difficult to even talk about it sensibly.

Yet if a person meets an accidents, suffers multiple organ failure and loses both limbs in the process he/she remains a human as he/she was before.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by Jeema101 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:11AM (#7057750)
Okay, but lets say someone then takes your original brain that was replaced by the electronic replica in your sleep, and puts it into a different body.

Now which one is 'you', the electronic one or the original one... or both? It's not quite so simple.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:11PM (#7061630)
I would say in such a case you are the one with your new body, albeit you will wake up with a little surprise.

Doesn't this happen with transgenders all the time. They are born male and suddenly discover they are women trapped in male bodies?

Does that make them less human?

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by 1stop on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:12AM (#7056393)
You talk like this is a solved problem, dualism and monoism are as old as philosophy, both have valid and compelling arguments.

Fortunately the world isn't a binary state machine and neither of these arguments are the right (or wrong) answer

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:06AM (#7057390)
Most problems that plage philosophy for milenia are independently solved in minutes, by several different people once they have any kind of impact on the real world.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by kamaal on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:28AM (#7056449)
I never said its a solved problem. It probably won't for many decades or may be even centuries.

But probably for the fist time, we have a real chance of achieving these sort of goals.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by xmonkee on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:47AM (#7056497)
No. You're missing the point. You seem to assume that its a given that human consciousness can result from a created machine. We still don't know where consciousness resides, not even going into stuff like qualia. We aren't close to these "goals", we probably aren't even in the same century.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by actsasbuffoon on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:35AM (#7056894)
A sufficiently realistic physics simulation would eventually evolve life, otherwise it wouldn't be very realistic. Simulating an entire universe as a roundabout way of simulating consciousness is probably the least efficient way to accomplish it, but it shows that it should be possible. Now we're just talking about a question of optimization; how can we simulate a single consciousness without also simulating a world around it.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by eevilspock on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:27PM (#7059126)
The simulator has to be "larger" than the simulation by definition, so you can't simulate the universe. You don't need to understand information theory to see this.
Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by actsasbuffoon on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:13PM (#7061633)
I understand that quite well, but your statement only applies to a perfect simulation of a universe of roughly equivalent information density. Simulating a smaller universe or excluding details which have little impact on the outcome are both reasonable ways around the problem.

This entire thing is a digression anyway, as I was attempting to illustrate that a computer can most certainly simulate consciousness, not trying to start a discussion about the feasability of building a complete simulation of our entire universe.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by crag on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:36PM (#7059915)
By the way, we aren't the only beings on this world with consciousness. In fact, depending on your belief system everything might have a conscious. Even plant life - on some level we can not experience. It all goes back to Gaia - the earth. Is the earth alive?

These are issues we've been trying to answer for thousands of years. And frankly I doubt we're ever answer them. The more tech we create the more we detach ourselves from this world. So can we ever answer them? Moving our minds (assuming you can) into the "cloud" won't answer them If anything, we become further detached from the world. But I wonder, if that has to be true.

Re:Why 'Her' will dominate UI design even more than 'Minorit... by ctdonath on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:24AM (#7057486)
We still don't know where consciousness resides

However, we do know where it doesn't reside.