News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by jval on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:42PM (#7044087)
This is just ridiculous. If Overstock is the biggest retailer in the world accepting Bitcoin, and on their opening day they only manage $130,000 in sales (130 BTC), what does that tell you about the volume of Bitcoin actually being used in trade and commerce rather than speculation?

There are 12.5 Million BTC in circulation. I don't doubt that Bitcoin will become a revolutionary system of payments and money storage down the track, but the price of coins is outrageously inflated at the moment.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by olalonde on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:26PM (#7044262)
It's not as small as you think. This is what Overstock's CEO had to say about it on Twitter: "#Bitcoin's first full day on @overstock.com was a huge success: 840 orders, $130,000 in sales. Almost all new customers. #stunned". https://twitter.com/OverstockCEO/statuses/421754592427139072

130 BTC is 0.001% (130/12.5M) of all Bitcoin spent in one day at Overstock. Does Overstock typically receive 0.001% of all the USD money supply in one day (~30M$)? My math is probably a bit off but my point is that before calling 130 BTC ridiculous, you have to put it in perspective with regards to other currencies.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by toomim on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:53PM (#7044379)
We don't have to guess, we can calculate this precisely.

The M1 supply of all USD is $2.1 Trillion [1]. Overstock has $1.1 Billion in revenue per year [2]. So they pull in .05% of US currency per year, or 0.00014% per day.

The bitcoin money supply is $12.5 Billion [3]. Overstock pulled in $130,000 in a day, which is .001% of the bitcoin money supply.

So they got 7 times the proportion of bitcoin than they get of USD.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overstock.com [3] https://blockchain.info/charts/market-cap

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by atmosx on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:05PM (#7044423)
Wait 1 week. Then check the numbers of BTC sales again :-)
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by olalonde on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:15PM (#7044475)
I believe that $1.1 billion revenue figure includes international orders whereas the 130 BTC figure was for US orders only (they haven't enabled Bitcoin payments for international orders yet). In other words, that proportion should be a bit higher.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by maxerickson on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:45PM (#7044336)
From a comment below, they do about $3 million in a day.

But there has never been a day where excited dollar enthusiasts spent easy money on Overstock to help the dollar look better.

Yes, I'm insinuating that at least some of that volume is bitcoin millionaires having a laugh.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by jljljl on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:35PM (#7044552)
That "Almost all new customers" bit seems to emphasize your point. A lot of these people probably hadn't considered Overstock before they heard they were accepting BTC.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by AJ007 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @08:12PM (#7044659)
There are also a lot of holders who want to convert their BTC in to something else without paying taxes. (some of whom will be billed, or jailed, for many years in to the future as tax authorities reverse the transactions paths.)
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by judk on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:42PM (#7044325)
Alternatively, Overstock marketing department could spend $130k of BTC on itself (keeping most of the value due to self-dealing) and make the transaction costs back in PR advertising value.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by RoboTeddy on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:52PM (#7044126)
> I don't doubt that Bitcoin will become a revolutionary system of payments and money storage down the track, but the price of coins is outrageously inflated at the moment.

Prices rise immediately in anticipation of positive future events.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by atmosx on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:13PM (#7044467)
Really?

If that was the case the bust of DPR and the downfall of SR should drive the price of BTC down, to it's knees - since it was the only market where BTC was treated like a curency. This fact shows that either BTC is not as rational as one might think or that big players (or a small team of players) are trying to keep the price as high as possible (by not selling in bulk).

Note that if A. Shamir's paper is correct, and we don't have proof of the opposite, than 98% of BTC is owned by 2% of portfolios. IF that's the case, then it's no wonder it's over-inflated.

The sad thing is some people believe, that somehow this is more liberal while might complete driven, by a small team of unknown/anonymous players.

NOTE: I'm not stating that this scenario is real, but to me seems not far fetched at all.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by ok_craig on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:54PM (#7044614)
I don't see why the closing of silk road should have resulted in a drop of the price if "prices rise immediately in anticipation of positive future events." The closing of silk road lead people to anticipate that bitcoin would come to be associted with mostly legitimate purposes instead of nefarious ones in the future. So the price rose. (That was only part of it though; the senate hearings had a greater effect.)
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by atmosx on Sunday January 12, 2014 @03:34AM (#7045558)
> I don't see why the closing of silk road should have resulted in a drop of the price if "prices rise immediately in anticipation of positive future events."

That's elementary: Since SR was the only place where owning BitCoin was actually useful since you couldn't buy using dollars and was a big market (in turn-over), it's seizure by the FBI should driven BTC price down because the largest btc-related goods trader closed, so all those people buying illegal products, would stop searching/buying for bitcoins. Simple as that.

So losing 40% to 50% of it's value should be expected/rational, IIRC lost from 10 to 20% for a couple of hours. The senate thing you're referring happened later on and it's still NOT clear how will end.

Then you go making an assertion... Like if anyone really cares if you buy drugs, guns or chocolate with your currency. The world doesn't work like that, no one bought/used BTC because suddenly became ethical to own one since the good BFI caught the bad Silk Road guys. If that was the case, the USD wouldn't be so widely used.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by ok_craig on Sunday January 12, 2014 @01:37PM (#7046896)
I mean, we clearly saw that the price rose. You provided an explanation for why it should have fallen. It didn't, so you are wrong. Therefore I think the world "does work like that", in some contexts.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by atmosx on Sunday January 12, 2014 @02:31PM (#7047102)
I offered an explanation of the context in which the prices did not rose, but you clearly you don't believe that's the case.

Out of curiosity, you think that Adi Shamir is wrong?

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by ctrl on Saturday January 11, 2014 @09:47PM (#7044931)
Because people != common sense. The closing of silk road put it in the news as a currency for bad things.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by ok_craig on Sunday January 12, 2014 @01:38PM (#7046899)
It was already widely known as a currency for bad things. The closing basically eliminated that argument.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by drewblaisdell on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:35PM (#7044549)
> the price of coins is outrageously inflated at the moment.

I would love to listen to you justify this statement, or rather, explain how any store of value without intrinsic value can be over/undervalued.

In attempting to do this, you will find that there are gaps in your understanding of how currencies work.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by mrb on Sunday January 12, 2014 @01:49AM (#7045414)
You fail to realize that Overstock represents a tiny fraction of all the commerce done in bitcoins.

Bitpay alone is seeing an exponential growth of Bitcoin transactions: they appear to be doing about $20-30 million/month at their current rate: http://blog.bitpay.com/2013/12/bitpay-drives-explosive-growt... and http://blog.bitpay.com/2013/12/bitpay-exceeds-100000000-in-b...

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by throwaway_yy2Di on Sunday January 12, 2014 @02:12AM (#7045448)
That's still astronomically low compared to non-bullshit money. The US economy goes through its M1 money supply 7 times per quarter, or over twice per month [0]. If Bitcoin had that ratio, it would now be running $30 billion of meaningful transactions per month, not $30 million.

[0] http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/M1V

[Ctrl-F keyword: "velocity of money"]

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by mrb on Sunday January 12, 2014 @06:51PM (#7048016)
You don't understand Bitcoin. $30 million/month is just the Bitpay figure.

In reality, there are many more payment processors other than Bitpay, and many economic transactions happen outside of payment processor networks. It is hard to estimate money velocity in Bitcoin: http://blockchain.info/charts/estimated-transaction-volume-u... shows approximately $3 billion/month ($100 million/day) but this is an upper bound, because some of these transactions are just people moving coins around their wallets. The real figure is probably $100+ million/month to give an order of magnitude. And $100 million/month is not bad at all considering that it started from zero merely five years ago!

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by throwaway_yy2Di on Monday January 13, 2014 @08:09PM (#7054732)
"The real figure is probably $100+ million/month to give an order of magnitude."

So we are completely in agreement on the numbers. I used $30 million as my anchor point: the same power of 10. Either way it's 2.5-3 orders of magnitude from $30 billion (B), which is what you'd predict if money was moving around as fluidly as the rest of the economy.

Emphasis: you're fiddling with a factor of 3, within an uncertainty of a factor of 10 and a shortfall of a factor of 1,000.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by saalweachter on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:49AM (#7045981)
Bitcoin actually isn't doing too bad, according to blockchain.info.

They estimated a transaction volume of 82,659.87740705 BTC for the previous 24 hour period. Multiply that by 365 and divide by 12.5 million, and you get 2.4x. 2.4x is less than half 7x, but it really ain't bad.

Of course, if you take the same stats, and divide the money which went to miners -- 4,811.59892633 BTC -- by the transaction volume, you get an effective transaction fee of 5.8% for that same period...

EDIT: Whoops, mixed up quarters and years. BTC goes through its money supply 0.6x per quarter. I'm not sure if that's good -- "only" an order a magnitude off from USD -- or bad -- a "full" order of magnitude off from USD.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by throwaway_yy2Di on Sunday January 12, 2014 @06:30PM (#7047963)
Yes, but what fraction of that is "economic" stuff that goes into a GDP? With cryptocurrency you have clearly non-economic transactions that get registered in the global blockchain, like someone reorganizing their wallet internally, or a group shuffling bitcoins in circles as a money laundering method. Bitcoin transaction volume could be orders of magnitude higher than the Bitcoin "GDP'; it's not a measurement of it.

"They estimated a transaction volume of 82,659.87740705 BTC for the previous 24 hour period. Multiply that by 365 and divide by 12.5 million, and you get 2.4x. 2.4x is less than half 7x, but it really ain't bad."

I think that's off by a factor of four: the Fed uses financial quarters (3 months) as the time interval.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by CamperBob2 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:01PM (#7044169)
Why would I want to spend Bitcoins that are increasing in value? I'll spend them on the way down, not up.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by ok_craig on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:18PM (#7044235)
1. They are not guaranteed to increase in value

2. Spending bitcoin helps the ecosystem, thereby increasing the value of your other coins in the long run.

3. Having things now is often more desirable than slightly more later.

(You can't eat bitcoin. If bitcoin is all you have to spend, you will spend it on food, because food now is worth more than more valuable bitcoin later. If you also have dollars, then you'd just spend the dollars. If you have dollars and bitcoin, you can spend the bitcoin to help support the system, and replenish it immediately with your dollars.)

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by nofi3939 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:27PM (#7044267)
I would describe #3 more generally by saying that holding BTC creates an opportunity cost, unique to each person's circumstances.

Some more reasons:

4. Lower transaction cost (especially for international transactions)

5. If you want to help out the merchant, he may get a lower transaction cost out of it too (if the alternative is credit card, for instance).

Edit: Oh, and let's not forget the spend-and-replenish BTC strategy to keep your BTC holdings fixed.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by jljljl on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:30PM (#7044529)
>> Spending bitcoin helps the ecosystem, thereby increasing the value of your other coins in the long run.

One person spending Bitcoin has a negligible impact on helping the ecosystem, so the incentive for doing this is pretty small. You would likely gain a bigger benefit holding on to your BTC and letting other people help the ecosystem.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by aqme28 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:18PM (#7044488)
Why would I ever save dollars when they're always decreasing in value?
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by jljljl on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:46PM (#7044586)
You would almost never want to save dollars, in the sense of putting them under your mattress and forgetting about them.

What you would want to do is invest your dollars, either in assets or in a savings/checking account, to get some return above the rate of inflation.

This is partly why the Fed is trying to raise inflation: a low, steady level of inflation encourages people to spend and invest in the economy, rather than simply sitting on dollars.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by CamperBob2 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @09:27PM (#7044876)
You don't. When your bank proudly advertises 0.9% CD rates, it's time to start taking chances.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by natrius on Saturday January 11, 2014 @09:41PM (#7044916)
Last night, I bought food from a truck in Austin that discounts Bitcoin purchases by 15%. I have both dollars and Bitcoin, but there are many scenarios in which I'd rather spend Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by tcbawo on Sunday January 12, 2014 @10:34AM (#7046221)
Since Bitcoin has a fixed currency pool, with population growth and increasing supply of goods/services, we might see the cost of goods/services priced in Bitcoins fall. In such a deflationary environment, the rational incentive is to delay purchases for the future, which is bad for the aggregate economy. When people stuff money under the mattress, it reduces the velocity of money (decreasing trade, decreasing wealth). This is why the Fed sets an inflation target in the low single digits.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by aaronpeck on Saturday January 11, 2014 @10:43PM (#7045066)
Yeah, a currency that has no transactional cost from a third party thus offering a 2-4% discount to either buyer, seller or split by both, that maintains one value globally, and isn't controlled buy a particular nations government, probably is of no interest to the retailers of the world and likely just inflated bits that will never become an actual system of payments down the road. If you believe that, I have a plethora of REAL investments to sale you.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by uniclaude on Sunday January 12, 2014 @12:37AM (#7045274)
> I don't doubt that Bitcoin will become a revolutionary system of payments and money storage down the track

The tone I get from your comment makes me wonder if you really understood what GP meant. You could be both right, as in BTC being very useful to a lot of people, but still overinflated.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by aaronpeck on Sunday January 12, 2014 @03:53AM (#7045584)
I hear you, but the author of the comment heavily edited his post. That's not what it initially said. Either way, we all have our views. With something like BTC the future is unknown and thus just fun to discuss. It's great to engage with you and everyone else here. Theres's obviously a pool of great minds in the HN community.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by baddox on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:53PM (#7044610)
Or perhaps not that many Bitcoin holders need an area rug right now?

Most of my wealth is in USD, and yet in my entire life I've never bought anything from Overstock. I suspect there are millions of USD holders that can say the same. I don't think that says anything bad about the USD.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by 1qaz2wsx3edc on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:34PM (#7044296)
On the value of bitcoins:

There was another discussion on hacker news, where I commented on the fact that bitcoins should have a higher value due to lost coins: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6859991

In that thread, @nl provides the most interesting look at bitcoins from the perspective of bitcoins as a part of GDP: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6860024

Anywho, the value is largely speculative, but most indications seem to point to a long term growth.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by XorNot on Saturday January 11, 2014 @09:09PM (#7044829)
What happens when the mining difficulty exceeds the cost of electricity to run the ASIC miners?
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by wmf on Saturday January 11, 2014 @09:26PM (#7044875)
In theory, people will turn off miners and difficulty will reduce.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by 1qaz2wsx3edc on Saturday January 11, 2014 @09:44PM (#7044926)
Also, it puts the breaks on volume, which in theory should increase demand & become scarce commodity.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by notdang on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:52PM (#7044371)
It makes sense to buy from Overstock if you are in US, otherwise the shipping prices are ridiculously high. I assume that the majority of orders came from US, but Bitcoin is used all over the world.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by fragsworth on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:25PM (#7044257)
Your implied assumption that Overstock is the only thing influencing the price isn't right.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by greyman on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:07PM (#7044429)
Why do you think the price is inflated? The whole market cap is only $11B.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by ye on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:48PM (#7044110)
It tells you bitcoin is at the adoption stage. People are just finding out about it.

Plus Overstock isn't exactly a hot retailer. If Amazon does this, it will be HUGE.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by kysol on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:13PM (#7044224)
Even bigger would be for Paypal to add BTC as a payment method . Stores wouldn't have to "accept BTC", Paypal would do the dirty work and send on the amount in fiat to the store.

What would be better (from a branding point of view), Paypal to use PPC as "Paypal Coin". The masses wouldn't have a clue that it was actually named something else.

Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by bwilliams18 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:45PM (#7044335)
Thats effectively whats going on here though–Coinbase is handling the bitcoin and sending USD to Overstock. So on the retailer side of things the only difference is Coinbase doesn't have the cache that PayPal does(or the baggage). They are backed by some solid VC though–so a worry about them disappearing is probably unwarranted.
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by intelliot on Saturday January 11, 2014 @08:52PM (#7044780)
Perhaps you mean "cachet" instead of "cache"
Re:Bitcoin Price Touches $1,000 Again as Overstock Sales Hit... by notdrunkatall on Saturday January 11, 2014 @06:08PM (#7044200)
It's the first day.