Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by kfk on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @08:51AM
(#6880667)
I was very disappointed with the debian version of linux mint. It was just awful. I have used archlinux for 2 years and I wanted a rolling release easy to use, but mint debian was slow, had connection problems and overall crashed way too many times.
I moved to crunchbang and it works very well. All out of the box. Fast, very fast. Very nice design overall. I don't understand why its releases never reach the front page of HN.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by klrr on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:13AM
(#6881113)
Could not agree more, although I dislike Arch. The reason I do is since it's extremely unsafe, I would want something as bleeding edge as Arch but with a purely functional package manager like Nix or GNU Guix. (I know you can install Nix on Arch but then I will still have to use Nixpkg repo.)
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by mintplant on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:49PM
(#6882250)
Many AUR packages just pull from the HEAD of some git repo or pull down X random tarball from a URL.
With something like Debian, you have layers of package maintainers in the middle to insulate against attacks, and specific, immutable bundles of data included in the packages themselves. Also, the entire Debian infrastructure (signing keys and all) being compromised, and such an incident going unnoticed, is a much less likely occurrence than the same for the hosting site some individual software author uses.
Sure, you can still add third-party repositories to Debian and install deb packages from outside the main sources. But when you do that, you're making a conscious decision to do so, on a package-by-package basis. Any package you pull from AUR could be vulnerable, unless you manually check the source of each and every one. When you install from the Debian repos, you can trust that a certain standard of quality and security is being upheld.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by yogo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:17PM
(#6881976)
Why not? Because of the problems due to running updated software or are you aware of some problem with packages?
I ask because I have run Arch in production for the past 3 years on about 10 servers without any problems (knock on wood). Only official packages and always after quickly testing the latest pacman -Syu on a test machine.
Compare to a couple Ubuntu servers I have to deal with I have to go out of the way to get more recent packages, which are often unofficial (I avoid having to build packages where possible).
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by klrr on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:37PM
(#6889093)
If I run bleeding-edge packages I want atomic updates (if install fail it won't change the state of the rest of the system) and support for roll-back (if a package is unstable I can easily go back one version without ruining the dependency tree for all other packages).
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by kfk on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @09:32AM
(#6880888)
Arch is very lean and it's absurdly up to date. Debian is a monstruosity and even it's testing branch is not as up to date as arch.
However, arch breaks things often, very often. You make updates crossing fingers you will be able to reboot. Debian, crunchbang, overall, is very stable.
It depends what you want. If you are not a linux guru and need to work on your system, then go for something easy and stable like debian, otherwise do go for arch.
---
Edit
Yes, I talked all the time about Debian and I missed #!. Let me say, crunchbang for me it's just an easy way to get a debian testing. I prefer it like this as last time I used Debian it had some rough edges I have no time anymore to smooth over. I want things to work out of the box and a good community, check #!, they actually have a nice welcoming community.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by at-fates-hands on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:06AM
(#6881451)
I would say although Arch has a steep learning curve, there's plenty of documentation and tutorials about getting started. I have a machine that runs it and love it and I'm in no way a Linux guru.
I've only had one update issue, otherwise, it's pretty been reliable.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by cylinder714 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:35PM
(#6882620)
Note that Manjaro (http://www.manjaro.org/) is a "user-friendly" distro based on Arch. I tried it briefly via a liveCD from a British Linux magazine, and it looked promising.
That's kinda what I expected, an out of the box OpenBox setup built on top of Debian. It does say they use packages from their repository so there must be some differences than if you did it yourself.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by crasshopper on Thursday December 12, 2013 @02:26AM
(#6893286)
yes, but archbang and crunchbang have nice defaults.
As great as Arch's documentation is (best in all linuces I've tried), I still prefer to have some nice defaults so I can get stuff done whilst learning the knobs.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by drcube on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:17PM
(#6882464)
I'm wondering that myself. Mint doesn't normally use XFCE, or at least didn't when I used it in the past. It was always a fork of GNOME. So maybe that's the news?
Mint is also pretty popular as an alternative to Ubuntu for Linux newbs, so I can see why people think it's interesting and upvote. We get a fair amount of distro release announcements on HN.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by gorhill on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:06PM
(#6881887)
Is it the nemo file manager? under some circumstances, nemo starts to hog memory and CPU. It has to be killed. It will restart ok when you open the file manager again. Aside that annoyance, all has been working fine. I don't recall exactly but it is a known bug in 15, so I expect it to be fixed in 16.
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by codfrantic on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:02AM
(#6886659)
Nothing wrong specifically with Mint Cinnamon the only thing I can remember bugging me was the mintMenu being slow to show up after clicking it. I do enjoy messing with a different OS every now and then, XUbuntu actually stuck for quite a while, might be going back to it too, but I installed Mint XFCE yesterday (after trying ElementaryOS for a little bit) and it seems to run quite nicely on my AMD-E450 APU 11,6 inch net(ish)book
Re:Linux Mint 16 “Petra” Xfce RC released
by rpupkin on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:13PM
(#6881944)
i try other distros but i always wind up back w/Xubuntu. so hard to beat. recent 13.10 upgrade on an old Inspiron 8600 is clearly faster than 11.04 it was previously running. what a concept ... OS version upgrades w/smaller resource footprint. Mint/Xfce sounds promising, i'll give it a shot this weekend on similar old hardware. will also try CrunchBang's "older hardware" version. but Xubuntu is the rock.
I moved to crunchbang and it works very well. All out of the box. Fast, very fast. Very nice design overall. I don't understand why its releases never reach the front page of HN.
It provides everything that I love about Debian without the Ubuntu overhead.
With something like Debian, you have layers of package maintainers in the middle to insulate against attacks, and specific, immutable bundles of data included in the packages themselves. Also, the entire Debian infrastructure (signing keys and all) being compromised, and such an incident going unnoticed, is a much less likely occurrence than the same for the hosting site some individual software author uses.
Sure, you can still add third-party repositories to Debian and install deb packages from outside the main sources. But when you do that, you're making a conscious decision to do so, on a package-by-package basis. Any package you pull from AUR could be vulnerable, unless you manually check the source of each and every one. When you install from the Debian repos, you can trust that a certain standard of quality and security is being upheld.
I ask because I have run Arch in production for the past 3 years on about 10 servers without any problems (knock on wood). Only official packages and always after quickly testing the latest pacman -Syu on a test machine.
Compare to a couple Ubuntu servers I have to deal with I have to go out of the way to get more recent packages, which are often unofficial (I avoid having to build packages where possible).
However, arch breaks things often, very often. You make updates crossing fingers you will be able to reboot. Debian, crunchbang, overall, is very stable.
It depends what you want. If you are not a linux guru and need to work on your system, then go for something easy and stable like debian, otherwise do go for arch.
--- Edit
Yes, I talked all the time about Debian and I missed #!. Let me say, crunchbang for me it's just an easy way to get a debian testing. I prefer it like this as last time I used Debian it had some rough edges I have no time anymore to smooth over. I want things to work out of the box and a good community, check #!, they actually have a nice welcoming community.
I've only had one update issue, otherwise, it's pretty been reliable.
http://crunchbang.org/about/
That's kinda what I expected, an out of the box OpenBox setup built on top of Debian. It does say they use packages from their repository so there must be some differences than if you did it yourself.
As great as Arch's documentation is (best in all linuces I've tried), I still prefer to have some nice defaults so I can get stuff done whilst learning the knobs.
Switched to normal Debian.
Mint is also pretty popular as an alternative to Ubuntu for Linux newbs, so I can see why people think it's interesting and upvote. We get a fair amount of distro release announcements on HN.
Mint Cinnamon for Xubuntu.
Maybe Mint with XFCE is what I really want :P Will try it for sure :)
-Aptosid