Terrorism is the root password to everything from our constitution to our tax load. Playing up these charlatans and lifelong federal bureaucrats as some kind of saviors against the mythical hacker terrorist is a little much in my book. These are pork programs that go nowhere and do nothing but enrich the inside players and connected defense contractors.
Agreed.
> Terrorism is the root password to everything.
Terrorism is pretty scary stuff, it's intended to be scary. No way are people in government singing hallelujah everytime innocent people are killed, look we can fund more nefarious shit! They're honestly trying to do the right thing and simply went overboard with collecting too much data.
Could it be that he just supports or believes an opinion you don't?
Think back to 2003 and the run-up to the Iraq war; which was the first time we saw what a domestic propaganda initiative on the internet looked like. Think about how much more sophisticated those tools are today. How defining and shaping issue oriented discourse can be viewed as a zero-sum game where one side "wins" and all other viewpoints are neutralized.
The thing is; once the suspicion has been planted that not all of the people one is talking to are honest participants it is impossible to ignore; impossible to disprove; and very difficult to act against.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_for_the_New_American_C...
Hell, you can see this kind of behavior in tower defense games; people build a great power and dare anyone to cross them. The only difference is that real lives are at stake, but I think the government has proven they don't see the real lives in their game. For example, they don't even tally civilian casualties. They only even seem to care about such things because they don't want to anger the public.
Terrorism is a convenient trope to get people to willingly relinquish their liberties, just like "for the children" but with the goal of deploying ubiquitous scanners, drones, and microphones instead of censorship schemes.
I agree with the mission. Just not with their methods.
I'm not scared of acts of terrorism. I am much more concerned about vehicles killing cyclists and, really, the brain dead response the non terrorists will/have had when it comes to terrorism, like taking away our freedoms, wasting my tax dollars, and general stupid panic.
I disagree with you on this one. I know this is a crazy conspiracy theory video, but please take the 30 minutes to watch it.
When you say nobody in "government" is excited, you need to refine the meaning of the term "government": Look at the players who have been at the center of this for the last 3 decades: GHW Bush and Carlyle group CIA drugsters.
Are there terrorists? Yes, some. But to them it's like a boogeyman under every bed and in every closet.
Precisely. WOW itself is the first level of steganography ("I'm not communicating, I'm gaming"), but one can think of many more, inside and outside of MMOs.
Given proper use of steganography, small groups will always be able to communicate with low risk of detection. But for obvious reasons, you will always have to roll your own scheme, and may end up overlooking aspects that render it insecure.
http://www.tomshardware.com/news/watermark-screenshots-World...
The whole point of steganography is that you're supposed to transmit information while simultaneously concealing the fact that information even exists in the first place.
As long as you have a premeditated code, you can use practically anything to facilitate such communication, and the chances of it being uncovered are dubious.
This does not justify such ridiculous intelligence operations.
Your best bet is to read whitepapers on stego. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6843575 for related discussion.
what about "provably secure steganogrpahy"? there seems to be some papers on this. isn't is by definition science, not art?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_channel
It's important to realize that any system of any size will be packed with covert channels; the thing to do is try to identify them all and drive their bandwidth down to an acceptable level.
https://www.schneier.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-search.cgi?tag=stegan...
One must be careful with it. IIRC, Anna Chapman was a pro among Russian spies, but at one point she got so confused by the steganography software on her laptop that she asked another known spy for help in using it ... before she realized she was talking to a CIA agent trying to figure her out.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Chapman
http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-20009101-38.html
Bruce Schneier's articles -- and his readers' comments -- provide fascinating details and analysis of these topics.
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/07/cryptography_...
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/07/protecting_e-...
al Qaeda is known to have used steganography within porn videos.
http://arstechnica.com/business/2012/05/steganography-how-al...
Amazing too that we can't find money for food assistance (SNAP) to poor people but we can pay NSA agents for fools' errands in video games. I'm waiting for the revelation that Gen. Alexander's NSA underwrote "The Mists of Pandaria" with tax dollars.
I'm complaining about us wasting money on COMPLETE NONSENSE. If you think "investigating" whether Al Quaeda is communicating versus gnomes jumping on top of the auction house is a valuable use of taxpayer resources, why aren't we investigating whether terrorists are using kebab interval-spacing as a communications medium?
Funding SNAP will feed my fellow hungry humans. Funding the NSA will... Who knows? We just have to take their lying word for it.
Usually I treat posts like yours with a base modicum of respect, but I'd really think twice the next time if I were you.
https://twitter.com/NASA_SLS/status/401818661931208704
"I love space exploration, but the expenditure simply cannot be justified when kids die for lack of clean water"
"But as we're discussing children's lives only someone lacking a moral compass would consider it an issue here"
A better option for covert communication would be a more open platform such as Second Life, where you can upload custom content. But, frankly, there are so many options if you have any imagination... If what they're really worried about is recruiting and outreach then they at least only need to worry about reasonably popular alternatives.
There would be trillions of possible outlets for such communication, making looking for those specifically in MMO extremely futile.
I suppose the bigger bang for the buck would be in the metadata. Knowing who is playing at the same time, or who is looking at each other's profile or whatever.
That isn't something you can decide by waving your hands at games. WoW is cheap compared to even simple things purchased by the military on a regular basis.
Would they have caught Anna Chapman if she had met her case handler virtually instead of a coffee shop.
I find the task of finding terrorist communications in MMO's so daunting that I'd never even consider making an attempt at it. However, the NSA is one organization that seems to have nearly infinite resources to throw at impossible problems. This is an organization that is literally trying to "hack the planet"! I seriously doubt they'll ever managed to uncover anything significant, even if they're plugged directly into the servers at Blizzard, etc.. However, at least some spooks get to play WoW for a living on the government's dime!
Seriously... The NSA makes military spending look frugal!