News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by yawgmoth on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:31AM (#6846438)
I don't understand why the penalty for his crimes is so severe (Wikipedia: Federal prosecutors later charged him with two counts of wire fraud and 11 violations of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act,[16] carrying a cumulative maximum penalty of $1 million in fines, 35 years in prison, asset forfeiture, restitution and supervised release.[17]).

That seems like a preposterous amount of time, money, and stipulations post-release. What was the federal prosecution's motivation for making an example out of him?

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by danielweber on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:22AM (#6846655)
He wasn't facing 35 years of time. His lawyer did not just fall off the turnip truck and knew how federal sentencing guidelines worked.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:32AM (#6847050)
Wrong, wrong, wrong. The only way he didn't face 35 years of prison time is if he was prepared to plea guilty despite believing firmly and with sound reason that he was not a criminal.

As I've argued elsewhere [1], "A prosecutor forcing someone to admit guilt by threatening a life-destroying cruel and unusual punishment if they do not admit it - why, that is the very essence of using torture to extract a confession!"

[1] http://quandyfactory.com/blog/103

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by tptacek on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @04:01PM (#6850138)
No, this is not in fact how it worked. Swartz's own lawyer wrote up the range of possible sentences presuming Swartz refused to plead out, ranging from "no custodial sentence at all" (his lawyer's own expectation) to 7 years on the outside, if the prosecutors carried out all their threats and the court sided with them entirely and Swartz had been convicted on all counts.

Once again: Swartz's own lawyer wrote that he believed it unlikely that Swartz would do any time in prison even if he was convicted after pleading not guilty.

The "35 years" thing is entirely fictional. Popehat has a fantastic blog post on why this fiction exists and how it is misunderstood.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by danielweber on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:14AM (#6847338)
Even if he went to trial and lost on absolutely every charge, he was not facing 35 years. Not even 10 years, or 5 years.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by rayiner on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:59AM (#6847252)
Wrong, wrong, wrong.

Many of the counts would have been grouped under the guidelines.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by wglb on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:20PM (#6851249)
But the one thing that I think was the hardest for him to accept was to be classified as a felon.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by adestefan on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:43AM (#6846766)
It's also the journalists, too. Anytime you see a story about someone's punishment for the crime and it includes the words "cumulative" or "up to" you know all they did was start adding up random numbers from every little charge. Sentencing doesn't work that way and at that point you need to just ignore the story.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by DEinspanjer on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:33AM (#6847060)
I'd be willing to accept your statement at face value. Are there any good indicators for laymen what likely punishments he would have been facing if he would have continued to trial and lost?

What sort of crimes typically have similar actual and enforced punishments? I'm wondering where on the scale it gets slotted. Is it between assault and shoplifting or grand theft and kidnapping?

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:32AM (#6847493)
> Are there any good indicators for laymen what likely punishments he would have been facing if he would have continued to trial and lost?

For federal crimes, sentencing is generally governed by the federal sentencing guidelines. [1] The application is conceptually simple -- there are guidelines for determining the offense level for each base crime, guidelines for grouping offenses (some of which just keep the most serious, some of which start with the most serious and increase based on other offenses), and guidelines for adjustments to the offense level for various factors such as actual harms inflicted, the defendants criminal history, the defendants acceptance of responsibility, and so forth, and finally guidelines to translate offense level into sentence. But the details are quite involved.

Perhaps the most important thing to note, in the federal guidelines, is that in most cases, where multiple convictions are handed down for offenses involve the same victim and the same act or transaction, or different acts or transaction as part of the same plan or scheme, the offense level is set by the single most serious count alone -- charging multiple counts of the same charge basically just increase the chance of getting a conviction.

For state offenses, sentencing is handled by state-specific rules.

[1] http://www.ussc.gov/Guidelines/2013_Guidelines/index.cfm

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by girvo on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:49AM (#6847175)
Setencing is hard. Prosecutors have the incentive to put as many charges on them as possible, to get a guilty plea, but not all of them make it through, so it's hard to know what is going to happen until the defendant goes to trial. This goes for all sorts of crimes (most of them, in fact).
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by adestefan on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:15AM (#6847349)
You don't know what's going to be the final result until the defendant is actually sentenced. Of course this is all dependent upon the jurisdiction, but in most judges have significant leeway in the sentencing.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by girvo on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:09AM (#6847797)
Sorry, that's what I meant, yeah.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by coldtea on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:13AM (#6846932)
People have gone to jail for 35 years (or life) for far less -- especially if they are targeted minorities.

So let's not use the "it was just to pressure him" defense.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by danielweber on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:31AM (#6847045)
If we are bringing up totally unrelated things, sure. Why not say he was facing a firing squad?
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by coldtea on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:48AM (#6847171)
What exactly is "unrelated"?

Restating: people, in the same country as Aaron, have been sentenced to same or worse sentences, even for lighter stuff.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by rayiner on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:01AM (#6847258)
I can't even begin to fathom what you could be talking about, unless you're talking about some "three strikes" circumstance, which is in fact unrelated because Aaron didn't have two strikes.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by coldtea on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:12AM (#6847815)
Well, he was charged with over nine felony counts. So how is that unrelated to the "three strikes" cases?

Plus, the Obama administration raised maximum sentences for hacking count to 20 years (up from 10).

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by rayiner on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:24AM (#6847920)
Because the federal three strikes law only applies to serious violent felonies, and only if there are two or more prior federal or state felonies, at least one of which must be a serious violent felony as well and the other of which can be a serious drug crime.

As far as I know, only California has a three strikes law that can apply to non-violent felonies, and I don't know of any three strikes law that applies to convictions on multiple counts for the same conduct.

When you see stuff like "man gets life for possessing an unregistered firearm" (at least outside of California), you need to read the fine print and look for the prior murder or armed robbery convictions.

I disagree with three strikes laws even when structured to only apply to violent felonies, but they're totally irrelevant to this discussion.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by coldtea on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:41AM (#6848050)
Fair enough.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by smm2000 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:22AM (#6847893)
Three strikes all have to be separate convictions. Stealing one gallon of milk from three different stores is not three strikes.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by davvolun on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @12:40PM (#6848574)
So stealing three gallons total? I guess I'm not clear here. The idea is that I steal a gallon of milk, am convicted, punished, then three months later steal another gallon, repeat, and the third time (three more months later) I potentially face the three strikes rule, right? (Ignoring that stealing milk probably doesn't trigger the three-strikes rule being non-violent; also the 'three months' is just to suggest "some time has passed since conviction").
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by jack-r-abbit on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @12:58PM (#6848717)
I think if each criminal act resulted in a separate conviction, then three strikes can apply. But I think if you go on a milk theft spree (over some period of time keep stealing a gallon of milk from a bunch of different stores), when they catch you, you would likely be charged with multiple counts of milk theft and get "Strike 1" for the conviction. (also ignoring that stealing milk probably doesn't trigger the three-strikes rule.)
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by acdha on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:23AM (#6846988)
A former federal prosecutor explained why most of the numbers and potential years of jail-time you saw are a gross exaggeration:

http://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentence...

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by rayiner on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:58AM (#6847241)
Great description!

The main thing that confuses people is grouping. Prosecutors charge a large number of counts because they don't want to lose a conviction by being imprecise in characterizing the specific set of acts out of an overall course of conduct that was illegal. If you add up all the counts you get some big number, but the sentencing guidelines (3D1.2) clearly state: "All counts involving substantially the same harm shall be grouped together into a single Group."

I think the sentencing guidelines are ridiculous (look at that big list of meaningless factors in the sushi chef example!), but its much more sensible to calculate a guideline range than to add up the theoretical maximum sentences.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by gadders on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:29AM (#6846689)
His plea bargain offer was 6 months in a Club Fed prison. Martha Stewart managed 5 months.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by sp332 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:27AM (#6847019)
To accept the plea bargain, he would have to waive his right to a trial. (Edit: he would also have to admit he was guilty of the crime.) If he was innocent, there was no incentive for him to accept 6 months in prison in exchange for his rights.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by philwelch on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:08AM (#6847305)
He was "guilty" of the "crime". That's the whole point of civil disobedience.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by HNJohnC on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:03AM (#6847747)
Isn't the entire point of civil disobedience to admit you are guilty of the crime and then go on the fight the fact that it's a crime in the first place? Otherwise you are not some heroic freedom fighter, only a coward who took the easy way out.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by JonFish85 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:32AM (#6847049)
Sure there was: 6 months vs. up to 35 years. Even if I'm not guilty, as a pragmatist, that's a trade you can't refuse unless there is ROCK SOLID evidence that you're innocent of everything.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by sp332 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:44AM (#6847139)
That's an argument for letting the prosecutor get away with putting any innocent person in jail, as long as a harsher sentence is threatened for the nonexistent crime.

There was no way Swartz was getting 35 years even if he was convicted of everything. And the prosecutor piled on every charge he thought he had a chance at. Knuckling under and serving 6 months quietly isn't too appealing. And the alternative was lots of publicity for the cause, a good chance to change precedent in IP cases, and the possibility of serving some time as a martyr.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by pyre on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:05AM (#6847289)
Swartz didn't want to serve any jail time. IIRC, as a political activist he didn't want to have a conviction on his record as it might hinder his efforts (or possible future aspirations of holding a public office).
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by philwelch on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:10AM (#6847312)
Because serving time for an act of conscience always ruins someone's aspirations as an activist.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by pyre on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:31AM (#6847480)
If you want to do more than tilting at windmills, maybe. Also, it wouldn't be like a "holding up traffic to protest" conviction.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by girvo on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:50AM (#6847186)
That's the issue, though. Prosecutors now have an incentive to stack as many charges as possible on a defendant for precisely this reason. To me, this is a bad thing, and not justice.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by gadders on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:56AM (#6847227)
Plea bargaining is a bad system and open to abuse. However, it's incorrect to say Aaron Schwartz was faced with 35 years in jail.

I've always wondered if the felony conviction aspect of the punishment wasn't just as unacceptable to him. It would prevent any political ambitions in the US, I believe.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by DanBC on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:51AM (#6846513)
i) US prison system is weird and puts people in prison even when they pose no risk of harm to others

ii) US justice system is a machine. Roll over and give up, or they're going to crush you like a bug.

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by agilebyte on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:57AM (#6846538)
It is easy to be tough on crime, it is harder to politically justify the opposite.

Edit: English

Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by canweriotnow on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:41AM (#6846752)
You mean to be crime on tough?
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by deaconblues on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:11AM (#6846920)
It's a crime to be tough on easy.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by agilebyte on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:10AM (#6846910)
No, have fixed the sentence now.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by nova on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:54AM (#6846811)
Intellectual "property" is a serious business.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz by lasermike026 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:10AM (#6847806)
Repeal it yesterday.