Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by gadders on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:29AM
(#6846689)
His plea bargain offer was 6 months in a Club Fed prison. Martha Stewart managed 5 months.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by sp332 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:27AM
(#6847019)
To accept the plea bargain, he would have to waive his right to a trial. (Edit: he would also have to admit he was guilty of the crime.) If he was innocent, there was no incentive for him to accept 6 months in prison in exchange for his rights.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by philwelch on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:08AM
(#6847305)
He was "guilty" of the "crime". That's the whole point of civil disobedience.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by HNJohnC on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:03AM
(#6847747)
Isn't the entire point of civil disobedience to admit you are guilty of the crime and then go on the fight the fact that it's a crime in the first place? Otherwise you are not some heroic freedom fighter, only a coward who took the easy way out.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by JonFish85 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:32AM
(#6847049)
Sure there was: 6 months vs. up to 35 years. Even if I'm not guilty, as a pragmatist, that's a trade you can't refuse unless there is ROCK SOLID evidence that you're innocent of everything.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by sp332 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:44AM
(#6847139)
That's an argument for letting the prosecutor get away with putting any innocent person in jail, as long as a harsher sentence is threatened for the nonexistent crime.
There was no way Swartz was getting 35 years even if he was convicted of everything. And the prosecutor piled on every charge he thought he had a chance at. Knuckling under and serving 6 months quietly isn't too appealing. And the alternative was lots of publicity for the cause, a good chance to change precedent in IP cases, and the possibility of serving some time as a martyr.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by pyre on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:05AM
(#6847289)
Swartz didn't want to serve any jail time. IIRC, as a political activist he didn't want to have a conviction on his record as it might hinder his efforts (or possible future aspirations of holding a public office).
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by philwelch on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:10AM
(#6847312)
Because serving time for an act of conscience always ruins someone's aspirations as an activist.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by pyre on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:31AM
(#6847480)
If you want to do more than tilting at windmills, maybe. Also, it wouldn't be like a "holding up traffic to protest" conviction.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by girvo on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:50AM
(#6847186)
That's the issue, though. Prosecutors now have an incentive to stack as many charges as possible on a defendant for precisely this reason. To me, this is a bad thing, and not justice.
Re:This Is the MIT Surveillance Video That Undid Aaron Swartz
by gadders on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:56AM
(#6847227)
Plea bargaining is a bad system and open to abuse. However, it's incorrect to say Aaron Schwartz was faced with 35 years in jail.
I've always wondered if the felony conviction aspect of the punishment wasn't just as unacceptable to him. It would prevent any political ambitions in the US, I believe.