News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by martingordon on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:32PM (#6677016)
> They spent too much time on the product and not enough time on growth and distribution. The first pitch deck they put together for investors was mediocre. They began marketing too late. They failed to effectively position themselves against giants like Apple and Google, who offer fairly robust — and mostly free — Everpix alternatives.

People on HN crap all over MBAs, but these are the types of problems many of them have been trained to solve.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by cookiecaper on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:49PM (#6678621)
Does an MBA inoculate someone from making these judgment errors? If so, I personally know multiple MBA-holders who've made similar errors who should be informed that they deserve their money back or something.

It's important to be aware of the necessity to perform those business functions that coders probably would rather not bother with, but once that happens, I find that technical people tend to make much, much better judgment calls than their business school superiors.

In reality, it's rare to find people who're daring enough to apply simple rationality across most or all spectra, regardless of their background. Unfortunately, an MBA seemingly does very little to mitigate this, and it's the core problem.

Yes, people could hypothetically learn, but most don't. I don't understand why we've all fooled ourselves into believing that four years of rote memorization and arbitrary compliance will do anything. I guess it being a much more fundamental problem is scary, because as simple as it may be, it's apparently quite difficult for most people to change.

We have a big problem with our educational and hiring cultures.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by ryanhuff on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:20PM (#6678849)
Does an MBA inoculate someone from making these judgment errors? If so, I personally know multiple MBA-holders who've made similar errors who should be informed that they deserve their money back or something.

An MBA inoculates somebody from making poor decisions just as much as anybody having expertise in any specific field. As you would agree, nobody is beyond making a poor decision.

Let's also be clear than an MBA is a broadly defined credential, as there are a host of specializations (including Human Resources management, Marketing, Finance, etc) that are often bundled within the "degree". However, from what was described in the Everpix case, I am confident that somebody with the right mix of educational training in early-stage venture management (MBA w/entrepreneurship concentration) and smarts could have added value.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by enjo on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:58PM (#6677231)
The anti-education bias of HN simply fascinates me.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by vondur on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:38PM (#6678534)
I don't think one would need an MBA to figure out getting paying customers is the number one priority. They had a tough job ahead of them, lots of free competitors, so they felt that they had to make a vastly superior product to differentiate themselves. It's not a bad assumption, it's just a tough market to compete in.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by emn13 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:37PM (#6678968)
Yeah, it's weird. And for all it's inefficiency, there are absolutely brilliant things to be learnt that you'd never come up with it all.

I'm not sure it's specific to programming, but I find it dismaying to see how many solved problems we still need to fight with every day just because the people that originally wrote the code never paused to think enough about the theory behind it all.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by kyro on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @03:27PM (#6677984)
But code-slingers are world-changers.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by rfnslyr on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @03:42PM (#6678127)
It's strictly from a code monkey perspective. If you want to be a coder, you really don't need to go to school. If you want to take it to the next level and learn the theory behind what you are doing, get a degree.

I dropped out, or semi-dropped out because I wanted to be a frontend/UI guy and learning shit like C++ and basic C/PERL/PHP <3 (seriously) for two years, while paying 10k/year, was super pointless.

I'm saving now for a proper degree, and the rent to go along with it. Probably going to do electrical or computer engineering, because that, you can't really learn online like you can HTML/CSS/JS.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by cookiecaper on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:42PM (#6678571)
A "proper degree" is ridiculously inefficient. If you've already established a feasible career path, there is little reason to learn these things by following the standard curricular programs available at most educational institutions. Find good online communities and resources, buy textbooks and other primary informational sources, and hire a good private tutor to help fill in the blanks or answer questions and you can get the same stuff down much better in a fraction of the time it'd take with generalized mass schooling, i.e., universities.

University is an outdated model that's never really been applicable to the "real work" that needs to occur in an economy. Not sure why everyone decided it needed to become a general thing after WWII.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by enjo on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:05PM (#6679144)
Only if you view a degree as skills training.

The idea that it is inefficient is what I find so interesting, because from my point of view it's entirely the opposite. For most people a degree will greatly improve their ability to learn new things. It will expose them to a whole host of thoughts, ideas, and areas of exploration that they would otherwise never touch.

The thing is, I don't have a degree. I have a LOT of one (well two actually). I feel that it's ok, because the last 30 hours or so that I'm missing are basically all computer science. That's the stuff I've been able to learn.

Still I can't imagine not having the college education that I do have. I use what I learned in psychology almost every day (absolutely essential for anyone trying to run a company). I use the lessons learned in history and literature to guide my decision making. Philosophy has greatly influenced HOW I interact with others and informs the type of team that I want to have.

College made me a much better entrepreneur and it did it only four years! Give me that experience every day over someone who skipped college.

Now, can you get all of that elsewhere? Of course. You can learn to program. That's easy. You can read every day. Of course. But unless you are a remarkable human being (and they do exist), you'll never achieve the breadth of knowledge that comes with a degree.

Hell I'm all for restructuring how we think about education. The answer isn't to eliminate it. Instead lets decouple the skills training aspect. Liberal arts degrees for everyone!

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by kansface on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:43PM (#6679977)
"Liberal arts degrees for everyone!" strikes me about the same as "Engineering degrees for everyone!".
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by criley2 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:33PM (#6678939)
It's not just code monkey.

Who do you want to run your company?

A guy with no MBA but a 6 year history as CEO of a successful company, or a guy with 6 years of academic training and a MBA, but no history of ever running a company?

Same for coders. What do you want, the guy who has coded in a similar environment for 6 years, or the guy who spent 6 years in academia being taught to code with no experience on any project outside of academics?

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by enjo on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:52PM (#6679068)
I want both.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by weixiyen on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @03:57PM (#6678232)
You don't need an MBA to solve those problems. It's a problem with prioritization, not lack of ability.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by EricDeb on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:06PM (#6678302)
That's exactly what an MBA does. Teaches you to prioritize effectively. It also gives you countless examples of businesses who don't, and the consequences they suffer. Sometimes learning these lessons in the real world can be very costly.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by ringdabell on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:18PM (#6678836)
One of the biggest myth about getting an MBA is that you learn anything at all.

The two primary motivations for getting an MBA are completely unrelated to obtaining an "education":

1. Career transformation (i.e. you're a marketer that wants to go into banking.. basically impossible to get interviews without going to bschool)

2. Obtain a professional network

"Learning" is really a tertiary priority.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by NirDremer on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:51PM (#6678646)
MBA is great but I think your expectations are high. Oftentimes the issue is not knowledge but rather working at high pressure and to do it well nothing beats experience & good mentors.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by lazyjones on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @03:18AM (#6681540)
> People on HN crap all over MBAs, but these are the types of problems many of them have been trained to solve.

So, didn't their investor have any MBAs? These are also the kinds of problems VC investors are supposed to advise on, to protect, you know, their investment.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by megablast on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:39PM (#6679352)
I am going to tackle this, from a coders point of view, you can very quickly see if someone is any good. Or a designer, sysad, most other things.

But MBA are like economists, they all have different ideas on how to advance, and it is very hard to actually hard to test them, takes a long time to see if they were actually correct, if they fail they have a good reason, and it all sounds like something you could have worked out anyway.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by rhizome on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:16PM (#6677385)
To be fair, the slogan their late-term marketing consultant came up with was pretty lame.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by drp4929 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:29PM (#6678470)
Your response seems to assume that she has earned MBA, but she has not. http://www.linkedin.com/in/juliesupan
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by joelandren on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @07:03PM (#6679503)
To be fair, there's a lot more to user acquisition than a slogan.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by argonaut on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:55PM (#6679456)
Let's be clear: learning about those lessons will take maybe, at most, a month or two of reading a couple of books, reading PG's essays, and reading a few of the blogs written by great entrepreneurs and VCs. That's it. An MBA probably does teach you this - it just doesn't need to take two years and XYZ thousand dollars. There's a lot of fluff in an MBA that's just not necessary for a startup.

The fact also remains that the vast majority of people I know who got an MBA did it for the network, not for the education.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by mathattack on Thursday November 07, 2013 @05:37AM (#6688696)
Is this an issue of needing an MBA, or just needing to think about marketing and finance?
[deleted]
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by kohanz on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:47PM (#6677145)
I do not hold an MBA, but have a few friends that do and this seems like an inaccurate generalization. My understanding is that MBA's can have varied focus areas, with a varying curriculum. For example, MBA's can be focused on: Finance, Marketing, Management, etc, and yes, Entrepreneurship.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by dm8 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:23PM (#6677454)
How can you have formal education in Entrepreneurship? It's pretty much on job type of learning. Not trying to be snarky but I'm genuinely curious.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by arbitrage on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:43PM (#6677625)
90% of small businesses fail within the first year, or so the conventional wisdom goes.

Not all of them can possibly fail for completely unique reasons.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by kansface on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:45PM (#6679990)
Sure, but lack of hustle/perseverance is probably the biggest factor past the trivially solvable problems.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by acjohnson55 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @10:34PM (#6680449)
Product-market fit? Team's ability to execute? Resource constraints?
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by kohanz on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @03:07PM (#6677829)
Eric Ries, for example, might differ that you can't formalize learning about startups.

Almost every job has quite a bit "on the job" learning that you won't get in your academic studies. An MBA still teaches a lot of the skills, whether they be in finance, business planning, networking, IP issues, or presenting, that are useful for entrepreneurs. I imagine an MBA focused specifically on entrepreneurship would have even more useful stuff in the curriculum. Would be great if someone with such a qualification could chime in. A friend of mine with an MBA had one course where the main project was to basically to development a business from scratch and pitch it to real investors. Several students went on to launch those businesses after school.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by EricDeb on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:00PM (#6678257)
I have an MBA and MS in CS from Arizona (who at the time was ranked top 10 in entrepreneurship). I did not have a focus in the MBA so I could do Computer Science but the entrepreneurship track sounded like a less serious/competitive YC with a few classes thrown in the mix. You grouped up with others and worked on an idea for a year. The program recruited successful retires to both teach the classes and advise you on your idea. It actually sounded fairly practical, and the caliber of advisors they recruited was pretty good (most of them had run several businesses and made a few million dollars over their lifetime). It was definitely less tech-oriented though.
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by ojbyrne on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:39PM (#6677596)
Like any field, there are people who do research on it. Being familiar with the research that can be useful.

Just replace the word "Entrepreneurship" with "Sales" (which is similar) and perhaps you can understand.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by ngoel36 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @03:51PM (#6678191)
The same way you can have formal education in Computer Science...but never mind, you're right, no on-the-job learning in CS...
Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by rscale on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:45PM (#6679017)
An MBA in entrepreneurship has business classes adapted for an entrepreneurial audience.

A typical MBA involves the study of topics such as marketing, finance, risk management, accounting, economics, statistics, operations, HR, organizational dynamics, business law, and strategy.

Many of these can easily be adapted to be more useful for entrepreneurs. A finance class can focus on venture capital more than the bond market. A marketing class can focus on new product development more than the promotion of existing products. A law class can deal with the issues most relevant to startups. The accounting needs of a startup exec are different than those a future partner at Deloitte. etc.

As a clear example of the type of content that an entrepreneurial class could cover, Steve Blank's book Four Steps to the Epiphany originated not as a book, but as the notes for his class at Haas.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by martingordon on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:54PM (#6677195)
Part of the problem is that an MBA can be a lot of different things even within a schools. I, for one, am working on learning how to solve problems that startups face, problems that can't be solved by code.

I'm not saying that hiring an MBA would have been a magic fix for Everpix, but when looking at the business as a whole, the product looked great (despite its lack of support for non-JPEG formats, but that's more of a personal nitpick) and there was engineering talent to continue building the product. However, the part of the article I quoted above indicates that the team lacked the business talent to successfully find a market for the product (or to identify that there wasn't a market and pivot while they still had cash left).

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by dm8 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:28PM (#6677506)
Is working at a startup mandatory as part of curriculum then?

Also, every startup has tons of different problems at micro level even though macro themes are consistent (e.g. getting new customers etc.). It will be hard to generalize problem solving across startups.

I agree that Everpix couldn't find scalable business model for their product. But what I'm saying is you may not necessarily need MBA to find market/business model.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by untog on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @03:41PM (#6678110)
Also, every startup has tons of different problems at micro level even though macro themes are consistent (e.g. getting new customers etc.). It will be hard to generalize problem solving across startups.

I don't see why. Startups aren't some magical beast unmatched anywhere else in the world. They're small businesses.

Re:Everpix was great. This is how it died by brandnewlow on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:46PM (#6677133)
Either way, they need to hire an annoying "business guy" to worry about money 24/7 at some stage during the 18 months.