News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by joe_the_user on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:15AM (#6499389)
The odd thing is how we keep seeing these impressive prototypes and yet we don't see the deployment of even the five-years-ago prototypes.

It's interesting to think about the factors that go into this. I could imagine:

* High unit cost

* High maintenance cost, especially in remote locations.

* It is only useful in remote locations where wheeled vehicles can't go.

* It requires special training to operate.

* It doesn't have enough intelligence to avoid obstacles by itself in the remote, rough locations it would otherwise be fit for.

Other ideas?

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by danbmil99 on Saturday October 05, 2013 @02:14AM (#6499663)
This is really core research, not product development. BD and Darpa spin it a bit to keep the funding going, but having worked in this field my guess is we are at least 15-20 years away from serious deployment of legged robotics in the field.

That said, it's amazingly impressive what they have achieved.

I am curious as to why the robot's front legs are so close together in some clips -- maybe approximating a 3-legged device was somehow algorithmically simpler?

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by egypturnash on Saturday October 05, 2013 @03:19PM (#6501710)
Quadrupedal animals have multiple gaits; at higher speeds, they'll start bringing the forelegs down together at closer points in time.

Check out, for instance, this video of an actual cheetah running around: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIeXEiJuJUY - you can see the front paws coming down very close to each other in time and space, followed by the wide-spread rear paws making huge leaps forwards.

Also a quick images search for "horse muybridge" may be enlightening - Muybridge's books are super well-known in the animation circles I come from, as they were the first major works of research into high-speed photography documenting How Stuff Moves. You can see that horses have a whole bunch of different gaits available to them; most other animals are similar, but less tractable to a photographer's whims!

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by vapidResponse on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:00PM (#6501053)

  > why the robot's front legs are so close together
Hypothesis: The amount of force required to effect motion changes when you form a small, tightly focused fulcrum, using two legs.

I'm thinking there's some kind of efficiency gained, where, to us, it looks precarious and awkward, but to the machine-calculated algorithms, a trend is detected, where it's easier to stay continuously balanced on a small point while in motion, because it can use it's own inertia and apply smaller amounts of torque and pressure to it's actuators, and use smaller movements, when attempting to stay on it's feet.

When it's at rest, a wide stance is probably safest, but in motion, maybe it's a different story. Given that it's a somewhat rigid machine, with appendages that have alimited range of motion, maybe it targets, the smallest most effective movements?

I would also wonder: What is the net energy consumed from it's power source, to cycle one limb, moving it from fully contracted to fully extended and back again? You would need to test this unloaded in free air, and completely loaded under the weight of the entire robot at rest. And that test would not account for the amount of work it would take to safely absorb the full weight ofthe robot, while it's moving at 20MPH, to bring it to a full stop, with a single limb.

I'm not sure if those sorts of efficiencies are anything more than a simple practical concern in a prototype, given that the only goal is to run some quick, untethered tests in a parking lot, but it might be relevant to a small degree.

This is just my amateur guesswork, though.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by trentmb on Saturday October 05, 2013 @03:06PM (#6501664)
I see a lot of four legged animals run like that in assorted nature docs.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by MechSkep on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:45PM (#6501180)
I agree that it's core research, but it isn't published anywhere. Their control algorithms are not public; even plenary talks from Mark Raibert don't go into the details.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by danbmil99 on Sunday October 06, 2013 @11:31PM (#6506400)
Excellent point. As I understand it, Darpa does not preclude recipients of funding from patenting their work, nor do they insist on publication. I believe the govt gets some sort of free lunch on the patent side -- they can use anything they want with some sort of IP override (if someone knows more about this please explain).

The way the govt avoids vendor lock-in (in principle anyway) is by farming out the money to multiple vendors, especially as the progress moves towards real practical deployment. They did that with autonomous vehicles, and they're doing it again with legged robotics (http://www.darpa.mil/our_work/tto/programs/darpa_robotics_ch...)

However in this one area (legged locomotion) it seems to me that BD is far, far ahead of anyone else, unless that work is taking place in complete secrecy.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by MechSkep on Thursday October 17, 2013 @01:20AM (#6563819)
Shall we not forget the MIT cheetah: http://biomimetics.mit.edu:8100/wordpress/

I like the design much better than BD's weighty quadrupeds.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by maxerickson on Saturday October 05, 2013 @10:09AM (#6500698)
Speculating, one possible reason would be that it can then make balance corrections by pushing (making the leg longer). A wider stance would require making balance corrections by making the leg shorter.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by Cthulhu_ on Saturday October 05, 2013 @11:34AM (#6500961)
It's what you generally see in nature too when (catlike) animals are bounding: http://cincinnatizoo.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/sarah_ru.... Front paws go between the rear ones, etc. Rear ones are used for the brunt of propulsion, front ones for balance and direction etc.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by sytelus on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:25AM (#6499411)
My guess is that military is buying up all their tech. We usually hear these teasers designed to encourage decision makers to speed up the funding. It's like putting a gun on their head "if you don't buy this, we will sell to someone else". After the rounds of funding is over we hear silence. It is not unlike many other cool very promising research projects but they can be threatening if other countries get their hands on them. Their main page says...

Organizations worldwide, from DARPA, the US Army, Navy and Marine Corps...

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by mturmon on Saturday October 05, 2013 @01:07AM (#6499487)
> It's like putting a gun on their head "if you don't buy this, we will sell to someone else".

I don't understand where you're going here. The linked video shows a robot designed under DARPA's M3 program. This was DARPA's initiative. DARPA has had a string of highly successful practical robotics programs.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by robotresearcher on Saturday October 05, 2013 @04:21PM (#6501921)
Guys in sunglasses don't knock on Tony Stark's door and buy ready-make gadgets. BD bids against other contractors to take money offered by the government to do original R&D. The work would not get done if the government didn't pony up the money in advance. Often they don't get a hell of a lot for their money beyond the training of grad students and engineers who did the work. Sometimes a program kicks ass and changes the world, e.g. Internet.

Sometimes the government knows what it wants and the programs are very focussed, e.g. we need proof of concept demos for small radios that can perform X, Y, under Z conditions. Sometimes the programs are very blue sky and strategic, e.g. we don't want the other guys to get ahead in robotics, so let's make sure we keep up. Please send us your proposals for around $BALLPARK and we'll pick the most promising.

The focussed kind of program always exists. The funding for blue sky programs comes and goes, depending on the political climate and the personalities of the incumbent director and program managers.

But the government doesn't buy tech to keep it off the streets. One great thing about DARPA funding is that the government doesn't own the IP afterwards. They often don't even insist on a free license to use it themselves. They just want it to exist so they can choose the best stuff later.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by cdash on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:44AM (#6499441)
They are DARPA research projects, it doesn't surprise me at all that we have not seen anything deployed yet as it simply isn't ready yet. DARPA focuses on far out research.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by dm2 on Saturday October 05, 2013 @10:19PM (#6502814)
While they do focus on advanced projects, any project that is cost-effective and beneficial to a Defense agency will be given the necessary funds to get it done as soon as possible.

It seems like they are getting faster and faster when going from prototype to on the battlefield.

If there is one organization in the entire world that has enough funds to do almost anything it is the US DoD.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by smoyer on Saturday October 05, 2013 @08:29AM (#6500477)
I'm not affiliated and may not know what I'm talking about but ... the drones we're currently flying are programmed with a set of GPS waypoints, and assume uninterrupted airspace between those waypoints, avoiding collision with the ground by gaining altitude. Self-driving cars have the advantage of a map and can assume a reasonably flat road surface.

Imagine how complex the path planning would have to be for a robot like this to successfully climb and descend a rocky mountain ... not only would it have to plan where to place it's feet for balance, but it would have to look much farther ahead to avoid walking/running into dead-end paths.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by Game_Ender on Saturday October 05, 2013 @01:08PM (#6501263)
You should take a look at the research [0] people are doing using the little dog [1]. They are creating some very interesting planning algorithms for unstructured terrain like that.

0 - http://cs.stanford.edu/groups/littledog/ 1 - http://www.bostondynamics.com/robot_littledog.html

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by Alterlife on Saturday October 05, 2013 @08:53AM (#6500535)
I have no idea what I'm talking about... and much less than you because I've never used drones.

When I saw the big dog prototype not falling when pushed, the assumption I made is that the eventual objective would be to just try to keep going and self-correct when unevenness is encountered.

Never thought about fully automated walkers -- just manually guided, but able self correct on rough terrain.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by itchitawa on Saturday October 05, 2013 @10:07AM (#6500692)
My education by Youtube says they're supposed to follow a person. So it might still be quite useful even blind as long as it goes roughly the route its leader went.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by bayesianhorse on Saturday October 05, 2013 @11:19AM (#6500904)
As far as I know the autopilot in a drone isn't so much more sophisticated than autopilots of manned aircraft. They are usually controlled by human pilots, albeit assisted with tons of artificial intelligence.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by smoyer on Saturday October 05, 2013 @11:59AM (#6501049)
I didn't mean to imply any more than what you've described, but the key point was that you could avoid practically any obstacle by gaining altitude. Drones are often controlled by human pilots while in friendly airspace and during take-offs and landings, but who'd want to fly a series of way-points when the plane can do that itself ... Instead you switch that fancy console into game mode (just kidding).
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by bayesianhorse on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:07PM (#6501074)
How exactly are human pilots usually avoiding crashing into terrain/objects other than by gaining altitude?
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by smoyer on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:23PM (#6501110)
The original point was that obstacle avoidance was not so easy for a walking vehicle ... human pilots usually try to avoid obstacles the same way (with exceptions being cases for the NTSB).
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by kmfrk on Saturday October 05, 2013 @09:42AM (#6500640)
The development on Siri started two years before the first iPhone was released.

Product pipelines are tricky, and not everyone has a Steve Jobs to pitch the final release.

http://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/1nptvv/susan_bennett_...

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by jostmey on Saturday October 05, 2013 @03:37PM (#6501763)
Apple can develop new technologies so quickly because the technologies that Apply deals with are relatively simple by comparison. Developing a machine to mimic the abilities of a Natural animal, discovering a drug to cure disease - that stuff is very hard to do.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by vanderZwan on Saturday October 05, 2013 @04:24PM (#6501931)
It took a while to go from this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_Flyer

to this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Age_of_Aviation

Give dynamic robots another decade or two, and until that time:

http://www.strandbeest.com/ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSKyHmjyrkA&nofeather=True

(I'm sure that Jansen's aesthetic similarity to the Wright Brothers' flyers is no coincedence)

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by joe_the_user on Saturday October 05, 2013 @05:38PM (#6502178)
Just to play devil's advocate:

* Your golden age was about decade out from the Wright flyer and Big Dog has been out for a while.

* More to the point: the airplane had little competition in it's field - the wright flyer was already faster than a balloon. Walking robots' primary advantage is in rough terrain, which is only a advantage in marginal areas (if walkers moved with even the same efficiency as (inherently simpler) wheel vehicles, we would still want to confine them to paved roads. Consider how, relative to a wheel vehicle of the same weight, it's likely a walking robot would take a greater toll than on any path or road it used because it's movement would involve inserting its weights at specific points and pushing).

* Treaded vehicles have around for a while and they do some portion of what a walking vehicle could do in a military setting - an army is quite will to the destroy a forest to move through it. And further, continuous track can things walkers couldn't - moving over swamp and other muck. Walkers might, maybe find a marginal use along side other specialized vehicles. But walkers have an inherent problem - if they are a lot bigger than a horse, what keeps them from sinking in the soft ground they have to be targeted for. If they aren't bigger than a horse, what makes them better than the presumably cheaper horse? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuous_track

* We never got our flying cars and video-phones have taken a long time. Shows that not all possible tech becomes practical tech in a simple fashion.

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by dm2 on Saturday October 05, 2013 @10:15PM (#6502809)
I think the one you're missing that is most important is the current state of battery technology.

Notice how the indoor version of BigDog has a tether for power and the outdoor has a very loud engine. That noise hardly acceptable on the battlefield.

Are these considered "robots"?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Close-in_weapon_system

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_X-47B

Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by prawn on Saturday October 05, 2013 @06:52AM (#6500271)
Power source? What are they using now? Typical petrol/LPG? Until they feel comfortable putting nuclear hearts in these, I suspect they'll be limited.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by AmVess on Saturday October 05, 2013 @08:00AM (#6500420)
The unit in the linked vid is using a gas/oil mix 2-stroke engine.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by officialjunk on Saturday October 05, 2013 @11:56AM (#6501037)
These are research milestones to get the next round of funding from DARPA. They are probably still many years from the goal product.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by zokier on Saturday October 05, 2013 @03:45AM (#6499905)
5 years is really short time. I wouldn't be surprised if deployment of completely finished product would take five years.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by jotm on Saturday October 05, 2013 @12:16AM (#6499394)
Yeah, I think it's pretty much down to the cost - humans are still cheaper and way more effective/flexible...
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by danbmil99 on Saturday October 05, 2013 @02:16AM (#6499665)
The fact is that for almost any "dangerous environment" one might suggest using robots for, there is a human who will do the same job for a few dollars extra per hour.
Re:Boston Dynamics Unleashes Wildcat, the Sprinting Quadrupe... by jotm on Saturday October 05, 2013 @04:40AM (#6500013)
Except extraterrestrial objects - maybe BD will team up with SpaceX and send these robots to Mars :-)