News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:23AM (#6489070)
(Note, I technically work for Yahoo - but this is all personal opinion)

Great on Yahoo for putting a reward program in place, but when did everyone become so entitled to getting something for reporting a bug/security concern.

If you stumble on to an issue, and you are a good person, submit the report. If you are looking to make a living off of finding bugs, go directly to the companies that actually have a reward program in place. Don't be mad when you get a thank you gift that wasn't what you expected. Don't get mad at your security report not meeting guidelines.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by wpietri on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:54AM (#6489803)
It's not that I disagree with your opinion; if I found a bug and I reported, all I'd really want to know is that they were taking it seriously. So a personal note would be great. And I love that this guy was, in the midst of dysfunction, just buying the t-shirts and sending them out because it was The Right Thing.

However, it is a little much for a for-profit, publicly traded company with $4 billion in annual revenue (mostly made from manipulating how their users spend money) to think that other people should do things for them for free.

I certainly miss the long-ago days when the Internet was an academic community, mainly free of commercial influence. And I love it when people rise above base commercial motives to do something more beautiful. But if we line people up based on their right to complain that the Internet is all crass and money-oriented these days, Yahoo, who led the first wave of Internet commercialization, surely must be near the back.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by dopamean on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:33PM (#6490504)
> However, it is a little much for a for-profit, publicly traded company with $4 billion in annual revenue (mostly made from manipulating how their users spend money) to think that other people should do things for them for free.

I'm not sure I understand this. Yahoo! did not have a bounty program that paid out money so if you were submitting a vulnerability you found it would be a little ridiculous to expect any remuneration.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by wpietri on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:21PM (#6490855)
My point here is that a for-profit company shouldn't expect random people to do nice things for free. Sometimes they do and that's great. But they shouldn't expect it.

The post I was replying to comes from a "let's all help each other out" perspective, which I like and is the mode I want everybody to be in. But the last people who should be pushing that line are those who are making billions of dollars. Especially so when those people are the ones who led the first wave of commercializing the internet.

It comes across to me as something like, "Hey, let's all work together so I can line my pockets."

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by ars_technician on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:40PM (#6491424)
I think the message he was portraying more is of the annoyance with someone showing up with a vulnerability and demanding a reward. The same way you might view someone mowing your lawn without your permission and then getting angry when you didn't pay enough for it.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by wpietri on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:28PM (#6492220)
Who is it that showed up and demanded a reward? I missed that happening.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by forgottenpass on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:28AM (#6489103)
when did everyone become so entitled to getting something for reporting a bug/security concern

Sometime around the point where:

- Yahoo!'s competition started offering bounties, and

- "Entitlement" became a rhetorical tool to dismiss discussion of any business practice that might cost money

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:31AM (#6489125)
This has nothing to do with Yahoo - this has to do with every time there is someone complaining about them not receiving the bounty they wanted - and in this case about getting a t-shirt as a thank you. I am happy Yahoo is putting a reward program in to place - but the general commentary from the community annoys me.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by thaumaturgy on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:02PM (#6489875)
It's simple pragmatism. I'd expect that HN, of all places, would get this. (And most seem to.)

You are a security "researcher". Maybe that means you work with a group of bona-fide professionals, maybe that means you're still in high school.

Either way, you have the capability to break things. But, breaking things isn't trivial; you don't expect to spend a few minutes "poking around" and come up with something, especially something interesting.

So you have some choices. You can: try to break things which will give you rewards proportional to the time you spent and the severity of what you find; try to break things which will give you almost no official reward at all; or try to break things and then sell the solution to the highest bidder or make use of it yourself. (Let's assume that people aren't generally in the habit of working for free.)

Now then. You're Yahoo, with millions of user accounts and a not-great track record for security. What would you prefer for the hacker to do, and how would you incentivize them to do it?

You can gripe about "the community" or "entitlement" all you want -- until it becomes sufficiently annoying or unproductive -- but that won't change the end result, which is that companies which give substantial rewards for bug bounties are creating a marketplace where they win by getting lots of good talent to examine their systems without paying by the hour or day for it and the company gets first dibs on the details of the bug.

Companies which don't do this, lose.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by drharris on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:58PM (#6490257)
> Companies which don't do this, lose.

People lose. As in, real flesh and blood people. Everyone seems to think, "Ah, they'll just sell it to the highest bidder." You know what, screw that belief, and screw those people who think that way. You do that, you become evil. End of story. Should it be the company's job to ensure this doesn't happen as best as possible? Yes. Does the lack of a reward justify the demonstrably evil behavior of selling vulnerabilities? No. Sick and tired of the idea it's ok to sell a vulnerability wherever the money is. When is the computing community going to step up and put an end to morally wrong behavior like this? We need to ostracize those people, not condone and justify such behavior.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by shawn-furyan on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:05PM (#6490741)
I agree. I think the problem is conflating the dark grey market[1] values of vulnerabilities with their white market values.

Reportedly there is a lot of money in the security vulnerability dark grey market at this particular moment in time, and that seems to be pushing up the perceived monetary value of these vulnerabilities.

But if you think about it, it would feel an awful lot like extortion for a researcher who's found a vulnerability to allude to the grey market value of a vulnerability in a responsible disclosure discussion. This is kind of what the community is doing by consistently bringing that point up in regards to rewards for such responsible disclosures.

At the end of the day, if the researcher is virtuous, then the black/grey market value of the vulnerability is irrelevant, and so acknowledgement of the issue, followed by rapid action to close the vulnerability, and optionally, a token of appreciation is plenty of reward for the disclosure from a moral point of view.

Now, I'm not naive. I believe that people respond to incentives and when you're talking about incentives, then the black/grey market values do come into the calculation. But that's a purely amoral and pragmatic optimization problem, and therefore not a proper object for the moralizing that we've seen regarding these programs.

I don't have any particular issues with pontificating about how a particular company could be more effective if it increased its bug bounty rates[2], but any pseudo-moral outrage is hollow because it's founded on the assumption that moral and immoral disclosure are relatively equivalent options.

[1] That is, it's not always technically illegal, but I think that the market is fairly universally regarded as antisocial if not a major threat of the day.

[2] Though it would be very difficult for a company outsider to actually accurately determine the value of responsible disclosures to a company. There are a whole lot of vulnerabilities in complex software, and really, any particular disclosure is essentially worthless. I would imagine that the real monetary value of a given disclosure is orders of magnitude less valuable to the vulnerable company than it would be to a potential attacker. For the vulnerable company, they still have a vulnerable product after fixing the particular vulnerability, but for the attacker, they have a successful attack vector by having knowledge of the particular open vulnerability. Also, I can't imagine that the value of a particular vulnerability is proportional to the company's revenue/valuation/etc. which is the metric that seems to always be trotted out when talking about how a particular company's reward program is not generous enough, especially with regards to "billion dollar companies"

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by zem on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:51PM (#6491079)
it's a bit more complicated than that, though - it's not that the same people who would have found and reported vulnerabilities to yahoo if they were properly incentivised will instead turn around and sell them to the highest bidder. the black-hats will always get a higher reward from other criminals than they will from the companies; the point is that if you can also get a white-hat to report stuff to you, you can perhaps fix it before the criminals exploit it.

in the absence of incentives, the danger is that the white-hats will simply not bother with you. and yes, people lose, but you cannot really lay a moral responsibility on people to help a profit-making company out for free just because if they don't other people might get hurt.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by forgottenpass on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:24PM (#6493206)
Sick and tired of the idea it's ok to sell a vulnerability wherever the money is.

The idea that money always overrules morals is a deep and pervasive belief in the business culture of this country. The vuln market is no exception and is a symptom, not a cause.

When is the computing community going to step up and put an end to morally wrong behavior like this?

About the same time any other industry puts an end to the morally wrong behavior they engage in (read: never).

Or, to push the same buttons as above but in another direction: when did everyone become so entitled to getting exclusive access to a bug/security report about them instead of competing for it in the market like anyone else?

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by nodata on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:48AM (#6489241)
and to ensure the bug gets to the vendor and isn't sold elsewhere.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by ramses0 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:17AM (#6489478)
Isn't that ransom / hostage-taking?
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by tomjen3 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:14PM (#6490372)
Yes. Just like the store next to me who expects me to pay for their food. They have so much and I need that or I will die.

No, it is business. Yahoo has no right to expect you to work for free for them.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by ars_technician on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:44PM (#6491461)
Yahoo doesn't have a right, but a researcher is acting immoral if he/she sells the vulnerability to someone else that may exploit it.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by wmeredith on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:58AM (#6489837)
It sure seems like it to me. However, considering the climate of business ethics in this country, it's no surprise that businesses themselves would be treated poorly by customers/individuals. Businesses these days mostly seem to sacrifice all for the bottom line. If something has negative affects (to customers, the environment, their employees, etc.) they run the actuary tables and the most profitable solution wins. It's tit-for-tat.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by PeterisP on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:25PM (#6490881)
Ransom / hostage-taking is when you take something that doesn't belong to you.

This action is taking something that you created (important, unique data) and offering it for auction instead of gifting it to the place where it would benefit everyone.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by ars_technician on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:46PM (#6491476)
Similar to finding nudes of your neighbor laying in their driveway. Sure, you could let them know and hope for a reward, or you could put it up for auction, which is totally not exploitative. /s
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by PeterisP on Thursday October 03, 2013 @04:16PM (#6491691)
Yahoo is neither my neighbor, peer or equal. There are very different social expectations when doing 'business' with your neighbor versus doing business with a corporate entity. Also, losing photos is a very different than distributing a partly defective product - you're generally not morally at fault for accidentally losing your own stuff, but you are fully responsible for accidentally manufacturing and distributing defective products.

An appropriate non-IT analogy would be noticing a particular simple way how a Bigcorp chainsaw could be made safer, fixing a risk of hurting the user - you could just let them know "hey, do X and all your chainsaws will be safer for all of us" and get nice fuzzies, or offer to sell them (or other chainsaw manufacturers) the discovery - it's your choice, and although one is much more charitable, both choices are acceptable.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by Xorlev on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:30AM (#6489582)
It's business.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by tesseractive on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:19PM (#6491261)
Serious question: I'm familiar with bounties for browsers and OSs, but do most websites offer bug bounties now?
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by arkem on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:11PM (#6492075)
Many websites do but I wouldn't say most.

Bugcrowd maintains a list of websites that have bounty programs: https://bugcrowd.com/list-of-bug-bounty-programs/

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by tytso on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:00PM (#6490699)
>Great on Yahoo for putting a reward program in place, but when did everyone become so entitled to getting something for reporting a bug/security concern.

For better or for worse, cyber criminals started paying black hats for exclusive access to vulnerabilities, and now "good guys" such as the NSA and the FBI are paying grey hats for exclusive access to vulnerabilities. At this point, if you are a security researcher, if you voluntarily disclose a vulnerability you find to a company like Yahoo or Microsoft, even with the fairly generous rewards getting paid out, it's likely they will be taking a monetary hit compared to what an organization like the NSA would be willing to pay.

Fortunately, there are still people who have enough of a conscience that they still care about doing the right thing, as opposed to optimizing for their monetary return (and if you are selling to the government agency like the NSA, you are automatically on the side of the angels, right?). But if you are looking for someone to blame, I'd nominate organizations like the NSA and the cyber-criminals. That's not particularly constructive, though --- the world is the way it is now, and it's unlikely to be something that can be changed back to the "Good Old Days" (which, for the record, was never really all that Good).

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by masklinn on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:41AM (#6489201)
> when did everyone become so entitled to getting something for reporting a bug/security concern.

Somewhere between the ability to sell vulnerabilities and the implementation of bug bounties.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by markolschesky on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:30AM (#6489588)
I don't think it's about entitlement.

Twilio, either formally or informally, sent me a t-shirt twice when I found a bug. For me as a programmer, a bug on the 3rd party partner side generally means I spent some amount of my time figuring out that the bug wasn't something I was generating, but rather my vendor. Programmer time has a pretty real value to it, which no one likes wasting.

When I reported the bug and the support person offered to send me a t-shirt, I forgot about the time I spent on the bug and went "Neat! A t-shirt!". Now, when I look at the t-shirt, I couldn't tell you the specifics on the troubleshooting or how it ruined my afternoon 10 months ago. But, I can tell you that it felt like the vendor actually responded to my concerns. Some vendors haven't, and then I do the natural thing and spew vitriol about them across the internet and to my colleagues.

If I didn't like a vendor and they were replaceable, the second that I hit a bug that I felt the need to report, I would just not use that vendor anymore. Anyone who files a bug report has some amount of loyalty to a company that is not worth upsetting.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by EnderMB on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:30AM (#6489584)
I've submitted a number of bugs to different tools and sites, and in the vast majority of cases the company involved have promptly got back to me, have thanked me for my time, and have informed me of the status of the bug.

In the rare instances where my report is ignored, and any attempts to report to a developer (easily found on Twitter) are ignored, I tend to just forget about it. I assume that it gets read, and that eventually it gets fixed. That being said, when you've found a software bug, especially a large bug, the teams treatment of the bug reflects your opinion of the entire company. I noticed that one large website was pushing new registered passwords around in plain text, and I reported this. Six months later, the bug still exists. My opinion of the holding company (which runs a number of popular sites) has dropped significantly.

I think most developers are just happy to be thanked, and are hopeful that their report will be taken seriously and fixed as a priority. Gifts are nice, but a fixed bug and a genuine thanks from a real person at that company are much better.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by yogo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:31AM (#6489127)
I don't think it is entitlement. We live in a value for value world. Bringing to light a problem that can cost the company millions of dollars is worth something. No one was bitching (at least not loudly) about Yahoo not having a bounty program, the reaction was that if they only want to shell out $15 then they're cheap (not recognizing value).
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by eli on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:37AM (#6489168)
Sorry, but I don't get this mindset. It would have been better to give them nothing rather than a "cheap" gift?

If you want to get paid market rate for the value you provide as a security researcher, then stop doing work on spec and just hoping that someone compensates you for it.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by kens on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:22AM (#6489518)
There's a big discussion of this in the book "Predictably Irrational", chapter 4: "Why we are happy to do things, but not when we are paid to do them". It explains that there are two worlds: The first is "social norms", which is community based. This is where you have friends over for dinner, help someone move a couch, and other friendly things. The other world is "market norms", where things are transaction based with something exchanged for something of equal value (normally, but not always money).

The problem is when the worlds of social norms and market norms cross. The book gives the example of Thanksgiving dinner, and what would happen if you offered your mother-in-law a couple hundred dollars to pay for the meal at the end. Another example is sex: paying for sex makes it a very different situation. (Also note the difference between giving someone flowers on a date and giving someone cash.)

The book describes a research experiment, where participants were paid $5, 50 cents, or nothing to perform a short task of sorting shapes. The people paid $5 sorted 50% more shapes than the people paid less (since they were more motivated), but the people paid nothing did the most of all since they were motivated by helping out the researchers.

This ties in with intrinsic vs extrinsic motivation - if you're getting paid, it's extrinsic motivation, and then you're motivated by whether you're getting your money's worth.

(There's a lot more, but I don't have time to get into it, so check out the book.)

The point is, that if people report bugs for free, it's part of the social norms world, where they are keeping the world safe, making it a better place, etc. If they are getting paid, it's part of the market norms world, and they expect to get paid what the bug is worth. With Yahoo, the lines got crossed: giving a T-shirt is generally part of the social norms world, but giving a $12 gift certificate crosses over into the market norms world, and $12 is insultingly low. This is why it would have been better for Yahoo to give nothing.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by DanielStraight on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:41AM (#6489704)
Exactly. This guy accidentally crossed into market norms by doing something that seemed completely reasonable at the time.

Imagine you ask a friend over to help fix your car in exchange for beer. This would clearly not be interpreted as payment, but as a way of saying thanks. Now suppose it turns out they generally like beer but hate the particular kind you purchased, so you feel bad and give them $10 to buy themselves a beer they like. Suddenly, thinking you were doing something nice, you've crossed into market norms.

This, as far as I can tell, is basically what happened.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by ronaldx on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:15AM (#6489463)
> It would have been better to give them nothing rather than a "cheap" gift?

Yes. Giving nothing doesn't give any indication of value - maybe the work is very highly valued but it's not Yahoo's policy to compensate. Fair enough.

Giving a cheap gift attaches a very particular value.

There is a body of research on this, e.g. http://ideas.repec.org/p/zur/iewwpx/007.html

"rewards undermine the intrinsic motivation of volunteers." "a large literature in social psychology [emphasizes] that external rewards can undermine the intrinsic motivation for an activity"

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by bryanlarsen on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:51AM (#6489264)
"Sorry, but I don't get this mindset. It would have been better to give them nothing rather than a "cheap" gift?"

Standard practice to deliberately insult a waitress is to leave a short tip. That's more insulting than leaving nothing.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by zequel on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:10AM (#6489434)
Probably related to the fact that the waitress can justify no tip with the thought "they might have forgotten to leave one". A short tip sends a message.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by nmcfarl on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:21AM (#6489505)
Which is a good point - as it gives illustration to mikeash's point in this same thread. This doesn’t make logical sense at all - but there are practices based on it.

And in this case both the "a token of our appreciation" and "short tip" practices could been "meant", and were as a matter of fact taken as "meant" by the sender and receiver respectively.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by Suitov on Friday October 04, 2013 @01:22PM (#6496653)
Oh hell, is it? Quite often I'm short on cash and just tip with the change I have - not tiny-denomination coins, I hasten to add, but 50ps/£1s. Bugger.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by wpietri on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:00PM (#6489855)
I was once at a busy bar. The guy in front of me, his order came to $9.75. He gave the bartender $10; she gave him a quarter back as she delivered the last of his drinks.

He tried to leave the $0.25 as a tip. She said, "Oh, no, you must need this," and gave it back to him. Her clear view was that no tip was better than $0.25. I congratulated her, and made up for his idiocy with my tip.

If you don't tip at all, you're either clueless or an asshole. Tipping a quarter is more insulting: you're acknowledging the need to tip, but making it clear you don't think much of the bartender.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by danielweber on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:20PM (#6490412)
I would think he avoided the concept of paying them by giving a gift instead, which sidesteps the concept of "pay" the same way an honorarium[1] would.

I was at a company where someone reported a security problem to the support team. I didn't quite believe it, but they got me on the phone, and within 10 seconds the guy had said the right words to tell me he had found something. So we fixed it.

What then? The company had no formal bounty system in place. I said we should send him something, so I got him an Amazon gift card and sent it to him along with a letter of thanks.

He said thank you back to us.

It all seemed good, but maybe it was just luck of the draw that an Internet mob didn't show up for me the next day.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honorarium

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by yogo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:51AM (#6489269)
Yahoo is free to do whatever they want. I think that's obvious. My opinion from the sidelines reflects what I think it looks like. Certain things become the norm, for e.g. someone finds $100K and returns it, the norm is to pay them a nice reward for doing so. There is absolutely no agreement or law in place that says they have to get anything in return. In fact, neither I nor most people I know expect anything in return for doing the right thing. What would your reaction be if the finder received nothing?

Just in case you want to know where I stand: if I find $100K in cash and there is no way to trace it back to me I'm not returning it. However, that is different to finding a bug and selling it for monetary gain.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by mikeash on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:53AM (#6489285)
> It would have been better to give them nothing rather than a "cheap" gift?

YES!

There seem to be two camps here, neither of which can even fathom the other's position.

On your side, we have people who do a purely logical comparison that non-zero is greater than zero, so this is better.

On my side, we have people who inherently separate tasks done for free for fun or just to be nice, from tasks done for money. For these people, getting paid a pittance is a grave insult, while not getting paid at all (when nothing is owed) is just fine.

I don't really know how to explain it any further. I think the people in your camp just need to understand that the other camp exists and contains a lot of people, and that regardless of logic, giving someone a $12.50 gift card is a massive insult, far worse than giving them nothing. You don't have to understand why, but you have to know that this is how it is for a lot of people.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by javajosh on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:16AM (#6489474)
You are right there are two views, but they are reconcilable.

I think the problem mostly lies in conflating "token of gratitude" with "gratitude". The token is a cheap thing, and has some small monetary value. The gratitude itself is a much more valuable thing, for both the giver and the receiver. Reporters are motivated by doing the right thing, and perhaps getting some recognition for their contribution. The recognition has two parts: recognizing cleverness (you caught something others missed), and recognizing honor (doing the "right thing", reporting it to the affected party rather than exploiting it yourself).

You can't put a price on cleverness and honor. And if you try to, and you come up with $12.50, then you're an idiot. The only thing you can do is recognize it, and show gratitude for the help.

What the OP tried to do was show gratitude and recognition with a token, and some recipients confused the token for the gratitude. It doesn't sound to me like the giver was confused! E.g. he wasn't saying "Here, let me pay you for your time, eliminating the need for us to recognize your cleverness and honor for the cost of a T-shirt." Now you might say that the token was poorly chosen: there is a reason people invented trophies, items that are totally worthless other than as tokens of accomplishment. It's because the recipient will NEVER confuse a trophy for the price of the accomplishment behind it.

Personally, I think a cool little useless trophy would have worked better, and certainly no gift certificates! Being named and honored somewhere on the Yahoo website would be great. Giving a small cash prize, like $1000, would be a classy move.

The bottom-line remains: there was nothing fundamentally wrong with the T-shirt-as-trophy, apart from the (apparent) risk of recipients confusing it for T-shirt-as-payment.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by mikeash on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:25AM (#6489536)
I think you're absolutely right. There's nothing fundamentally wrong with giving a t-shirt, or even a gift card for a t-shirt, if it's properly communicated. But it has to explicitly be something like, "Thanks so much for this. I'm terribly sorry that we can't give you a proper reward, much though I'd like to. As a small token of my appreciation, I hope you'll accept a t-shirt as my way of saying thanks. Since I don't know your size, here's a gift card you can use to obtain whatever size and style you prefer." If it had been done like this, I think it would have gone over fine. There might be some grumbling about how a large company "should" have a bug bounty program, but not the sort of attitude we've seen.

As best I can tell, the gift card was offered without comment. And while the intentions were good, the lack of such a message meant that it was taken badly.

I guess the lesson is, if you're offering only a token of appreciation, make sure the recipient knows you know it's only a token.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by yogo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:00AM (#6489346)
I wish a sociologist or anthropologist would comment and explain formally what this is but I'm thinking it is something along the lines of a thank you or appreciation not being quantifiable. Where as putting money (or something quantifiable) on the table communicates some sort of value.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by chc on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:40AM (#6489687)
I'm not a sociologist, but I've had a longstanding interest in the origin of manners, so I've read a bit on this. The problem here is that putting a number on something invites comparisons. We almost can't help comparing numbers. If my friend gets a number and I get a "You are awesome! Thank you so much!" I can't easily compare those because they are unlike each other. But when my friend gets a 500 and I get a 12.5, it is obvious to everyone that the number I got is so much lower, it's embarrassing. That guy's number is way bigger than mine.

Basically, no monetary reward is necessarily expected here. But once you give one, it is a faux pas to give one that looks small in comparison to what is considered the "norm." We even have common insults reflecting this fact, where bragging about something I impressive will invite comments like, "Wow, here is a shiny nickel." The impromptu offer of a clearly paltry reward is understood as a slight.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by asmithmd1 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:13AM (#6489451)
Yahoo "owed him one" when he reported the vulerabilty.

When they traded a shirt for the report Yahoo was implying that they no longer owed him anything, it was a fair barter

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by mikeash on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:04AM (#6489372)
Yeah, I'd like a better explanation myself. I feel it, but I can't really explain why.

It seems like there are just two distinct modes. When you do something for free, you're basically doing a favor, and you get pleasure from being altruistic. Once you get paid, it's now an exchange of value, not altruism, so you only get pleasure from being paid. If the pay is small, you'll feel upset because your end of the bargain is based entirely on that, while if you're doing it for free, you switch over.

I could be full of it....

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by turtle4 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:25AM (#6489542)
If nothing is given, you assume the first party is indicating that their thanks/recognition is enough.

If something is given, then they are acknowledging that their thanks/recognition is not enough, but that $x monetary value makes up the difference.

Some people take it as an insult that if thanks isn't enough, they can be 'bought' for $x, where $x is $12.50, or whatever. The reasoning is basically that if you are saying the time taken to reproduce and report the issue is important enough to compensate, you should probably compensate commensurate with what they would expect to make for their time/expertise.

I think most people who report these things do so because they want to improve things, not for the money, so most probably fall into the first camp, but I can understand where the second camp is coming from.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by eli on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:15PM (#6490377)
No, I get what you're saying. But they originally DID do this task for free. The work they did was already done regardless of what Yahoo did with their report next. If they were expecting or counting on a charity gift from Yahoo, that seems like a mistake.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by jack-r-abbit on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:18AM (#6489484)
> separate tasks done for free for fun or just to be nice, from tasks done for money

Sure. But given the lack of a formal bounty program at Yahoo!, it was a poor choice to pick them as a place for "tasks done for money"

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by mikeash on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:26AM (#6489547)
They didn't necessarily pick that, though. When you submit a vulnerability to a company that doesn't have such a program in place, it is their choice as to whether that falls into the "free" or "paid" category.

Yahoo's reaction put it into the "paid" category, and then paid an insultingly low amount. That was their error. A different reaction, even just different wording when sending the gift card, could have put it into the "free" category.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by jack-r-abbit on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:36AM (#6489660)
You can see it as an insultingly low payment or as a bigger than usual thank you. If you expected nothing, the shirt is a pretty decent thank you. If you expected to be paid, the shirt is an insult. Clearly the people who bitched about the shirt expected to get paid. So they had already put their work in the "paid" category and then complained when the pay was low. It sounds like a lot of other people didn't expect anything and put their work in the "free" category and were (at least a little) pleased to get an unexpected thank you.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by tomjen3 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:06PM (#6490746)
You are misunderstanding things. A dollar amount automatically puts it into the paid category, because it is comparable.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by jack-r-abbit on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:46PM (#6491032)
You are misunderstanding things. It used to just be an actual t-shirt. But people who already had a t-shirt said they didn't need another one. So an equivalent amount of store credit was given to get something other than a t-shirt. I guess he could have just offered for them to pick from a few different schwag items. Any physical item as a thank you is going to have some sort of dollar value... but I still don't think that automatically puts it into the paid category.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by res0nat0r on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:52AM (#6489283)
Yet there have been dozens upon dozens of threads in this same forum of people making up all kinds of explanations of why they don't want to pay $15 for a music cd they will listen to possibly dozens of times over their lifetime. Ironic...
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by snarfy on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:56AM (#6489312)
It implicitly meant they don't really value security.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by yogo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:04AM (#6489382)
Exactly. When that comment came from a Yahoo employee I caught a glimpse of what I think the company's attitude towards security is. To me it seemed like there was no understanding that by not taking care of the little things that are lurking in the dark it can cost the company big time. Yes, I know this is an employee's personal opinion, but still...
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:11AM (#6489443)
Kind of an unfair statement imho. I work for Tumblr, and we run independently still. That being said, a companies policy does not reflect every employee, especially when you have a company that employees over 11k people.

I think it's great they are making a policy change, and making it retroactive even. My opinion is facing the community and the perceived entitlement people have at getting something for reporting a bug. I applaud those that have policies in place, but the community is shining a bad light on itself with the outrage.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by nknighthb on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:06PM (#6490313)
It's amazing how every time Yahoo is in the news, I end up that much more grateful to have rejected their job offer.

Every act an employee takes and every word they speak while on the job is directly attributable to their employer. No exceptions, no excuses, ever. It doesn't matter if it was against policy, and it doesn't matter how many employees there are. The company must take responsibility. It reflects extremely poorly on the corporate culture of Yahoo and Tumblr that you don't recognize that.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:47PM (#6490580)
We have different opinions and different values. I value my right to speak freely and not in representation of my employer. I wouldn't judge your employer for your words, hobbies, extracurricular activities - they are not a representation of you, nor are you a representation on them. If you feel otherwise, that's your right to do so - I hope that the corporate culture that you found suits you better then the one that works for me.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by nknighthb on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:03PM (#6490725)
> I value my right to speak freely and not in representation of my employer.

You fail to understand two things. The first is that you have no such "right". You are speaking as a representative of your employer when others perceive you to be. What you or your employer think is irrelevant.

The second is that this isn't about you. Whether you must take responsibility internally is up to your employer. But whether your employer must take responsibility in public is not. It has nothing to do with your "rights". You don't have a say in the matter.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by oijaf888 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:53AM (#6489789)
Because an employee feels that a lot of people have an entitled view towards security payouts as opposed to just reporting them because its the right thing to do...this means that that Yahoo has a bad attitude towards security?

Could you please explain your logic there?

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by yogo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:45PM (#6490173)
I felt like if there is a company culture where everyone understands that security vulnerabilities can be costly then there wouldn't even be a discussion about security researchers being entitled, there would be a good bug bounty program in place from the get go. Maybe my logic is flawed but to me no bug bounty program says we really don't care enough about this and it's not a big priority, we'll just let/hope people do the right thing and report problems because that's how big internet companies do things in 2013.

That's how I see things from the outside, I don't have any inside information and it could very well turn out they have most of their staff working on software testing and security.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by kozhevnikov on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:07AM (#6489406)
Agree, but how would you feel if you got an Addison-Wesley t-shirt instead of a check for $2.56?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knuth_reward_check

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by oijaf888 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:46AM (#6489737)
You did read that right? Knuth doesn't send real checks anymore due to check fraud. So the actual thing you get is comparable to a t-shirt (admittedly a very limited edition t-shirt).
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by kozhevnikov on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:16PM (#6489975)
I did. The question was 'when did everyone become so entitled to getting something for reporting a bug' to which I provided a valid (or at least humorous) possible answer, i.e. since Knuth's reward checks became a status symbol.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by asmithmd1 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:36AM (#6489154)
Money is how we keep score and literally show each other what we value. I think there is a threshold amount that demonstrates that they really care and I would define that as enough money for a date.

I found a vulnerability with a large regional service I use a couple of years ago and did the right thing by discreetly reporting it. They thanked me and gave me credit for their service equal to about $50; I felt like they really appreciated my report.

If they had given me swag they give away for free I would have been nonplussed.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by PhasmaFelis on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:32PM (#6490496)
If you report a bug to a company that has no posted bug-bounty policy, you really shouldn't be expecting anything but a "thank you". If you don't get a thank you, then you have a right to be nonplussed. Anything beyond a thank you (cash, T-shirts, warm hugs) is pure gravy and, IMHO, ought to be appreciated as such.

That said, yes, big companies really ought to have official bug bounties. But that doesn't mean you have a right to expect them.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by robin_reala on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:37AM (#6489668)
There’s a market rate for vulnerabilities in highly trafficked websites. If you want people to give you the bug report instead of selling it to zero-day gangs or governments then you need to pay the market rate. You can expect a small discount because selling the bug to you is ‘doing the right thing’, but if you’re not paying more than a tee and you want to attract the people that go out of their way to discover issues then you’re automatically on the back foot.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by spullara on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:29PM (#6490041)
Roughly similar to a guy that walks through your neighborhood jiggling door knobs and asks for $100/house when he discovers an unlocked door or disabled alarm system otherwise he will report it to his burglar friends.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by csmatt on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:37PM (#6492629)
Not at all similar to that. Ignoring the fact that the characteristics of residences and a very high traffic website with an enormous user-base are vastly different, your argument relies on the discoverer of the vulnerability choosing one of two paths: get paid by the company or get paid by nefarious people.

A third option is to choose neither because the discoverer doesn't think it warrants his or her time to report it. Reporting a security vulnerability requires more than just sending an email. Meanwhile, others who have discovered the same vulnerability may be selling access to it and a company like Yahoo has no idea until severe damage has been done.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by spullara on Sunday October 06, 2013 @04:05PM (#6505231)
Assuming they spent effort to discover the vulnerability the idea that there is a 3rd option where it is suddenly not worth their time to report it makes little sense.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by jessaustin on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:25AM (#6489540)
...I technically work for Yahoo...

Why on earth are you undermining Yahoo's official communications in a public forum?

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by dangrossman on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:31AM (#6489600)
Because taking a job with Yahoo! did not involve signing away his rights to his own opinions, or the ability to discuss them with others without hiding his employment relationship. Which is a good thing.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by jessaustin on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:35AM (#6489645)
Of course I challenge the wisdom of the undermining, not anyone's rights or abilities with respect to it.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by ars_technician on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:50PM (#6491507)
He explicitly advertised it though and then gave a contrary opinion. The only reason to do that is to intentionally harm the original message.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:38AM (#6489671)
The opinion stated is with the general mentality around bug rewards. In what way was it undermining Yahoo?
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by jessaustin on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:52AM (#6489780)
You say, "go directly to the companies that actually have a reward program in place" while Ramses says, "when you work for a company that serves more than 800 million people every month, you take network and user security very seriously." Ramses would probably prefer you not to discourage vulnerability reporting in the way that you have. But more importantly, his tone is entirely different. He doesn't mention the term "entitled" once, and he doesn't imply that the original report was somehow deficient.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:10PM (#6489935)
I said "If you are looking to make a living off of finding bugs, go directly to the companies that actually have a reward program in place." which is a little different. I encourage reporting bugs at any capacity. If your motives are aligned differently, then why would someone get mad at not receiving what they think they should be getting? My tone is different because I am expressing my opinion on how there seems to be a sense of entitlement out there lately - at least that is how I perceive it. I don't want to discourage the reporting aspect, I want to discourage the way people are behaving when their bug report doesn't meet certain standards, or where even a thank you rubs them the wrong way.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by leke on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:21AM (#6489507)
You're absolutely right. That's why I would never use Yahoo for anything important of mine. Having such an incentive in place is a crucial measure in today's security climate.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by elliottcarlson on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:29AM (#6489573)
Great - so do you use Github? Because if you do, then you are obviously putting your important files at risk.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by vinceguidry on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:14PM (#6489962)
Paying bounties in this way is in my mind comparable to tipping in restaurants. It's a compromise that doesn't really solve the stated problem, but it's adequate enough to allow business to move forward until the status-quo evolves.

Ideally in a restaurant, we'd pay servers real wages. Well the market won't bear that. So we have this tipping system set up. It's by no means ideal, but it works well enough and eventually, tipless restaurants will bowl everyone over with how much better they are and we'll just move in that direction.

Security research needs to be paid. There's too much on the line to just leave this work to unpaid volunteers. But a real security department, for many reasons, is simply unfeasible. Real security has to audit everything. Too much manpower is needed. Bug bounties allow websites to get the security updates they need while compensating researchers somewhat adequately.

It's not entitlement to believe that you should get an appropriate payment for your research. These companies have a responsibility to their customers. They all need to be paying bounties. Even the ones that have security departments should be paying them because people miss things all the time and the consequences of a breach are tremendous. Better pay a little now to avoid a lot of pain later.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by guyzero on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:44PM (#6490159)
It's not so much entitlement as that there is a real and active marketplace for security vulnerabilities. If Yahoo isn't going to pay, someone else is going to pay for vulnerabilities and that would be a lot worse.
Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by kefka on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:03PM (#6490296)
I look at getting paid for bugs from the other side as well. The company can offer X dollars for a bug. Cool. So, you're buying my time.

Or I can take this bug to an Onion site and auction this bug off to the highest paying blackhat. It would most likely bed used for illegal purposes, but selling bugs isn't illegal if found accidentally.

What I'm saying is this is Capitalism in action.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by javajosh on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:28AM (#6489562)
>when did everyone become so entitled to getting something for reporting a bug/security concern.

When did everyone stop reflecting on how communication can be improved? Yahoo! wants to better show it's appreciation and gratitude for these security finds. Security researchers don't want their work cheapened.

Re:So I’m the guy who sent the t-shirt out as a thank you by teh_klev on Friday October 04, 2013 @05:09AM (#6494426)
I generally agree with this. It's trying to make a living off of handing in lost wallets or purses full of money then expecting a cut just for doing what any civilised person should do. Personally, I'm happy with a thank you, a t-shirt would have been a bonus.