News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jimmyhmiller on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:31PM (#6478533)
>A scientist generally starts with the conservative working assumption that proposed new ideas are not true or that hypothetical new entities do not exist, and then revises her probability estimate upwards only when the evidence forces her to do so. A pseudoscientist typically starts with the assumption that a novel proposal seems to be true, and then revises her probability downward as the evidence leaves her no choice—if she is willing to surrender the possibility to any degree at all.

That sounds more like a verificationist idea of science than a Popperian falsification process. Is verificationism coming back in vogue in the sciences? Wouldn't it be a much better criticism to say that the cryptozoologists are not scientific because they do not make falsifiable predictions?

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by api on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:49PM (#6478632)
Ahh philosophy...

But if cryptozoologists are unscientific by the Popperian criteria then so is SETI.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:51PM (#6479013)
> But if cryptozoologists are unscientific by the Popperian criteria then so is SETI.

Not at all. Cryptozoologists assume their subject exists, SETI researchers assume it doesn't. Surely you don't think SETI people assume a priori that they will hear a transmission from an intelligent alien species? Or that they have heard such a thing?

There's a single report of an anomalous reception, now called the "Wow" signal, that no serious SETI person thinks represents an alien broadcast. By contrast, there are any number of books and articles by cryptozoologists that analyze, but don't doubt, the many reports of Bigfoot, Yeti, Nessie, etc. sightings.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wow!_signal

Quote: "Ehman has voiced doubts that the signal was of intelligent extraterrestrial origin: 'We should have seen it again when we looked for it 50 times. Something suggests it was an Earth-sourced signal that simply got reflected off a piece of space debris.'"

Spoken like a true scientist.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:45PM (#6478971)
> That sounds more like a verificationist idea of science than a Popperian falsification process.

Actually, it's an informal statement of the null hypothesis:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Null_hypothesis

In the null hypothesis, supposedly the basis for all experimental science, you start with the assumption that there is no effect, and let the evidence force you to a different conclusion. In other words, you assume nothing out of the ordinary and take no position on the subject of study.

> Wouldn't it be a much better criticism to say that the cryptozoologists are not scientific because they do not make falsifiable predictions?

Yes, it would, but that's not a very popular definition of science these days. If it were, psychiatrists and psychologists would be immediately excluded -- they make plenty of predictions, but the predictions don't work out.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:47PM (#6479296)
"Yes, it would, but that's not a very popular definition of science these days. If it were, psychiatrists and psychologists would be immediately excluded -- they make plenty of predictions, but the predictions don't work out."

It is a popular definition of science in some circles for exactly that reason. Psychoanalysis in particular is heavily criticized for this.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by ChuckMcM on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:29PM (#6478517)
I like the similar argument for Alien visitors, we are approaching saturation in terms of cameras that can take videos and a highly discoverable channel for making such videos available (*tube) and so, like the neutrino detectors in mine shafts, if there is an "event" we'll catch it on camera. That gives us the ability to start computing the probabilities more accurately vis-a-vis alien visitation.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by api on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:46PM (#6478615)
There's tons of UFO videos on YouTube. The problem is that if you exclude the obvious CGI and other hoaxes, that leaves a data set of unidentified objects captured on camera. But that provides little evidence as to what that object might actually be. There are many prosaic explanations: illusions, imaging artifacts, really good hoaxes, top-secret experimental aircraft built by us, ball lightning, etc.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by ChuckMcM on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:55PM (#6478676)
Exactly right. I went to a talk at the SETI institute where analysis of such videos left a very small residue of "unexplained" visual phenomena.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by wtvanhest on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:45PM (#6478611)
I was thinking the same thing while reading it. We do have a way to go before consumer camera technology is good enough to capture moving spaceships (or even jet liners at night).

Cameras are not very good at catching sharp movement of low lit objects. Just to photograph sports clearly requires several thousand dollars in equipment and you can be as close as 50 meters most of the game.

That will change a lot over the years as sensor technology continues to improve and eventually your point will be important.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by mathattack on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:15PM (#6479128)
I thought cameras would be the death of paranormal, but then we have photoshop and facebook to convert a whole new wave of believers.

I do like the thought process though - if it's supposedly this common but still unproven, it's less likely to be true. Do we put ghosts in the same category?

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by dkersten on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:24PM (#6479175)
I always think about it the other way around: given we have photoshop and similar tools, every bit of photographic and video evidence is suspect. Just look at a movie - if that's what we can do, how could anybody ever believe a photo or video of, say, aliens unless they were there themselves.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:42PM (#6479259)
If you see one video of aliens visiting Central Park^, then you can probably be sure that it is fake. If twitter is suddenly flooded with reports about aliens in Central Park^, and dozens to hundreds of people all upload different cellphone videos of it, then something just might actually be happening.

There is still potential for mass-fraud, but repeated seemingly uncoordinated reports improves credibility. Maybe they're all Photoshopping the same thing from different angles, but that is less likely than a single person doing it.

^ I mean come on, if you were an alien, where would you go first? I'd totally go to New York. Here is another rule of thumb: if the aliens are doing something boring, like stealing cows or fucking with corn fields, they probably aren't real.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by kanzure on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:11PM (#6479382)
> There is still potential for mass-fraud, but repeated seemingly uncoordinated reports improves credibility

Hmm. That would be an interesting piece of fraud (oops I mean public art) to architect. Make a Blender scene of Central Park, populate the scene with bystanders with phones (yes, this will take time to source realistic models and skeletal animations). Each phone gets to be a camera in the scene. Not all cameras start and stop at the same time, and a few of them will have to capture video before and after the event without the actual event included. Timestamp and tag the videos appropriately, including clock drift, then have fun with avconv/ffmpeg converting the formats to different video formats based on known phone sales and what default formats iOS/Android encodes to (ugh, I actually had to do this once back when zencoder/pandavideo).

Create twitter accounts in advance, make them look real by copying other twitter users, and the day of the event just start uploading the youtube videos all at the same time and get your fake tweets flowing.

Now, what could this pipeline be useful for? Suppose you know that the videos are fake, but also suppose you can be reasonably sure that others will accept this data as real news. What could you do with that? First idea is some killer marketing stunt..

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:18PM (#6479422)
Yeah, as I wrote that I actually began to think that it would be a pretty neat idea.

I think maybe you could do it by actually filming in Central Park with some sort of structure with white balls on it, in a certain known arrangement, that you could automate a lot of the video editing from various angles.. I'm not sure about that but I suspect it is feasible. If you get everyone to film different angles at the same basic time then the scene would be the same (just from different angles) and you'd have everyone else filming in the background that would lend credibility.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by johnchristopher on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:13PM (#6478781)
You are both forgetting Suliban and Romulan cloaking devices.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:39PM (#6479241)
Aliens are advanced and have cloacking ability, the only proof we have are stories from abductee hypnosis sessions.

Professor Jacobs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_M._Jacobs has researched the subject scientifically for decades.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by krapp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:55PM (#6479325)
>the only proof we have are stories from abductee hypnosis sessions.

That isn't proof of anything.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:09PM (#6479379)
Seriously. If we were to accept that sort of bullshit nonsense as evidence then we would also have "evidence" for widespread organized "Satanic ritual abuse" in the 1980's, devils which sit on the chests of sleeping people, ghosts and/or spirits of the dead, aliens riding DC-8's exploding hydrogen bombs in volcanoes...
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:15PM (#6479401)
I agree that even if millions claim that have been abducted this is not solid proof but I think that the main reason for the lack of solid proofs is the impact of such proofs on the human society.

Also this is subject is very taboo, most people reject the subject immediately as ridiculous and compare it to fairies and ghosts. Maybe they are afraid, closed minded or really belive we are alone in this vast universe.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by krapp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:26PM (#6479463)
>Maybe they are afraid, closed minded or really belive we are alone in this vast universe.

You're asserting false dichotomies. The universe may be teeming with life, but that still wouldn't lend any credence to the scenario of alien abduction. You don't have to be afraid or close-minded to doubt it, you just have to be rational.

It isn't proof, simply because it's entirely subjective. It exists inside people's minds.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:42PM (#6479555)
>Maybe they are afraid, closed minded or really belive we are alone in this vast universe

I was trying to find an explanation for the immediate rejection of the subject as silly.

> It exists inside people's minds.

The strange thing is that millions have the same thing in their minds, could this be a collective mental illness? but why do all of them report the same things and have the same details?

If you read Jacobs reports you will see that many people that never met experienced similar events, how can this be explained?

You could at least see read some of the reports or see some of the "non" evidence before rejecting it as silly.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:54PM (#6479615)
> "I was trying to find an explanation for the immediate rejection of the subject as silly."

"Space is big", "boy who cried wolf", or a combination of both.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @07:10PM (#6479676)
So you reject the posibility with the argument that the space is big? the vastness of space says nothing about life density or travel capabilities of advanced civilations also we know so little about the structure of the universe.

But I don't understand the ridicule and lack of arguments, I fell like I'm in 1400 saying that the earth is round.

Also why the hate and downvotes?

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @07:20PM (#6479722)
I am saying people scoff at the idea because space is big. Come back with actual evidence and the off the cuff dismissal will stop. (though even then, expect some resistance since UFOists have been crying wolf so often)
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @07:54PM (#6479835)
The funny thing is that I say the same things to a religious friend, how can you belive in all those stories without proof? I don't think we can compare the two but they are very similar from this point of view, lack of evidence.

It's true that there is no real public evidence, no flesh and bone alien or goverment confirmation but I think the main difference from religion is that there are all kind of information bits that seem to support it, the sexual experiments on abductees and very similar details they provide in their stories still don't have any other explanation to disprove it, just read Jacobs reports or see his video presentations, remember that he has a Ph.D and years of research on this so you can't compare him to a conspiracy nut on the internet.

Also there is the impact on society of such discovery, the world would literally panic, most people will interpret this in all kind of apocaliptic ways.

So the most credible argument on the lack of evidence is that human society is not ready to accept the fact that they are not alone, people rejected throughout history the ideea that they are not the center of the universe so this will be very hard to accept.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @04:42AM (#6481343)
The most credible explanation for the lack of evidence is simply that no evidence has been found. You are literally working science backwards, making a perversion of the scientific process. This very literally is what many religious people do when attempting to reconcile unscientific beliefs that they hold. (And it should therefore come as no surprise that all the bullshit you see Jacobs spewing is bullshit that religious charlatans have spewed as well, though with their own prefered twist of course. Seriously, they used this same shit to justify the 'Satanic ritual abuse' scare not many years ago. "They?" you ask? People with PhDs, you know, 'totally unquestionably not quacks' /s Yeah right.).

Trust me, I'm not afraid of the concept of aliens. Far from it, I am damn near certain that we are not the only life the universe has ever seen. Other life visiting this planet though? Without evidence of it... there isn't evidence of it. No reason to make that any more complex than it is, since it is a pretty fucking simple concept.

Now, this idea of people rejecting an idea because they are afraid of it? I am sorry, but you are clearly not very familiar with the history of religion and cults. People dig doomsday shit. They love to be frightened, they love reasons to believe their life won't matter soon (for whatever definition of 'matter' they are working off of), they love feeling irrelevant. I mean, you clearly dig this shit. What, you think you are special in this regard?

This hypothesis of yours, that people "can't handle the truth, because it is too intense for them", but they totally dig Revelations? Give me a break.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @05:28AM (#6481470)
You don't seem to understand the sociological impact that such a discovery can have on society to take it as an argument, if you think that things will continue as nothing happened and people will accept it as scientists, as something normal, you are wrong.

People always searched for things like this but it never happenend, if it happened how do you thing they would react?

You also want aliens to land on your backyard or the president to say it on tv but you dismiss the fact if they are so advanced maybe they don't care talking to us and don't need to explain to us, see zoo hypotesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoo_hypothesis and the president will never tell this on tv because of the the first argument, even in the famous http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roswell_UFO_incident case the military first released a press conference that said they found an unknown object and later they changed their statement, why do you think they changed their mind? They probably didn't thought about the consequences of the statement.

You can't really refute all the adbudcation experiences and people experiences without scientific research just because it seems unlikely to be true, a very small percentage of them are not hoaxes and they can't be scientifically explained.

It's sad that even at scientific level peope reject it as silly instead of looking at the facts and research it and gives us a scientific proof that this true or false.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @11:22AM (#6482934)
> instead of looking at the facts and research it and gives us a scientific proof that this true or false.

Listen, this has been addressed many times now but you keep dodging it, so this is the last time I'm saying it: There isn't evidence for aliens visiting earth. The shit you cite as clear evidence is a fucking joke.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:15PM (#6483792)
It seems that you have trouble understanding what I said. Indeed there are no proofs but there are unexplained phenomena that deserve to be researched and if all people would be closed minded and rejected the possibility as silly then with this way of thinking we will still be in that "earth is flat" mentality.

According to drake equation the probability of life in the universe is immense, the strange things is that nobody visited us, either they didn't or they didn't want to show us that they did like we don't disturb the life of the lions in the jungle when we film a documentary.

If this is so hard for you to understand then I give up, have a nice day.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:52PM (#6484045)
Science isn't even about "proofs", christ you are a nut. Where do people like you get these ideas?
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @02:50PM (#6484412)
All scientific theories require proof that comes from repeatable objective experimentation.

Nut? If this conversation continues you would probably also call me a nazi, this is a classic for lack of arguments.

I know, you don't need arguments because et contact is so silly that it doesn't need arguments.

Grow up.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by krapp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @07:11PM (#6479678)
>The strange thing is that millions have the same thing in their minds, could this be a collective mental illness? but why do all of them report the same things and have the same details?

First, I don't know that it's necessarily true that "millions" of people have experienced this. But let me offer some evidence that at least to some degree this phenomenon whatever it is doesn't represent objective truth.

There was a point when the majority of UFO sightings comprised of airships and not what we would recognize as spacecraft. It's telling that this occurred at a time when there was no popular archetype of what qualities a spaceship might have to have. The denizens of these craft were described as basically human looking, and some claimed to be from Mars (at a time when the possibility of intelligent life on Mars was commonly accepted as possibility.)

One would expect an alien spacecraft to have some properties which are, well alien but all the descriptions i've seen and heard about don't often describe technology at a level far beyond the understanding of the time. Until it was scientifically proven impossible, many "aliens" appeared to be humans claiming to come from Mars or Venus.

Prior to this, many of the phenomena associated now with alien abduction was associated with demonic possession. There were no spaceships or airships, but plenty of hoary beast-men in the woods and wicked things convincing wizards to swap wives with each other.

My point being, the nature of this phenomenon never seems to rise above or to give information beyond what could be generated in the imagination of a single human being, and it seems to evolve as popular culture evolves. now we have to deal with the post-Lazar post-Roswell Post-Ancient Aliens/X-Files world of self-aware media irony in which it's claimed these aliens are responsible for practically every event and are behind every government and have portals everywhere and secret bases and yet despite the media and camera saturation... still nothing but mythology to account for any of it.

Now you could say the demons were aliens, and the airship captains were just taking on an appearance which we could comprehend. But again, while that makes for an internally consistent narrative, it doesn't really prove anything. The face on mars turned out to be a trick of the light, and i'm sitting here near the end of 2013, and it turns out the Mayans didn't know shit about the future after all.

meanwhile we do know there are such things as hallucinations, and hoaxes, and sleep paralysis, and any number of physiological and psychological phenomena to account for much if not all of the alien abduction scenario. What we don't have is strong, credible, independently verifiable publically credible evidence that aliens are abducting anyone. I'll tell you what it would look like - something undeniable and irrefutably alien. Not stories. Not weird lights someone's brother's cousin once heard someone saw one time. When they crash their saucer into the White House i'll maybe consider it. Until then, it's just faeries in the garden with updated costumes as far as i'm concerned.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @07:27PM (#6479760)
It's true that 99.99% percent of reports are either hoaxes or misinterpretation of venus or human aircrafts and that here is a lot of misinformation.

The only argument that I see is that there is no real explanation for the fact that most abductees describe the same experiences down to extreme details and even if the grey alien figure can be traced to subconcious influenced by media I don't see what could influence abductees to imagine sexual experiments, until a real explanation for this is found I don't think we can dismiss the probability.

Maybe there are no other proofs because they are really good at leaving no traces and probably don't want to provide them yet to avoid panicking the masses, in a world that 88,5% of the population is religious http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations I don't think this will be received too well and they probably understand this.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by krapp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @07:42PM (#6479805)
>The only argument that I see is that there is no real explanation for the fact that most abductees describe the same experiences down to extreme details

Not true. Before the current narrative of sexual examination and hybridization became commonplace, it was just as common for 'aliens' to 'abduct people' and tell them stories of the Aryan supermen from Atlantis. You have to account for the similarity in detail being due to the existence of the phenomenon being well known. You also have to account for your own assertion that since it's true that 99.99% percent of reports are either hoaxes or misinterpretation this also calls into question the bulk of those stories attached to alien abduction.

>I don't see what could influence abductees to imagine sexual experiments, until a real explanation for this is found I don't think we can dismiss the probability.

Your need for a "real" explanation assumes there must be a physical reality behind the phenomenon. That doesn't have to be the case.

>Maybe there are no other proofs because they are really good at leaving no traces and probably don't want to provide them yet to avoid panicking the masses, in a world that 88,5% of the population is religious http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations I don't think this will be received too well and they probably understand this.

And maybe there's no other proof because it's fiction. That's the problem for someone arguing your point of view -- your fact is indistinguishable from fiction from an impartial point of view.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @08:08PM (#6479881)
> Your need for a "real" explanation assumes there must be a physical reality behind the phenomenon. That doesn't have to be the case.

But what can explain the phenonemen? Currently there is no explanation for this. You could read some of Jacobs books, he found all kind of patterns, if this is just some collective halucination originating deep in our subconscious then is just as fascinating.

> That's the problem for someone arguing your point of view -- your fact is indistinguishable from fiction from an impartial point of view.

Indeed this is the biggest problem, because of lack of evidence it all looks sf. If the reason for the lack of evidence or encouter is the large percent of relious people or people with limited knowledge about the universe that can't cope with this fact then probably this will not change in our lifetime and we will not live to know if there was lack of evidence or it was all sf and we are alone in the universe or just never been in contact.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by krapp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @08:12PM (#6479892)
>But what can explain the phenonemen? Currently there is no explanation for this

https://www.google.com/search?q=rational+explanation+for+ali...

There are explanations aplenty.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @08:55PM (#6479988)
> There are explanations aplenty.

I clicked on some links and some of them explain the phenomenon by presenting people that say all kind of conspiracies and are not credible, others have confused it with sleep paralysis and some others cases that make the usual 99.99%. Also sleep paralysis can't be an explantion because as Jacobs says here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_M._Jacobs "in numerous cases people report they were abducted when fully awake and conscious, and that therefore sleep paralysis is not a tenable hypothesis"

So I can say the same thing, where is the undeniable proof that the abduction phenonemon is not real? Because there is no scientific explanation to explains all cases yet. The same thing as in ufo sightins happens, the 0.01% is hard to see from all the hoaxes and disinformation.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @04:48AM (#6481356)
"So I can say the same thing, where is the undeniable proof that the abduction phenonemon is not real?"

This question betrays a very basic failure to understand the basis of science. I suggest you research on your own why I might say this. Research it, and make sure you really comprehend it.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @05:54AM (#6481543)
No it's not, as this must be proved scientifically to be real it must also be proved scientifically wrong to fully dismiss it, until then it's something unexplained.

Our science lacks the knowledge or the tools to prove or disprove it, remember what are we dealing with and or science is young and limited.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @11:18AM (#6482909)
I'm sorry; you're going to have to go back to the drawing board on that one.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:20PM (#6483826)
Because you said so? You need arguments to sustain your claim.

Science should prove or disprove some phenomena to be sure that is either true or false, otherwise there is still a probability, this is how it works.

If you have a valid scientific proof that the abduction phenomenon is a collective hallucination then you could dismiss the phenomenon, until then this is just unexplained and the probability remains.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:40PM (#6483962)
> Science should prove or disprove some phenomena to be sure that is either true or false,

No. Absolutely not. This is what I am talking about, a failure to understand what science is on the most basic of levels.

You don't prove a null hypothesis. Expecting proof of a null hypothesis is flat out retarded, you only disprove them. Without accepting null hypothesises until they are disproved, that is to say, without any functional sense of skepticism, you fall down the rabbit hole of believing all sorts of religious, supernatural, and pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo.

Have you disproved leprechauns? Xenu? Have you disproved the notion that I am in fact a god, descended from Mount Olympus on a mission to take out the Reptilian Queen?

Sane, rational, people do not expect these claims to be disproved. They expect them to be proved, and reject them until they are.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @03:43PM (#6484758)
Your analogy is false, you are comparing a real psychological disorder with Xenu fairytales or myths.

I don't have the time anymore to explain in more detail why you are wrong, you simply want to argue without arguments and you are right because you say so and because et contact is silly and of course because you know what science is.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by givan on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @09:14PM (#6480049)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_E._Mack

"I would never say, yes, there are aliens taking people. [But] I would say there is a compelling powerful phenomenon here that I can't account for in any other way, that's mysterious. Yet I can't know what it is but it seems to me that it invites a deeper, further inquiry"

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:26PM (#6479469)
> or really belive we are alone in this vast universe.

...or understand that space is big. Really big.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by 8_hours_ago on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:43PM (#6479271)
Obligatory XKCD reference: http://xkcd.com/1235/
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by roc on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:19PM (#6478457)
The approach seems fine when considering sightings vs (lack of) data for a specific potential-creature in a specific habitat.

But it seems rather flawed to group together all the various "large ape", "ape/human hybrid" type legends under the single umbrella of "bigfoot", so as to dismiss it as being "spotted too frequently to likely exist".

Why do this for "bigfoot" but not for giant squid? Surely the incredible breadth of "sea monster" legends and stories and sightings dwarfs the limited evidence that anyone had that a species of giant squids might exist.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lhc- on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:53PM (#6478658)
Sea Monsters (such as Nessie) are in the same category as Bigfoot. The Giant Squid has been caught on camera, and bodies have washed up on shore, leaving real evidence.

No bigfoot-like creature has ever been found, nor any evidence. Is there a reason to differentiate between different varieties of them when none of those varieties have any evidence?

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by roc on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:23PM (#6478848)
We did eventually get bodies, but only fairly recently. We had scraps before that, but those were often dismissed and had their aberrant characteristics ascribed to mutation or decomposition. In hindsight we have identified them as being of colossal squid, but that was anything but accepted at the time. It wasn't really until the 2000's and a live specimen was discovered that it was generally accepted that these things were real.

And, again, my point isn't whether Bigfoot does or doesn't exist. But whether the logical argument survives such abstraction. And I don't think it does.

The inexistence of bigfoot in the Pacific Northwest doesn't really speak to the (un)likelihood of the Yeti in the Himalayas. Nor does the lack of evidence for elves and goblins in Europe speak to the likelihood of an Orang Pendek.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:23PM (#6479174)
I think the article addresses your point nicely. People reportedly see bigfoot everywhere, all the time. For so many citings, we really should have an abundance of physical evidence, but we just don't.

Giant squid citings however are rare. The infrequent discovery of physical evidence is therefore not particularly troubling. (And before we found any credible physical evidence, the lack of physical evidence was still less troubling than the lack of physical evidence for bigfoot).

(Also not covered by the article: Thanks to sperm whales, who eat the things and sport scars from fights with them, we've actually had credible physical evidence of giant squid for quite some time. As far as I can tell nobody was mistaking these things for abnormally large regular squid since at least the 19th century, and people have been finding credible intact (although dead) specimens of them since about that same time: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_giant_squid_specimens_a...

"Steenstrup wrote a number of papers on giant squid in the 1850s. He first used the term "Architeuthus" (this was the spelling he chose) in a paper in 1857. A portion of a giant squid was secured by the French gunboat Alecton in 1861, leading to wider recognition of the genus in the scientific community. From 1870 to 1880, many squid were stranded on the shores of Newfoundland. For example, a specimen washed ashore in Thimble Tickle Bay, Newfoundland on 2 November 1878; its mantle was reported to be 6.1 m (20 ft) long, with one tentacle 10.7 m (35 ft) long, and it was estimated as weighing 2.2 tonnes.[citation needed] In 1873, a squid "attacked" a minister and a young boy in a dory in Bell Island, Newfoundland. Many strandings also occurred in New Zealand during the late 19th century.")

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by roc on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:47PM (#6479293)
> "Giant squid citings however are rare."

That's missing my question. Colossal squid sightings are rare, but "sea monsters" are sighted everywhere, all the time. And if we're expected to roll up the large bipeds (bigfoot, yeti, skunk ape, letiche, et al -- many of which with very distinct reported features) shouldn't we have rolled up "sea monsters" and dismissed the colossal squid until (almost literally) someone dropped it onto our faces? Granted, that isn't far from what happened, but shouldn't we have learned from that experience, rather than seek to codify the logic?

> "we've actually had credible physical evidence of giant squid for quite some time."

Accounts, but a dearth of specimen. Should someone discover the Orang Pendak tomorrow, surely hindsight will declare credible the records of the early 20th century dutch colonists. But as of this moment, it's far from generally accepted that these creatures exist, let alone that those accounts are actually credible.

And the logic of this article is literally arguing that we ought to weigh the likelihood of Orange Pendak, based on whether other creatures on other continents, that just happen to be roughly the same shape, have any credible evidence.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:59PM (#6479339)
Sightings of other assorted sea monsters are common, but the frequency of sea monster sightings is still not as concerning as the frequency of bigfoot sightings because we typically expect evidence of shit in the sea to be less forthcoming. This is the key takeaway from the article: not all improbabilities are made equal. Failure to find evidence in one case is not necessarily as damming as failure to find evidence in another case.

Rolling up all "sea monsters" and all "other great apes" only makes sense if all of these "sea monsters" are said to be basically big tentacled squidy things... The reason we roll all those "other great ape" claims together is because, frankly, it is all the same shit. Hairy biped, grunts a lot, leaves no trace like a model boyscout, etc. Same story, different continent.

> Accounts, but a dearth of specimen.

No. We have had credible specimens of giant squid since the 1800s. This isn't in hindsight, they were quickly accepted at the time by the scientific community as credible.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by joshmaker on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:28PM (#6479191)
> We did eventually get bodies, but only fairly recently.

While living giant squid have only been filmed recently, their bodies have been washing ashore and studied for over a hundred years.

>It wasn't really until the 2000's and a live specimen was discovered that it was generally accepted that these things were real.

Not true. Many dead giant squids have been caught in fishing nets or have washed ashore and have been studied by scientists or even put on display in museums for years. Additionally, scars from giant squid suckers are common on certain whales.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_giant_squid_specimens_a...

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by dllthomas on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:36PM (#6478930)
The fact that people all over describe similar things indicates that people have a predisposition to see human-like shapes. Therefore, people seeing human-like shapes is very poor evidence - whereas if the claims were more geographically (or environmentally) localized it would be comparatively likely to be telling us about features of that space (like existence of a creature) rather than features of humans.

Of course, memes cluster as well, so it's not really clean-cut...

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by api on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:44PM (#6478610)
More accurately: there is not enough good-quality evidence vs. the sample size to tip the needle.

If we had very very few observations of Loch Ness -- like say if it was Lake Vostok -- but we had a few Nessie sightings, that would be different. But we have only a few Nessie sightings in a place that's constantly being observed and photographed.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by GhotiFish on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:21PM (#6478836)
I find the position that cryptozooligists never "abandon any discredited evidence" to be unfair. They're talking about a whole demographic here. There are likely to be more reasonable cryptozooloigists that disregard discredited evidence, and would happily admit to hoaxes in this area.

I think the majority would hacker news would be with me if I said that, on the whole, cryptozoologists are a little nutty. You don't need to resort to political smear tactics to say it.

However. You do need to use smear tactics if you want to create outrage. If that was the articles objective... then... good job I guess?

As a side note: squatchers is a great name.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:36PM (#6478929)
> I find the position that cryptozooligists never "abandon any discredited evidence" to be unfair.

Science isn't about what's fair, it's about what the evidence tells us. The fact that, in spite of no evidence whatsoever, Bigfoot stories, books and TV shows have escalated tremendously over the past 20 years, supports the claim you're objecting to.

> There are likely to be more reasonable cryptozooloigists that disregard discredited evidence, and would happily admit to hoaxes in this area.

Those aren't cryptozoologists, at least not gainfully employed ones. It's sort of like psychologists who know talk therapy is a waste of time -- they may still be psychologists, but they're not making a living at psychology.

> You do need to use smear tactics if you want to create outrage.

The article didn't need to use smear tactics, and it didn't use smear tactics -- it used evidence.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by DanBC on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:47PM (#6478992)
> It's sort of like psychologists who know talk therapy is a waste of time -- they may still be psychologists, but they're not making a living at psychology

I know you hold anti psychology views, but some forms of talking therapy are evidence based and are as effective as medication for some mental illnesses. They are quick and achieve good rates of recovery (both amount of recovery, sometimes total, and length of recovery, sometimes many years.)

I'd agree if you'd used the terms "counselling" and "counsellors".

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:08PM (#6479099)
> I know you hold anti psychology views, but some forms of talking therapy are evidence based ...

I said that talk therapy doesn't work. You say it's evidence-based. Both are true -- the evidence shows that talk therapy doesn't work.

> ... and are as effective as medication for some mental illnesses.

Yes, that's also true. Talk therapy doesn't work, and it's as effective as the available medications, which also don't work. Here's just one example:

"New Study: SSRI Antidepressants ‘Clinically Insignificant’ For Most People" http://www.spring.org.uk/2008/02/new-study-ssri-antidepressa...

On that basis, I think we're in agreement. Talk therapy is evidence based, and it is just as effective as many of the available medications.

> They are quick and achieve good rates of recovery ...

Yes, and in controlled studies, so does taking no action, sending the client home untreated, or the application of placebos -- all equally effective.

> I'd agree if you'd used the terms "counselling" and "counsellors".

It's well-established that counsellors, fortunetellers, bartenders, and psychologists have the same effectiveness rates in settings where one of the choices isn't unfairly stigmatized.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by vacri on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:45PM (#6479281)
That is momentously bad science: X doesn't work due to the evidence, and to prove it, here's a paper on a different topic.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:01PM (#6479347)
If you think talk therapy works, the burden of evidence is yours, not mine. The default scientific assumption under these circumstances is that there's no effect, and as it happens, there's no evidence to contradict this assumption, and plenty to support it.

I posted what I did because it's relatively new and unfamiliar to many of psychology's advocates. As to talk therapy, these findings are in some cases decades old, with no change in the outcome.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by PixelPusher on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @08:30PM (#6479939)
Agreed, I actually had some trouble with this sentence:

"Science — psychology in particular..."

Psychology, in itself, is not a science. This diminishes any of his further arguments and not being evidence based.

PS. Sorry was meant for parent comment.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by GhotiFish on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @04:13PM (#6485005)
>Those aren't cryptozoologists

they arn't Scotsmen either.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by wmeredith on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:11PM (#6479114)
Hitting this link on a mobile device redirects you to the home page of their mobile site, not the mobile version of this story. Ugh. When will web masters stop doing this?
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by codezero on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:32PM (#6478542)
I think an interesting analogy here is the idea that there is (or was) life on Mars.

Most assumptions are that there is life on Mars and time is simply whittling away at the probability, rather than, as the article says, assumptions are made that there is no life and probabilities are increased as evidence suggests that there is.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:54PM (#6479030)
> Most assumptions are that there is life on Mars and time is simply whittling away at the probability ...

Certainly not, at least not among scientists. To a scientist, there's nothing up there but sand and thin air, until evidence proves otherwise. Popular reports naturally enough get this scientific, appropriately skeptical outlook completely wrong.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by everettForth on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:20PM (#6478832)
If I don't know what "unlikely" means, Bigfoot is not unlikely?
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by woodchuck64 on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @03:32PM (#6478545)
Note that when you substitute "God" for "Bigfoot" the article works quite well, suggesting that cryptozoology is more of a religion than a science.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by JackFr on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:46PM (#6478988)
I think you're wrong in both premise and conclusion.

"Cryptozoological creatures like [God] are (supposedly) large animals living in large areas, and both have decades of 'evidence' to suggest that we might film one someday—as we did the giant squid."

Nope. Doesn't quite work.

Further, a religion is typically characterized as an organized system of beliefs, rituals and rules used to worship a god or group of gods. Maintaining one particular irrational belief does not a religion make.

(Although I'm sure "What Would Bigfoot Do?" bumper stickers would sell quite well.)

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by woodchuck64 on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:41PM (#6479550)
How about: "Cryptozoological creatures like [God] are (supposedly) [all powerful entities] living [somewhere outside time], and both have decades of 'evidence' to suggest that we might [measure one's effect in some shape or form]—as we did the giant squid."

> Maintaining one particular irrational belief does not a religion make.

According to the article, cryptozoologists have many irrational beliefs, one for each creature.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @06:56PM (#6479622)
You're stretching. Both can be irrational beliefs while not being particularly similar to each other.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by woodchuck64 on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @08:20PM (#6479911)
On the contrary, most irrational beliefs are similar to each other because they all stem from the same neurological modules crafted by evolution. Fallacies that are easily exposed by formal logic often seem correct to people not trained in science. For example, anecdotal evidence is given perverse weight because most of the time, anecdotal evidence is pretty solid evidence for a group of hunter gatherers.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @04:30AM (#6481310)
Oh, I get that. What I am saying is that just because two concepts are irrational does not mean that the language we have constructed to talk about these concepts plays into the shared root cause.

As a concrete example: Tea leave reading and bigfoot sightings are both related to (really, both stemming from) apophenia, but accusing tea leave readers of being basically bigfoot-ologists is a rather... 'clumsy' way of handling the subject matter, for better or worse.

Sometimes it is certainly useful to point out that an underlying phenomenon is the basis for another absurd hypothesis, but that is something that you need to go into with some degree of fineness. If you just jump right into that, you'll be accused of being "rude, and therefore wrong" (illogical, I know...).

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by JackFr on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:06PM (#6483714)
Careful, you're falling into a trap there...

By the same token, your skepticism and rationality are also only neurological modules crafted evolutionary selection. It is not necessary (or even proveable) that those beliefs actually correspond to the true nature of the universe.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by woodchuck64 on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @03:56PM (#6484848)
No trap or problem here (except in the minds of confused religious philosophers). "True nature" is impossible to know, agreed, but rationality is aimed at a much more practical goal: accurately communicating the entirety of shared sensory human experience and abstractions built thereon. Rationality at root entails nothing more grand or mysterious than standing in a forest with another person and agreeing that "this is a tree". Language is born of the need to communicate with another being and logic is born of the need for precision and efficiency in communication.

Natural selection can shape neurological modules for language in order to propagate genes, but after that there is nothing that stops language-using primates from improving and enhancing language, making it work better, building higher and more strictly defined classes of abstractions that eventually form math, logic and science.

As this relates to the original subject, the primary point was that people, cryptozoologists or the religiously devout, were judging correctness by what "seems" correct rather than by rigorous science. What seems correct is the strong influence of certain default neurological modules, absent training. Only with training do people appreciate how misguided one's instincts can be and how much better science is in communicating accurate observations.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by static_typed on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:50PM (#6479008)
It most comes down to the human condition, the need in our psyche for some mystery, things to keep our eyes and mind active, even when occasionally the rational part tends to point out the unlikeliness of the creature or event.

Some like Bigfoot, some Aliens, some Nessie - me personally, I am fond of the tales I was told as a young child of a few remaining dinosaurs in the large remaining land masses, such as Central Africa, and Brazil. Probably unlikely, yet, nice to dream that perhaps, maybe, a few select dinosaurs are at this moment hiding away.