News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by lutusp on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:45PM (#6478971)
> That sounds more like a verificationist idea of science than a Popperian falsification process.

Actually, it's an informal statement of the null hypothesis:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Null_hypothesis

In the null hypothesis, supposedly the basis for all experimental science, you start with the assumption that there is no effect, and let the evidence force you to a different conclusion. In other words, you assume nothing out of the ordinary and take no position on the subject of study.

> Wouldn't it be a much better criticism to say that the cryptozoologists are not scientific because they do not make falsifiable predictions?

Yes, it would, but that's not a very popular definition of science these days. If it were, psychiatrists and psychologists would be immediately excluded -- they make plenty of predictions, but the predictions don't work out.

Re:Why Bigfoot is unlikely only if you know what "unlikely" ... by jlgreco on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @05:47PM (#6479296)
"Yes, it would, but that's not a very popular definition of science these days. If it were, psychiatrists and psychologists would be immediately excluded -- they make plenty of predictions, but the predictions don't work out."

It is a popular definition of science in some circles for exactly that reason. Psychoanalysis in particular is heavily criticized for this.