> Maintaining one particular irrational belief does not a religion make.
According to the article, cryptozoologists have many irrational beliefs, one for each creature.
As a concrete example: Tea leave reading and bigfoot sightings are both related to (really, both stemming from) apophenia, but accusing tea leave readers of being basically bigfoot-ologists is a rather... 'clumsy' way of handling the subject matter, for better or worse.
Sometimes it is certainly useful to point out that an underlying phenomenon is the basis for another absurd hypothesis, but that is something that you need to go into with some degree of fineness. If you just jump right into that, you'll be accused of being "rude, and therefore wrong" (illogical, I know...).
By the same token, your skepticism and rationality are also only neurological modules crafted evolutionary selection. It is not necessary (or even proveable) that those beliefs actually correspond to the true nature of the universe.
Natural selection can shape neurological modules for language in order to propagate genes, but after that there is nothing that stops language-using primates from improving and enhancing language, making it work better, building higher and more strictly defined classes of abstractions that eventually form math, logic and science.
As this relates to the original subject, the primary point was that people, cryptozoologists or the religiously devout, were judging correctness by what "seems" correct rather than by rigorous science. What seems correct is the strong influence of certain default neurological modules, absent training. Only with training do people appreciate how misguided one's instincts can be and how much better science is in communicating accurate observations.
"Cryptozoological creatures like [God] are (supposedly) large animals living in large areas, and both have decades of 'evidence' to suggest that we might film one someday—as we did the giant squid."
Nope. Doesn't quite work.
Further, a religion is typically characterized as an organized system of beliefs, rituals and rules used to worship a god or group of gods. Maintaining one particular irrational belief does not a religion make.
(Although I'm sure "What Would Bigfoot Do?" bumper stickers would sell quite well.)