The only argument that I see is that there is no real explanation for the fact that most abductees describe the same experiences down to extreme details and even if the grey alien figure can be traced to subconcious influenced by media I don't see what could influence abductees to imagine sexual experiments, until a real explanation for this is found I don't think we can dismiss the probability.
Maybe there are no other proofs because they are really good at leaving no traces and probably don't want to provide them yet to avoid panicking the masses, in a world that 88,5% of the population is religious http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations I don't think this will be received too well and they probably understand this.
Not true. Before the current narrative of sexual examination and hybridization became commonplace, it was just as common for 'aliens' to 'abduct people' and tell them stories of the Aryan supermen from Atlantis. You have to account for the similarity in detail being due to the existence of the phenomenon being well known. You also have to account for your own assertion that since it's true that 99.99% percent of reports are either hoaxes or misinterpretation this also calls into question the bulk of those stories attached to alien abduction.
>I don't see what could influence abductees to imagine sexual experiments, until a real explanation for this is found I don't think we can dismiss the probability.
Your need for a "real" explanation assumes there must be a physical reality behind the phenomenon. That doesn't have to be the case.
>Maybe there are no other proofs because they are really good at leaving no traces and probably don't want to provide them yet to avoid panicking the masses, in a world that 88,5% of the population is religious http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations I don't think this will be received too well and they probably understand this.
And maybe there's no other proof because it's fiction. That's the problem for someone arguing your point of view -- your fact is indistinguishable from fiction from an impartial point of view.
But what can explain the phenonemen? Currently there is no explanation for this. You could read some of Jacobs books, he found all kind of patterns, if this is just some collective halucination originating deep in our subconscious then is just as fascinating.
> That's the problem for someone arguing your point of view -- your fact is indistinguishable from fiction from an impartial point of view.
Indeed this is the biggest problem, because of lack of evidence it all looks sf. If the reason for the lack of evidence or encouter is the large percent of relious people or people with limited knowledge about the universe that can't cope with this fact then probably this will not change in our lifetime and we will not live to know if there was lack of evidence or it was all sf and we are alone in the universe or just never been in contact.
https://www.google.com/search?q=rational+explanation+for+ali...
There are explanations aplenty.
I clicked on some links and some of them explain the phenomenon by presenting people that say all kind of conspiracies and are not credible, others have confused it with sleep paralysis and some others cases that make the usual 99.99%. Also sleep paralysis can't be an explantion because as Jacobs says here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_M._Jacobs "in numerous cases people report they were abducted when fully awake and conscious, and that therefore sleep paralysis is not a tenable hypothesis"
So I can say the same thing, where is the undeniable proof that the abduction phenonemon is not real? Because there is no scientific explanation to explains all cases yet. The same thing as in ufo sightins happens, the 0.01% is hard to see from all the hoaxes and disinformation.
This question betrays a very basic failure to understand the basis of science. I suggest you research on your own why I might say this. Research it, and make sure you really comprehend it.
Our science lacks the knowledge or the tools to prove or disprove it, remember what are we dealing with and or science is young and limited.
Science should prove or disprove some phenomena to be sure that is either true or false, otherwise there is still a probability, this is how it works.
If you have a valid scientific proof that the abduction phenomenon is a collective hallucination then you could dismiss the phenomenon, until then this is just unexplained and the probability remains.
No. Absolutely not. This is what I am talking about, a failure to understand what science is on the most basic of levels.
You don't prove a null hypothesis. Expecting proof of a null hypothesis is flat out retarded, you only disprove them. Without accepting null hypothesises until they are disproved, that is to say, without any functional sense of skepticism, you fall down the rabbit hole of believing all sorts of religious, supernatural, and pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo.
Have you disproved leprechauns? Xenu? Have you disproved the notion that I am in fact a god, descended from Mount Olympus on a mission to take out the Reptilian Queen?
Sane, rational, people do not expect these claims to be disproved. They expect them to be proved, and reject them until they are.
I don't have the time anymore to explain in more detail why you are wrong, you simply want to argue without arguments and you are right because you say so and because et contact is silly and of course because you know what science is.
"I would never say, yes, there are aliens taking people. [But] I would say there is a compelling powerful phenomenon here that I can't account for in any other way, that's mysterious. Yet I can't know what it is but it seems to me that it invites a deeper, further inquiry"
First, I don't know that it's necessarily true that "millions" of people have experienced this. But let me offer some evidence that at least to some degree this phenomenon whatever it is doesn't represent objective truth.
There was a point when the majority of UFO sightings comprised of airships and not what we would recognize as spacecraft. It's telling that this occurred at a time when there was no popular archetype of what qualities a spaceship might have to have. The denizens of these craft were described as basically human looking, and some claimed to be from Mars (at a time when the possibility of intelligent life on Mars was commonly accepted as possibility.)
One would expect an alien spacecraft to have some properties which are, well alien but all the descriptions i've seen and heard about don't often describe technology at a level far beyond the understanding of the time. Until it was scientifically proven impossible, many "aliens" appeared to be humans claiming to come from Mars or Venus.
Prior to this, many of the phenomena associated now with alien abduction was associated with demonic possession. There were no spaceships or airships, but plenty of hoary beast-men in the woods and wicked things convincing wizards to swap wives with each other.
My point being, the nature of this phenomenon never seems to rise above or to give information beyond what could be generated in the imagination of a single human being, and it seems to evolve as popular culture evolves. now we have to deal with the post-Lazar post-Roswell Post-Ancient Aliens/X-Files world of self-aware media irony in which it's claimed these aliens are responsible for practically every event and are behind every government and have portals everywhere and secret bases and yet despite the media and camera saturation... still nothing but mythology to account for any of it.
Now you could say the demons were aliens, and the airship captains were just taking on an appearance which we could comprehend. But again, while that makes for an internally consistent narrative, it doesn't really prove anything. The face on mars turned out to be a trick of the light, and i'm sitting here near the end of 2013, and it turns out the Mayans didn't know shit about the future after all.
meanwhile we do know there are such things as hallucinations, and hoaxes, and sleep paralysis, and any number of physiological and psychological phenomena to account for much if not all of the alien abduction scenario. What we don't have is strong, credible, independently verifiable publically credible evidence that aliens are abducting anyone. I'll tell you what it would look like - something undeniable and irrefutably alien. Not stories. Not weird lights someone's brother's cousin once heard someone saw one time. When they crash their saucer into the White House i'll maybe consider it. Until then, it's just faeries in the garden with updated costumes as far as i'm concerned.