News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by dekz on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:02PM (#6396208)
I'd hate to tell you that you're in a bit of a minority buying bluray and using bluray medium. The future isn't physical disks that you lose.

Linux runs my media pc and my media server. Valve have already accomplished full platform support for most of their games, Humble indie bundles require full platform support for their games. Linux versions of most games, isn't some far away dream, it's here.

I'm not sure I fully comprehend your linux 'open-source' only argument. Have you seen ubuntu?

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by rodgerd on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:11PM (#6396994)
> The future isn't physical disks that you lose.

No, it's a Netflix subscription, so when they drop your kids' favourite shows you have fun explaining corporate politics as the reason they can't watch Bob the Builder any more.

> Linux versions of most games, isn't some far away dream, it's here.

Very little of my Steam library is available with Linux versions. Almost none, in fact. This would be the norm for most people, unless you're limiting yourself to games that run on Linux in the first place.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by dekz on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:49PM (#6397120)
> No, it's a Netflix subscription, so when they drop your kids' favourite shows you have fun explaining corporate politics as the reason they can't watch Bob the Builder any more.

Mate, the 'future' you're suggesting here and the related straw man argument is one of your choosing. Netflix or some known current company isn't a future to a medium. I'll assume you're suggesting online streaming as a service as opposed to other potential digital medium schemes. Physical disks provide no advantages in this scenario either, what happens when (not if) this favourite disk becomes scratched and unreadable?

> Very little of my Steam library is available with Linux versions.

Very few of mine don't have Linux versions. This might not be the norm for most people of course, because it's linux that is gaining in the field of gaming platforms over windows. Sure, I can't play the same amount of AAA games as if I ran windows. With the Half-Life engine now running on Linux and many indie games having ports, I don't _need_ to run windows to game.

I'd love to throw in some data, but alas many a site related to numbers are classified as 'games' and blocked on this connection.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by yaeger on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @03:30AM (#6398074)
>what happens when (not if) this favourite disk becomes scratched and unreadable?

Wow, really? I have you know I still own DVDs from 1997! and they work just fine so you might want to dial down the "when not if" argument.

On the flipside, I do have some trouble finding streaming sites that offer their services for that long. Not to mention the fact that these services have recurring payments to use. So excuse me if I and many many others opt to buy our media to own and to be in control of it rather than trusting some company with offering it for god know how little time.

And here is the real kicker: If you own a disk, you have ways to digitize it yourself if you can't be arsed to put a disk in the drive. So it seems to me that I have the better end of the deal compared to someone who just streams everything. Not to mention the fact that not everybody has internet connections that lend itself to stream blu ray quality.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by eirikm on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @04:15AM (#6398180)
>Wow, really? I have you know I still own DVDs from 1997! and they work just fine

I have you know I still own a horse-drawn cart, and the wheels work just fine!

It really is more of a "Where we are going, we wont need wheels" situation. Sure there are some edge cases for physical media today, but they will slowly fade.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by rodgerd on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @06:41PM (#6408658)
> Mate, the 'future' you're suggesting here and the related straw man argument is one of your choosing.

It's a thing that actually happened. I'm sorry facts don't accord with the world in your head, but there you are.

> Very few of mine don't have Linux versions. This might not be the norm for most people of course, because it's linux that is gaining in the field of gaming platforms over windows.

"You shouldn't want to do that" is rarely a compelling argument to customers.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by dekz on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @10:21PM (#6409401)
> It's a thing that actually happened.

Just like HD-DVD is the future? Netflix cannot obviously in the point in time be a future for most citizens on the internet. You may be screaming in an echo chamber if you're located in the US. Netflix certainly isn't a solution elsewhere.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Monday September 16, 2013 @09:39PM (#6397083)
> Very little of my Steam library is available with Linux versions. Almost none, in fact

That probably means you don't play any Indie games. Not sure who is the norm here. Indie Games have been booming in digital distribution, in case you did not notice.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by BSousa on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @03:30AM (#6398076)
Yes, and I love me some indie games, but I'm pretty sure each version of Call of Duty will sell more copies than most (if not all) indie games combined on Steam.

I buy indie games that I already own to support the developers (some of which I know personally), heck, I just bought the Humble Bundle even though only of the games there I didn't have, but Medal of Honor/Call of Duty/Skyrim/Bioshock/GTA are the games most of the players want, not Frozen Synapse or Hotline Miami.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by TheCraiggers on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @09:35AM (#6399143)
You seem to be making the assumption that you'll never see a Call of Duty game on Linux. It wouldn't be the first AAA FPS title to come out for the platform (UT, Quake, etc), and if Valve's console thing sells well enough, they could entice them onto Linux.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by BSousa on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @06:24AM (#6404454)
But you will have a chicken and egg problem. If the steam box sells well, they will port, but except for some early adopters, they won't buy it until the games are ported.

I hope we see more games ported, but having worked in the industry for many years, going the extra lengths to support yet another OS which will most likely be just a small beep in the sales numbers isn't going to happen anytime soon. Heck, look at the franchises that started on the PC (CoD for example) and how the developers still focus more on the console versions then the PC ones.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by jonny_eh on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @11:08AM (#6399709)
I remember that the Windows version of Call of Duty 1 worked perfectly on Linux using WINE.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by rodgerd on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @06:43PM (#6408670)
I have. I play some of them (e.g. Limbo, which is great). I also want to play the Saints Row and Risen series, too.

Unfortunately, the games market as a whole leans more towards the big series, which are much less likely to be cross-platform beyond "several consoles and maybe a PC port."

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by jeffool on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @01:52AM (#6397809)
>No, it's a Netflix subscription, so when they drop your kids' favourite shows you have fun explaining corporate politics as the reason they can't watch Bob the Builder any more.

I suppose this is as good a time to ask as any... Why has UltraViolet not taken off, in anyone's reasonable estimation?

Seems smart to me. I buy a UV film, everyone recognizes my purchase. I buy a film once. I own it. Do I have this wrong? I only own a few, mostly with other purchases, but it seems smart to me, and easy.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by Already__Taken on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @05:05AM (#6398308)
You don't own it. You have a lease until they shut down the ultraviolet service. You've giving control of all rights to the operator of the service. If they don't want you to have subtitles in your language then you don't get them.

It give up so many freedoms I can't wish for ultraviolet to die more.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by wmf on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @04:42PM (#6401820)
I guess UV doesn't offer enough lock-in to its partners. These days if you can't build a Thiel-style "monopoly" you might as well not even bother.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by cgh on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:48PM (#6396396)
Like the OP says, for people serious about audio and video quality, they will buy Blu-ray (or whatever physical media replaces it) for a long time to come. The bandwidth simply isn't there otherwise.

That said, I agree with you that the future is not with physical media - that's very obviously the case. But the future isn't here yet.

> Linux versions of most games, isn't some far away dream, it's here.

That's absurd. There are no AAA titles available on Linux. Newell's prediction might seem more realistic if Ubisoft, Rockstar, etc. jump on board. Maybe it will happen if a viable Linux-based console came around.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by XorNot on Monday September 16, 2013 @08:46PM (#6396898)
I'd say the bandwidth is easily there for Blu-Ray. I can download a 40-80gb file on BitTorrent pretty easily if its well-seeded. What I can't do is legally buy a Blu-Ray, and have it downloaded at Blu-Ray quality to me from any vendor.

Which is absurd because the first thing I do with all my Blu-Rays is rip them losslessly to MKV files on my server.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by gambiting on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @02:31AM (#6397904)
easily? Maybe in some really well-off parts of the world. Blu-Ray bandwidth is between 20-30mbps, and where I live you can't get anything higher than 10mbps, and even that is lucky,the highest option most people can get is 4-6mbps. I purchase all of my films on BluRays - the quality is there, the media is forever mine and not bound to any subscription, I mean I am pretty sure we will get there eventually,but until you can get 100mbps fibre connection to everywhere it's impossible to phase out physical media.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by willvarfar on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @03:51AM (#6398123)
Would it plummet if your neighbours did the same?

Where I am its popular for whole villages to decide to lay fibre and they set up little trusts to do just that and they even get grants from the government. And they have really great speeds, but at some point their bundle of fibres meets a switch.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by jeltz on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:07PM (#6396490)
> There are no AAA titles available on Linux.

Other than the Valve games Linux will soon get Metro: Last Light and Football Manager 2014. Almost no AAA games so far, but it is to be expected that AAA producers are generally slower and more conservative.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by adwf on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:17PM (#6396538)
Not to mention that AAA games take 2-3 years to produce, whereas Steam Linux has been out for only 6 months. There's a lot of inertia to overcome.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Monday September 16, 2013 @08:10PM (#6396776)
Exactly. You cannot expect AAA games to come anytime soon on Linux.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by YokoZar on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @03:07AM (#6398003)
AAA games can be ported from Windows to Linux in a matter of days if they already work well in Wine. When they don't, extending Wine to make them work is vastly cheaper than you probably think.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by Sprint on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @05:04AM (#6398307)
Running in Wine is not porting. It is using a intermediate layer. Porting means native code.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by YokoZar on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @09:47AM (#6399198)
Wine absolutely can be a porting tool; Codeweavers offers porting services using this exact technology: http://www.codeweavers.com/services/

From a technical standpoint, Wine is extended to make the game work, that version of Wine is bundled with the application, and a script is included to run it without further user involvement.

I don't get why people still insist this sort of port somehow doesn't count. If it runs at full speed, shows up as a "Linux game" under Steam, and the user literally can't tell the difference, what does it matter?

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @08:49PM (#6402811)
Limbo did that and its performance was awful. No thank you.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by dllthomas on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @11:56AM (#6400014)
Why does it matter if that compatibility layer sits in a system-wide library or in application code (as anyone would add if writing a program to target multiple kinds of system)? Wine is not an emulator, it's a free re-implementation of the windows API that runs on Linux.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @05:06AM (#6398309)
Using WINE is not porting, it does not run natively, and this is not what Valve recommends to do.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by sergiosgc on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @06:22AM (#6398464)
It does run natively. You don't think it runs in an emulator, do you?
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @08:51PM (#6402818)
You lose a lot of raw performance with wine. Left 4dead ran on wine at probably half the framerate of the windows version. No thank you.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Monday September 16, 2013 @11:30PM (#6397403)
Let's not forget Wargame: European Escalation, which is far from being an indie game. Probably close to a AAA category.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by jeltz on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @06:25AM (#6398472)
Serious Sam 3 is another game which is not exactly AAA but very close to it.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by TsiCClawOfLight on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @09:08AM (#6399032)
I would say the Wargame franchise also counts as AAA. Other than that, you are correct :)
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by ekianjo on Monday September 16, 2013 @08:09PM (#6396771)
People serious about audio and video quality dont run stuff from their all in one pc based player. They have dedicated, high quality bluray player and cd players. And like someone mentioned bluray is not going anywhere for the masses. Too expensive, not practical, in the end convenience trumps all.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by gillianseed on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @02:08AM (#6397854)
>Maybe it will happen if a viable Linux-based console came around.

Eh, isn't that what Valve's Steambox is: a Linux based console?

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by AsymetricCom on Monday September 16, 2013 @08:27PM (#6396839)
I thought bluray was already abandoned. I never see blurays for sell in display ends anymore, Walmart has basically been forced to refocus on third-world-style living in suburban USA.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by jasomill on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @06:41PM (#6402404)
Where are you? They're as available as DVDs at most big-box, media, and electronics retailers in urban and suburban locations across the midwestern US, at least. Wal-Mart, sure, but also Target, Best Buy, Barnes and Noble, Fry's, most independent stores that sell, resell, or rent movies, and Red Box rental kiosks. They're also available from chain drug stores like Walgreens and CVS. Smaller and rural locations tend to have smaller selections, but that's true of most any product type.

Honestly, the only retailers that come immediately to mind selling DVD but not Blu-ray are gas stations and truck stops.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by pjmlp on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @03:28AM (#6398070)
In Europe they are everywhere.

I still use DVD and am starting to have problems, because the new titles at our library are mostly Blueray.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by DigitalJack on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:04PM (#6396476)
I watched a bluray movie last night for the first time and I was shocked. I was so surprised how much higher the definition was vs streamed "hd" content.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by wwweston on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:46PM (#6396670)
I can also definitely detect a significant distinction, but it doesn't feel more "real" to me -- in fact, I experience it as falling into a kind of uncanny valley between video-realistic and near-realistic. Don't much care for it.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by microcolonel on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @01:31AM (#6397761)
A lot of HDTVs have motion interpolation, colour enhancement, and noise reduction; all of which absolutely ruin movies.

I suggest turning these off(In my case, all of them were on by default, and some of them needed to be manually toggled on every start for a month before it magically decided to default correctly).

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by sk5t on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:58AM (#6397660)
Perhaps you watched it on a system with the horrible, high-framerate interpolation switched on? Not everyone is sensitive to 24fps (traditional film) vs. 30fps (looks like Handicam output) and the effects of TV/processor motion enhancement.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by snarfy on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @09:59AM (#6399264)
This is because traditional film cameras had horrible images compared to what your eye can see. This resulted in various techniques such as movie make up and bright lighting.

Now that the camera is much better, all of those compensation techniques are now making the image look fake. The lighting is too bright, the makeup too heavy.

Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by s_baby on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @05:25PM (#6402053)
I'm not convinced that's the whole story. Even old movies converted to digital fall into the uncanny valley. Try watching bluray Godfather for example. Looks staged.
Re:Gabe Newell: Linux is the future of gaming, new hardware ... by jasomill on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @06:48PM (#6402431)
You might want to check the settings on your Blu-ray playback system, because the Godfather Blu-ray is one of the more "filmic" transfers I've seen, preserving the grain of the film print rather than attempting to "clean it up" with digital noise reduction, and it should play back at the original 24fps frame rate on any system that supports it.