He actually fails to create a properly nutritious and tasty diet. And writes about it. And that's without additional constraints, in "easy" mode. I think that's very illustrative.
I've seen quite a few of those comments on HN. I recall one commenter, even, claiming that the obesity problem in the US proved that welfare payments were generous if not over-generous, because "our poor eat like gluttons".
The more evidence against idiotic viewpoints like that which accumulates through experiments like this, the better.
The poor are derided by politicians and the media alike.
However, there has been a growing campaign regarding the 'cost of living crisis'.
Food, shelter, water and transport are beyond the means of too many people. For no good reason. Inflation is not a market effect. It is nations purposefully stealing from the poorest.
(I might be the commenter you are referring to, I certainly take both the positions you've described. I've observed that I get an extremely emotional reaction when I cite statistics on this topic and I'm curious what evidence would be sufficiently persuasive.)
Note that "healthy diet" means more than "enough calories".
"As I said in my initial post, you won't hear me claim that my experiences from the upcoming week represent an authentic representation of food insecurity in America. My goal is merely to help bring awareness to the issue and spark deeper conversations about food insecurity and possible solutions – discussions that organizations like Feeding America are driving every day."
I'm pretty sure he's well aware of all the luxuries he has at his disposal that others who rely on food stamps don't. He's not shooting for an authentic representation because he just can't. Even if he were to give away all of his wealth, he'd still have many luxuries (such as friends and family to look after him) that some folks in dire situations don't.
This isn't to say that there isn't insight to be gained from running this experiment, though.
In Ron's case, you're probably off a couple or three of those bank figgers.
Go start a company and then make some good jobs - pay your customer service people well and you will reap it in.
Well yes, that's pretty much the definition of news: reporting uncommon events. "You never read about a plane that did not crash".
Science 30 August 2013: Vol. 341 no. 6149 pp. 976-980 DOI: 10.1126/science.1238041 Poverty Impedes Cognitive Function
I just don't understand the rationale behind this. It's not like there is a big misunderstanding about the poor living an awesome life. What's missing is the slightest shred of empathy for them.