News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by codeka on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:39AM (#6385294)
> the stated motivation for this design is to reduce electrical waste. The best way to do that in the short term is to ensure devices are more repairable

Right, a replaceable screen and battery and an SD card slot would get you 99% of the features you'd actually want from phonebloks, and it's actually something that would be achievable (if there were demand, which I think is the biggest problem here: there's just no demand for this from the majority of consumers)

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by mxfh on Saturday September 14, 2013 @09:31AM (#6385499)
A replaceable battery, SD card and easily replaceable screens were all features of phones available more than 5 years ago, yet these features disappeared because the iPhone showed that most consumers don't value those features over a sleek integrated lifestyle product.

Besides all points mentioned already, I just can't think of a way to protect the pin-connection from wear in daily use without adding an additional shell or individual screws, which would make it even more bulky. Simply haven't seen a single miniature socket yet that works well under constant external stress.

Regarding the proposed design, with all it's sharp edges and deep ridges I'm already looking forward to weekly lint removal sessions.

In terms of total energy waste it might be worth considering that there's not only one logistic process anymore but a mere 5 to 10(?) with each has it's own packaging, transportation and handling footprint. So it's debatable that the total environmental impact might be actually worse than that of a 2 year life cycle smartphone.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by 001sky on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:19AM (#6385825)
iPhone showed that most consumers don't value those features over a sleek integrated lifestyle product.

Consumers have no acess to bid on the incremental value of features. There is no supply side market for these. There is no market because apple is playing monopolist (legal). Lets not use sloppy language !!

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by ant512 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @12:53PM (#6386196)
> Consumers have no acess to bid on the incremental value of features.

They could have kept buying Nokia 3310s instead of iPhones if they thought that a replaceable battery was more important than everything else they got with the Apple product. People made the same argument about physical keyboards, and look at what happened to RIM.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by thedufer on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:40PM (#6388045)
The fact that the Droid line sells despite it being basically a keyboard bolted onto a 2-3 year old phone shows that there is a market there. RIMs problem was one of software - only Android and iOS smartphones are really doing well these days, since nothing else has the app ecosystem.

Which comes back to the incremental value of features thing.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by cowsandmilk on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:39AM (#6385900)
> apple is playing monopolist

what? how does apple have a monopoly?

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by AnthonyMouse on Saturday September 14, 2013 @12:26PM (#6386095)
You're going down the road into a philosophical argument. Defining a monopoly requires you to define a market, which is a huge can of worms. If you make the market "computing devices" then nobody has a monopoly. If you make the market "Win32 API PCs" then Microsoft has a monopoly. If you make the market "devices that run iOS apps" then Apple has a monopoly. And so on.

The larger point is that consumer choice isn't there. You can't get an iOS device with a removable battery. That doesn't prove that current Apple customers don't want a removable battery, it just proves they value some other characteristics more, and the market may not be offering any single product that satisfies their optimal set of preferences.

When that happens it means there is room for a newcomer to disrupt the market. If someone started selling iPhones (or something sufficiently equivalent) with removable batteries, some people would buy them -- if only because it would double the resale value since the phone wouldn't become landfill after the non-replaceable battery goes flat.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by mason240 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @12:19PM (#6386060)
>There is no market because apple is playing monopolist (legal). Lets not use sloppy language !!

Are you going for satire?

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by 001sky on Saturday September 14, 2013 @12:49PM (#6386181)
Patents and trademarks are legal monopolies. Because of these protections, there are no non-apple "iphones". As a result, there are no ipohones with features not offered by apple. There are no a-la-carte prices for the features discussed. plain and simple. nothing nefarious, its their right by law. that being said, you cant infer/measure market values in non-existent markets. that's what the previous poster was trying to do.
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by felipeerias on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:52PM (#6386846)
Small, affordable, easy to repair. Pick two.

If you disagree about the "affordable" part, I invite you to estimate the cost of an iPhone that had replaceable parts, while maintaining the performance, battery life and size of the current, integrated one (if such a device is even technically doable).

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by mxfh on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:26PM (#6387122)
Lumia 820 anyone? Selling close to just 200 EUR, replaceable battery, SD-card slot and a replaceable cover with optional wireless charging as a bonus. It's still a WP but it's doable.
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by LaGrange on Sunday September 15, 2013 @06:05AM (#6388609)
> yet these features disappeared because the iPhone showed that most consumers don't value those features over a sleek integrated lifestyle product.

Actually, at the time when the shift to non-replaceable battery happened the alternatives had significantly worse software, which easily overtook any benefit from a replaceable battery, but also means that it means little in terms of estimated consumer expectations for a single hardware feature.

To get actual information we would need Apple to produce a device that's pretty much identical to the iPhone with the only differences being whatever's necessary to achieve battery replaceability.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by mabhatter on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:09AM (#6385583)
Except manufacturing and cost considerations go exactly the other way. An iPhone 5S entire electronics that make it go is slightly smaller an an average stick of gum.... That's all the "modules" except screen and battery. It's made in one shot my high-speed machines that took about 30 seconds from bare board to operating phone parts.. Parts are so small you'd need a magnifying glass to handle them by hand.

The current situatuion is about as good as it gets. There are enough iPhones sold third parties can copy parts or simply canibalize broken ones for repairs. Apple only updates models once a year, so that means there is lots of effort by third parties because their efforts pay off a whole 3 years of repairs. Fixing individual boards takes $1000+ of lab equipment and 2x what the part is worth for labor.

Even Apple's MacBooks only have one main board that's small as possible. That's why Apple started using REAL glass screens, and metal bodies that can be pealed down for their bare scrap costs. To get the ELECTRONICS metals back is going to require some kind of furnace that can contain toxic fumes and perform exotic metals separation. Even then 3/4 of electronic waste is pastic and F4 circuit board material which is utterly useless except to burn off. That leaves 2/3 of at waste as dirt cheap tin-lead solder and a small bit of super fancy alloys.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by JoelSutherland on Saturday September 14, 2013 @09:09AM (#6385458)
Plus encasing every component in its own plastic capsule with high quality metal interconnects won't exactly save materials.
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by DanBC on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:07AM (#6385331)
> > the stated motivation for this design is to reduce electrical waste. The best way to do that in the short term is to ensure devices are more repairable

> (if there were demand, which I think is the biggest problem here: there's just no demand for this from the majority of consumers)

I'm old enough to remember people treating their phone less carefully towards the end of the contract, so that they "had the excuse" to upgrade to a better phone when they got a ew contract, and not just keep the same phone on a cheaper contract.

So, repairability is good, but WEEE is also important. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_Electrical_and_Electroni...)

Luckily phones contain comparatively large amounts of gold so they're desirable for recyclers. It'd be great if all the other rare earth minerals etc could be recycled too.

It's great that there's a lot of aluminium cases being used, if that's creating a market for recycled aluminum. Not so great if new ore is being mined for it.

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by snogglethorpe on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:12PM (#6391033)
Do iPhones represent a significant use of aluminum?

You'd think that pedestrian everyday uses like beer cans would use many many orders of magnitude more aluminum...

Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by jt86 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @01:35PM (#6386342)
It's difficult to express demand for something that doesn't exist.
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by archagon on Saturday September 14, 2013 @12:47PM (#6386177)
Another option is to ensure that most of your phone can be recycled: http://www.apple.com/recycling/
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by telephonetemp on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:31AM (#6385380)
Could you standardize how screens are connected?
Re:Why Phonebloks Will Never Happen by Kliment on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:28AM (#6385636)
The actual communications protocol is already standardized, so it's more a matter of connectors and form factor.