News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by anon1385 on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:19AM (#6359802)
>We need an army of software developers on the look out for potential NSA back doors — to borrow a phrase, if you see something, say something. And if you can't see anything because you can't get the source code... well, who knows that they might hiding?

Of course this rules out all 'cloud' software other than simple dumb data storage. RMS was right again[1].

[1] "Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder Richard Stallman" http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2008/sep/29/cloud.comp...

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:29AM (#6359858)
I never liked the "cloud" from the start. To me it was simply dumb terminals all over again, which had the potential to shift everything to a server which was not mine. Security was an issue, but also it meant being reliant on the connection and service being up and running. In my experience, web sites were down more often than my desk top. And that's just on a personal level. Why a business would do such a thing was even more beyond me. Personal or business owned clouds for limited scope use, fine. But handing all that control over to a 3rd parts, over the net, in a foreign country? I see the marketed advantages, useful as a throwaway extra, but over all? No way.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by davidw on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:32AM (#6359877)
> Why a business would do such a thing was even more beyond me.

Mostly the same reason they rely on third party infrastructure like electricity and plumbing: economics.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by belorn on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:52AM (#6359982)
Both electricity and plumbing has immense regulations, and historical perspective of being neutral and non-threatening to businesses.

Cloud services has none of that, and can cut off service for any reason. Work on any competing services that "the company" dislike, or do anything disruptive to people in power, and instant see your future, your business, you speech be taken down to a 404 not found. Any logs, any files, any property at all confiscated. Even pure money is not safe from "indefinite suspension of the account".

Maybe this is a lesson that if you ever want to legally produce a scam, steal, or do anything that normally would land you in jail, all you need to do is go into producing third-party digital infrastructure. There is basically nothing a cloud service can do that would lend the owners to go to jail except tax evasion.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by saosebastiao on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:15AM (#6360127)
The regulation has to do with the fact that plumbing and electricity are Natural Monopolies. If they were not Natural Monopolies, they would have competition (as Cloud providers do), which acts as a form of regulation.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by shiven on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:26AM (#6360178)
That is not regulation, merely threat of competition. And competition is moot if all the servers are accessible to the "bad guys", in this case, NSA. Unless, you mean to tell me there is a viable alternative to AWS that is located in Switzerland?
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by pyre on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:03AM (#6360419)
Right, because it's not like the US government has been able to pressure the Swiss banks into giving up the historically famous anonymity of their clients! Oh wait...
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by shiven on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:35PM (#6361136)
Alrighty then, pick another country FWIW. Germany, Iceland, wherever. Still doesn't change the point I'm making.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by res0nat0r on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6361172)
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @01:03PM (#6361336)
Apples and pears.

There was not a time when the mass population had their own generators, then flocked to supplied electricity in preference. They never had power independence.

Water was originally done locally, rivers and what not, but hygiene and health became a game changer. The benefits were huge and clear.

The whole history of all three are so different, you cant reasonably compare any of them.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by anigbrowl on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @02:48PM (#6362297)
The benefits of outsourcing your computing infrastructure are also huge and clear, as are the benefits of sharing your personal information. That's why so many people do it, and will continue to do so.

In-house computing infrastructure is very expensive and most firms have their comparative advantage in doing Something Else, so it makes much more economic sense to run on AWS or somesuch instead of buying a pile of physical machines and running their own server farm. Likewise, many web and mobile services provide huge benefits for their users via network effects. I personally don't enjoy using Facebook enough to maintain an active account, but many millions of people clearly do, and I can't say they're wrong for choosing to spend their time that way.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by davidw on Thursday September 12, 2013 @10:18AM (#6374144)
You wanted to know the reason why companies choose cloud computing, and I answered. Computing power is - no - not exactly like other things like electricity and water, but it's headed that way for certain types of applications.

What hosting solution(s) your own company use?

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by speeder on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:40AM (#6359925)
In the company where I work, everything but the IDE is in cloud...

We use Google Apps, Trello, Wave (for accounting), Corona SDK (that builds in Corona cloud servers), Google Drive (previously was Dropbox), Google Docs (we never used any office here, MS, Libre, or anything else), and so on...

I am personally against it, but the CEO decided it that way because he did not wanted to bother about IT infrastructure, we are not big enough yet to bother about it, cloud stuff make things much easier.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:14AM (#6360493)
Yeah, sure, until some numpty digs up your internet connection cable. Cheaper, I can vaguely accept, but "easier" to me means "lazy". Nothing good comes from easy. But, yes, in reality, I can see how CEO types would be sold on the cloud. I just think its potentially misguided.

BTW, IT infrastructure? You are all networked, right? So, whats left? One large ish server? Hardly my idea of "infrastructure", which to me implies something a bit more large and diverse. IMHO, being networked for the internet means you already have infrastructure, ish!!!

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by speeder on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:59PM (#6361311)
Right now our office has two workstations, two desks, two chairs, a water filter (not cooler, only a filter, made of clay), paper, pens, two potted plants, and of course, all relevant cables.

We don't even have a place to put a server... We already freak out enough fearing people will steal the workstations and test devices! (we are in Brazil, last year there was 20 mass robberies, 90 cops executed, several random murders, and 3 different incidents resulted into homeowners ending in hospital after being shot with military-grade rifles in common robberies)

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by bdunbar on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @02:50PM (#6362316)
> Yeah, sure, until some numpty digs up your internet connection cable.

My last employer was not into 'the cloud'. Just a smart manufacturing company, with sites in five countries, two data centers, one on each continent.

Which would die in about a day without the internet.

Each site could chug along for a while, but without the bits flowing in, and out, coordination gets out of whack and after about three workshifts they'd have no idea what to work on next.

Cloud or not, if the internet goes so goes the business.

That or they'd ask us to re-install those doggone fax servers we retired in 2007.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by PeterisP on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @04:10PM (#6363062)
What do you do if some numpty digs up the power cable to your HQ+server site? You can put the servers on generators, but in most companies users still couldn't use them as their office gear would be offline.

In any case, if your servers are running but you can't connect to your suppliers and customers - you might as well turn them off, your business likely can't function without connectivity even if you avoid the cloud completely; so avoiding cloud doesn't decrease your risks much.

Just buy two or more redundant, reasonably different internet channels - and then prolonged loss of connection is no more common as other major downtime risks such as flooding, fires, etc.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by tommi on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:27AM (#6360188)
So, you're not using https://c9.io/ yet? ;) Are there any other tools that could fit the description of cloud IDE?
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by cperciva on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:24AM (#6359832)
Cloud software is fine as long as you don't need to trust it. I use Google Calendar, for example, because it's convenient and I really don't care if the NSA knows when my next dentist appointment is.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:32AM (#6359871)
No, but the NSA might care about your movements, who you know, who you deal with, and so on.

Remember that video that was posted of a Lawyer given a talk to law students about never speaking to policemen? Remember how innocent things can be completely twisted and used against you?

Yeah, I'd worry about the NSA snooping in my calendar.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by ihsw on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:54AM (#6360002)
This cannot be understated, especially when it's not just the NSA snooping -- it's the entirety of the US Government. The DEA and the IRS revelations about using NSA-sourced information are just the tip of the iceberg, and it should be clear and obvious that there are use-cases for this data in a variety of other areas.

Unless the government puts explicit restrictions (not secret restrictions!) on how their resources (not just stored data!) can be used and actively punishes those using it improperly, then it should be assumed that all the resources at the NSA's disposal will be used for the convenience of the rest of the government.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by tedunangst on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:13AM (#6360115)
How do you know the NSA isn't snooping on your dentist's calendar?
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:59AM (#6360397)
Well, we dont. And if they are, that's data connections. Maybe the dentist is connected to some one scary, a client. Now "you" are connected to some one scary. That's a terror network...
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by mpyne on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @04:45PM (#6363351)
Even in the braindead idiocy of government, which I can confirm from firsthand experience, that would not constitute a "terror network".
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by girvo on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:54PM (#6364978)
I'm personally more frightened about someone like the IRS being handed data from the NSA, than the NSA thinking I'm a terrorist, and I pay my taxes and everything. I'm just frightened about being nailed for any tiny mistakes that I have made in the past, that this data capture could glean, if that makes sense?

FWIW, I'm not even from or in the US of A, but I'm worried about my government doing something exactly like that considering how much it's cooperated with the NSA directly in the past and present.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by jacques_chester on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @08:17PM (#6364569)
The problem is that connections like these occur purely by chance. When you multiply the events together you get a low probability ... but there are hundreds of millions of Americans. There will be a lot of false positives.

And how will they be treated? It seems: poorly.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by tommis on Wednesday September 11, 2013 @05:19AM (#6366227)
ah, but it's plausible cperciva is connected to a suspected terrorist and might be using the magazine stand in the dentists waiting room for dead drops..
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by beachstartup on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:03AM (#6360055)
the sad truth of the matter is it's a cultural thing, not a technology thing.

sharing your calendar can be twisted against you.

not sharing your calendar can also be twisted against you ("you don't seem to be sharing your calendar like most of your fellow citizens, what are you hiding?")

see: mccarthyism.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:05AM (#6360431)
Yeah, indeed. I remember some thing posted here a while ago about about a prospective employer assuming something is wrong with a candidate with out a facebook profile for the prospective employer to snoop over prior to hiring.

Perhaps we should exercise our little grey cells more. Granted for a busy sales man or something that's impractical, but Im sure we could generally commit more exclusively to memory..

I posted this before, but to repeat... I think the legacy here is that we move more and more as a matter of habit or routine to a more secure way of living. No, we cant ever fully insulate ourselves from the NSA, but I think more and more of us will commit less to the internet, choose HTTPS via automatic extensions, use more secure software as a default, self censor, and so on.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by anonymfus on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:43AM (#6359945)
It's very convenient for NSA to know your next dentist appointment because they can search your home at that time. Or install/remove bugs.

BTW it's a major trope in spy movies. Literally dentist appointment in "The Tall Blond Man with One Black Shoe" ("Le Grand Blond avec une chaussure noire").

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by eliasmacpherson on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:26AM (#6359844)
They might care when everyone's birthdays are though.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by zrail on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:30AM (#6359864)
That information is already in many, many places. In particular, if you have a passport or drivers license it's already available to the government.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by derefr on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:52AM (#6359984)
In fact, practically, your birth date is only your birth date inasmuch as the government believes that that's the date it is. If a nurse in the pregnancy ward makes a typo, and that's what gets submitted to the government, then that's your birth date, and no arguing.

(I say this from a position somewhere in-between: I was born in British Columbia, and my birth date is right on my birth certificate, but wrong on the public-health-plan card you also get issued at birth. I had a very strange time bootstrapping my first credit card...)

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by maxerickson on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @04:47PM (#6363375)
I like the linguistic ambiguity here. Of course, you are talking about a legal birth date and how in practice that is what matters, but really, what the government thinks has no bearing on your actual birth date.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by aestra on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:02AM (#6360049)
@derefr, my sister had a similar thing happen. In the public records department someone possibly mistook a 7 for a 1 and my sister's original birth certificate got issued with the wrong date and was filed wrong. When my parents called about the error, they issued a new one, but never requested the old one back. She has two official birth certificates with two different birth dates. I'm not sure which one the government believes is "correct" but she's been using her real birthday birth certificate on all documents (drivers license, passport...) since.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by girvo on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:59PM (#6364989)
I have a birth certificate with a different last name, as my Dad adopted me (natural father and mother, got married a year later, born with mum's name but now have dad's once I turned about 1.5yrs). I even am pretty certain I have a second birth certificate with mt dad's name, but I'm not certain.

I also have my adoption papers, and I left the country I was born in when I was young (7 years). As far as the country I live in is concerned I'm my Father's last name, but have legitimate primary ID with my mother's pre marriage last name.

Always wanted to get my spy on and build up a second identity with that. Of course that's highly illegal, so itw only ever been a fun thought exercise :)

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by TsiCClawOfLight on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:13AM (#6360112)
Did you read "The silicon jungle"? You Should. Holds for all of you, btw.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by Zigurd on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:36AM (#6359898)
There are a lot of places the "cloud" can be zero-knowledge for payloads in storage, email, and real time communications, but most services are not set up that way, and they would have to charge a subscription fee to replace their ad revenue.

It is possible to make cloud services where trust is not needed. It remains to be seen if cloud services will have to change to remain in business.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by derefr on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:54AM (#6359993)
People say email can be zero-knowledge, but I'm not quite sure--ever since Gmail pushed us from organizing everything into folders, to one giant Archive + labels, I find server-side search to be an essential attribute of my email service. I don't want to pull my entire mail history down onto my phone just to find one message; even the index would be ridiculous.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by Fargren on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:59AM (#6360021)
But the server-side could be a desktop computer at your house instead of Google's servers. Seems harder for the NSA to access
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by cmdkeen on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:53AM (#6360344)
For those with the wherewithal to run their own server both in terms of hardware and software along with secure backup policies. The likelihood of be compromised through missing a security patch or poor configuration is almost certainly massively higher than anything like this.

But then where do you get the software for said server? Or your mobile client? We're back to the age old question of how do you trust the compiler? How do you trust the source code?

There's a reason that Governments that take security seriously have their own, private, WAN infrastructure that has gateway upon gateway before it reaches the internet, if it ever does.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by navait on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:37AM (#6360243)
That sounds like a lot of work. You have to set up the server, get a domain, update it, back it up etc; What do you get out of it? An email server. Google will give you all of that in a few seconds. Google's uptime is way better than what I could hope to get.

When my laptop had water spilled on it, there was no need to worry about my thesis. I went to a lab and started working on it again 10 minutes later. No work lost. My own backup solutions would be far worse, and likley involve losing some work.

When using these services, I have to ask myself, how much do I value my privacy? I think I get more from google's services than I lose. For me, and a lot of people, it's not worth the time to set up an email server, let alone maintain one.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by gyepi on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:35AM (#6360639)
Yes, for some people, it's too much work. However, there are many for whom it would not be at all. I have always run my own servers both for personal and business use and I don't find it the least bit onerous. Honestly, I think it only seems like too much work until one learns more about it. Just like anything else, I suppose.

I'm not trying to change your mind; not everyone is meant to run their own systems. But I certainly want to counter your discouragement against doing so.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by PeterisP on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @05:39PM (#6363697)
It means that my mail archive (which is very useful to me) either (A) is vulnerable to risks such as theft/fire/flood that are orders of magnitude more likely than google losing my data; or (B) will cost me effort to make and maintain proper regular offsite backups, which is a rather significant chore that I'd want to outsource anyway to someone else.

Heck. I really could host everything at home but the mere thought of the periodic hassle when some hardware or software inevitably breaks... I'd rather simply send all my email archive to NSA, KGB and Chinese gov't, the hassle is really not worth it (for me).

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by bcoates on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @06:19PM (#6363955)
The home search server would just be a cache, presumably the authoritative mailbox would be on an encrypted cloud service. Disaster recovery would consist of replacing the appliance and reauthenticating it.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by Zigurd on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:49AM (#6360737)
It would be hard to trust a Web client, never mind implementing folders etc in anything but a desktop client. There really isn't any way to make the semantics of encrypted email identical to Webmail that is sent and stored in the clear.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by pyre on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:01AM (#6360403)
> Of course this rules out all 'cloud' software other than simple dumb data storage.

This is pretty much the conclusion that I've come to as well. Using cloud storage to keep thing in sync, but only doing decryption on the client. Even doing something like storing a SQLite database and encrypting all of the fields seems like it would be leaking information rather than just encrypting/syncing the entire database.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by devx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:53AM (#6359987)
I wonder if stuff like this could help, but it could be years away from deployment anyway (and that's if the companies are even willing to do it - so all the more reason to avoid current cloud services):

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/09/10/boffins_propose_more...