News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:29AM (#6359858)
I never liked the "cloud" from the start. To me it was simply dumb terminals all over again, which had the potential to shift everything to a server which was not mine. Security was an issue, but also it meant being reliant on the connection and service being up and running. In my experience, web sites were down more often than my desk top. And that's just on a personal level. Why a business would do such a thing was even more beyond me. Personal or business owned clouds for limited scope use, fine. But handing all that control over to a 3rd parts, over the net, in a foreign country? I see the marketed advantages, useful as a throwaway extra, but over all? No way.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by davidw on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:32AM (#6359877)
> Why a business would do such a thing was even more beyond me.

Mostly the same reason they rely on third party infrastructure like electricity and plumbing: economics.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by belorn on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:52AM (#6359982)
Both electricity and plumbing has immense regulations, and historical perspective of being neutral and non-threatening to businesses.

Cloud services has none of that, and can cut off service for any reason. Work on any competing services that "the company" dislike, or do anything disruptive to people in power, and instant see your future, your business, you speech be taken down to a 404 not found. Any logs, any files, any property at all confiscated. Even pure money is not safe from "indefinite suspension of the account".

Maybe this is a lesson that if you ever want to legally produce a scam, steal, or do anything that normally would land you in jail, all you need to do is go into producing third-party digital infrastructure. There is basically nothing a cloud service can do that would lend the owners to go to jail except tax evasion.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by saosebastiao on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:15AM (#6360127)
The regulation has to do with the fact that plumbing and electricity are Natural Monopolies. If they were not Natural Monopolies, they would have competition (as Cloud providers do), which acts as a form of regulation.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by shiven on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:26AM (#6360178)
That is not regulation, merely threat of competition. And competition is moot if all the servers are accessible to the "bad guys", in this case, NSA. Unless, you mean to tell me there is a viable alternative to AWS that is located in Switzerland?
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by pyre on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:03AM (#6360419)
Right, because it's not like the US government has been able to pressure the Swiss banks into giving up the historically famous anonymity of their clients! Oh wait...
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by shiven on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:35PM (#6361136)
Alrighty then, pick another country FWIW. Germany, Iceland, wherever. Still doesn't change the point I'm making.
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by res0nat0r on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6361172)
Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @01:03PM (#6361336)
Apples and pears.

There was not a time when the mass population had their own generators, then flocked to supplied electricity in preference. They never had power independence.

Water was originally done locally, rivers and what not, but hygiene and health became a game changer. The benefits were huge and clear.

The whole history of all three are so different, you cant reasonably compare any of them.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by anigbrowl on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @02:48PM (#6362297)
The benefits of outsourcing your computing infrastructure are also huge and clear, as are the benefits of sharing your personal information. That's why so many people do it, and will continue to do so.

In-house computing infrastructure is very expensive and most firms have their comparative advantage in doing Something Else, so it makes much more economic sense to run on AWS or somesuch instead of buying a pile of physical machines and running their own server farm. Likewise, many web and mobile services provide huge benefits for their users via network effects. I personally don't enjoy using Facebook enough to maintain an active account, but many millions of people clearly do, and I can't say they're wrong for choosing to spend their time that way.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by davidw on Thursday September 12, 2013 @10:18AM (#6374144)
You wanted to know the reason why companies choose cloud computing, and I answered. Computing power is - no - not exactly like other things like electricity and water, but it's headed that way for certain types of applications.

What hosting solution(s) your own company use?

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by speeder on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @09:40AM (#6359925)
In the company where I work, everything but the IDE is in cloud...

We use Google Apps, Trello, Wave (for accounting), Corona SDK (that builds in Corona cloud servers), Google Drive (previously was Dropbox), Google Docs (we never used any office here, MS, Libre, or anything else), and so on...

I am personally against it, but the CEO decided it that way because he did not wanted to bother about IT infrastructure, we are not big enough yet to bother about it, cloud stuff make things much easier.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by alan_cx on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @11:14AM (#6360493)
Yeah, sure, until some numpty digs up your internet connection cable. Cheaper, I can vaguely accept, but "easier" to me means "lazy". Nothing good comes from easy. But, yes, in reality, I can see how CEO types would be sold on the cloud. I just think its potentially misguided.

BTW, IT infrastructure? You are all networked, right? So, whats left? One large ish server? Hardly my idea of "infrastructure", which to me implies something a bit more large and diverse. IMHO, being networked for the internet means you already have infrastructure, ish!!!

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by speeder on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @12:59PM (#6361311)
Right now our office has two workstations, two desks, two chairs, a water filter (not cooler, only a filter, made of clay), paper, pens, two potted plants, and of course, all relevant cables.

We don't even have a place to put a server... We already freak out enough fearing people will steal the workstations and test devices! (we are in Brazil, last year there was 20 mass robberies, 90 cops executed, several random murders, and 3 different incidents resulted into homeowners ending in hospital after being shot with military-grade rifles in common robberies)

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by bdunbar on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @02:50PM (#6362316)
> Yeah, sure, until some numpty digs up your internet connection cable.

My last employer was not into 'the cloud'. Just a smart manufacturing company, with sites in five countries, two data centers, one on each continent.

Which would die in about a day without the internet.

Each site could chug along for a while, but without the bits flowing in, and out, coordination gets out of whack and after about three workshifts they'd have no idea what to work on next.

Cloud or not, if the internet goes so goes the business.

That or they'd ask us to re-install those doggone fax servers we retired in 2007.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by PeterisP on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @04:10PM (#6363062)
What do you do if some numpty digs up the power cable to your HQ+server site? You can put the servers on generators, but in most companies users still couldn't use them as their office gear would be offline.

In any case, if your servers are running but you can't connect to your suppliers and customers - you might as well turn them off, your business likely can't function without connectivity even if you avoid the cloud completely; so avoiding cloud doesn't decrease your risks much.

Just buy two or more redundant, reasonably different internet channels - and then prolonged loss of connection is no more common as other major downtime risks such as flooding, fires, etc.

Re:Don't trust me: I might be a spook by tommi on Tuesday September 10, 2013 @10:27AM (#6360188)
So, you're not using https://c9.io/ yet? ;) Are there any other tools that could fit the description of cloud IDE?