News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by nohuck13 on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:45AM (#6339651)
Am I the only on that thinks this is a bit of an overreach? Seems to me, good justifications for legislating would be

-If customers were being tricked into paying roaming charges in nefarious ways;

-If there were serious externalities somehow not being included in the roaming charge transaction

-If there were monopolistic / market manipulating behaviour going on.

-If the companies were subject to a tragedy-of-the-commons situation where private resolution was not feasible (they're not- the public broadcast spectrum is both rival and excludable in practice).

Instead, the state interest according to Kroes is that it's an "irritant." This kind of top-down control seems a bit counter to the hacker/startup ethos.

Edit: if you're going to down vote, please can you comment and have a dialogue?

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by marceldegraaf on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:00AM (#6339713)
I didn't downvote but would like to comment either way. I think this is exactly something the EU should be doing. The EU is largely about breaking the borders between all these smaller countries and making trade and travel between these countries easier for EU members. Although the ease of trade and travel have certainly improved massively (no more need for passport controls, one currency for the Union), I think these mobile roaming costs are actually quite a big problem.

In the current situation, as a customer, when I'm on holiday in another EU country I have three options for using my iPhone on the go:

1) Shelling out for roaming costs, which are expensive, extremely untransparent, and seem very arbitrary. What are these costs for? Who determines what the right price is? 2) Buying a SIM-card in the country of my destination, which is cheaper but also prevents me from using my own phone number while abroad 3) Not using mobile data at all and hoping for free WiFi at my hotel or in the nearest village (which is what I do)

Removing roaming costs altogether means I can freely drive to France for a two-week holiday and use Google Maps or check my email on my iPhone, all within my normal data bundle, without the risk of getting a bill of a few hundred Euro.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by masklinn on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:51AM (#6339675)
> Am I the only on that thinks this is a bit of an overreach?

Not a all. Vodafone, Telefonica and Orange completely agree with you.

> Instead, the state interest according to Kroes is that it's an "irritant."

The state interest is the people's interest. Roaming charges are not in the user's interest:

1. It's very easy to be hit by roaming charges in Europe if you're not careful, many countries can be gone through in an hour or three and since Schengen moving across borders has become an habitual past-time.

2. The charges are not fair and not about costs these days, they're about free money, notice how the operators which have issues with that are present or have partnerships in pretty much all of the EU? A roaming user doesn't cost them much, but it earns them a lot.

3. Roaming charges are especially problematic with modern "always connected" smartphones, forgetting to disable data roaming (if you can even do so) is common, and the charges for data roaming are completely crazy.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by rmc on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:00AM (#6339711)
If you live near a border, and the 'foreign' network mast is closer than your 'national' one, and has a stronger signal, you might be 'roaming' while at home.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by mcv on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:18AM (#6339783)
That should definitely be illegal.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by masklinn on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:25AM (#6339808)
Sadly electromagnetic waves are not very handy at lawbooks.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by mcv on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:36AM (#6340326)
That's why you don't tackle this at the electromagnetic wave level, you tackle it at the operator level. Or maybe at the phone level. Shouldn't the phone be able to recognize and prefer a local cell over a foreign one?

I mean, why does my phone prefer the crappy network that I have my crappy subscription with over the much stronger networks of the competitors? Why would this stop working when I'm near the border?

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by rsynnott on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:28AM (#6340047)
A phone can discriminate towards low signal strength cells of network A vs high strength cells of network B. Of course, the key word is 'can'; due to a lack of standardisation this will often fail to work properly for particular models.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by mavhc on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:18AM (#6339998)
The universe cares little for your beliefs, and even less for your laws
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by Kliment on Friday September 06, 2013 @10:34AM (#6340618)
Friend of mine lives 400m from a border. He has to call his cell provider monthly to contest the roaming charges he gets charged every month for using his phone at home. So far they've removed them every time.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by mason240 on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:20AM (#6340007)
>Not a all. Vodafone, Telefonica and Orange completely agree with you.

Of course they do, they already have near continental wireless coverage. The small carriers don't.

This would obviously lead to no more roaming at all, which run the small carriers out of business and creates a huge barrier for entry to new carriers (as the would need a huge network before even launching your service).

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by rsynnott on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:27AM (#6340039)
Current regulations already cap wholesale (telco to telco) roaming pricing, and new regulation should improve this.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by aestra on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:25AM (#6340289)
No they wouldn't. They would pay the same roaming rate as everyone else does.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_roaming_regulati...

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by Jacqued on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:02AM (#6339723)
To me the ineptness of the practice seems to be reason enough.

For anyone who travels, it really is a hassle in 2013 to have to put everything digital in your life on hold and stop relying on your smartphone just because you are moving around inside of Europe.

Given how small the oligopoly of those companies is, and how they charge roaming fees even when you are still using their own network (only it's another subsidiary in another country), roaming fees seems to me like a case of distorted competition.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by solistice on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:04AM (#6339728)
I come from the German-Swiss border, and roaming charges can be a total PITA over here. If you have your phone with roaming enabled (and most people do), and you come too close to the swiss border (which happens on the train line down the Rhein river), your phone will repeatedly switch from the German network to the Swiss network and back. Even if you have an all-germany flatrate, you will get milked over here.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by DasIch on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:01AM (#6339716)
Communication has become so essential to daily life, that having access to communication networks is as import as having access to water or electricity. Communication has become infrastructure, some might argue a human right and that changes the rules that apply to it.

Letting providers do as they want without restraints does not create desireable outcomes, as can be clearly seen right now. So it's necessary to apply some restraints that do create those desireable outcomes.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by jakobe on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:31AM (#6339827)
> If customers were being tricked into paying roaming charges in nefarious ways

If your phone rings abroad, and you don't pick it up, and the call goes to voicemail, they charge you for an incoming call and for an outgoing call. Even if the caller doesn't speak on your voicemail, you are billed at least 1 minute active + 1 minute passive.

Assume you're an Austrian, and you miss 3 calls while in Montenegro, that's 20€ in unexpected charges.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by martinml on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:45AM (#6339880)
You must have outdated information. Incoming calls going to voicemail must be free since 2010. Check this table:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_roaming_regulati...

Edit: I just realized Montenegro is not in the EU yet, so you may be right!

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by adrinavarro on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:37AM (#6339841)
Huh?

Then there's something wrong with your operator. Roaming charges are for the "international" segment: from home, to the country you are, and from the country you are to home. That's why you pay extra to make calls, and that's why you get to pay when you receive calls.

But it's also "opt-in": you only pay for what you accept. You won't pay for SMS because you can't elect to receive them or not. And, if you miss, or reject a call, it goes to your voicemail. And the voicemail is in your country operator's. So, of course, you won't pay. Unless you have a weird phone and the voicemail is in your phone. Then turn off your weird mobile phone.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by vidarh on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:54AM (#6339918)
That voicemails are not subject to roaming charges within the EU is a quite recent thing, and I'm not sure if it's a result of regulation or if the operators have just pre-empted being forced to do it. When roaming outside of the EU, you can still expect to get hit with massive charges for receiving voicemail.

It's result of a quirk of how voicemail calls get routed: If you set up call diversion to your voicemail with your network, you'd not pay anything.

But if you fail to answer, or divert calls to voicemail with your phone, the calls would get routed to the network your phone is active in, you'd fail to answer, and the call would get routed back by the operator you're roaming with, rather than having that operator somehow just signal that the calls should be diverted at source, and you'd get to pay for the pleasure.

At least that's the excuse the operators used. Of course it was particularly shitty that they'd charge people extortionate rates due to shortcomings of the way they do call routing.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by adrinavarro on Friday September 06, 2013 @05:11PM (#6342708)
I've been travelling for a number of years (when a MB in Europe was around 10€), inside and outside Europe, and never ever had this happen, or heard about this happening.

Probably something intentionally made by your operator — but in Spain, I don't know of a single mobile operator who does not route voicemail at their own network level.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by rmc on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:40AM (#6339862)
Alas Montenegro isn't in EU (yet), so wouldn't be covered by this. I recently travelled around that part of Europe and it just shows the absurdity of roaming rates. Cross one border (into the EU) and suddenly roaming is 10% the price!
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by tonyedgecombe on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:57AM (#6339698)
-If there were monopolistic / market manipulating behaviour going on.

If the market was operating efficiently roaming charges wouldn't be so high. They are high which discourages use and so is a drag on the whole economy (apart from the telcos).

If we left everything to the free market we would have the same problems the US has with it's telecoms infrastructure. Communications, just like other utilities are too important to the economy for governments to ignore.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by ZeroGravitas on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:09AM (#6339967)
Well, let's be precise here. The EU changes, like many EU changes are intended to create a "free market". It's not possible to have a free market without some level of government support (e.g. courts, contracts, regulations about externalities etc.). With utilities it's particularl crucial due to network effects.

The telecom situation in the USA, much like their healthcare, is not messed up because it's a free market, it's messed up because governments, under the guise of creating a free market, introduce absolutely brain-dead regulations that achieve the exact opposite of a free market and the corporations take advantage of that to gouge consumers, free from worries about competition because it's not a free market.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by yxhuvud on Friday September 06, 2013 @10:28AM (#6340581)
Strictly speaking, the EU changes is to create a common market, not a free market. There is a big difference between those two poles.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by CaptainZapp on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:01AM (#6339717)
(off topic)

I re-upvoted you.

I utterly disagree with your reasoning, but downvoting HN contributors for having a different opinion should really be beyond us and there's nothing in your post, which warrants downvoting.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by benilov on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:54AM (#6339687)
There is monopolistic/market manipulating behaviour going on - it's basically an oligopoly, and the barrier to entry into the mobile telecoms market (ie building your network) is only growing.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by aestra on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:37AM (#6340327)
How so?
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by noselasd on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:52PM (#6343292)
It is _amazingly_ expensive to start building a network. There's about 4 vendors providing the gear needed for a large scale cell network. And they're not bothering talking to you unless you want to buy a lot of gear.

Then you need spectrum licenses. And since you're placing cell towers around, you're either going to rent rather expensive towers, or build your own, which requires permits and a lot of civil engineering.

It's a bit easier today, as there's more infrastructure in place - but you may very well end up needing to provide the network backhaul from a cell site, somehow get power lines to the cell site. And that cell site might need backup power, which require refueling and maintenance every now and then, you might need to build a small cabin to house the gear, and you might need to hire helicopters to fly in that gear.

When you get this far, you need a marketing department, so people can actually buy connectivity, refill cards, sim card distribution, and similar.

At some point you might need roaming agreements with others as well. If your're lucky the government requires you to have agreements with other operators in your country - important enough, cause unless you have greate coverage people won't bother if they can't use their phone. If you want your customers to use their phone while abroad, you get to make individual roaming agreements with all those other operators in other countries.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by henningb on Friday September 06, 2013 @07:19AM (#6339788)
I don't think it is overreach even if it is a rather strong market regulation. The EU has the responsibility to tear down economic borders inside the EU. Just like you don't have to pay import tax when buying stuff from another EU country, you should not have to pay roaming charges. Obviously the better solution would be the free market takes care of that by itself. It didn't. And there are no signs of it happening. So the EU regulation is a pragmatic solution.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by rsynnott on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:26AM (#6340037)
Essentially, roaming charges are of benefit to nobody but a small number of large telecoms. They hurt the consumer and they hurt business. Removing them will not cripple the telcos.

> If there were monopolistic / market manipulating behaviour going on.

In practice, with few exceptions, before the regulation started (remember, the EU already sets roaming price caps), there was a form of cartel system, at least informally; prices were pretty much standard and extremely high.

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by felxh on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:54AM (#6339686)
I agree that the best scenario would be one carrier simply dropping roaming charges and other carriers eventually following suit, because of market pressure. However, the fact that this hasn't happened makes me suspect that carriers are mutually agreeing not to drop roaming charges since it is such a big cash cow for them. I have no evidence for this, though.

(didn't down vote you btw)

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by colomon on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:16AM (#6340245)
Here's my question. Every comment I read here seems to assume that the roaming charges will be eliminated and that is that. Isn't it more likely the companies will raise prices elsewhere to compensate for the lost revenue?
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by justincormack on Friday September 06, 2013 @11:35AM (#6340930)
I think everyone would prefer that. Basis ally now a few people pay a lot and most people try to avoid using the product as it has high unpredictable pricing versus the normal fixed monthly cost. A revenue neutral solution would be better.
Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by tiatia on Friday September 06, 2013 @08:09AM (#6339963)
"If customers were being tricked into paying roaming charges in nefarious ways;"

Like, living on the border and your phone checks into the wrong side of the border and you get billed 1000nds? Tricked like that?

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by aestra on Friday September 06, 2013 @09:40AM (#6340346)
It must suck cellphone-wise if you lived in one country and commuted daily to work into another. I'm sure that with the EU, and the ability to freely live and work within other EU counties, there are people who do that.

(Disclaimer: I don't live in Europe)

Re:Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges by TsiCClawOfLight on Friday September 06, 2013 @06:54AM (#6339683)
read the other posts. Most operators are present everywhere, it's just free money for them without any justification - that really hinders users in the process.