News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by alphaoverlord on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @09:53PM (#6247711)
I'm all for people having the freedom to eat whatever they want and I really like the quantified self aspect of seeing how diet affects how they feel and metrics of health, but I have to say the author grossly does not understand the medical tests he had done and misinterprets the data. I'm not going to comment on the drink, but rather on his misunderstanding of medicine.

First, EGFR is not "Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor", rather is it estimated glomerular filtration rate, which is a metric of kidney function and is derived entirely from age, sex, and Cr.

Second, all his labs are normal, well within the range of normal and stay normal after two weeks. There is normal daily fluctuation (for example, my Cr will probably go from 1 to 1.2 just by not drinking water for a day) which the labs show. All the changes he mention in his metabolic panel does not even register to me as changes and most likely would happen had he ate a regular diet.

Third, the body is a powerfully homeostatic system, even had he not ate for two weeks, most of the labs he got would stay the same. Recently, on HN there was the article of the guy who didn't eat for a year - his BMP would have been similar. The only potentially reasonable medical test to get would have been the lipid panel, which stayed grossly the same.

Finally, a DEXA scan is really silly in this scenario. It's for old ladies and others at risk for osteoporosis. Your bones are a large of reservoir that it wouldn't put a dent on your Ca levels even if you had no Ca for two weeks, and even if it did, it would not show up as a meaningful change on a DEXA scan.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by w1ntermute on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @10:42PM (#6247856)
One of the best parts about this whole Soylent debacle is getting to watch well-known people make complete fools of themselves by commenting on things that they clearly know absolutely nothing about, but still feel like they have the right to make authoritative statements on.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jacques_chester on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @10:55PM (#6247896)
Funnily enough, that's the whole pitch for Soylent. "I'm just a smart guy with a fresh pair of eyes who spent a few weekends reading undergrad textbooks and skimming pubmed".

Not: "we're a large company with deeply-interested professionals who've made this their life's work, our own multi-million dollar labs and decades of accumulated experience in the development, testing, validation and manufacture of temporary food substitutes". Because that's boooorrrrinnnng.

Basically it's getting buzz because of novelty (to people who didn't know there were existing products) and homophily (Rhinehart is "one of us").

The actual product is at this point nearly completely tangential to the marketing.

It's a bit like a dietitian bursting in and saying "I've invented a new thing, I call it 'computertalk'. What you do is you 'type' your 'instructions' into your computer. It's going to change everything, you won't need programmers any more!"

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jlgreco on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:39PM (#6248013)
This Soylent thing is literally the SV techie equivalent of those "This School Teacher(tm) found one weird trick to [BLANK]... [BLANKERS] hate her!" advertisements that we all like to make fun of.

Why do those ads use "school teachers"? Because it is relatable to the target audience and sufficiently anti-authoritarian that they don't question the credentials.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by visakanv on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:15AM (#6248128)
Well it's like that story of Colonel H. McMaster, who DID technically find "one weird trick", and the Army DID pass him over for promotions, etc...

I'm not for or against Soylent, and I usually find this kind of advertising annoying, but it's also entirely possible that people further down the chain of command in any system discover things that people higher-up won't or can't.

That's part of the entire premise of why startups work, no?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:31AM (#6248994)
Re McMasters - I think the parent refers to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._R._McMaster and the change from daily location in Tal Afar to permanent location there.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by namdnay on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:31AM (#6249700)
> people further down the chain of command in any system

Here we're talking about people who aren't even in the same system!

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by julius on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:58AM (#6249858)
Einstein was a patent office guy. Yet his notable weird tricks (like constant speed of light) aren't even in the same system.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jerf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:10AM (#6249935)
Yeah, a "patent office guy" who knew nothing about physics at all until he suddenly overturned the entire world through sheer force of will. Certainly not a guy who already wanted to be a physics teacher with all the requisite training and credentials, including published papers in prestigious journals in his first year of working in the patent office, but had to find a job to make money in the meantime while he searched for one.

Einstein was someone who went up the academic course for physics, but had a brief detour during a jobless interval. I imagine many of us here can relate to that. He's not some sort of quintessential outsider.

(He's not a quintessential insider either; while the rumors about his poor grades are overstated, he did have a rough relationship with any academic subject he didn't really care about. He certainly wasn't the valedictorian type or a groomed, perfect academic from tip to toe. But neither was he an outsider. He's just an average everyday genius who combined tons of hard work with immense native talent.)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by mimiflynn on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:00AM (#6250285)
Exactly, just like all the barista's and waiters / waitresses that became doctors and lawyers ;)
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by scotty79 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:37AM (#6249433)
> Not: "we're a large company with deeply-interested professionals who've made this their life's work, our own multi-million dollar labs and decades of accumulated experience in the development, testing, validation and manufacture of temporary food substitutes". Because that's boooorrrrinnnng.

I think it's not because it sounds boring but because it sounds like a marketing bullshit. Guy in a suit tells you "trust us, we have a whole basement of experts and years of experience" but when you check them out, the company was funded few months ago and only one employee doesn't have some sort of "manager" or "director" in his job title.

I guess openness of soylent and creator's low experience in bullshitting is what makes it attractive. Those of us who eat to live don't expect much from industry after McDonalds and sugar everywhere but we still desperately hope for something better. That hopes fuels enthusiasm for soylent.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by DanBC on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:44AM (#6250192)
> I think it's not because it sounds boring but because it sounds like a marketing bullshit. Guy in a suit tells you "trust us, we have a whole basement of experts and years of experience" but when you check them out, the company was funded few months ago and only one employee doesn't have some sort of "manager" or "director" in his job title.

But this is an aspect of the large nutrition companies that can be checked out. Unless you're talking about the other companies.

They do have a lot of people with respected qualifications working for them; they do produce all these different products.

The bullshit with these companies is that they push multivitamins as useful for everyone, when really there's a limited market. They push a bunch of other stuff as useful for all kinds of conditions, when really the evidence is weak at best.

> Those of us who eat to live don't expect much from industry after McDonalds and sugar everywhere but we still desperately hope for something better. That hopes fuels enthusiasm for soylent.

That's fair enough. It's your body, and you can make your own choices. You know that as well as Soylent there are a bunch of these liquid feeding products, so if you wanted to experiment now you can?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stcredzero on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:54PM (#6252132)
> don't expect much from industry after McDonalds and sugar everywhere

Sometimes a fresh set of eyes are valuable, because the industry culture has developed some pathologies. Sugar in the food industry is a prime example.

And sometimes, it's just a cover for charlatans.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by smacktoward on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:05PM (#6247929)
But can your computertalk run in the cloud? Please advise.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jacques_chester on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:27PM (#6247980)
Give me a million dollars and I will ship you a box full of randomly chosen words. You can see if they evaporate. That's a cloud, right?
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by scarecrowbob on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:39PM (#6248011)
FWIW this is an analysis of the rhetoric, not the science. As such, I think it's pretty accurate. It's like noting that with Rush Limbaugh advertising you get appeals to what he personally does or enjoys using, whereas on NPR advertising you get vague references to strange sounding companies....

you don't need to know about dietary supplements or supply chain management to understand the rhetorical distinctions.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by namdnay on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:25AM (#6250062)
It's brilliant marketing though, because they've managed to sell a $230/month system as cheap!
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by samstave on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:27AM (#6248382)
While I have no ability to judge the veracity of the claims of Soylent.me -- let me tell you the only reason I am hopeful it works is for the same reason Jobs only wore black turtle-necks and jeans: simplicity.

I want to be able to take a good fuel for my body and indulge in great food whenever I want.

I want to be able to back-pack for a week with only a 4-pound food supply.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:41AM (#6248422)
> I want to be able to take a good fuel for my body and indulge in great food whenever I want.

Then eat some meat and some vegetables.

> I want to be able to back-pack for a week with only a 4-pound food supply.

Then take trail mix.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by homosaur on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:41AM (#6249751)
Trail mix is elementary school crap, we trail Nazis have all moved to pemmican. Better density and energy content.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by samstave on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:51AM (#6248446)
jacques_chester, The Dream Killer.

P.S.: I am currently eating Chicken I made with a side of snap-peas from my garden. I do what you say already -- I just also want an alternative which has incredible shelf-life, portability, cost-benefit, etc. etc. etc.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:00AM (#6248466)
Dream killer? Nah, merely a young curmudgeon. I need my 10,000 hours of grumping so that "get off my grass" really stings, y'know?

By the way -- there are such alternatives already available. Have you bought any before?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by StavrosK on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:36AM (#6248869)
What are they? I'm interested in "I'm too lazy to cook today but don't want to eat unhealthy fast food" food.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by lsc on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:50AM (#6248909)
Seriously? You are unaware of meal replacement bars and drinks?

https://www.google.com/search?q=meal+replacement+shakes

Almost all of them are marketed to the diet crowd. There are a bunch of 'atkins' branded bars, too, if you are going the low-carb route. Slim-fast, I know, can be had in giant tubs for relatively little money per serving; I remember as a kid, looking through my grandparent's pantry and finding a giant tub of slim-fast.

This is a huge industry. I mean, sure, marketing it to hackers is a new thing, and something I, personally, would have never considered, and the guy is doing a hell of a job of it, but yeah; the product itself is nothing new, even if he's selling to a group that has not yet been targeted.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stcredzero on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:57PM (#6252162)
> marketing it to hackers is a new thing, and something I, personally, would have never considered, and the guy is doing a hell of a job of it

Really, it's textbook. He's using his ties and understanding of a subculture demographic to market to it specifically.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by lsc on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:10PM (#6254452)
>Really, it's textbook. He's using his ties and understanding of a subculture demographic to market to it specifically.

Sure, but the execution (to me) looks good. He is doing a way better job, for example, than I've done at marketing VPSs - a product that is much more natural to this market. Better, I think, than I did even back when I had a compelling price advantage over the competition.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by StavrosK on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:58AM (#6248937)
I was indeed unaware of them, they sound good, thank you.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by lsc on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:09AM (#6248954)
Yeah, I can't guarantee they are better than fast food. But, I bet you can find one that is similar to Soylent. It is more convenient than fast food.

I actually kinda like the McDonald's salads. I mean, as far as you can like fast food at all. If you go easy on the dressing, (the dressing comes in a package that looks like a giant-size katsup packet, so you get to decide how much you eat.) I think it's probably pretty healthy, I mean, at least when you compare to shakes.

I have used meal-replacement shakes in the past as supplemental breakfast; I like to load up on calories in the morning, but eating can be... hard before my system wakes up, so the meal-replacement shakes (with as much breakfast as I can choke down) is a reasonable way to consume as many calories as I can in the morning.

Of course, for me? meal-replacement shakes have never quelled hunger like real food, so I'm no longer using them just because I'm trying to reduce the number of calories I consume. If I eat something, it had better make me feel not hungry for a good long time. I'm having the best luck with meat and vegetables... the carbohydrates tend to make me hungry shortly afterwards. On the other hand, I have not lost significant weight. (I vary from 200 to 195#, and that has been true for some time now. As far as I can tell, most of that 5# is either water gain or loss, or inaccuracy of my cheap bathroom scale.) so "you shall know him by his fruits" - don't take my advice on losing weight, as I've not managed to do so myself.

Also, a big, sarcastic thanks. after that 'meal replacement shake' query on google, now just about every webpage I load is trying to sell me some sort of 'optimized nutrition' (Google seems to get that I'm male-identified and thus is trying to sell me the shakes targeted at 'building lean muscle' - you know, the stuff with the rippling abs on the can. Google does not seem to be smart enough to notice that I quite often google things I don't intend to buy. Really, books on what I'm searching for are usually more appropriate than products I'm searching for. Not that I often buy books through ads... but it's more likely than me buying nutrition shakes targeted at bodybuilders.)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by StavrosK on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:33AM (#6249419)
Hmm, thanks. If they don't sate my hunger, there's no reason to them. I'll either keep cooking chicken breasts (you just pop them in the oven for an hour with minimal preparation and are delicious) or have milk with cereal, one cup of which keeps me full for 5-6 hours. Losing weight with that sort of diet has never been a problem, as I feel full all day and still manage to have a nicely-sized dinner.

About the targeting, either use incognito mode or opt out of targeted advertising (it's in your Google account preferences).

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by thewordis on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:05AM (#6250310)
I bought a week's worth of Ensure Complete and was unable to sustain any sort of meal replacement plan on it. Each drink only seemed to alter the 'flavor' of my hunger rather than sate it in any way.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:52PM (#6254096)
Liquids are nowhere near as effective at satiation as solids.

Fibre and protein can increase the satiety of a drink, though.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by DanBC on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:06AM (#6250323)
You can add fibre, if you think that's going to help.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by lsc on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:24PM (#6254504)
Yeah. I like chicken; cheap and easy. I put dried chopped onions on mine before cooking, but yeah, that's a huge part of my own diet, along with salads, which are good for 'fill you up' bulk.

I've also started doing slow-cooker pork. I pan fry it when I'm done, and it comes out kind of somewhere between pulled pork and carnitas. I slow-cooked a bunch of boneless beef short ribs last night, I haven't tried them yet. more expensive per pound, but short ribs are so good.

Especially if I cook something in sauce (like chili) I put it in little ziplock baggies and freeze it.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:11AM (#6250363)
How about actually clicking the links in those search results. Nothing in the first few pages even attempts to provide a food replacement. None of them provide 100% of known essential nutrients. You will develop a vitamin deficiency consuming any of those exclusively. That is in no way accomplishing what soylent claims to do.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by lsc on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:19PM (#6254481)
>None of them provide 100% of known essential nutrients. You will develop a vitamin deficiency consuming any of those exclusively. That is in no way accomplishing what soylent claims to do.

Personally? I dismiss those claims as marketing fluff. I am not competent to evaluate those claims; I'm not saying that the guy is lying or anything, soylent may in fact be perfect. I don't know. but the claims sound so out there that I don't think they are worth evaluating. I am treating them as marketing fluff until/unless credible people do a credible study.

I suspect that none of the other meal replacement drinks make such claims due to fear of legal liability. "A delicious shake for breakfast, lunch, and a sensible dinner" is the standard formula, which is reasonable; I'm sure Soylent would work just fine on a similar plan. (hell, for most of us, water would work just fine.)

I bet that as Soylent accumulates money (and lawyers) they will move towards a model where they emphasize 'And a sensible dinner'

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:04AM (#6256821)
I am not talking about claims, I am talking about the nutrition info required to be provided by law. We know that there are a bunch of chemical compounds we call "vitamins" which are required to maintain our health. Soylent provides 100% of all of them. Meal replacement drinks do not.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by lsc on Monday August 26, 2013 @11:40PM (#6281329)
http://abbottnutrition.com/brands/products/ensure-plus-retai...

And really, if you think that the RDA is good enough, just take your vitamin pills.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jacques_chester on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:50PM (#6254082)
Does Soylent explicitly and specifically claim to be a total food replacement?

Or do we all just think that because of the original blog post?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Shivetya on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:25AM (#6249388)
Well we all know how Steve Jobs foray into doing it his way turned out. I am all for new and ingenious ways to maintaining one's health. However I am not for new ways that don't have the strong trusted evaluations.

The number of bad habits I engage in over my days is one thing, I am not about to jump from fad to fad in hopes of out smarting the medical community.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Tloewald on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:39PM (#6254570)
Um, blaming pancreatic cancer on eating too much fruit?
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by dagw on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:08AM (#6248799)
I want to be able to back-pack for a week with only a 4-pound food supply.

That's doable already. 4-pounds of dehydrated food will last you a week, and has the advantage that you get to eat something different for every meal.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:07AM (#6250330)
>to people who didn't know there were existing products

Would you care to link to where people can purchase these existing products? It seems that every time someone makes that claim they are either referring to medical products not available to the public, or to crap like MET-Rx that doesn't provide a complete, balanced micro nutrient profile.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by DanBC on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:10AM (#6250355)
> they are either referring to medical products

Very few of these products are prescription only or even pharmacy only products. It is possible to persuade companies to sell to individuals. To answer your question - Ensure brand includes complete meal replacement products; the Fortisip range also includes suitable products. There are a bunch of others but these are easiest to obtain.

Most companies are very careful about selling these products. Some people think that's a good thing.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:48AM (#6250663)
>Would you care to link to where people can purchase these existing products?
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Retric on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:03AM (#6250784)
Did you even try google?

Enshure: http://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes click buy online from the product page.

Fortisip: http://www.fortisipdrink.co.uk/. Again, click the buy online link from there homepage. (Though I think this is a UK brand.)

PS: You can find a wide product range at http://abbottstore.com/

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:43PM (#6251572)
Did you try reading the thread you are attempting to participate in? The whole problem is vaguely claiming that there's already products that cover the use case of soylent, but not giving a specific. None of the products you linked to provide 100% of known essential nutrients. None of them are intended to be used as a replacement for food, and none of them can be used as such with long term safety. It is absurd to see people bitching about how unsafe soylent is while claiming that products we 100% for certain know are not nutritionally complete already make soylent useless.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Retric on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:47PM (#6251608)
None of the products you linked to provide 100% of known essential nutrients. None of them are intended to be used as a replacement for food, and none of them can be used as such with long term safety.

No, that's almost exactly what these products are designed for.

EX: Similac, Complete nutrition for your baby's first year.

It should be noted that most of these are balanced nutritionally but not calorie wise because it's easy to backfill empty calories with soda etc and people generally drink quite a few extra calories. But, you really can live off of ensure complete and empty calories or just ensure if you don't mind spending more money.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:10PM (#6251770)
Isn't silly nonsense like that supposed to be reserved for reddit? You are of course fully aware that I, and everyone else in this discussion, is over the age of 1.

How is 13% of one micronutrient and 65% of another balanced? In order to get complete micronutrient coverage from ensure, you have to drink 5 a day, putting you at risk of overexposure to manganese assuming you drink water still.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Retric on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:40PM (#6252007)
Ahh, ok your assuming nutrients all need to hit exactly 100% each day to be heathy. The reality is perfection changes with age, Heath issues, pregnancy, sun exposure, body weight, and a host of other issues. However, close enough is plenty to stay in good heath. So, while there is no diet that works equally well for a nursing mother and a sedendary accountant both can stay heathy eating just rice and a multivitamin or enshure and some empty cal.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:10PM (#6252242)
No, I am not assuming anything. I gave you a specific real example of an actual problem. Do you have anything constructive to add to the discussion, or did you just want to provide an example of the kind of deliberately dishonest hand-waving I was referring to?
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Retric on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:21PM (#6252711)
Let's look at some actual science.

http://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/DRI/DRI_Vitamin_A/394-419_150.p...

The Manganease recommendation is based on observed western diets not actual need. From existing studies it looks like there is a fairly wide tolerable range for Manganease with some people needing quite a bit to maintain Manganease levels. Anyway, 5x ensure is well within the 'Tolerable Upper Limit' and thus Not an issue.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:27PM (#6252734)
Except that most people get a significant amount of manganese from their water, thus putting them at risk. This is what I said in my post, which you should read before you reply to.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Retric on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:43PM (#6254061)
Sorry, assuming you drink water still. does not read as assuming your water has unusual concentrations of Manganese. Even still, known heathrisks relate to breathing excesive Manganease as it's normally excreted though the gut not the urine.

Edit: If it's really bothering you. Ambient manganese concentrations in seawater have been reported to range from 0.4 to 10 μg/l (ATSDR, 2000), with an average of about 2 μg/l (Barceloux, 1999). Levels in fresh water typically range from 1 to 200 μg/l (Barceloux, 1999). ATSDR (2000) reported that a river water survey in the USA found dissolved manganese levels ranging from <11 to >51 μg/l. The United States Geological Survey’s National Water Quality Assessment Program has gathered limited data since 1991 on representative study basins around the USA. These data indicate a median manganese level of 16 μg/l in surface waters, with 99th-percentile concentrations of 400–800 μg/l (Leahy & Thompson, 1994; USGS, 2001). Higher levels in aerobic waters are usually associated with industrial pollution.. (http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/dwq/chemicals/man...)

So, again there may be people that need to be consurned to it's less than 1% of the population and they can get buy by drinking bottled water if nothing else.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Thursday August 22, 2013 @09:02AM (#6256812)
It doesn't need to be unusually high levels, that's the point. You are already half way to the TUL just from ensure.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Retric on Thursday August 22, 2013 @10:29AM (#6257347)
No, the high end of the 99th percentile is 800 μg/l or .8mg/ liter. 2 liters per day of water is 1.6mg/ day and the TUL is 11mg/ day. Thus adding 50% from ensure and 1.6 / 11 = 14.5% from unusually high water levels is at worst 64.5% TUL and again not a problem.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by DanBC on Sunday August 25, 2013 @02:38PM (#6273113)
> None of the products you linked to provide 100% of known essential nutrients. None of them are intended to be used as a replacement for food

You keep making this claim and it is just not true.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:11AM (#6248114)
That's true, from both the "for" and "against sides". Anyone who things that only happens on one of the sides should check their confirmation bias.

And no, this is not an "every opinion deserves equal airtime" claim. The vast majority of nutrition and health experts draw on a mix of science, pseudo science and superstition, and assume it is all science.

(Quick check: Think salt intake causes hypertension? That dietary cholesterol (and cholesterol in general) is bad for you? That you can only get B-12 from meat, or that cows make it? If you answered "yes", your answers are not based on science)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by mseebach on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:50AM (#6248908)
Yes, you are making a "every opinion deserves equal airtime" claim.

When someone who isn't trained at all in a field claims to have made a revolutionary advance in that field, the rational response for a non-subject-matter-expert member of the public is deep skepticism. The discovery might indeed be revolutionary, but the way we find out is by running proper scientific tests on it, not by pioneering the revolution.

The rational objective news angle on this is as a human interest story. Until a proper, falsifiable scientific test is at least planned, this project is genuinely interesting, but has no scientific merit.

(FWIW, health advice condensed into headline "do" and "don't" edicts is bad science reporting as well)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by JPKab on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @11:29AM (#6250994)
Let's keep one thing that the poster you are replying to had in mind:

Human nutritional science is HORRIBLE from a "meta-science" perspective. Gary Taubes, who admittedly is a bit of a one trick pony, has written extensively on the failings of the nutritional scientific community to adequately fund real, controlled studies that test out poorly performing hypothesies that have been taken as gospel.

Eggs are good for you now, but a few years ago every doctor was saying they were bad for you, along with butter. Why is that? Because nutritional science SUCKS. The general public thinks that eating a serving of bacon is worse for their body than eating a serving of raisin bran. The actual data shows that the opposite is true. The fault for this lies 100% with the nutritional science community in the United States.

As a person who fell victim to their bullshit for years until I tried the Atkins diet (tons of green vegetables, meat, minimal carbs/sugar) and subsequently lost weight, improved my blood profile (HDL went up, triglycerides went down, LDL decreased slightly) and all the while going against the conventional wisdom on diet. I tried low fat, I tried vegetarian/vegan, none of it worked. It was scientifically unproven bullshit due to a flawed scientific community embedded in the study of human nutrition.

I'm not saying reject the scientific credentials of individuals in the community. I'm saying reject the establishment. They have repeatedly failed the public, so fuck em.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stcredzero on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:08PM (#6252621)
> Human nutritional science is HORRIBLE from a "meta-science" perspective.

What most people don't realize is that their gut is probably the single thing with the biggest influence on nutrition, and it is practically its own goddamn biome. Also, what we know of human metabolism would fill an entire wall with an intricate nightmare spaghetti chart, and that would be the abridged version.

At this point, the only viable way to proceed is to continue research and empirical data on large populations. This is why traditional diets and whole foods win, because we already have a lot of data.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @06:55AM (#6249278)
On the contrary. I am saying "experts ALSO deserve skepticism". Not equal doubt, but certainly nonzero doubt. And I gave three examples that experts often get wrong, and the only times I see them questioned is when I do that.

Most of the criticism directed at soylent is of "this doesn't seem right" variety, rather than the "this detail is wrong" variety. The latter is what I read the discussions for. The former is a waste of bits.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by asdasf on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:14AM (#6250385)
>the rational response for a non-subject-matter-expert member of the public is deep skepticism

And the response in question is not deep skepticism, but equally non-scientific and inaccurate nonsense. "Soylent will kill you because you need the magic spirits of whole foods!" is not skepticism, it is bullshit.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by will_work4tears on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:29AM (#6249689)
"That you can only get B-12 from meat"

Well, maybe "meat sources (dairy products under the umbrella) are the only significant source of B-12 without supplementation" is more accurate.

Cereals are "fortified" so I count that as supplementation.

Sure, many yeasts contains B-12 too, some quite a bit. I'd even agree that it is significant, but it doesn't occur in foods people normally eat (maybe a guess here, but if that were true, vegans wouldn't need to supplement with yeast, etc), so it's taken as a supplemnt.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:48AM (#6249801)
And now for the science: neither people nor animals make their own B12. Instead, we employ good bacteria in our gut to do that (and so do cows).

After the discovery of antibiotics, many people in the western world became B12 deficient - especially vegetarians. However cows and other animals are just as incapable of making it - and in the last 30 years or so, just as deficient as humans, as they've also been getting lots of antibiotics.

So we give them supplements. Thus they have enough B12, and meat eaters do too. According to some estimates, 80% of the world's B12 production goes to animals these days. So, likely, your B12 coming from meat is still from supplement, albeit one given to your hamburger while it was still alive.

I have no dietary sources of B12, and yet have good levels, way above population average. You might call me a liar, more then one MD did. But they usually apologize if they actually research this (Wikipedia B12 has enough info)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by will_work4tears on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:37AM (#6250143)
I think if anyone reasonable researches this they'll see that there is still some controversy on the issue (Studies show both sides). I don't have an axe to grind in this argument, so I'm not even going to bother digging that deep, but I'm not entirely convinced. I'm not a meat eater for the sole purpose of getting B12 and dont' try to convince vegans to eat meat with such sad arguments, so I hardly care what the true concensious is (though I'd be convinced with some real sites by actual qualified dieticians or other health professionals -sorry, It's a fallacy, but I don't like getting my "facts" from programmers and Wikipedia).

Anyway, my guess is you are in your early to mid twenties, and probably have only been a vegan for a handful of years, am I right? Give it 20, 30 years and lets see if your B12 levels are still good.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:18PM (#6254231)
> I think if anyone reasonable researches this they'll see that there is still some controversy on the issue (Studies show both sides).

I've never heard of a study claiming B12 in animals in vivo is not synthesized by bacteria (or archaea). Care to give a reference?

> sorry, It's a fallacy, but I don't like getting my "facts" from programmers and Wikipedia

Programmers, ok. Wikipedia - why? and "dieticians and health professionals" - sorry, most of them have no idea what they are talking about - they are just parroting what they learned. You admit yourself it is a fallacy. What's the point then?

> Anyway, my guess is you are in your early to mid twenties, and probably have only been a vegan for a handful of years, am I right? Give it 20, 30 years and lets see if your B12 levels are still good.

Your guess is very wrong. Been vegetarian for over 35 years (only a few years of those vegan, but not having a B12 source in almost any). And my B12 levels are very good, although they weren't in the past.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by will_work4tears on Thursday August 22, 2013 @08:25AM (#6256648)
"I've never heard of a study claiming B12 in animals in vivo is not synthesized by bacteria (or archaea). Care to give a reference?"

That's not what I was referring to. I'm referring to the (implied) claim that the B12 synthisized in our gut by bacteria is available to us.

Wikipedia doesn't support that claim, and Wikipedia is editable by anybody, so while it's mostly trustworthy, if a heavy portion of the editors have a bias, it's going to show in an article that is heavyily political/quasi-relisious like veganism. Or vice versa if Wikipedia editors are heavily carnivorous (e.g Atkins) and hate vegans or something like that.

"Been vegetarian for over 35 years (only a few years of those vegan, but not having a B12 source in almost any)."

Well, I don't know you, and can only assume you aren't lying or bending the truth, so I'll say that it is possible you are an outlier. In a cursory search yesterday (a couple hours only) I found references on both sides of the fence claiming that we can use B12 synthisized in our gut, and about the same number of sources saying we couldn't.

Who to believe in such a hot, political topic. A guy with an axe to grind (vegan trying to defend/promote his lifestyle) or the fact that there seems to be no concensious in the sciencific community?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Thursday August 22, 2013 @05:16PM (#6260145)
> In a cursory search yesterday (a couple hours only) I found references on both sides of the fence claiming that we can use B12 synthisized in our gut, and about the same number of sources saying we couldn't.

If you can actually link to them, I would be grateful. I can only find yahoo-answers style discussions that claim people cannot.

> A guy with an axe to grind (vegan trying to defend/promote his lifestyle) or the fact that there seems to be no concensious in the sciencific community?

You are making an awful lot of assumptions about me. I'm not a vegan (I was for a few short years; I've been vegetarian for 35 though). And I more often in these discussions advocate against veganism and vegetarianism because even though they can be very healthy, most people do them wrong - and if you can't stand your ground with science in these discussions, you shouldn't be vegan.

And about consensus in the scientific community - I believe I have science backing me here, but let's put it aside - I gave two other examples in which the (so-called) scientific consensus is provably wrong (and others mentioned egg consumption). Personally, I'm not ignoring scientific consensus on everything and try to look at the details. Follow the common/average belief, and you get common/average results. If you like mediocrity, all power to you.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by goostavos on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:38AM (#6248555)
As a young-ish person with hyper tension who was told to cut back on the salt, I would love to see you back up your claims.

Could you link to a few relevant medical studies?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by mysterywhiteboy on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @06:22AM (#6249127)
As someone else in the same position (young and mild hypertension) I too was told to cut back. I am a CS PhD and have no medical/nutritional background. Everything I know came from Google, PubMed, and my GP - so (for want of a better phrase) take what I say with a pinch of salt ;)

The causal relationship between salt and blood pressure appears to have historically been under debate. I don't however think it should be so readily dismissed as not backed by "Science". In fact the evidence appears to suggest that there is now little to debate.

A study called INTERSALT [1] in the late 1980s appears to have muddied the waters, and is often brought up. It supported the causal link - but was subsequently seen to be the victim of poor statistical analysis.

This seems to have been the theme of those arguing pro-salt, finding flaws in studies. Fair game - but it doesn't disprove the link. More recently though the general consensus seems to be that a long term reduction sodium has a measurable and beneficial impact on BP[2]. A key study in demonstrating the link was the DASH-Sodium study, a randomized controlled trial [3].

The Harvard School of Public Health has some great articles[4][5] discussing the "Salt Debate" and points to a number of papers.

Personally, having taken time to read (and understand what I can), I think the evidence supporting is pretty compelling so have reduced the levels of sodium in my diet.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersalt_study [2] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23558162 [3] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11136953?dopt=Citation [4] http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/2010/07/10/its-t... [5] http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/salt-and-heart-d...

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:29AM (#6249400)
By all means, if you already have hypertension, it is good advice to reduce salt intake - I don't know what the posterior probability for salt sensitive hypertension given hypertension, might be >50%, and it is definitely prudent especially since AFAIK there's no definite test for salt sensitivity.

However, iirc (can't review now), the data supports the following:

A) on average, if hypertension, reducing salt reduces blood pressure. But so does adding potassium.

B) despite that, there is a population with hypertension for which salt reduction does not reduce blood pressure.

C) In healthy individuals, increase of salt intake increases blood pressure slightly, but does not get to the hypertension realm.

But the often repeated meme "salt causes hypertension" is not supported by data. Furthermore, sodium deficiency is a serious condition, which was practically unheard of before the low sodium craze.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by MDS100 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:58AM (#6249061)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt#Recommended_intake

Have a look at the relationship between potassium/nacl and Blood pressure.

TLDR: Focus on unprocessed foods and foods you like that are rich in potassium. Lower your bodyfat percentage and exercise in same fashion regularly.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by beagle3 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @06:06AM (#6249079)
http://www.menshealth.com/mhlists/food_myths/Salt_Causes_Hig... was the first google answer. I am on a phone and can't do a real search, but the gist is: there's a small percentage of the population (estimates I am familiar with are 5-20%) for which, once hypertension appears, it IS related to salt intake. However, in general it's a sodium potassium balance.

Analogy: peanut allergy is not caused by peanuts. But if you have it, you should avoid peanuts. It is possible that your hypertension is related to salt intake, in which the advice to cut back on salt is a good advice. But that's not generally true - not any more than general the advice to avoid peanuts is good.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Fuzzwah on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:30PM (#6252748)
I think the best part of all this is actually that more and more people are realizing that no human clearly knows what humans should be doing to get the most out of a human body.

Maybe "no human" is over stating it.... I could easily just slot "the vast majority of intelligent adult humans" into the sentence and it should still be mind blowing.

People have used their brains to explain nuclear physics, create a network of computers which spans the globe and landed a man on the moon. Yet no one can clearly tell me what I should be fueling my brain and body with?

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stcredzero on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:51PM (#6252104)
> One of the best parts about this whole Soylent debacle is getting to watch well-known people make complete fools of themselves by commenting on things that they clearly know absolutely nothing about, but still feel like they have the right to make authoritative statements on.

One of the worst parts is watching how ill equipped most of society is to detect something is off-kilter. This pretty much applies to anything requiring technical understanding beyond that required to visit a mall.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by rlpb on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @06:37AM (#6249221)
Nevertheless, I'm pleased that they're trying. In today's Internet age, there's no reason that the things they clearly know absolutely nothing about can't be made wider known, and they're helping to make that happen.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by shanedanger on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:37AM (#6248202)
"the author grossly does not understand the medical tests he had done and misinterprets the data"

As the author himself, I can corroborate your statement that I don't understand medical tests as well as a trained physician. :) However, the point of the post was to present the data so others could interpret / draw conclusions. I gave my observations and perspective, but I made every attempt to indicate the potential weaknesses in my experiment. I do hope people don't lose miss the forest for the trees here.

The EGFR thing is regrettable. Thanks for pointing it out!

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by pron on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:26AM (#6248985)
I'm sorry, but you've collected no data, only noise. Eating rice for 2 weeks would have produced similar effects. As to your subjective experience – it's probably 100% placebo.

If you want to call something an experiment, you should know how to conduct an experiment in that respective field. Your experiences only show how a product like Soylent induces magical thinking in its consumers.

If you want to produce a single data point with Soylent (that would hardly be relevant, as it would be a sampling size of one, but still, it would be one sampling of data rather than zero), eat nothing but Soylent for at least 6 months.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by hnaccount8888 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @10:02AM (#6250297)
If you don't mind me asking, can you produce some food studies/experiments that are up to your standards, so I can get an idea of what one would look like?
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by pron on Thursday August 22, 2013 @03:43AM (#6255710)
Most of those published in the New England, for example. Of course, one can substitute a shorter duration for a larger sample if the results are ver significant with a large effect. But if you have a sample size of 1, and want it to be data, however insignificant, rather than noise, you better keep at it for a while.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by shanedanger on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:11AM (#6249339)
So something is not an experiment unless you do it for 6 months? :)
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by danparsonson on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:29AM (#6249402)
I don't think you read the parent comment properly.

Of course it was "an experiment" but that doesn't mean you can automatically draw useful or even valid conclusions from it. If I ate nothing but peas for a day, my "experiment" wouldn't say much (if anything) about the effects of a pea-only diet on the human body, but if I did it for a year, I might get some useful data. Except that would still only be the effects of peas on my body, and may not generalise to other humans anyway.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by ekianjo on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:22AM (#6248827)
You did not mention the placebo effect though. That's the largest weakness of such an experiment. Your brain may be convinced (without you being strictly conscious about it) that Soylent is good for you and trigger all kind of benefits that you assessed yourself.

That's why clinical trials are running in double-blind modes, to remove as much as possible the placebo effect. A self-assessed experiment is, and will always be, meaningless.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by sgarman on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:38AM (#6248875)
After reading the opening paragraph and seeing how excited the author was to try this I couldn't help to think about the placebo effext. With all the bogus diets out there they show results in 2 weeks and then fail miserably I can't help to think longer testing periods are needed.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by shanedanger on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @07:10AM (#6249337)
Obviously you didn't read the whole thing; search for the word "placebo" and you'll find my discussion of it under the section called "Potential Weaknesses In The Data".
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by ekianjo on Friday August 23, 2013 @04:58AM (#6262422)
I read the whole thing but I did not notice it as being very prominent, while it's the number ONE "FAIL" point of your experiment.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by raverbashing on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:34AM (#6249002)
Well, they can't use a placebo for that, you'll starve the placebo group.

You could provide a different meal replacement powder and compare the results (provided the subjects don't know which one looks like what)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stcredzero on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:59PM (#6252559)
We don't need to re-research nutrition starting from verification of macronutrients. The placebo could be an imbalanced mix of macronutrients. That way, you would expect malnutrition, not starvation.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by ekianjo on Friday August 23, 2013 @04:57AM (#6262416)
> You could provide a different meal replacement powder and compare the results

Yeah, you could at least do that.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by anigbrowl on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @10:01PM (#6247737)
Comments like this are why I read HN, and why it's often so valuable to read the comments before the article. Thanks for sharing your insights.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by plainOldText on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:00PM (#6247918)
I think it's even better to read the comments after reading the article. Here's a possible flow:

1. Read the article

2. Analyze. Establish your position/beliefs

3. Read the comments

4. Adjust your beliefs in the light of new evidence

:)

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by hcarvalhoalves on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:46PM (#6248039)
OT: Often I read HN comments before reading the article, it helps to filter the BS off.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by jonnathanson on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:21AM (#6250036)
That, and briefly glancing at the outbound URL before clicking the link. In this case, my logical progression was: 1) "Hmm, that title looks interesting." 2) "Oh, it's by Tim Ferriss." 3) "Skepticism shields up!"

I have nothing against Tim Ferriss in general. I think he's an interesting character, and in a weird way, he's to be commended for his exceptional skill at self promotion. He's sort of our generation's equivalent of P.T. Barnum. And occasionally he'll even make a really insightful point. But I take at least 70% of what he says with a grain of salt.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by anfedorov on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:10AM (#6248480)
I almost skipped the article because of the top comment, but he says a lot more than the comment addresses, so it's worth reading nonetheless.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by anigbrowl on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:09PM (#6247943)
I'm not in a position to do step 2 on this subject, as I'm not sufficiently into nutrition or medicine or judge the claims in the article independently, and for a non peer-reviewed source addressing what looks like a food fad, there's a good chance that it won't be worth my time to repair that deficiency.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by oblique63 on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:52PM (#6248053)
I believe the parent's point wasn't the accuracy of the information you'd be receiving, but just the exercise of evaluating conflicting viewpoints and coming out more enlightened as a result of it. Believe it or not, being able to apply that anywhere (as opposed to just thinking you can) is a skill, and skills need practice. It's an important part of thinking critically, and it can easily be lacking in a lot of very smart people.

EDIT: It wasn't my intention to offend if that was the reason behind the downvotes. It wasn't about anybody specifically, I was just trying to elaborate on a slippery slope issue that seems to be common among smart people.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by plainOldText on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:44AM (#6248579)
I think you've captured the essence of the point I was trying to make, well.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by anigbrowl on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:12AM (#6248961)
Fascinating.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by marze on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:38PM (#6248006)
Nice job missing the forest but spotting a few trees. I see some promising initial signs given the short duration of the trial.

Imagine if there was a new drug that gave the mental benefits the guy reported after two weeks of use and saved you money too. It would be front page news.

The guy doesn't claim to be a medical expert, he just did his best to report the results of a bunch of miscellaneous tests that were suggested to him.

With a drug for which if you took 40x the daily dose you might die, or a drug that might cause significant harmful side effects at normal dose, you need careful studies to prove a benefit and quantify risks. With a dietary change, the risks are orders of magnitude lower. I'd be surprised if the average American wouldn't improve their nutritional status doing this for a while, with an existing diet likely low in magnesium, copper, zinc, vitamin c and d and probably more.

The need for careful studies is greatly reduced for a food product like this one. People can try it, report how they feel. If other think is worth trying, they can see exactly how it works for them by giving it a try. That is the power of self experimentation.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by alphaoverlord on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:01AM (#6248081)
Again, my first paragraph is: > I'm all for people having the freedom to eat whatever they want and I really like the quantified self aspect of seeing how diet affects how they feel and metrics of health, but I have to say the author grossly does not understand the medical tests he had done and misinterprets the data. I'm not going to comment on the drink, but rather on his misunderstanding of medicine.

I'm not trying to refute what he says about how he feels, whether that saves him money, or his mental ability - those aren't my areas of expertise. I do know a little about medical tests, and I think it's valid to point out that he clearly does not and how the results he reports are either incorrect or irrelevant. I'm just suggesting you shouldn't consider his medical tests in deciding how good this product is.

I have no horse in this race, but I'll tell you if this racetrack is not standard regulation. Self experimentation might be useful, but only if you understand the metrics you measure and whether it's stochastic noise or meaningful results.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by marze on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:14AM (#6248121)
"Self experimentation might be useful, but only if you understand the metrics you measure and whether its stochastic noise or meaningful results."

I feel you miss the whole point of self experimentation. If your aim is for improved mental function, more energy, less health problems, etc., you don't need to know how to interpret any obscure tests. You'll know.

A low-risk food product (such as this) can simply be trialed in a n=1 trial. If the results are positive, great. If not, go back to what you were doing before.

All the studies in the world only suggest how something might work for you. It is only the n=1 test that matters.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by nonchalance on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:31AM (#6248187)
> If your aim is for improved mental function, more energy, less health problems, etc., you don't need to know how to interpret any obscure tests. You'll know.

Perception is different from reality, as exemplified by an Apple anecdote:

http://www.asktog.com/TOI/toi06KeyboardVMouse1.html

We’ve done a cool $50 million of R & D on the Apple Human Interface. We discovered, among other things, two pertinent facts:

- Test subjects consistently report that keyboarding is faster than mousing.

- The stopwatch consistently proves mousing is faster than keyboarding.

This contradiction between user-experience and reality apparently forms the basis for many user/developers’ belief that the keyboard is faster.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:39AM (#6248413)
>This contradiction between user-experience and reality apparently forms the basis for many user/developers’ belief that the keyboard is faster.

Interesting article. I'm sure the $50M in studies were of non-power users, though, and so irrelevant for developers with sufficiently powerful keyboard shortcuts.

I can guarantee it doesn't take me 2 seconds for my top 20 keyboard shortcuts, any more than it takes 2 seconds for me to hit "return" at the end of a line, or to move around with arrow keys. That said, I frequently use the mouse as well, and always prefer to work in a GUI instead of a text-mode editor.

What I found most revealing, though, was the admission that part of the problem was the awkward location of the command key. Whenever I'm on a Mac I end up remapping it so that I can hit Control (in the corner of the keyboard) -- Control-ZXCV are all easier to hit than Command-ZXCV.

Which just goes to prove that most studies are wrong [1], or at least can't always be generalized.

[1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1182327/

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by vidarh on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:15AM (#6248811)
> I can guarantee it doesn't take me 2 seconds for my top 20 keyboard shortcuts,

From observing developers I've worked with over the years, I doubt most developers know more keyboard shortcuts than "normal people".

In fact, I've come to realise just how appallingly bad most of us are at using our tools.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:16PM (#6252286)
>In fact, I've come to realise just how appallingly bad most of us are at using our tools.

I don't disagree. I know developers who use Notepad to develop, which boggles the mind.

In fact, I don't know why I bothered posting. I'm enough of an outlier in keyboard performance that, even if I'm right, it proves nothing. I've had many developers' jaws hit the floor as they watch over my shoulder. I've even shocked vi and emacs users into no longer trying to convince me their ways were better.

Maybe I should teach a class on how to use a GUI efficiently.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by coldtea on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:45AM (#6248900)
>I'm sure the $50M in studies were of non-power users, though, and so irrelevant for developers with sufficiently powerful keyboard shortcuts. I can guarantee it doesn't take me 2 seconds for my top 20 keyboard shortcuts, any more than it takes 2 seconds for me to hit "return" at the end of a line, or to move around with arrow keys.

Without measuring it A/B I cannot guarantee anything. Those people were just as sure. And I don't think they were keyboard un-savvy -- at that point in computing, they were far more proficient with a keyboard (AppleII etc) than a mouse.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by SomeCallMeTim on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:26PM (#6252364)
>Without measuring it A/B I cannot guarantee anything.

You don't need to guarantee anything; I know my navigation and coding are way faster my way than if I were to ignore my shortcuts.

>And I don't think they were keyboard un-savvy

As a sister comment to your mentions, MOST users, even developers, are still extremely limited in the number of keyboard shortcuts they use. I'm an outlier.

If I want to save, my fingers hit Ctrl-S before I could even FIND where the mouse pointer is on the screen. Same with Ctrl-A for Select All. Or Shift-Ctrl-Left for select the previous word. No A-B testing required; it's seconds using the mouse for any of those, and 300-700ms for the keyboard.

And those aren't even my most powerful shortcuts; they're just the ones ANYONE can use on Windows. If you get into "complete this word from [above/below] in this file", "jump to definition of this function" or "show references for this function", or "jump to previous bookmark", or "set bookmark" even, all of these are sub-500ms key sequences that would all take longer than a second if I had to use a mouse. It's not even close.

Part of the problem with the study is that it was comparing using shortcuts vs. mouse on the Mac, where shortcuts are far less useful than they are on Windows. Navigating through menus by keyboard is easier for me with the keyboard on Windows as well; that's not even an option on Mac.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by marze on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:55AM (#6248269)
No doubt people can misjudge things. With health changes, I think it is often easier to see changes in the negative direction, like the author when he stopped the soylent trial.

If the changes are great enough in magnitude to be obvious, then you know you're on to something. Also, measures like weight and computer mental agility tests can be quite reliable if you are consistent in your testing, and they aren't subject to misinterpretation or wishful thinking.

Edit:

Below, skore is skeptical that a person can notice a significant change to their own health. I respectfully disagree.

Check out the blog of Seth Roberts. He is a professor who is involved in the quantified self movement. He records many subjective measures qualitatively, and feels he has made some significant discoveries doing so. I won't try to summarize anything here, but anyone interested can read for themselves on his blog. Roberts studies rats, and he is the ultimate human rat.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by skore on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:18AM (#6248348)
> then you know you're on to something

No, no you don't. That's the whole point of doing scientific experiments. Your brain is very, very, extremely bad at judging objectively. Any subjective "test" is simply no test at all.

> Also, numbers like weight and computer mental agility tests also can be quite reliable if you are consistent in your testing...

That's a pretty big 'if', plus a 'can' and a 'quite'.

> ...and they aren't subject to misinterpretation or wishful thinking

That's the whole point of the OT in this discussion thread. They very much clearly are subject to misinterpretation. A zillion factors can impact weight and "mental agility".

People aren't lab rats because they don't live in labs and aren't rats.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by skore on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:52AM (#6248758)
Responding to the edit:

> Below, skore is skeptical that a person can notice a significant change to their own health.

Yes, a point which still stands.

> Roberts studies rats, and he is the ultimate human rat.

No, Robert might be the ultimate rat conducting experiments on himself. He cannot be his own lab rat, he can only be running his own asylum.

> He records many subjective measures qualitatively, and feels he has made some significant discoveries doing so.

That sums it up perfectly. I suppose all this boils down to is whether you want your science science-y or feel-y. I prefer the science science. Because while I trust them in many things, I don't trust human emotions when making important decisions that are supposed to influence millions over millions of other humans.

I don't know Seth Roberts and I hope I don't come across as overly disrespectful. I'm not saying that it's impossible to make scientific discoveries this way. The problem is that any discovery you make is N=1 and as far away from a double-blind trial as it can be. So this might be an important tool to pre-select what you want to concentrate your actual science on.

But as with the Soylent stuff, I would never in a million years base my own health decisions on some quantified self guy on the internet.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by Blahah on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:57AM (#6248775)
'and they aren't subject to misinterpretation or wishful thinking.' ... right, and we have no way of knowing whether they are.

This is exactly why we have science: people have prior beliefs that affect how they perceive the thing they're trying to measure. People cannot objectively judge their own health in response to a variable. There are thousands of placebo studies that demonstrate this.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stonemetal on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:51AM (#6250234)
Ah so then you also believe horses can do math. After all we have proof: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by rsynnott on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @06:01AM (#6249065)
> you don't need to know how to interpret any obscure tests. You'll know.

You mean like the people who take homeopathic 'medicine'? They know. They're wrong, but they know.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by homosaur on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @08:42AM (#6249757)
This right here is how patent medicines and the like continue to sell. Placebo is powerful.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by obstacle1 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:23AM (#6248369)
>Imagine if there was a new drug that gave the mental benefits the guy reported after two weeks of use and saved you money too.

I found this drug that makes me feel way relaxed and totally content with the world. I don't do anything while on the drug, 'cause life's great just sitting here on the couch. As a consequence of sitting on my couch enjoying my great life, I don't spend any money, so I'm totally saving compared to before I took this drug. Pass the joint, man.

I'm legitimately not sure if your argument in this thread is serious. You are basically recommending we throw out any pretensions of objectivity or science or knowledge in favor of "do what you feel".

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by marze on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:30AM (#6248390)
"recommending we throw out any pretensions of objectivity or science or knowledge in favor of "do what you feel"."

Not so. Mental agility, weight, blood pressure are all easy and inexpensive to track.

A person's perception of how well they slept, overall feeling of well being, etc., can also be tracked if they are careful to quantify and record them.

I think you underestimate the power of carefully recorded data, which is at the core of the quantified self movement.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by obstacle1 on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:25AM (#6248519)
Here is what you said earlier:

>If your aim is for improved mental function, more energy, less health problems, etc., you don't need to know how to interpret any obscure tests. You'll know.

The above directly contradicts your most recent reply, since it obviously precludes the possibility of any meaningful quantification.

"Screw the tests, you'll know" is precisely the opposite of objective analysis. We'll know what? Nothing objective, that's for sure.

Since you appear to be arguing both for and against quantified self-style living in this thread, I can't help but wonder what your angle is. Are you actually just arguing for Soylent? Your position makes no sense, but you're enthusiastically defending the product, and you've done it in prior threads about Soylent, too.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by marze on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:52AM (#6248602)
I'm not arguing for Soylent, but arguing that people should personally test out low-risk dietary changes and see for themselves if they help.

Many argue against Soylent by arguing that we need some careful studies before anyone should try it. I think that is overkill for a food product like Soylent.

As for how to tell if Soylent or anything else is helping you, big changes should be obvious, smaller changes would require careful quantified-self style tracking to detect. Sorry if I wasn't more clear, but by obscure test I'm referring to blood work and other harder to interpret tests. Easy to interpret tests are reaction time, weight, fast arithmetic tests for mental agility, as well as recording qualitative feelings of health quantitatively, in a consistent and rigorous manner.

Edit:

As for this article on the Soylent trial, my take was it had "some promising initial signs given the short duration of the trial". Hardly blind enthusiasm.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by kybernetikos on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @03:17AM (#6248669)
Often, a strong expectation that a person will do well on a particular regime is enough to cause that person to do well on that particular regime. And I'm talking about measurable, physical changes.

I'd like to see some proper triple-blind studies involving people who haven't strongly invested themselves in the outcome.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by carbocation on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @12:07AM (#6248101)
Imagine that there was a drug that reduced your renal function by 25% in two weeks.[1]

People will see in this what they want to see. This is why case reports are evidence of the lowest grade. This is more a curio than it is evidence, and there is nothing wrong with writing a blog post about a curio.

1 = I think the creatinine bump is quite likely due to stochastic fluctuation, but if for discussion's sake we attribute all positive changes to Soylent, we should do the same for the negative ones.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by vidarh on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:18AM (#6248974)
As my doctor pointed out to me when I warned her to expect significantly elevated creatinine because of my protein supplementation: Raised creatinine in itself is not a "negative". Substantially raised creatinine may be a symptom of reduced renal function, but it is also a symptom of any number of other things - such as, indeed, increased protein intake.

It could be just fluctuating in his case, or it could very well be, given his past diet (how could he survive on that), that he was finally getting decent amounts of protein.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by carbocation on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:34AM (#6249003)
I think you might be thinking of BUN.

For creatinine, there is peer-reviewed data demonstrating that in people without renal disease, increasing the protein in your diet tends to improve your eGFR, not decrease it (which is what happened here). So for him, it either fluctuated or was a marker of true kidney disease, but in any case this is not just a marker of adequate protein intake.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by vidarh on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:58AM (#6249058)
Neither. I'm talking of creatinine levels in the blood, and my doctor was also very clear on that, and that it wasn't normally a concern at the levels she would expect to see from protein supplementation, but if it was too high, she'd need to establish filtration rate to rule out renal problems.

Also, while you may very well be right that GFR would improve, the little bits of reading I've had time to do indicates that unless they did eGFR by measuring his urine over 24 hours, then they likely estimated it from his creatinine levels, and so anything increasing creatinine levels would presumably cause the eGFR value to drop whether or not the increased creatinine levels are due to renal function or anything else.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by carbocation on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @09:31AM (#6250106)
The definition of eGFR is generally done from a random serum measurement (if you measure it in the classical but rarely done fashion, then you don't have to call it an estimate).

Also, creatinine is measured in serum to estimate gfr. Urine creatinine is more used as part of a test to look for nephrotic syndrome.

Creatinine is produced constantly, filtered and not resorbed, without active secretion, which is why it is an excellent proxy for glomerular filtration rate.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by stephenbez on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:26AM (#6248373)
From this NYTimes article (http://www.nytimes.com/1986/09/07/business/the-ever-fatter-b...): "The Government forced all liquid protein products off the market after they were implicated in 59 deaths."

The article doesn't give many details, but it looks like changes in diet can be dangerous.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by vidarh on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:24AM (#6248837)
No, it looks like people can be scared by correlation.

Of course changes in diet can be dangerous (you just try switching to an all cyanide diet).

But "liquid protein products"? Like milk? Or protein shakes? There are certainly plenty of "liquid protein products" on the market, and heavily used, and tons more protein products sold as powders to be mixed with water, milk or juice by consumers.

Somehow we don't have weightlifters dropping like flies.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by venomsnake on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:51AM (#6248915)
Milk cannot not be liquid protein product by almost any sane definition. It has more fat and more carbohydrates per gram than protein.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by vidarh on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @05:15AM (#6248970)
Most protein products have substantial amounts of carbs and fat. The point is not - unless you are buying pure protein products or "diet" protein shakes for cutting - to avoid carbs and fat, but to get more protein.

It is far easier to stomach large amounts of protein (due to taste and consistency) when mixed with a lot of carbs than alone, and unless you're cutting you generally need a lot of carbs too when training hard, so there's little incentive for most general protein supplements to keep carbs down.

In fact, there are a large number of protein supplements on the market where the majority of calories comes from carbs and fat, and many will have more carbs alone by weight than protein (many often also are specifically advertised for weight gain / bulking).

They are still commonly referred to as protein products because the main basis for calling something a protein supplement amongst suppliers and people using them is generally large amounts of protein, not low amounts of carbs and fats. (And yes, that means some of them - intentionally - have massive amounts of calories)

You also probably talk about "pure" milk, but there's also a number of milk products on the market that are milk + extra casein extracted from milk, for very high protein concentrations - my favourite has about 40g of protein per 300ml; you are free to not accept that as "milk", but it tastes like milk and is generally marketed as "protein milk" or similar.

But milk alone is also frequently used by weight lifters for the decent protein content and good ration of protein, carbs and fat (a well known "supplemental diet" for bulking for lifters is called GOMAD: Gallon Of Milk A Day)

The main point being that large amounts of protein is being ingested in liquid form every day all around the world, and has been for decades, and we're not seeing mass deaths.

Barring actual evidence to the contrary, there's very little reason to believe that the deaths referenced in the article had anything to do with getting "liquid protein", and very good reasons to believe it was hysteria.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by gwern on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:58PM (#6252167)
> Imagine if there was a new drug that gave the mental benefits the guy reported after two weeks of use and saved you money too. It would be front page news.

He used

> Finally, I took some tests on Quantified-Mind.com to measure my mental alertness while I was eating my typical diet of burritos and Diet Wild Cherry Pepsi. In this way, I could try to reproduce Rhinehart’s claim that Soylent improves mental acuity.

Those tests tend to exhibit substantial practice effects until you've done them a lot.

And then there's the obvious placebo effect. I present to you a training regime which due essentially to an expectancy effect by subjects can increase your IQ by 9 points... or 2 points: http://www.gwern.net/DNB%20meta-analysis Quite a difference.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by IanCal on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:44AM (#6248890)
> Imagine if there was a new drug that gave the mental benefits the guy reported after two weeks of use and saved you money too. It would be front page news.

Sell people a green pill and tell them it'll make them want fast food less. Done.

Make it more dramatic and you'll get a better effect. Expensive helps, requiring it to be injected would help even more.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by ekianjo on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:16AM (#6248813)
> Imagine if there was a new drug that gave the mental benefits the guy reported after two weeks of use and saved you money too. It would be front page news.

Benefits are not self-assessed for drugs.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by ParkerK on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @11:12PM (#6247950)
>Finally, a DEXA scan is really silly in this scenario. It's for old ladies and others at risk for osteoporosis.

Actually, DEXA can be used for very accurate calculations of body fat %, so it could be used to show how much lean body mass (as opposed to fat) the author lost.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by cabinguy on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @10:10PM (#6247761)
DEXA scans can be used to accurately measure body fat, too.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by andyakb on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @02:26AM (#6248522)
Right. I would wager money that this is why they were suggested; to measure muscle preservation
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by ekianjo on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @09:58PM (#6247725)
> First, EGFR is not "Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor"

I LOLed at that one. He clearly didn't get the acronym and went for one of the cancer mutation indicator seen in several lung cancers.

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by typicalrunt on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @10:55PM (#6247895)
Even funnier, the first sentence in the Wikipedia entry for EGFR states:

This article is about a cell surface receptor. For estimated measure of kidney function (eGFR), see Glomerular filtration rate.

The author could have taken a few minutes to research both the EGFR for cell surface receptor and the kidney function measure and come to a reasonably good conclusion as to which one is used on the lab tests. Instead...

Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by billybob255 on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @10:10PM (#6247760)
Just a little more on DEXA scans; it might be a little much for someone like the blogger, but they are valuable for measuring central adiposity.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by richcollins on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @01:15AM (#6248337)
Dexa scan is used to measure body composition in this case.
Re:Soylent: What Happened When I Stopped Eating For 2 Weeks by venomsnake on Wednesday August 21, 2013 @04:53AM (#6248923)
Can you give more details about the article "not eating for a year". I can't seem to find it, and I don't know how it is possible to maintain the nitrogen balance for so long.