News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by jcase on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @07:25PM (#6208987)
Not sure if you mean for profit and proprietary or just making money in general. For some reason though a lot of people think you can't sell GPL'd software which you absolutely can.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by foobarbazqux on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @08:00PM (#6209137)
Why would I pay for a copy of some GPL software when I could just wait for someone else to buy it and then get it from them for free?
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by belorn on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @08:49PM (#6209331)
#1 Support?

#2 Hosting/cloudiness?

#3 Administration?

#4 Custom adaptation?

#5 Privileged early access to updates/content files?

All those different strategies has been used to "sell" GPL software. Even the last one has been used, even if their customers could repackage the update and redistribute it to non-paying customers.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by pjmlp on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:32AM (#6210171)
All of them fail for desktop software, this is why FOSS as business works only for developer tools or SaaS software.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by gillianseed on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @06:30AM (#6210729)
Not necessarily. For example there's the model used by the x264 project (and upcoming x265 project), they offer the encoder as free software under GPL but they also sell licences for using it in proprietary projects and apparnetly they (the developers) make good money this way.

Then there's the recent example of Openshot, a GPL licenced video editor where the author went to kickstarter to gain funding for improving it greatly, the goal was $20.000 and it reached $45,028.

I see a combination of these models as a future popular way of making money out of your open source efforts.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by foobarbazqux on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:15AM (#6211253)
Selling licenses for use in proprietary software is not selling GPL software. In particular, I can not sell you a proprietary x264 license for software that I received under the GPL.

Dual-licensing effectively says, "We'll let you take away user freedoms, but only if you pay the original copyright holders." Which is akin to openly bribing communist party officials.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by pjmlp on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:14AM (#6210843)
Your first example is a developer tool, as mentioned by me.

Kickstarter projects is USA specific, and it seldom works if you need a steady income of money.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by gillianseed on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:35AM (#6210918)
It's a video encoder, hardly a 'developer tool'.

As for steady income of money, true that this type of funding isn't of the steady pay-check variety but if you can continue to add value to your project then it could become a long term income.

Either way I'd say the vast majority of open source desktop software today is done without any compensation and during developers spare-time, things like kickstarter opens up possibilities for them to actually make money while doing what they would likely have done either way, and it can also give them the financial opportunity to work exclusively on the project for a period of time.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by pjmlp on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:31AM (#6216443)
> It's a video encoder, hardly a 'developer tool'.

Quoting from the VideoLAN web site, > x264 is a free software library and application

That is a developer tool on my language.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by teddyh on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:55AM (#6210219)
Perhaps. But even if no-one would pay money for a direct software download/package, this does not preclude sponsorship of companies to free software projects they wish to be more developed. Indeed, there are many such large projects.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by nisa on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @08:45PM (#6209311)
Derivates of GPL software are also GPL licenced. If you use a lot of GPL code in your product you have to provide the source.

The possibility of a dual licence gives the creator a compensation because he waives the rights the GPL gives him for you.

Also: Support contracts. A lot of poeple live in the support ecosystem and adapt GPL/BSD software for costumers.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by GalacticDomin8r on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @09:14PM (#6209418)
> If you use a lot of GPL code in your product you have to provide the source.

Fixed:

If you use ANY GPL code in your product you have to provide the source.(There are of course exeptions eg LGPL)

Also it isn't simply derivative work that that can be forced to re-license under the GPLv3. If FreeBSD had elected to adopt a GPLv3 compiler and distribute the source(as they do with the compiler) then the FreeBSD kernel itself would become subject to it. In fact, it isn't just gcc which has this restriction. Any GPL v3 code isn't allowed in base.

Further reading:

http://www.freebsdfoundation.org/press/2007Aug-newsletter.sh...

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by nly on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @10:46PM (#6209687)
Nonsense. Just putting GCC source code in to the BSD repository wouldn't magically spread the requirement that the entire project become GPL any more than keeping a copy on my hard drive requires I give the FSF the complete contents of my /home directory. What matters is the dependency/linkage.

The GCC 'runtime library exception' firewalls all 'target code' from the GPLv3, and even allows proprietary preprocessors, linkers and assemblers (but nothing that would involve modifying GCC to split what it does in to more granular stages)

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by foobarbazqux on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @11:12PM (#6209753)
In particular, Apple shipped GCC with Darwin.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by TylerE on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @10:03PM (#6209580)
If you're going to be a pedant, get it right.

You have to license any code that links with GPL code under the GPL. This does not prevent you from dual-licensing your own portion of the code base, or shipping non-GPL, non-linked code as part of the same product (Although in the case of things like DLL plugins it gets a bit hazy)

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by rickjames28 on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @11:42PM (#6209820)
You have to license any code that links with GPL code under the GPL. This does not prevent you from dual-licensing your own portion of the code base, or shipping non-GPL, non-linked code as part of the same product (Although in the case of things like DLL plugins it gets a bit hazy)

Actually, that's a common, but wrong interpretation. The whole work becomes GPL, but the code that links to GPL code doesn't have to be GPL.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by foobarbazqux on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @11:46PM (#6209838)
It has to be "GPL-compatible" though, which means whoever you give it to can convert it to the GPL by adding the extra conditions of the GPL to it.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by nly on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @08:51PM (#6209333)
Most commercial GPL software outfits make their money by dual-licensing, or charging for support or bespoke add-ons.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by foobarbazqux on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:29AM (#6211327)
I pointed this out elsewhere, but dual-licensing isn't selling GPL software; it's more like giving away proprietary software under the GPL.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by wes-exp on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @09:18PM (#6209431)
You can sell GPL software. It's just really hard to actually make money :-P
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by kkowalczyk on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @10:07PM (#6209595)
You can put a price on GPL software.

What you shouldn't do is to hope that anyone will pay you.

The first person who pays can offer exactly the same thing for $0.

It's impossible to convince anyone that they should pay you even $1 if exactly the same thing is available for $0 from somewhere else.

The ability to charge for GPL software is purely theoretical. In practice, you can't.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by krrrh on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @11:04PM (#6209729)
Not true. Just see MySQL for one example. Before Oracle bought MySQL AB (for $1 billion) their revenues on commercial support for their largely GPLv2 software was in the tens of millions. The same may already be true for Monty Program AB who provide commercial support for MariaDB. The closer you get to infrastructure, the more being open source is a competitive advantage.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by pjmlp on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @02:41AM (#6210192)
This is not the case with most open source software.

Actually the majority of corporations are leechers, using it as "free beer", only paying back if they really have to, as many corporations don't use software without support contracts.

Or happen to have some FOSS followers taking business decisions.

Otherwise, I can tell you from my experience working on Fortune 500 consulting projects, very seldom is any money or contribution given back.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by joesb on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:52AM (#6210501)
I thought MySQL AB has dual licensing model and that business can pay for commercial non-GPL MySQL.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by icebraining on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:07AM (#6210537)
It's impossible to convince anyone that they should pay you even $1 if exactly the same thing is available for $0 from somewhere else.

Radiohead's In Rainbows, the Humble Bundles and other pay-what-you-want sales disprove that statement. All had average purchase prices well above the minimum. (That doesn't mean such a model is very profitable compared to fixed prices, of course.)

Even in a purely self-interested point of view, there are reasons for paying (e.g. keeping development active).

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by pjmlp on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:50AM (#6216491)
Those are one shot successes, hardly a model to follow for anyone that needs a steady source of income to pay things like mortgage, employees and such.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by icebraining on Friday August 16, 2013 @09:44AM (#6223914)
Those are one shot successes

Maybe so; can you point out those cases where the average payment for a pay-what-you-want sale was no higher than the absolute minimum?

hardly a model to follow for anyone that needs a steady source of income to pay things like mortgage, employees and such.

That's a very different claim from what I was contesting.

But in any case, it may work in when you have modest needs; Joey Hess just got his second year of development of Git-Annex funded[1]. Of course, not everyone is willing to work for $15k/year, even if it comes with few strings attached, particularly obviously talented and experienced developers like him.

[1] https://campaign.joeyh.name/

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by pjmlp on Friday August 16, 2013 @11:55AM (#6224773)
> Of course, not everyone is willing to work for $15k/year

That is the main point, in Germany you can earn around 5x that on an average consulting job.

Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by icebraining on Monday August 19, 2013 @11:24AM (#6237709)
You don't get the freedom he has, though, both in terms of working hours, location, etc.
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by justincormack on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @03:57AM (#6210362)
Redhat seems to make money...
Re:Why is FreeBSD deprecating GCC in favor of Clang/LLVM? by joesb on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:54AM (#6210505)
They sell supports. Theorically, they don't even have to contribute to development of Linux at all.