It's not because political discussions aren't important, they are, but because I don't think this is a useful place to have them.
Counterarguments are self-censored, because any moderates calmly pointing out hyperboles tend to be downvoted by the more passionate participants in the discussion.
With the moderates bowing out, online voting systems quickly gel into two extremes, maybe a far right and a far left. That's not sustainable though, one side quickly gets bigger and wins. The losing side now is best off self-censoring, because why get downvoted when you can just comment on other topics? You eventually get a political monoculture representing one extreme, with no voices of opposition or moderation.*
No moderation system has yet promoted any useful political dialogue, because you can't convince the 5% of people who are most emotional to rate argument quality independently of personal beliefs.
That's why, in general, I'm opposed to the political pulpit of HN, even for positions I agree with. It's a bad medium for good discussions on issues of significant controversy.
* (What's admittedly tricky is sometimes a political monoculture is the correct result. If someone made arguments on behalf of the KKK, we don't need a full and fair debate providing a false equivalence between both sides. One side is just wrong. The problem is, with politics, everyone thinks they're arguing against someone else who is just wrong, just like the KKK. There's no objective way to determine whether or not both sides of a discussion hold merit worthy of a full debate, or whether we should just downvote one side out of the discussion before it leaves the gate.)
Literally any valid view of American history would immediately demonstrate that we are moving forward in terms of overall liberty, not backward. With the possible exception of disenfranchised minority groups and lower classes, there has been increasing political transparency and quality of life in every respect, and the former are only still mistreated because of the power vacuum in their communities.
The only reason why this is so outrageous is because people have short memories - I doubt many people are as shocked at this who lived through the Nixon Watergate scandal. That kind of corruption wouldn't so easily take place today.
I think "Worse is Better" applies here. Political discussions in online forums (or anywhere) aren't ideal, but I still think it's better to have them than not to.
HN I'd actually say has better discourse than just about anywhere else online, as hackers, more often than not, are open to revising their opinions and ideas based on objective fact. After all, you wouldn't get terribly far coding were you to doggedly retain irrational beliefs about the subject matter you're engaging in.
As to downvoting - not so much, I don't think. HN's moderation system is pretty effective in ensuring that poor voters and contributors don't get to continue doing so.
The SNR here is still much better than, say, reddit.
Finally, the argument of "we shouldn't talk about this, because it's polarising" is a dangerous one, as ultimately it serves only to stifle discourse.
I'm not sure if that's a net benefit or a net negative (it looks to be a benefit), one would hope adults can at least agree to disagree.
I do not respect people with opinions held out of dogma, with an unwillingness to explore other viewpoints.
Then again, my personal proclivities cannot possibly be taken as representative of the entirety of HN, so I take your point.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6062466
... or you deliberately reduce arguments to inflammatory absurdities to try to win them:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6064531
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6006933
... or you just get mad and yell:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6062497
In ~75 days of comments I didn't see you once acknowledge a point anyone else here made, even one that agreed with you. It appears that in the past ~quarter or so, you haven't observed a single argument that you managed to simultaneously disagree with and "respect".
We should be able to presume that you know your own comments better than I could know them in 5 minutes of skimming, so I invite you to prove me wrong and show me the place in the last 2 months where you demonstrated this appreciation of well-formed comments you disagree with.
Actually, I take your point, in its entirety. I can be quite the little shrike when it comes to political discussions, and I often manage to undermine my own point with my approach - although I think you have just managed a pretty great "the worst of" collection!
That said, just to provide you one recent little counterexample -
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6180222 - looks, there's me responding to your actually also reductio ad absurdum comment (it's an acronym so he's scared of it), in a balanced fashion!
But more often than not I don't feel the need to go "let's agree to disagree", in part because I loathe the phrase, and in part because even if I get and appreciate someone's counterargument, if I don't agree with them I'm unlikely to laud it.
But... I think you're right about the last few months. The Snowden affair has bought out the raving pareidoliac in me, and I've slewed from largely discussing engineering and science to, as you say, almost purely politics.
https://news.ycombinator.com/x?fnid=HnDzLnVwDzevzYJN1zt8QU - different dude, although I'm still a cranky old man.
Either way - thanks for providing an adjustment to my outlook, as it was evidently needed.
In fact, the attempt to distill a simple observation into a pointed personal attack is a good illustration of the kinds of bullshit arguments that happen on political threads here.
I don't feel good about singling you out and do appreciate the calm response to what was certainly an aggressive comment upthread. Please understand, I don't know you or really anything about you; it's not personal. My problem is with politics on HN.
Anyway - I see your point. I too worry that we're a) septembering and b) potentially balkanising on lines that this community shouldn't be balkanised upon.
I just try to take the optimistic view that HN'ers are collectively wise and mature enough to not get put out by internet bar fights, and to see them for what they are, without losing the signal.
You're right, as moderation systems and communities go, this is one of the better ones.
Please note, though, I wasn't saying we shouldn't talk about this, we should. I was saying we shouldn't talk about this with a voting system attached, because that structurally predisposes a forum towards a one-sided discussion.
In hindsight, I probably should have just solicited an "Ask HN: What's the best forum moderation system for political discussions?" instead of hijacking this thread.
I am a US citizen and my opinion matters as much as yours does.
This way, someone could vote for a third option knowing that it won't help the opposing party.
American voters don't elect the President, anyway, they elect Presidential electors; if you had more proportional (compared to FPTP single member districts) representation for the Congress [1], and PR within each states slate of electors for the Electoral College (for the EC, party-list proportional could work rather than candidate-centered), and then change the rules for the EC so that the whole EC meets physically and has a set time to elect a President and VP by majority otherwise those elections fall to the House and Senate, you'd neatly solve the problem of duopoly.
[1] Without abandoning candidate-centered elections and equal representation in the Senate, my preferred method of doing this for the Congress would be to add senators so that each state had 3 instead of 2, elect a slate of 3 Senators from each State every 6 years using Single Transferrable Vote, and also elect the House by STV every 2 years, dividing states up into House districts as follows:
If a state has 1-5 seats in the House, it has one district;
If a state 6 or more seats in the House, it is divided as evenly as possible in to districts of not less than 3 and not more than 5 members.
If by 2-turn you mean majority-runoff, that still has perverse incentives against voting for other than the more preferred major party candidate, though slightly less so than does plurality.
Highly less, I would say.
When the two most voted candidates go to the second round, you may vote for a third candidate knowing that, in case this preferred one fails, there is still the chance to vote against the one you hate more in the second round.
In a single-run voting, people are more compelled to vote against the candidate the hate more, instead of voting for the one they like more.
Not really. Its not like majority-runoff isn't a commonly used (in the US, even), highly studied election method, known to have very similar effects in terms of reinforcing duopoly to plurality.
It was silly enough to give the Nobel Peace Prize to somebody who hadn't really done anything worthwhile yet (but showed promise), but then to have that person act in such an extreme opposite to what the prize is supposed to stand for is just unreal.
That said, he could have done a better job living up to it.
That being said - a few drone strikes is a lot more peaceful than starting two big wars like his predecessor did.
Personally, i think we should never underestimate how petty people in power can be: I think the committee handing out the prize were like star-struck teenage girls and wanted to meet Obama.
Surely it is possible to imagine more of them.
> An optional war in Libya.
With a UN mandate, almost completely fought by the Europeans.
> Continuing a failed war in Afghanistan. However what he is doing is quite different from starting a war in Afghanistan.
Here you might have a point.
> Continuing to operate Gitmo.
Congress did that.
> Continuing and expanding the spying on US citizens and others.
This is terrible.
> If anything, Obama has expanded warfare to anyplace in the world that can't stop drones. Peaceful isn't an adjective that should be used in conjunction with this President.
Relatively peaceful compared to W. That is what I said, and I think it is accurate.
He's not a political incompetent. He could take the teeth out of it, unless congress is the commander in chief now.
That may have been the stated reason, but I doubt it was the real reason. Would a white male president have received the Nobel for that? Doubt it.
I think many people interpreted it as being awarded to Obama for having busted the glass ceiling, even if the Nobel committee went with a more pedestrian official explanation.
For what it's worth, I suspect Obama would have declined the prize if it were possible to do so. It came at a really inconvenient time.
It's possible to decline the Nobel Peace Prize. For instance, when the prize was jointly awarded to Henri Kissinger (Kissinger) and Le Duc Tho, Le Duc Tho declined to claim his prize and the associated rewards, because he didn't want to share a prize with Kissinger.
http://blog.heritage.org/2009/12/10/does-obama%E2%80%99s-nob...
For those of us who are hawks, it was followed by a 150,000 man armored invasion of South Vietnam, employing more tanks than used in any WWII battle. Which the South crushed with the help of US ammo and air support, only 40,000 managed to make it back home sans their equipment.
That worked the 2nd time they tried it due to Watergate denying the South ammo, which I don't believe he had anything to do with. But no matter how grim the outcome in Southeast Asia, including the Cambodian genocide, outfitting the North with three complete armored armies (the first was used up piecemeal) was critical in bankrupting the USSR and the peaceful end of the Cold War, which otherwise could have ended in even more megadeaths. And I think he gets some credit for keeping us alive when the Democrats turned dovish after one of their's was no longer in the Oval Office.
At least I'd know where to aim my spit. The mixed-up nature of the current prize is for the birds.
No awards during WWI except to the International Red Cross (ICRC).
1927: Ferdinand Buisson, France, Ludwig Quidde, Germany: "[For] contributions to Franco-German popular reconciliation" Well, at least they tried....
Same for WWII; the ICRC did fully earn their prizes to my knowledge.
While he didn't get an award for it, George Marshall was the USArmy Chief of Staff, top dog in uniform along with Admiral Ernest King.
It was rather delayed, but Begin and Sadat's 1978 prize ratified Israel's 1967 Six-Day War victory.
Excepting perhaps Norman Borlaug (Green Revolution), Lech Wałęsa (key role in the peaceful end of the Cold War), and Gorbachev (ditto, not that that was his intent), I don't think any of the awardees, or possibly all of them combined, did as much for "peace" (saving lives) as Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin did in ending WWII (Stalin of course gets a big asterisk because he was instrumental in starting it, and didn't join the other side until a figurative gun was at his head (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Barbarossa) ).
E.g. the "Greater East-Asian Co-Prosperity Sphere" was killing an estimated quarter million people a month when we terminated with extreme prejudice Imperial Japan 68 years ago this week.
"Political satire became obsolete when Henry Kissinger was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize." https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Tom_Lehrer
In short, the Vietnam ceasefire and American withdrawal wasn't a small thing, it's not his fault it eventually ended badly, and it bankrupted the USSR.
That none of the above contribute to satisfying governance should come as no surprise. I am (naively?) surprised that his administration turned out to so enthusiastically continue and expand the Bush era policies. It gives some credence to the idea that the administrations themselves are not primary drivers of policy. Or that power enjoys power and will forevermore.
FWIW a prominent member of Northern California's ACLU told me she believes that prioritization of healthcare is what has sidelined civil rights in this administration. I do not find her explanation entirely satisfying.
A lot of people who looked at his record and background were not in the least surprised that he "so enthusiastically continue[d] and expand[ed] the Bush era policies" As you posit, it has to do with power.
>she believes that prioritization of healthcare is what has sidelined civil rights in this administration
I think healthcare was more important for this administration to deal with than civil rights, which aren't rapidly declining except due to the disaster that both healthcare spending and lack of health care has done to this country. It's affecting black people a lot more than others mainly because of our relatively tenuous hold on the middle class.
Problem is that he used up all of his goodwill on the healthcare fight, using rhetoric to push it as if he was conjuring up a new utopia, but just managed to entrench insurers and corporate rent-seekers more into the process, and to only mildly increase the footprint of coverage. The main benefit of what he passed is that it will slow the growth of healthcare spending just enough to make it difficult for conservative-libertarian scum to paint Social Security as an immanent danger anymore.
To celebrate this exceedingly minor victory, he's been trying his level best to cut Social Security by raising the retirement age, changing the inflation indexing, and acknowledging dopey schemes like means-testing. The worst part is IMO, he thinks that cutting ("saving," in centrist rhetoric) Social Security is going to be his legacy, and that history is going to view him as a hero for it.
I just don't understand why people care that a drone launched the missile rather than an A-10 or an F-18?
To me, the problem is killing people. Killing people is wrong and you shouldn't do it. Shouldn't matter what means you have at your disposal. "How hard is this to do?" is not a proxy for "Should I do this?"
If your counter is, "sure, abstractly that's right, but now how actual governments think", I guess I agree, but you're never going to talk them down from that by pressuring them to use less efficient killing machines. "But we have all these people to kill!" You're better off being angry about the decision to murder all these people, regardless of how it's done.
Edit: grammar
Killing people is wrong, no matter what excuse you can come up with. Even killing terrorists is wrong.
Even killing Bin Laden was wrong, even if it was done by boots on the ground rather than by drone strike. (I assume they wanted confirmation of the kill).
Hauling him in front of a judge and having after due process and assuming he'd be found guilty serve the rest of his life behind bars would be acceptable.
2- Use of drones makes this worse, because they distort the traditional situation of war, where soldiers fight each other at a personal risk to themselves.
This, on the contrary, is the moral equivalent of shooting someone in the back.
In 18th century literary "salons" in Europe, people used to study moral dilemmas. One of the questions was "here's a button here that if pressed, would kill a very rich Chinese person. Upon her death, you would inherit all of her wealth. You don't know this person and you will never be associated with her death. Will you press the button?"
At the time it was an entirely rhetorical question, and yet it generated a lot of debate and moral questioning.
Today the question isn't rhetorical anymore (and "wealth" has been replaced by "a mild and temporary sentiment of increased security") and yet the moral debate has all but evaporated.
How we allow ourselves to feel morally superior to 18th century aristocrats is beyond me.
Anything to back that up? These are extensive extra-judicial killings, outside of 'war' by any meaningful definition, which in my book makes them wrong even in the (highly implausible) best case where every victim is a genuine evil-doer.
See e.g. http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/may/12/pakista...
The use of force abroad exists purely in the political, diplomatic, and military realms, not the legal realm. If Pakistanis want us to stop drone strikes in Pakistan, they'll have to resort to one of those avenues.
Again, you are incorrect. International treaties are legally binding. What is the purpose of the Geneva Conventions, for instance, if the U.S. can, according to you, sign them, ignore them, and not have broken international law?
Outside of US courts international law is irrelevant as applied to the US. We're not a party to the ICC and we have veto power over any enforcement decision of the ICJ.
We're getting a bit into the woods here, but veto power over the enforcement of UN rulings _does_ _not_ change international law. You can say that it is irrelevant because it is unenforceable, but _it_ _is_ _not_ legal for the U.S. to violate international treaties which it has signed. This is "legally binding". This is what that means.
The U.S. can overrule any enforcement decision, as you said. It cannot determine the ruling in any ICJ case.
See: Nicaragua v. United States.
> At least 1 in 5 drone strike victims a confirmed civilian – leaked Pakistani records
http://rt.com/news/drone-strikes-pakistan-civilian-casualtie...
(I'm not making a moral argument about drone strikes, but the fact that you bring up in no way refutes `rayiner's.)
That is, if we believe the U.S. is making a good enough attempt to avoid civilian casualties in drone strikes, which is questionable.
Also, looks like you can't see that this scenario will only make more terrorists, because you seed hate between people. If you want someone to respect you and be your friend you don't really need to bomb, kill or bully him. And you know what, sorry to burst your bubble, but your GOV is doing all that shit on purpose, so they can defend you from terrorist -> by spying on everything you do.
No one in Yemen is waging war on the US, that's a construct of the creative imaginations of a bunch of people that stand to profit from having a bogeyman so they can sell their toys.
The people in the tribal lands of Yemen can't wage war on the US since:
(1) they don't have air strike capabilities able to reach the continental US
(2) they don't have a shared border where a land war could be waged
(3) they don't stand a chance of getting a boat in US coastal waters Yemeni people or people residing there are not waging war on the USA.
To which I respond:
> We have not declared war on Yemen or Pakistan.
Which means that our military actions in Yemen or Pakistan are illegal. This is still ignoring other obvious questionable points about drone strikes, such as issues regarding proportionality.
I'm more interested in his actions; among these we find (by decreasing order of importance):
- use of drones to indiscriminately kill civilians, "suspected terrorists" or their children (cf. the murder of 16 years old American citizen Abdulrahman al-Awlaki)
- the detention, and ruthless and aggressive prosecution of Bradley Manning
- force-feeding Guantanamo detainees on hunger strike, depriving them of even the right to end their own life
I'm not a US citizen, so what I think about Obama really doesn't matter; but he must have set some kind of record in the amount of goodwill he was able to destroy during his time in office.