Literally any valid view of American history would immediately demonstrate that we are moving forward in terms of overall liberty, not backward. With the possible exception of disenfranchised minority groups and lower classes, there has been increasing political transparency and quality of life in every respect, and the former are only still mistreated because of the power vacuum in their communities.
The only reason why this is so outrageous is because people have short memories - I doubt many people are as shocked at this who lived through the Nixon Watergate scandal. That kind of corruption wouldn't so easily take place today.
I think "Worse is Better" applies here. Political discussions in online forums (or anywhere) aren't ideal, but I still think it's better to have them than not to.
HN I'd actually say has better discourse than just about anywhere else online, as hackers, more often than not, are open to revising their opinions and ideas based on objective fact. After all, you wouldn't get terribly far coding were you to doggedly retain irrational beliefs about the subject matter you're engaging in.
As to downvoting - not so much, I don't think. HN's moderation system is pretty effective in ensuring that poor voters and contributors don't get to continue doing so.
The SNR here is still much better than, say, reddit.
Finally, the argument of "we shouldn't talk about this, because it's polarising" is a dangerous one, as ultimately it serves only to stifle discourse.
I'm not sure if that's a net benefit or a net negative (it looks to be a benefit), one would hope adults can at least agree to disagree.
I do not respect people with opinions held out of dogma, with an unwillingness to explore other viewpoints.
Then again, my personal proclivities cannot possibly be taken as representative of the entirety of HN, so I take your point.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6062466
... or you deliberately reduce arguments to inflammatory absurdities to try to win them:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6064531
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6006933
... or you just get mad and yell:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6062497
In ~75 days of comments I didn't see you once acknowledge a point anyone else here made, even one that agreed with you. It appears that in the past ~quarter or so, you haven't observed a single argument that you managed to simultaneously disagree with and "respect".
We should be able to presume that you know your own comments better than I could know them in 5 minutes of skimming, so I invite you to prove me wrong and show me the place in the last 2 months where you demonstrated this appreciation of well-formed comments you disagree with.
Actually, I take your point, in its entirety. I can be quite the little shrike when it comes to political discussions, and I often manage to undermine my own point with my approach - although I think you have just managed a pretty great "the worst of" collection!
That said, just to provide you one recent little counterexample -
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6180222 - looks, there's me responding to your actually also reductio ad absurdum comment (it's an acronym so he's scared of it), in a balanced fashion!
But more often than not I don't feel the need to go "let's agree to disagree", in part because I loathe the phrase, and in part because even if I get and appreciate someone's counterargument, if I don't agree with them I'm unlikely to laud it.
But... I think you're right about the last few months. The Snowden affair has bought out the raving pareidoliac in me, and I've slewed from largely discussing engineering and science to, as you say, almost purely politics.
https://news.ycombinator.com/x?fnid=HnDzLnVwDzevzYJN1zt8QU - different dude, although I'm still a cranky old man.
Either way - thanks for providing an adjustment to my outlook, as it was evidently needed.
In fact, the attempt to distill a simple observation into a pointed personal attack is a good illustration of the kinds of bullshit arguments that happen on political threads here.
I don't feel good about singling you out and do appreciate the calm response to what was certainly an aggressive comment upthread. Please understand, I don't know you or really anything about you; it's not personal. My problem is with politics on HN.
Anyway - I see your point. I too worry that we're a) septembering and b) potentially balkanising on lines that this community shouldn't be balkanised upon.
I just try to take the optimistic view that HN'ers are collectively wise and mature enough to not get put out by internet bar fights, and to see them for what they are, without losing the signal.
You're right, as moderation systems and communities go, this is one of the better ones.
Please note, though, I wasn't saying we shouldn't talk about this, we should. I was saying we shouldn't talk about this with a voting system attached, because that structurally predisposes a forum towards a one-sided discussion.
In hindsight, I probably should have just solicited an "Ask HN: What's the best forum moderation system for political discussions?" instead of hijacking this thread.
It's not because political discussions aren't important, they are, but because I don't think this is a useful place to have them.
Counterarguments are self-censored, because any moderates calmly pointing out hyperboles tend to be downvoted by the more passionate participants in the discussion.
With the moderates bowing out, online voting systems quickly gel into two extremes, maybe a far right and a far left. That's not sustainable though, one side quickly gets bigger and wins. The losing side now is best off self-censoring, because why get downvoted when you can just comment on other topics? You eventually get a political monoculture representing one extreme, with no voices of opposition or moderation.*
No moderation system has yet promoted any useful political dialogue, because you can't convince the 5% of people who are most emotional to rate argument quality independently of personal beliefs.
That's why, in general, I'm opposed to the political pulpit of HN, even for positions I agree with. It's a bad medium for good discussions on issues of significant controversy.
* (What's admittedly tricky is sometimes a political monoculture is the correct result. If someone made arguments on behalf of the KKK, we don't need a full and fair debate providing a false equivalence between both sides. One side is just wrong. The problem is, with politics, everyone thinks they're arguing against someone else who is just wrong, just like the KKK. There's no objective way to determine whether or not both sides of a discussion hold merit worthy of a full debate, or whether we should just downvote one side out of the discussion before it leaves the gate.)