News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by rayiner on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:37PM (#6149165)
Probably more accurate title: Americans didn't realize they smelled bad until marketers pointed out otherwise. If you've ever been to a part of the world where deodorant use is less common, you know its not a marketing-manufactured problem. The fact that people get used to it (like people get used to the garbage smell in New York) doesn't mean it isn't a real problem.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by nostrademons on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:23PM (#6149431)
Well, sort of. I think a lot of the distinction between yours' and the articles' title comes from confusion over objective vs. subjective experiences.

Here's the objective fact: when you sweat a lot, molecules corresponding to pheromones in your skin and bacteria that live on it (particularly in enclosed areas like armpits) waft into the air around you and enter the noses of nearby people. This triggers nerve impulses that travel to the brain and give the sensation of "smell".

Here's the subjective fact: you smell bad.

People often lift their subjective impressions to the level of objective facts, because they have no other experience to compare it to. But the brain is remarkably plastic, and people continually underestimate how much their subjective experience of something can change through exposure and perspective shifts.

Here's another objective fact: when researchers have exposed subjects to smell for a long period of time (usually hours is enough) and then MRI'd their brain, the neural pathways related to smell cease to fire. Prolonged exposure deadens the experience; the brain is no longer interested in smells that are no longer novel. Subjectively, the subject ceases to smell the offensive odor at all.

And from an evolutionary perspective, this makes perfect sense: smell is our early warning system for situations that might present danger or opportunity (eg. bacterial contamination, an aggressive rival, a desirable mate), but if we don't act immediately on that information, there's no purpose in continuing to smell the odor. Presumably we are unable to act otherwise, and continuing to fire those nerves just overloads the brain when it could better use that processing power elsewhere.

So both you and the article are right. You do smell natives who don't use deodorant - when you first encounter them. But if you lived shoulder to shoulder with them for years, as people did before deodorant was invented, you would cease to smell them, and it would cease to become a problem.

The way marketers work is to highlight the instances where it is a problem, so they enter your consciousness, and then reoccur in your consciousness whenever the stimulus occurs. Instead of "I stink, but I can't do anything about it, so why worry about it?" you think "I stink. I should put on some deodorant."

I've got lots more to say about how this affects adoption of products and cultural values (basically: you cannot get people to adopt a radically different innovation without relying on or creating some insecurity. If you can't create insecurity, you have to wait for everyone who was secure with the lack of your product to die off), but this comment is already pretty long...

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by mpyne on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:31PM (#6149469)
It's very much like how you don't realize how bad a submarine smells (due to atmosphere control chemicals) when you're submerged and underway, unless you're doing things like running the diesel engine or venting waste tanks inboard.

But once you get back home it becomes obvious how smelly everything from the boat really is.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by drcube on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:52PM (#6149265)
It kind of does. No one is hurt by bad smells, and at the very worst, you have to deal with a few unpleasant moments before your senses recalibrate, and then you don't notice the odor anymore. And when everybody smells more or less the same, nobody has to feel inferior.

Marketers basically invented a pretty pit for people to throw their money in, and made them self conscious of their natural bodies in the process. It's had an almost entirely negative influence on the world.

Garbage in New York is unsanitary, attracts pests, and causes disease. Human body odor does not. They are not comparable.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by tincholio on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:20PM (#6149422)
Dude, I have met (in France, yay stereotypes!) some people whose smell would make you retch. One guy in particular was in the next office, and I kid you not, you could tell how long ago he had arrived by the stench in the hallway. I can't even imagine how the guy he shared his office with managed to do any work...
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by hannibal5 on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:07PM (#6149695)
You might react so badly to his smell if you were not conditioned othervice.

You just don't realize that you are in cultural and subjective bubble and you don't have objective keys to the world of smells.

If you travel around, you will realize that people have different smells and some of them are really strong. When you get used to them, they stop bothering you.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by sliverstorm on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:51PM (#6149597)
The "natural human body" wasn't meant to have clothes on, or spend all day indoors in close quarters with other humans.

When you take humans out of their natural environment, can you really argue that features of the human body are "natural" and thus in some way inviolable?

Garbage in New York... attracts pests. Human body odor does not.

Good to know. Flies must be attracted to something other than body odor & sweat then. Perhaps... body heat?

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by dragonwriter on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:03PM (#6149671)
> The "natural human body" wasn't meant to have clothes on

Stop anthropomorphizing nature; it gets angry when you do that.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by sliverstorm on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:46PM (#6149876)
I'm adopting the speech device for the sake of communicating effectively with the people I am talking to, not because I believe nature "intended" this or that.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by beachstartup on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:33PM (#6149819)
> Perhaps... body heat?

well, mosquitos (which carry disease) are attracted to carbon dioxide.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by bluthru on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:27PM (#6149452)
>No one is hurt by bad smells

Sure we are. Productivity is reduced if we're distracted by stench. Why argue for making life less pleasant? Bathing and mitigating foul odor should be encouraged.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by rayiner on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:09PM (#6149359)
Garbage in New York is well contained in plastic backs and doesn't cause disease. The most offensive part of it is the smell, and it is comparable.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by dnautics on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:56PM (#6149630)
But human body odor may be indicative of physiological problems, and being aware of your own odor can give you insight into what's going on under the skin.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by mc32 on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:50PM (#6149244)
It's not just americans either -in some parts of southern europe and middle east, it's not only used, it's overused. Also, its use is more pronounced among some populations but less amongst others in the US.

And, as you mention, in hotter climes and where people do manual labor and take public transportation it is very noticeable if people opt not to use deodorant. It's like entering a stable on a hot day.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by fsck--off on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:01PM (#6149321)
> The fact that people get used to it (like people get used to the garbage smell in New York) doesn't mean it isn't a real problem.

New York smells much better than it did 150 years ago, when there was no organized sanitation service and decomposing food and horses lay in the streets. There were an estimated 25,000 horses in the city. Each horse produced 30-50 pounds of manure a day. Clouds of pulverized horse manure particles blew into the air and the unbearable stench spread everywhere. There were no electric fans available to move the air, and the humidity made people sweat profusely.

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/07/28/nyregion/heat-...

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by spiek on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:46PM (#6149220)
Well, they smelled like something (the article references men thinking that their smell was "manly" - I admit I still secretly think that), it's just that whatever they smelled like didn't have a negative connotation. Marketing convinced them that it was a bad thing and that they needed to fix it.

Anecdotally, deodorant was a rite of passage for me as a teenage boy. As an adult with an office job, I find a lot of the time I don't need it (just like it turns out to be not a great idea to wash my hair every day). Additionally, I feel increasingly leery about rubbing aluminum under my arms every day. Do I smell? I don't think so. Am I headed for an office intervention? God I hope not.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by fsck--off on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:53PM (#6149268)
> Additionally, I feel increasingly leery about rubbing aluminum under my arms every day.

Then don't use antiperspirants. Regular deodorants don't have aluminum zirconium in them, and in the U.S (I'm not sure about non-U.S regulations) deodorants that do have aluminum in them must declare it as an "active ingredient".

http://www.fda.gov/Cosmetics/CosmeticLabelingLabelClaims/Cos...

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by rayiner on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:51PM (#6149253)
It's possible that my gag reflex to a strong whiff of body odor is entirely a creation of marketing. Or, maybe modern technology frees us from some of the baser indignities of life, and marketing offers a way to inform people that there is a better way.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by apalmer on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:04PM (#6149336)
If you grew up without deodorant being available, you probably would not have a gag reflex to strong body odor. Now there are always exceptions, some people have excessive body odor, and probably anyone who hasnt bathed in a couple weeks would be smelly... but pretty sure if you were used to it then the smell of the average human who took a bath within the last 24 hours but has natural body odor probably would NOT (edit) cause gagging...
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by llamataboot on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:13PM (#6149377)
How can something "smell bad" before it is culturally declared as such? Maybe some smells like rotting food and corpses are hardwired to be unpleasant, but probably not the smell of sweating bodies.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by rayiner on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:24PM (#6149440)
What makes you think the smell of sweating bodies can't be hardwired to smell unpleasant? It's the result of bacterial activity. Can your nose tell the difference between the bacterial activity in this case, and in more harmful cases?
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by llamataboot on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:36PM (#6149499)
Anecdotally, absolutely. I don't find body odor to smell bad, nor do many people I know, and being a bit of a hippie, know a lot of people that don't wear deodorant. Given that there's no advantage to avoiding healthy sweating bodies the way there is to avoiding rotting meat, I think that evolutionary pressures are quite different. Objectively, much (most?) of the world doesn't find body odor particularly unattractive. Most of the world finds rotting flesh and feces to smell terrible.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by Hellenion on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:58PM (#6149936)
> What makes you think the smell of sweating bodies can't be hardwired to smell unpleasant?

Because smells are not hardwired [1], we are nurtured into being distasteful of the scent of sweat. One nice example of this that I like is that you can find infants happily playing in faeces without being disgusted by it, it doesn't bother them the sligthest.

[1] http://www.foodnavigator.com/Science-Nutrition/Nurture-plays...

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by coldtea on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:54PM (#6149611)
>What makes you think the smell of sweating bodies can't be hardwired to smell unpleasant?

The fact that people forgot about it and get used to it pronto, as you already admitted above.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by wanderr on Friday August 02, 2013 @11:44PM (#6151021)
Olfactory fatigue works for all kinds of stenches, it doesn't mean they aren't unpleasant.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by coldtea on Saturday August 03, 2013 @07:59AM (#6151854)
Not really. Some stenches bother you less due to it, but they still bother you.

Also, who said people found the smell of a sweaty human unpleasant in first contant (before olfactory fatigue)?

This pressuposes an essential "badness" of the smell, regardless of if someone perceives it as bad or not. Where would this "badness" essense lie?

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by coldtea on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:52PM (#6149601)
>Probably more accurate title: Americans didn't realize they smelled bad until marketers pointed out otherwise

Smell is a sense. If you "don't realize it", it might as well not exist.

>If you've ever been to a part of the world where deodorant use is less common, you know its not a marketing-manufactured problem.

Nope -- that only holds were people don't bathe frequently.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by dragonwriter on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:55PM (#6149623)
> Smell is a sense. If you "don't realize it", it might as well not exist.

I would put that differently: "bad" is subjective -- if you don't notice/think that a smell is bad, then it isn't bad, whether the smell exists or not.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by TeMPOraL on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:31PM (#6149809)
No, it works like GP described - whether something smells bad or pleasant, if you're near it long enough (few minutes tops), you stop to perceive it. The brain just ignores the signal.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by dragonwriter on Friday August 02, 2013 @06:19PM (#6150026)
While that description's been made in other subthreads, I don't see anything in the post you point to that said anything like that.

I also know this to be false from personal experience, unless you are using an unusual definition of "few". (Certainly, there are some smells that you stop noticing at all, and the rest are noticed less, after a few minutes.)

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by gamache on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:57PM (#6149288)
And over the years, other Good Samaritans helpfully pointed out that we're fat, ugly, pimply, and not so fresh. How did we get along??
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by aa0 on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:32PM (#6149476)
Don't forget diseased. Big pharma wants to lend a hand too.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by everyone on Friday August 02, 2013 @03:55PM (#6149282)
It is not a problem. Humans smell a certain way. This is one example of illogical and wasteful consumer driven society creating a need for more pointless crap to make and needlessly further deplete our resources.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by jwoah12 on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:28PM (#6149455)
Humans also grow hair a certain way. Do you similarly agree that shaving razors are illogical?

As a species, one of the these we enjoy is the ability to use our intellect to improve naturally occurring things about ourselves. Just because something is natural does not mean it is perfect.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by bitwize on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:48PM (#6149579)
Humans also grow hair a certain way. Do you similarly agree that shaving razors are illogical?

No, but just about every hipster in Allston-Brighton does. Walk into any indie record shop in the Boston area and there'll be at least one 20-year-old with a beard to make Santa jealous.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by neutronicus on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:11PM (#6149369)
> The fact that people get used to it ... doesn't mean it isn't a real problem.

Isn't that kind of the definition of "not a real problem"?

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by mynewwork on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:20PM (#6149414)
Not at all. Humans are incredibly good at adapting. People in war zones get used to violence, people in high-corruption societies get used to giving bribes, etc. Clearly those are still real problems.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by Goronmon on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:20PM (#6149417)
Isn't just about every improvement ever made to our way of life improving upon some situation that we were previously "used to" in some way?
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by nilved on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:35PM (#6149495)
It's not a real problem, it's a manufactured problem. People didn't get used to smelling bad, they never considered their smell to be bad.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by nsxwolf on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:48PM (#6149574)
Whomever invented deodorant must have thought someone smelled bad.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by ojbyrne on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:21PM (#6149425)
Personally I dislike body odor less than someone wearing an overpowering amount of cologne. Not that I am a huge fan of body odor.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by jlgreco on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:34PM (#6149490)
I'd be okay with disabling my ability to smell entirely. Smell seems to be a sense that is almost entirely used only for unpleasant or irrelevant things. Sure, food wouldn't taste as good, but it wouldn't hurt me to eat less anyway...

The less anything smells, the better.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by lysium on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:35PM (#6149826)
I know people who cannot smell (anymore) and they are not happy with it at all. Be careful for what you wish. :-)

For example, smell can alert you (of gas, of glycerin vs. water in a can, food burning during cooking, etc.). Further, it's not only that food doesn't taste as good, you either have to force yourself to eat (enough), or you eat too much, because the experience is more shallow than you were used too and you try to compensate.

Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by aleyan on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:47PM (#6149883)
Smell is a safety feature. It helps you avoid rotting food, rotting bodies, things contaminated with feces, unexpected chemicals, smoke and fire conditions.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by sliverstorm on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:55PM (#6149619)
That one is hard to call. Horrifying body odor is much more unbearable from the point of view of the senses; overpowering cologne on the other hand makes me feel like I can't breathe. Two different experiences.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by apalmer on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:00PM (#6149315)
Ahhh man... you got a chicken and egg problem.
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 03, 2013 @05:42AM (#6151623)
"Chicken and egg problems" are called "feedback loops" in the adultland and are actually well understood...
Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi... by rayiner on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:43PM (#6149548)
ITT: massive amounts of naturalistic fallacy.