Re:Americans Thought They Smelled Fine Until Marketers Convi...
by mpyne on Friday August 02, 2013 @04:31PM
(#6149469)
It's very much like how you don't realize how bad a submarine smells (due to atmosphere control chemicals) when you're submerged and underway, unless you're doing things like running the diesel engine or venting waste tanks inboard.
But once you get back home it becomes obvious how smelly everything from the boat really is.
Here's the objective fact: when you sweat a lot, molecules corresponding to pheromones in your skin and bacteria that live on it (particularly in enclosed areas like armpits) waft into the air around you and enter the noses of nearby people. This triggers nerve impulses that travel to the brain and give the sensation of "smell".
Here's the subjective fact: you smell bad.
People often lift their subjective impressions to the level of objective facts, because they have no other experience to compare it to. But the brain is remarkably plastic, and people continually underestimate how much their subjective experience of something can change through exposure and perspective shifts.
Here's another objective fact: when researchers have exposed subjects to smell for a long period of time (usually hours is enough) and then MRI'd their brain, the neural pathways related to smell cease to fire. Prolonged exposure deadens the experience; the brain is no longer interested in smells that are no longer novel. Subjectively, the subject ceases to smell the offensive odor at all.
And from an evolutionary perspective, this makes perfect sense: smell is our early warning system for situations that might present danger or opportunity (eg. bacterial contamination, an aggressive rival, a desirable mate), but if we don't act immediately on that information, there's no purpose in continuing to smell the odor. Presumably we are unable to act otherwise, and continuing to fire those nerves just overloads the brain when it could better use that processing power elsewhere.
So both you and the article are right. You do smell natives who don't use deodorant - when you first encounter them. But if you lived shoulder to shoulder with them for years, as people did before deodorant was invented, you would cease to smell them, and it would cease to become a problem.
The way marketers work is to highlight the instances where it is a problem, so they enter your consciousness, and then reoccur in your consciousness whenever the stimulus occurs. Instead of "I stink, but I can't do anything about it, so why worry about it?" you think "I stink. I should put on some deodorant."
I've got lots more to say about how this affects adoption of products and cultural values (basically: you cannot get people to adopt a radically different innovation without relying on or creating some insecurity. If you can't create insecurity, you have to wait for everyone who was secure with the lack of your product to die off), but this comment is already pretty long...