Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by tanzam75 on Saturday July 20, 2013 @11:31AM
(#6075473)
Microsoft had net income of $5 billion last quarter. $100 million isn't "getting rich," but it is 2% of net income.
Granted, it's a smaller percentage of net revenues than of net income. But patent licenses are essentially pure profit, right? You're not doing the R&D for the purpose of getting patent licensing revenue.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by nivla on Saturday July 20, 2013 @11:48AM
(#6075523)
Does anyone know what patents are claimed by Microsoft on Android? Is it one for FAT16/32? Correct me if I am wrong but isn't FAT16/32 Microsoft's proprietary format? So why is it wrong for them to put a claim on it? Wouldn't Apple do the same?
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by jkn on Saturday July 20, 2013 @02:52PM
(#6076102)
This is how a Microsoft exec described the patents when they filed suit against B&N [1] (see [2,3] for details)
The Microsoft-created features protected by the patents infringed by the Nook and Nook Color tablet are core to the user experience. For example, the patents we asserted today protect innovations that:
• Give people easy ways to navigate through information provided by their device apps via a separate control window with tabs;
• Enable display of a webpage’s content before the background image is received, allowing users to interact with the page faster;
• Allow apps to superimpose download status on top of the downloading content;
• Permit users to easily select text in a document and adjust that selection; and
• Provide users the ability to annotate text without changing the underlying document.
And here's a list of patents from a lawsuit against Mororola [4] (the first two concern FAT16 I believe):
5,579,517: Common name space for long and short filenames
5,758,352: Common name space for long and short filenames (yes, again)
6,621,746: Monitoring entropic conditions of a flash memory device as an indicator for invoking erasure operations
6,826,762: Radio interface layer in a cell phone with a set of APIs having a hardware-independent proxy layer and a hardware-specific driver layer
6,909,910: Method and system for managing changes to a contact database
7,644,376: Flexible architecture for notifying applications of state changes
5,664,133: Context sensitive menu system/menu behavior
6,578,054: Method and system for supporting off-line mode of operation and synchronization using resource state information
6,370,566: Generating meeting requests and group scheduling from a mobile device
As for your questions: So why is it wrong for them to put a claim on it? Wouldn't Apple do the same? It's not like Apple gets a free pass when they sue Android manufacturers for patent infringement...
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by felipeko on Saturday July 20, 2013 @01:20PM
(#6075794)
It's way worse than that. Microsoft uses FUD tatics to sign patent licenses. You can check Microsft vs B&N case, in which B&N showed the kind of patents [1] Microsoft is using against Android. (By the way, Microsoft had to invest in B&N to end this case. This is how strong good these patents are)
It's obvious that Microsoft is using IBM's old playbook on patents[2], where it's cheaper to license than fight.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by nivla on Saturday July 20, 2013 @12:32PM
(#6075642)
>You should not be able to patent data exchange formats;
I fully agree. I despise patents on anything that stifles interoperability. However this wasn't anything new. Din't we grow up with patents on GIF? Isn't Apple doing the same with patents on NFC sessions? [1] Or Google with their proprietary file system[2]? Don't even get me started on the bucket load of patents IBM has collected over the decade. Then why single out Microsoft? Patent wars between corporations is nothing new. (However, I would develop a deep hatred if they went after non-profit org like Linux with this.)
The point I am trying to make is, it was/is common for corporations to file patents on most trivial things. I find the Patent Office at fault here.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by jkn on Saturday July 20, 2013 @03:30PM
(#6076238)
Your position seems most inconsistent to me. FAT is a prime example of a technology that is essential for interoperability (yet trivial compared to modern alternatives). Good luck exchanging files using a USB thumb drive formatted with EXT4. Or getting the pictures from your camera SD card without supporting FAT32. FAT16/32 are the only filesystems that work seamlessly in Windows, OS X and Linux.
It's not about filing patents. Patents are routinely filed for defensive purpose and it's hard to blame the companies that do it, especially in light of the abuse by e.g. Microsoft. It's what companies do with the patents. Like getting Motorola phones banned in Germany due to FAT16 patent infringement [1].
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by zanny on Saturday July 20, 2013 @03:10PM
(#6076159)
> Neither do I see any other reason to stick with FAT16/32 unless it is somehow required on booting.
It is required under UEFI. Fat16 and 32 are the only recognized file system formats used by UEFI firmware, so you have to have a UEFI system partition using that filesystem. If Microsoft can patent troll people over it, technically that means there is no way to prepare a system for UEFI booting unless running Microsoft software to create a fat partition, and write to it.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by Anechoic on Saturday July 20, 2013 @02:05PM
(#6075975)
Does Apple have to pay Microsoft for the ability to access FAT partitions?
Apple & MS have a cross-licensing agreement dating back to 1997 that has been renewed at once (and probably more than once). FAT patents are presumably included under this.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by zanny on Saturday July 20, 2013 @03:13PM
(#6076175)
fat16/32 are the only recognized file system formats of EFI system partitions in the UEFI firmware standard.
If they are patent encumbered, that is worse than the secure boot nonsense. It would mean you can't format a drive for booting on a system using UEFI firmware unless you had windows software to create and write into that partition.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by pgeorgi on Saturday July 20, 2013 @04:20PM
(#6076417)
The patents cover long file names (which are embedded in the directory using "illegal" directory entries).
UEFI users (as in: OS installer) could restrain themselves to FAT16 with 8.3 names (FAT16 since the boot partition is usually tiny), and I haven't seen any longer file names yet.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by zanny on Saturday July 20, 2013 @04:33PM
(#6076459)
One thing to note is Windows 7 won't recognize a FAT16 formatted UEFI partition, but Windows 8 works fine. I use fat16 for my uefi partitions because I only ever add in memtest and Arch. Good job MS!
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by beagle3 on Saturday July 20, 2013 @11:54AM
(#6075538)
FAT goes back to CPM, maybe even farther (long before Microsoft, and any patents on the original would have expired 20 years ago, and there weren't software patents back then). The extension from FAT12 to FAT16 and FAT32 is trivial.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by Someone on Saturday July 20, 2013 @01:26PM
(#6075816)
IIRC, CP/M had 8.3 file names, ctrl-Z terminated text files, and drive letters, but its on-disk structures where totally different. That certainly was the case when comparing it to FAT versions that allow for subdirectories (CP/M did not have subdirectories)
The point still stands though: any patent protection for the original implementation would have expired before 1997, which is more than 15 years ago. And it shouldn't have received (in fact, didn't receive) patent protection.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by nivla on Saturday July 20, 2013 @12:12PM
(#6075576)
I thought FAT came from DOS, which was Microsoft owned. If FAT wasn't Microsoft's original design, then I think its very unfair that they got the patent for it in the first place, let alone enforcing it.
The point still stands though: any patent protection for the original implementation would have expired before 1997, which is more than 15 years ago. And it shouldn't have received (in fact, didn't receive) patent protection.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by guard-of-terra on Saturday July 20, 2013 @12:09PM
(#6075561)
The idea Microsoft gets money from Android devices despite not doing anything other than stiffling innovation for the last ten years makes me want ppl in Microsoft have bad stuff happening to them.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by mslot on Saturday July 20, 2013 @12:23PM
(#6075605)
Stifling innovation? Microsoft was developing software for mobile devices more than 10 years before Google did and for a long time it was the main driver behind the market for PDA/smart phone components (e.g., colour/touch screens, ARM CPUs).
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by lttlrck on Saturday July 20, 2013 @04:13PM
(#6076387)
You cannot compare the failure of Windows Mobile to IE6.
The situation created by IE6 popularity was in all likelyhood a fluke, I am not sure Microsoft had a grand nefarious plan that they successfully executed at all.
Besides without IE6 we would have most likely had to wait longer for Firefox and Chrome.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by guard-of-terra on Saturday July 20, 2013 @04:37PM
(#6076473)
I don't think it's a grand nefarous plan.
They just thought that they made it.
That all the revolutions of desktop browsing (or PDA OSes) are over, and what they have to do until the end of eternity is introducing small evolutionary changes while preserving reverse compatibility.
And that they did. But they were wrong, browsing revolution happened which left IE6, 7 and partially 8 in the dust. Mobile happened, which made them throw away all the Windows Mobile and make it from scratch.
They were not ready to innovate by writing heroic projects fast and tried to persuade market that glacial is okay from now.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by ladzoppelin on Saturday July 20, 2013 @02:27PM
(#6076036)
FYI the new Windows 8 mobile platform is better then anything I have used running Android so wishing harm on employees in MS for "stiffling innovation" is quite funny.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by harrytuttle on Saturday July 20, 2013 @02:49PM
(#6076087)
Agree with you entirely. I've completely switched to Nokia/WinPhone 8. Had a Lumia 710, now got a 620. The latter was dirt cheap (sim free), smooth as anything and it just works flawlessly.
This is after a history of Symbian, iPhone, various androids and a blackberry. The symbians were pretty good, the iPhones (3,4,4s) all had minor annoying bugs and to be honest felt like surgical instruments rather than phones, the androids were all buggy, slow and unreliable (HTC desire, Galaxy S2, Galaxy Ace). Blackberries are fiddly and odd and mine smelt like poo after a week which was odd (9310). Apparently something to do with the glue they use.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by codex on Saturday July 20, 2013 @01:06PM
(#6075734)
Google's somewhat foolish acquisition of Motorola would begin to show some dividends if they could leverage Motorola's patents to force a cross licensing agreement which didn't involve paying these fees.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by melling on Saturday July 20, 2013 @12:35PM
(#6075650)
This is unfortunate for Android but consumers are still much better off by having a 3rd major operating system. I really hope Android(or Chrome/Android) becomes a viable desktop solution.
Re:Microsoft Is Getting Rich on Android
by mtgx on Saturday July 20, 2013 @02:16PM
(#6076008)
That doesn't necessarily mean Nokia isn't paying a license fee. Also Microsoft is paying Nokia for using its maps, so I'm not sure how far the "freebies" go, on either side.
Granted, it's a smaller percentage of net revenues than of net income. But patent licenses are essentially pure profit, right? You're not doing the R&D for the purpose of getting patent licensing revenue.
The Microsoft-created features protected by the patents infringed by the Nook and Nook Color tablet are core to the user experience. For example, the patents we asserted today protect innovations that:
• Give people easy ways to navigate through information provided by their device apps via a separate control window with tabs;
• Enable display of a webpage’s content before the background image is received, allowing users to interact with the page faster;
• Allow apps to superimpose download status on top of the downloading content;
• Permit users to easily select text in a document and adjust that selection; and
• Provide users the ability to annotate text without changing the underlying document.
And here's a list of patents from a lawsuit against Mororola [4] (the first two concern FAT16 I believe):
5,579,517: Common name space for long and short filenames
5,758,352: Common name space for long and short filenames (yes, again)
6,621,746: Monitoring entropic conditions of a flash memory device as an indicator for invoking erasure operations
6,826,762: Radio interface layer in a cell phone with a set of APIs having a hardware-independent proxy layer and a hardware-specific driver layer
6,909,910: Method and system for managing changes to a contact database
7,644,376: Flexible architecture for notifying applications of state changes
5,664,133: Context sensitive menu system/menu behavior
6,578,054: Method and system for supporting off-line mode of operation and synchronization using resource state information
6,370,566: Generating meeting requests and group scheduling from a mobile device
As for your questions: So why is it wrong for them to put a claim on it? Wouldn't Apple do the same? It's not like Apple gets a free pass when they sue Android manufacturers for patent infringement...
[1] http://blogs.technet.com/b/microsoft_on_the_issues/archive/2...
[2] http://androidcommunity.com/barnes-noble-reveals-microsofts-...
[3] http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=2011111122291296
[4] http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2010/10/01/microsoft-files-itc-p...
[1] http://www.geekwire.com/2011/barnes-nobles-29page-slide-deck...
[2] http://www.forbes.com/asap/2002/0624/044.html
Imagine BMW patenting the shape of the hole you use to fuel your car, and then sending invoices to every fuel station.
>Imagine BMW patenting the shape of the hole you use to fuel your car, and then sending invoices to every fuel station.
That is an unfair comparison. I would have agreed to that statement if the patent was vague but it is very specific to implementation.
>Android supports to be compatible with windows systems.
Neither do I see any other reason to stick with FAT16/32 unless it is somehow required on booting.
I made a sabbatical in hating Microsoft for a few years but now I see why it is important for me to resume doing so.
I fully agree. I despise patents on anything that stifles interoperability. However this wasn't anything new. Din't we grow up with patents on GIF? Isn't Apple doing the same with patents on NFC sessions? [1] Or Google with their proprietary file system[2]? Don't even get me started on the bucket load of patents IBM has collected over the decade. Then why single out Microsoft? Patent wars between corporations is nothing new. (However, I would develop a deep hatred if they went after non-profit org like Linux with this.)
The point I am trying to make is, it was/is common for corporations to file patents on most trivial things. I find the Patent Office at fault here.
[1]http://www.patentlyapple.com/patently-apple/2013/05/apple-fi...
[2]http://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2006/06/google-file-system-...
One thing is to patent, the other thing is to enforce a bogus patent/"license" it and collect money. The latter has no excuses for a product company.
It's not about filing patents. Patents are routinely filed for defensive purpose and it's hard to blame the companies that do it, especially in light of the abuse by e.g. Microsoft. It's what companies do with the patents. Like getting Motorola phones banned in Germany due to FAT16 patent infringement [1].
[1] http://www.zdnet.com/motorola-android-devices-banned-in-germ...
It is required under UEFI. Fat16 and 32 are the only recognized file system formats used by UEFI firmware, so you have to have a UEFI system partition using that filesystem. If Microsoft can patent troll people over it, technically that means there is no way to prepare a system for UEFI booting unless running Microsoft software to create a fat partition, and write to it.
Which would be stupendous bullshit.
Apple & MS have a cross-licensing agreement dating back to 1997 that has been renewed at once (and probably more than once). FAT patents are presumably included under this.
If they are patent encumbered, that is worse than the secure boot nonsense. It would mean you can't format a drive for booting on a system using UEFI firmware unless you had windows software to create and write into that partition.
UEFI users (as in: OS installer) could restrain themselves to FAT16 with 8.3 names (FAT16 since the boot partition is usually tiny), and I haven't seen any longer file names yet.
The point still stands though: any patent protection for the original implementation would have expired before 1997, which is more than 15 years ago. And it shouldn't have received (in fact, didn't receive) patent protection.
I was mistaken above; FAT is actually a Microsoft design, although it predates MS DOS - see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FAT_file_system#Historical_evol...
The point still stands though: any patent protection for the original implementation would have expired before 1997, which is more than 15 years ago. And it shouldn't have received (in fact, didn't receive) patent protection.
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTI3OTQ
I guess they figured out they no longer have to innovate now when all the market was theirs following the fall of (Netscape, Mac & other OSes, Palm).
And when iPhone came the whole Windows Mobile thing imploded like a house of cards.
They just thought that they made it. That all the revolutions of desktop browsing (or PDA OSes) are over, and what they have to do until the end of eternity is introducing small evolutionary changes while preserving reverse compatibility.
And that they did. But they were wrong, browsing revolution happened which left IE6, 7 and partially 8 in the dust. Mobile happened, which made them throw away all the Windows Mobile and make it from scratch.
They were not ready to innovate by writing heroic projects fast and tried to persuade market that glacial is okay from now.
This is after a history of Symbian, iPhone, various androids and a blackberry. The symbians were pretty good, the iPhones (3,4,4s) all had minor annoying bugs and to be honest felt like surgical instruments rather than phones, the androids were all buggy, slow and unreliable (HTC desire, Galaxy S2, Galaxy Ace). Blackberries are fiddly and odd and mine smelt like poo after a week which was odd (9310). Apparently something to do with the glue they use.
I'm literally relieved to use a windows phone!