It's worth remembering that when CEOs talk about flexibility, this is what they are talking about: interchangeable workers, who can be swapped in and out (and thrown in the bin) like interchangeable parts.
My point isn't about engineers; the same can be said of architects or designers or even middle managers. If you have a team that you trust, having any number and grouping of them able to come together around a problem will produce results. A team being "flexible" does not make them "cogs".
You're looking at this from the perspective of a skilled professional, which is fine -- most of the HN audience probably does as well. But it's not the perspective I'm talking about. I'm talking about the perspective of the people who see skilled professionals as a problem, because their skills mean they can demand things like money and respect as a condition of employment. That reduces the CEO's flexibility to do things like take that money and put it instead into his own golden parachute.
Many organisations don't want to rely on a handful of supermen who solve all of their problems as such people may become indispensable and then demand higher wages or go to a competitor. They would rather break their processes down into a bunch of specialized tasks that require few skills so that new workers can be popped in and out quickly.
The wage level is somewhat orthogonal to this - doctors are generally interchangeable cogs, but they get paid well. The key point is avoiding single points of failure.
Besides there is a relatively small pool of people compared to the general population who are even capable of becoming doctors, not to mention the very long spin up time.
An analogy would be breaking down the tasks performed by a doctor into chunks that could be done in isolation by minimum wage workers.
Skilled professionals become more experienced at their jobs over time, they also have differing experiences and may have graduated from different schools etc.
This means that they will perform their jobs differently in ways that way be subtle and not easily quantifiable. So if you swap them out, things will change in ways that may not be easy to predict.
On the other hand a minimum wage worker is more likely to perform a job that requires a total training of 1 hour or less and they are likely to hit a ceiling in terms of productivity within a week. There may be minor differences in output, but these are easily quantifiable and if you have a large enough labour pool to draw from can be solved by saying "fire anybody who does like than X per hour".
Medicine is high skill, but the outputs are fairly homogeneous. Homogeneous output is what makes workers interchangeable cogs, not skill level.
I think the main difference probably comes down to medicine having more procedures and redundancy built in because you can't let a patient die when a particular doctor is not available.
OTOH my older relatives definitely complain about/praise individual doctors for bedside manor , professionalism and misdiagnosis etc.
Which would be amazingly hard for all the same reasons writing a program to replace a doctor would be amazingly hard.
In a company like Walmart, which is entirely predicated on the existence of interchangeable minimum-wage workers, the main component they can't replace is the process all those workers follow which results in a working store. That's the software run by all the human hardware.
http://programmers.stackexchange.com/a/45814
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_X_and_theory_Y#Theory_Y
There's no small number of managers that subscribe to the "widget factory"/theory X school, however; my impression is that it's the decided majority.
http://www.theonion.com/articles/temp-hides-fun-fulfilling-l...
I realize that's a joke, but it's a joke I and many people I know have lived. It's a cultural notion that we need to get a bunch of fulfillment from our jobs. Though I now have a fulfilling job, I was probably the happiest when I just had a job to make a few bucks and didn't take home the worries of knowledge work. Temp work was a good option because there was no responsibility and if I didn't want to go to work, I didn't.
I'm not saying that treating workers as animals is OK or that all temp workers are living a life of bliss – this article show most aren’t -- but there is certainly another side to the story.
The worst part wasn't the physical labor, it was the atmosphere. Never mind the fact that I was pretty much the only English speaker there, the other workers didn't even talk to each other. We'd go on the 30 minute lunch break at 11, and they'd all pull out their lunchboxes and eat in complete silence. Everything was so somber -- it was like everyone had the life sucked out of them.
My other favorite experience was working for a large energy drink supplier (you've heard of them), transferring cartons of drinks from pallets to other, differently-sized pallets, while 2-3 dudes in polos sat in a corner and chatted, occasionally laughing.
It gave me chills to read this and remember what it's like to work harder than you ever have before, and still be treated as a nameless soulless entity.
What would be wrong with that anyway?
These are simply a front, though. Most people object to minimum wage due to purely ideological reasons.
* Raising the minimum wage doesn't shift the distribution of wealth (companies lay off workers, companies no longer have profit margin close down, companies shift highering demographic).
* Raising corporate Tax doesn't shift the distribution of wealth (the increase is absorbed by the consumer)
* Income Tax on rich & (with exceptions on groceries/utilties/rent to make it non-regressive) sales Taxes & Social Programs do change the distribution of wealth, (danger being lower rewards = less risk taken, but this is debatable).
If I was a liberal, I would be pushing strongly for social programs & taxes instead of minimum wage. The economic benefit of having more workers actually working (because they are allowed to work for $4 an hour) is HUGE. and with social programs their life would be like you wanted it.
Anyway for that reason we have a variable estate tax up to %40. Yes, there are probably loopholes to this and they should be closed.
If anything, CEOs and corporate management in general tend to overvalue long term gains, so financial incentives for short term benefits probably push incentives back closer to optimal.
Picking WalMart (just because they are such an icon of this), if you zero'd out their CEO pay and distributed it to employees, each employee would see a raise of 20 cents a week.
Yeah, like more people who don't require social assistance, and eventually, more people spending money in local economies.
>Besides the fact that a small percentage of US work force are actually paid minimum, most more or less than it.
That's only because it just isn't survivable to earn minimum wage, at least not for any reasonable definition of survivable.
What jobs are teenagers supposed to have? We need to have entry-level jobs for people who are just getting started in the labor market, whose labor isn't worth that much because they are still working on basic job skills, like showing up to work on time sober.
FYI: I don't think raising the minimum wage just a buck is going to have any significant downsides. We need to remember that there can be people whose labor isn't worth that new minimum wage, though.
There is something to be said about an employer having 3 $8-an-hour employees versus 2 $12-an-hour employees.
This is the fundamental problem, it shouldn't be possible for any family of 4 to have difficult basic physical necessities, job or no job. However, in the current state of things some workers are so exploited that the only available work (if you can find any for your labor) pays at a minimum wage.
> What jobs are teenagers supposed to have?
Acquiring disposable income is really different from having to have steady work at a decent rate of pay in order to afford basics like food and shelter. Also, there are tremendous issues with young people and work and exploitation of labor in that age demographic.
> We need to have entry-level jobs for people who are just getting started in the labor market, whose labor isn't worth that much because they are still working on basic job skills, like showing up to work on time sober.
This is a deliberate slander, you are associating people who receive minimum wage (and are likely poor) with alcoholism. That kind of thing is a long running stereotype that undermines the value of low paid laborers or and workers.
Further, nobody is saying that all workers must have high pay, we would expect that pay levels have differences between types of work and types of workers. However, there should be a basic guarantee that people can access basic physical needs.
Sophistry. Come on, you can do better than that.
>What jobs are teenagers supposed to have?
They can mow yards, build crappy websites with PHP, Lemonade stands, etc. I don't know, nor do I particularly care. Teenagers aren't a significant part of the economy. For my part, I worked at all kinds of crap as a teenager, never making as little as the minimum wage, carefully saving up thousands of dollars (really, I was a tight fisted teenager). I pissed away lots of chances to have fun, only to face the realization that my years of constant after-school employment hadn't even netted me enough money for a single year of room, board, and tuition at a state college.
>We need to have entry-level jobs for people who are just getting started in the labor market,
If it isn't worth paying someone a livable wage, then it obviously isn't an essential need. That's basic econ telling you to stop wasting your time.
>whose labor isn't worth that much because they are still working on basic job skills, like showing up to work on time sober.
Vocational school, and probationary employment seem sufficient to me.
>FYI: I don't think raising the minimum wage just a buck is going to have any significant downsides.
Me neither. One might even argue for locales to define a minimum wage, maybe somehow indexed to the cost of living, as at least one has.
>We need to remember that there can be people whose labor isn't worth that new minimum wage, though.
Are you referring to mentally and physically disabled people? There is a gov't program to subsidize their wages, which still allows employers (like Goodwill Industries) to abuse them arbitrarily (but supposedly based upon an objective metric of productivity).
>There is something to be said about an employer having 3 $8-an-hour employees versus 2 $12-an-hour employees.
Is there? Please say it.
Yet every adult working at a job was at one point a teenager. The first time they have to punch a clock and say "yes sir" to someone giving them an attitude shouldn't be when they are starting their first job at 24.
> Is there? Please say it.
The first situation has three people with jobs, while the second only has two. Plus the people who only have skills worth $10 an hour can find a job in the first situation, where they can't in the second.
But the personal attacks have started, so I'm out on this thread.
Regardless, there are no references for either argument in this comment thread.
You seem quite invested in authoritarianism and suffering.
>But the personal attacks have started
Methinks thou doth protest too much.
What happens when they age out? Do people advertise for jobs and say "only people under 21 can apply?"
You're not allowed to age discriminate in hiring, so you can't advertise jobs on that basis.
How do employers know they can legally pay one person less than the other? Does the employer find out they are 16 and then lower their pay to 6 euros?
https://www.gov.uk/national-minimum-wage-rates
You wouldn't lower the pay, you'd likely just start them out at the lower rate.
If you think modern levels of intervention in the labor market --- not just minimum wage, but mandatory benefits and a host of other things --- have been imposed with such a marvellously deft touch that they shouldn't cause persistent failure of labor markets to clear, it is possible to dream up other reasons that might conceivably explain the observed outcome of historically high long term unemployment. Not everyone finds those explanations convincing, though.
What is this? I don't even...
>If you think modern levels of intervention in the labor market --- not just minimum wage, but mandatory benefits and a host of other things --- have been imposed with such a marvellously deft touch
I don't.
>that they shouldn't cause persistent failure of labor markets to clear, it is possible to dream up other reasons that might conceivably explain the observed outcome of historically high long term unemployment. Not everyone finds those explanations convincing, though.
Whether you like the fact that our economy is putzed around by central planners is a different topic. I'll approach this with the foregone conclusion that it's what we're stuck with, and that we have to find a way to live with it. Actually, central planning has little to do with the obvious necessity that the people who live in and around our communities must be able to support themselves, and if they cannot; then that problem will sort itself out either through social programs paid by taxes, charity, the population's mobility, or as a last resort theft and violence.
But surely that's just an artifact of liberal Krugmanite thinking infecting our institutions of higher learning! Let's see what the reliably conservative Cato Institute thinks: http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa106.html#4
There are several problems with the notion of cost-push inflation. The primary error in this analysis is that it confuses a shift in the structure of relative prices with a general rise in the level of prices. If the labor costs of businesses are increased and they succeed in passing on the costs to consumers in the form of higher prices, they will have managed to change the structure of relative prices at the expense of businesses that are unable to raise their prices because of more-intense competition. This is quite distinct from a general increase in the level of prices, which would be possible only if the real supply of money was increased.
Many firms, however, may be unable to pass on their increased costs to consumers. It is consumers who ultimately determine the price of any good on the market, and they may decide that a business's product is not worth a higher price. Producers cannot force consumers to buy what they produce, and businesses cannot always arbitrarily increase the prices of their products simply because the government has arbitrarily increased their costs.
Oh.
Well, how about free market champion Milton Friedman? What did he think? http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/08/1970-stagf...
Milton Friedman did not believe in cost push inflation. He believed that "inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon." In other words, he believed prices could not increase without an increase in the money supply.
Oh.
This is probably strictly true as written, but misleading, as it also provides a medium and long term benefit, as it (alone) drives inflation up less than the ratio by which the minimum wage was increased.
> The minimum wage and inflation are effectively proportional.
No, they aren't. Even price levels, which could be more reasonably expected to have some relation to minimum wage, aren't simply proportional. If inflation was proportional to minimum wage, places that didn't have a minimum wage would have zero inflation; if price levels were proportional to minimum wage, places that didn't have a minimum wage would have zero price levels. Neither of these is the case.
There were some jobs that were always "temp" - like one time government construction contracts. But, usually the way the process worked at that time was that employers were basically using Kelly to "screen" workers. They'd bring you in as a temp. and after six months if you were still there they'd transition you to permanent position. If they didn't asked you to come back as a temp, Kelly would just send you somewhere else. Sometimes, you'd not get asked back due to an inability to do the job (I once wasn't because I was asked to hand paint the buttons for tv remotes and just didn't have the dexterity for that) but usually it was because of a chronic problem. As you can imagine with people working temp jobs many had "issues". Plenty of people missed work because they were arrested for DUI's or drug related crime the night before. Some had their probation violated. Several showed up drunk or high. One guy had a medical issue (epilepsy) and had a seizure on the factory floor while operating heavy machinery. Using temps let the companies easily handle those types of problems with out interrupting their business. Part of it was not having to involve HR in the "firing" process by just letting the shift supervisor and Kelly handle it. But, it was also that they could just easily get a different temp. There was no need to put an add in the paper and have a person interviewed and entered into the payroll system etc.
I guess it's possible that things have gotten much worse since I worked for Kelly. Or, that things may be different in poor US inner cities (which I make it a point to stay away from). But, it's probably just some sensationalism in the writing of the article and some exaggerated hearsay from the temps. Notice that there's no pictures or any other evidence like that of the articles' most egregious statements.
The socialist initiative we need is to shut down unskilled immigration entirely. Read the article; they're all Hispanic. These people's plight is going to be made even worse by the coming wave of even greater unskilled immigration promised by the senate bill. This is why Caesar Chavez was vehemently anti-immigration.
This is the exact opposite of a "socialist" initative. Either you are being ironic or do not really know in what sense "socialist" is being used here.
Either way, feels kind of cheap considering that unskilled migration has historically been one of the driving forces behind US growth and progress, and that many first class US citizens today are probably descendants of some of those migrants.
Furthermore, one of the fundamental tenets of communism is a stateless society, so there's that. And many communists thought it was one of the more important initial goals, hence 'one world communism.'
So, giant Berlin Wall/border fence with drones and armed guards? Or viable trade/economic policy with Mexico? Nevermind, we've made that choice.
The wage and hours were terrible, but it was the absolute dehumanization that stuck with me. No body knew your name or particularly cared. You would walk in during the morning, flash your badge and get assigned to a particular stand. Every day it was brand new people who you've never met before with a brand new manager. There was obviously no room to move up, because you never had a chance to build a track record with anyone. There was also just plain disrespect on the part of the company towards its workers. We would spend 2-3 hours after the game just waiting for permission to go home. I can't imagine spending much of my life in a job like that, it was just horrible. But clearly there were enough people who had to do it, because there were many 40 year olds I worked with.
People who've never worked these jobs tend to read this article and assume that these articles have a hidden agenda: raising the minimum wage or some kind of socialist initiative. I read it differently, as a reminder of the depressing underside of the US economy.