News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jgrahamc on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:12PM (#5973913)
He's not a 'stateless person'. His passport has been revoked, but he remains a US citizen.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:28PM (#5974040)
Yes, those two words are probably not precise enough to describe the situation.

However if you read the context, what is being said is pretty much true: they are using citizenship as a weapon in order to deny him the human right to seek asylum.

    "The Obama administration has now adopted the strategy
     of using citizenship as a weapon. Although I am convicted
     of nothing, it has unilaterally revoked my passport,
     leaving me a stateless person. Without any judicial order,
     the administration now seeks to stop me exercising a
     basic right. A right that belongs to everybody.
     The right to seek asylum."
Pay too much attention to individual words and you fail to understand the big picture...
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by throwaway9848 on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:41PM (#5974146)
He _broke the law_ and is a fugitive from justice. He wouldn't be a hero if he wasn't risking consequences, and it should have been obvious from the start that he was going to be apprehended by the US eventually.

EDIT: Also, the concept of "a human right to seek asylum" is meaningless. Asylum is a two-party arrangement. Is that a legal obligation for all nations to _grant_ asylum to seekers, regardless of circumstances?

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:51PM (#5974211)
Yes, he did break the law but it is absurd for you to use the word 'justice'.

    Justice: The quality of being fair and reasonable.
He's not running away from something which is 'fair or reasonable', his human rights are in grave danger.

He is a fugitive from injustice.

I do not care whether he is a hero or not, but I do care about whether it was a right thing to do and whether he is treated as a human should be treated. These are principles worth upholding.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:28PM (#5974437)
> He's not running away from something which is 'fair or reasonable', his human rights are in grave danger.

How so? I mean this sincerely.

What do you think will happen to him when he is arrested? There's no brig to throw him in, as he's a civilian. Snowden was very concerned about the lack of judicial oversight in what he saw with PRISM, so why would he assume that very same judicial system would mark him for special treatment when people like Hanssen, the Walker gang, and even Aaron Hernandez have not received such?

If Snowden really felt beforehand that the civilian justice system was so completely inequitable it seems weird that he'd have been so insistent on its involvement elsewhere.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:56PM (#5974615)
>> If Snowden really felt beforehand that the civilian justice system was so completely inequitable it seems weird that he'd have been so insistent on its involvement elsewhere.

The 'justice' system fulfils what power requires from it. It will be as inequitable with a trial as it has been with this whole fiasco.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:02PM (#5974646)
Then there was never a reason to involve the 'justice' system in surveillance measures at all, was there?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by e3pi on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:48AM (#5976226)
>Then there was never a reason to involve the 'justice' system in surveillance measures at all, was there?

"...But Obama’s Justice Department, like Bush’s, has not been above an opportunistic (and occasionally downright Procrustean) reading of particular statutes to permit whatever it is that the White House wants to do."

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5961518

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:40PM (#5974866)
Agreed.

But I think underlying this is the thought that it would be good if there was an equitable justice system as opposed to an inequitable one.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:44PM (#5974885)
Yes, that would be good. I suppose it is a pity there is no middle ground between those two possibilities.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by gaadd33 on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:17PM (#5975030)
They could just hold him for years without a trial like what happened with Kevin Mitnick.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:19PM (#5975606)
Well... that was bad, but it was bad for different reasons. Mitnick himself waived his right to a speedy trial. The government swamped him and his court in so much shit that he'd have a difficult time preparing a proper defense otherwise.

The flipside for Snowden is that at least it will count as time served so if he gets sentenced to more than 2 years it might actually be beneficial as I'd imagine you get to meet with your lawyers more often while prepping for trial.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by zanny on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:32PM (#5975656)
This, the US gov't has plenty of backdoors and sleazy dealings to circumvent a speedy trial by ones peers. It is why most criminal sentences aren't heard by juries, because the system is rigged and intentionally bullies the accused into taking plea bargains.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by embolism on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @01:05PM (#5985933)
I am genuinely curious to know if there is a county whose judicial system could be used as a good example.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:16PM (#5974380)
> He _broke the law_ and is a fugitive from justice.

This, while seeming important, is basically irrelevant as long as the US is demonstrating their willingness to torture accused people prior to trial for crimes such as these.

He could have done something 10x worse and it still wouldn't matter. Nobody should ever be subjected to torture - even if convicted. They're torturing people for years before trials even start, if they start at all.

He cannot anticipate anything resembling justice in the US.

It's a red herring.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by eli on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:05PM (#5974668)
Yes, this whole line of argument that Snowden has put forward is beside the point. Whether you call it "exile" or not, it is perfectly reasonable for the US to revoke his passport. It is certainly not "extralegal." It's not even unusual. It is what happens when you're charged with a felony by a US court.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:10PM (#5975008)
Revoking his passport is not extralegal. Nobody's arguing that.

Exerting unknown influence behind closed doors with those who have the ability to grant or deny his requests for asylum is an entirely different matter, though.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by eli on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:24PM (#5975069)
I really hate arguments based on parsing words, but the Wikileaks statement says:

"This kind of deception from a world leader is not justice, and neither is the extralegal penalty of exile"

Doesn't "exile" refer to his being without a passport? So isn't he clearly saying that it's extralegal?

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by kpommerenke on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:32PM (#5974467)
Snowden hasn't been tortured, and will certainly not be tortured when he gets back to the US.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by kasey_junk on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:47PM (#5974570)
Bradley Manning was submitted to sleep deprivation & extreme isolation, both of which are widely regarded as torture by civilized people. Given that it seems reasonable for Snowden to believe he will be tortured on his return to the US and unreasonable for someone to say that he certainly won't be tortured.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by krapp on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:14PM (#5974722)
Not everyone who is convicted of a crime by the government is tortured and not every trial is a mocking pretense. Maybe, just maybe, Edward Snowden is speaking through the filter of his own prejudices and biases, which may not necessarily 100% reflect reality.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jellicle on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:06PM (#5975560)
Maybe we should put it this way: the last person that the U.S.A. got its hands on that caused a similar amount of embarrassment to the U.S. government was brutally tortured.

Snowden would prefer not to find out if that trend is going to continue.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by pekk on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:47PM (#5975703)
What you call brutal torture is certainly nothing anybody wants to experience, but the implication that it is legally unprecedented or obviously illegal is not correct, particularly for someone who is both subject to UCMJ and is reasonably deemed a suicide risk.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jellicle on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @09:52AM (#5977737)
Nice torture justification, bro. You should be proud of yourself: you've stood up for humans beings torturing other human beings. Probably the highlight of your life to date.

Hint: nobody has ever said they thought Manning was a suicide risk except for his torturers. All qualified medical personnel that have ever examined him (including the prison psychologist) have insisted that he wasn't. Hint 2: doing sleep deprivation and humiliation is not the way to reduce someone's chance of suicide, if you honestly believed they were a risk. Which no one did.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by gamacodre on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:52PM (#5974600)
You seem awfully sure about this. Being a US citizen myself I would certainly hope you're correct, but given the excesses that the government has already hidden or excused with "but... terrorists!!! fear!!!" I think there is an outside chance that he has legitimate cause for concern.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:06PM (#5974988)
It's not an outside chance. The last guy who leaked classified US military information to the press to expose a systemic coverup of abuses was tortured for several years prior to his trial beginning:

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2012/12/01/1166253/-The-Tortur...

Additionally, Obama himself declared him (Manning) guilty in public before his trial even began. (I wish I was making this up.)

It's not speculation. We've watched it happen, and recently. They are condemned before the trial even begins, and denied basic human rights from the outset - rights we shouldn't even deny convicted mass murderers.

It's an incredible shame for everyone who used to be proud to be from the USA.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:37AM (#5975851)
> The last guy who leaked classified US military information to the press to expose a systemic coverup of abuses was tortured for several years prior to his trial beginning:

His treatment was bad enough that you don't have to be counter-factual about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bradley_Manning#Detention

Last time I checked May -> April was still 11 months, and definitely not "several years".

> Additionally, Obama himself declared him (Manning) guilty in public before his trial even began. (I wish I was making this up.)

As far as I can tell from Googling, he said in a conversation, in the context of the rule of law, the "he broke the law". And that was it.

Am I missing something?

The rest of the context from the sites Google finds seems to indicate that Manning can't possibly get a fair trial, because the officers who would have to decide his guilt would treat that as some kind of order. Which is simply untrue, as evidenced by Manning's own reaction by asking for a bench trial.

If he had asked for a jury trial he would have had many more people to possibly conceive of his innocence. And the jury pool would have contained enlisted members as well, not just officers.

By asking for a bench trial he's one, and only one, commissioned officer away from being found guilty. That would be an insane choice, if this officer were really that susceptible to finding Manning guilty simply because Obama failed to use the word "allegedly" in a conversation.

Luckily, as Manning realizes since he's actually in the freaking military, that isn't the case at all.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by ekianjo on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:26PM (#5974787)
Yeah. And waterboarding is not torture, i guess. You can play with words all you like.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by adamconroy on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:35PM (#5974844)
Isn't his real concern that he could be electrocuted for this?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:55PM (#5974232)
If "being a hero" requires risk (which I disagree with), then whenever it is possible to take the actions of a hero without the associated risk then it in fact becomes preferred that people not be heroes. Nobody has an obligation to become a martyr; there is no obligation to seek out risk, or to not evade it.

To your edit: See Article 14 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by throwaway9848 on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:04PM (#5974284)
To the UN document (which has dubious jurisdiction, but I'll play along):

"Everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution"

Which is followed by:

"This right may not be invoked in the case of prosecutions genuinely arising from non-political crimes or from acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations"

Which negates your point, because of this:

http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/NEWS/A_U.S.%20new...

I don't understand what your point is about the nature of heroism.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:14PM (#5974371)
> dubious jurisdiction

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights has no jurisdiction, it is not a law... If you are confusing it for one, then I think you have some reading to do.

> http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/NEWS/A_U.S.%20new....

Most political charges are dressed up as non-political. Does this surprise you?

> I don't understand what your point is about the nature of heroism

If your intent for bringing up heroism was not to imply that he should be "brought to justice", "turn himself in", "should not have run", or any variation of those, then consider my point about the nature of heroism to be an aside.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:35PM (#5974487)
> Most political charges are dressed up as non-political. Does this surprise you?

Snowden's own father says he broke the law... but he wasn't a traitor in doing so. But I don't believe the UDHR talks about treason in their exception request.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:54PM (#5974605)
Of course he broke the law. So did Tank Man.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:01PM (#5974642)
Sure. But let's call a spade a spade.

He broke the law, and fled to avoid justice. All quite reasonable, from his perspective.

But why is he trying to claim something different? He claims the U.S. pursuit of him is somehow extralegal or some kind of perversion of justice. It's neither.

Snowden decided that the need of the public to know about PRISM was more important than the loss of national security value that would come from revealing the details about it. While that's his decision to make, it's not weird that there are laws in place to protect national security. His father acknowledges that. Hell, even Putin acknowledges that; why can't Snowden now? If you're going to go on the lam then hey, I see why.... but don't act like the government did anything weird in that regard.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:06PM (#5974673)
I don't think this is an "either-or" situation.

He is fleeing "justice", he believes that the US is using extralegal, political, methods to pursue him in order to "bring" him to justice, and he finds it plausible that "justice" will involve a gross violation of his human rights.

I am not seeing the problem here that you seem to think there is. What are you expecting him to say, "The only reason I am running is so that I am not subjected to a fair trail and humane punishment."?

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:09PM (#5974698)
> What are you expecting him to say, "The only reason I am running is so that I am not subjected to a fair trail and humane punishment."?

He could just say "I broke the law for the public good, there's no way to get this issue the attention it deserves otherwise. I intend to remain free even if I have to be in exile, as that is how I can do the most good for the people!" etc etc. Not really that hard, you know. :P

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:13PM (#5974711)
That would be a fine statement, but I have no problem with the statements he has made instead.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:13PM (#5974715)
I do, inasmuch as they are lies. :P
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by stordoff on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:38PM (#5974512)
The UDHR is not a law per se, but has likely forms part of the customary international law, and so carries some legal force.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:53PM (#5974602)
It has influenced the creation of laws much like many other documents that lay out rights have. It itself does not carry legal force, though there are laws that implement ideas laid out by it that do.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by baddox on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:06PM (#5974292)
> Is that a legal obligation for all nations to _grant_ asylum to seekers, regardless of circumstances?

No, it's a legal obligation to not infringe on the right of people to seek and enjoy asylum. Of course, it's the UN, so it's debatable how much of a "legal obligation" any of it is, especially for the USA.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by eli on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:51PM (#5974596)
Doesn't any attempt to capture an international fugitive necessarily infringe that person's right to seek asylum?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by meepmorp on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:03PM (#5974652)
> Doesn't any attempt to capture an international fugitive necessarily infringe that person's right to seek asylum?

Yes. This is what's wrong with this line of reasoning.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by baddox on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:14PM (#5974720)
Based on my reading of the article, yes. It's important to note, however, that the article does not apply to "prosecutions genuinely arising from non-political crimes or from acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations." Presumably the definitions of those terms would be determined on a case-by-case basis by the International Court of Justice.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by rosser on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:10PM (#5974335)
...and is a fugitive from justice.

Only in the narrowest, most legalistic sense of the term. In terms of what is just however, I think there's a lot of room for debate.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by cpleppert on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:50PM (#5974589)
"Without any judicial order," The federal arrest warrant gives the State Department the ability to revoke passports it isn't 'unilateral' nor can the 'administration' revoke a passport for any reason.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by brown9-2 on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:45PM (#5974890)
Assuming Snowden is referring to the UN Declaration of Human Rights, the second part of Section 14 would seem to apply here:

This right may not be invoked in the case of prosecutions genuinely arising from non-political crimes

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by gohrt on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:02PM (#5974649)
That makes no sense. 'Asylum' is a negotiation between the victim and the destination state. The origin state (USA) isn't a relevant party to the decision-making process. That's the whole point of the concept.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:43PM (#5974881)
Well it's quite clear they're a party in the decision-making process if they are able to call up those countries and twist their arms into refusing it, so I don't really understand what point you're making - I guess in theory they're not a relevant party ...but in practice?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by darkchasma on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:20PM (#5973961)
Usually, I respect and appreciate your comments, but this suffers from being overtly pedantic, and clearly missing the forrest for the trees.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by tcoppi on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:31PM (#5974063)
It is pretty much the backbone of his argument in the letter, so I don't think it is overly pedantic.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mindcrime on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:28PM (#5974036)
That's a question of perspective, isn't it? The USA may "claim" Snowden, but Snowden may not "claim" the USA. From his point of view, it may be entirely reasonable to use the term stateless.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:32PM (#5974069)
Well said; better than I could say it. In any modern just society being a "citizen" is an agreement between two parties. Governments no longer own their subjects.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by obviouslygreen on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:22PM (#5973982)
True, but "my passport has been revoked" is not nearly self-promoting or dramatic enough for Snowden. Also, being a citizen of any nation doesn't mean a lot when returning to your country of citizenship means a (possibly one-way) ticket to some place that's not home and comes with the concept of "solitary confinement," among others.

Not that self-promotion or drama are necessarily bad things in his position. Both are most certainly things he's using to keep himself on the minds of as many people as possible for as long as he can.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by michaelhoffman on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:21PM (#5973966)
Equally he has not been given the penalty of "exile." There is nothing the U.S. would like more than to have Snowden return to U.S. soil.

This stretching of the truth does not engender trust.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by EthanHeilman on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:29PM (#5974050)
Exile usually involves a threat of violence if the person returns home. Many exiles are exiles because their home country's government would hurt them if they returned.

"Exile means to be away from one's home (i.e. city, state or country), while either being explicitly refused permission to return and/or being threatened with imprisonment or death upon return." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile

Before calling into question the truth of statements made by a public figure please look up the common definition.

Update:

Websters does not use this exact definition, being a more compact format than wikipedia, but if you look under the examples in Websters you will see "Many chose to live as exiles rather than face persecution." http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/exile

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by michaelhoffman on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:34PM (#5974085)
Snowden is not using the common definition of the phrase. He is explicitly using a legal definition when he says "the extralegal penalty of exile."

To argue that any person who cannot return to their home country without being arrested is "extralegally exiled" would mean that any fugitive is "extralegally exiled," an absurd result.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by EthanHeilman on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:54PM (#5974225)
It depends if the punishment has been legally or extra-legal decided and would be extra-legally carried out. Such claims are always a matter of opinion and whose law, but not all opinions are equal.

1. Threats Made by the US Government: Obama's statements such that Snowden is not worth the effort of an expensive extra-legal killing (“not going to be scrambling jets to get a 29-year-old hacker”) by a president that has engaged in many extra-legal killings, at least one against a US citizen, is a threat of extra-legal action. For instance if someone sent a letter that said "I'd kill you but you aren't worth the bullets" would be interpreted by many courts as a threat. Furthermore direct threats of extra-legal killing have been made by other members of the US government.

2. Prior Actions Against Snowden: The fact that Obama has attempted to use trade deals and threats to prevent Snowdens asylum appeals suggests that Obama and the US government is not willing to give Snowden a fair hearing since they are manipulating the international system of asylum to prevent him from getting a fair hearing internationally.

3.Prior Pattern of Action Against Other Whistle Blowers: Obamas illegal treatment of Bradley Manning is part of a pattern going back before Obama of illegal mistreatment of whistle blowers by the US government.

Given this evidence I would argue that the threat of extra-legal punishment is very much real and has been publicly communicated to all involved parties. The reality and communication of this threat to Snowden makes a very strong case for the claim that he has been extra-legally exiled.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:53PM (#5974221)
It was in fact the one comment I had been about to make. Snowden has chosen to avoid the U.S., explicitly to avoid the legal system. His own father feels he probably technically broke the law so it's hard to claim that the U.S. government has somehow managed to switch all 3 of its branches into a KILL SNOWDEN mode.

If the charges are without merit then one of the very same judges that Snowden feels should be involved in these types of surveillance programs will throw them out.

Snowden's exile may very well be extralegal, but both the exile and the extralegality of it are on Snowden himself.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:19PM (#5974395)
> Snowden has chosen to avoid the U.S., explicitly to avoid the legal system.

No, he's chosen to avoid the US explicitly to avoid torture.

There's nothing legal about that.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:30PM (#5974453)
Are you saying that the US justice system is by definition torture?

If so, I would think Snowden would have made that his moral priority to emphasize. There's no reason to fear "turnkey tyranny" (as he said) when we're already living in a torture regime, is there? In that case there's no key to turn, it's already here!

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:13PM (#5974714)
"turnkey tyranny" describes the future consequence for the median citizen.

Torturing those who leak information prior to trial is something that the US government has already demonstrated a willingness to do. It's simply disgraceful - a national shame.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:21PM (#5974754)
Like how those other NSA whistleblowers were "tortured"? Their treatment was wrong, I'll admit, but calling it torture is insulting to those who have actually been waterboarded by the U.S.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jacquesm on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:00PM (#5974967)
No, it just means that the US engages in more varieties of torture, some of which we consider to be more severe than the others. That does not mean we can't use the same word to indicate all of them.

And why limit yourself to NSA whistleblowers, a government that has crossed this line has crossed that line in general, not just for some class. All this 'just NSA whistleblowers', 'just whistleblowers', 'just foreigners', 'just enemy combatants' and so on isn't fooling anybody.

Some lines you just don't cross, lest you become that which you claim to fight.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:09PM (#5975002)
> And why limit yourself to NSA whistleblowers, a government that has crossed this line has crossed that line in general, not just for some class.

Because the claim isn't that "the USA has tortured people". The claim is that the USA will torture Snowden. Given the wide disparity in justice systems utilized for U.S. citizens, "enemy combatants", and U.S. military, you have to at least make that broad type of distinction to evaluate the probability of the claim that Snowden will be tortured if he returns.

There's no end to the things you can do or refuse to do if your only justification for that action (or lack thereof) is that a government has, at some time, tortured somebody somewhere.

I agree wholeheartedly that the U.S. needs to account for instances where they torture, but that also doesn't completely invalidate the whole government.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by foobarbazqux on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:52PM (#5974924)
Solitary confinement is torture.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:55PM (#5974938)
Which NSA whistleblower was subjected to solitary confinement?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by foobarbazqux on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:02PM (#5974976)
Fair enough, I was thinking of Bradley Manning. I don't know if the other NSA guys were held in solitary. However, I'll be surprised if they capture Snowden and he isn't. Why wouldn't he be?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:12PM (#5975019)
> Why wouldn't he be?

Because there are no bored, humorless Marines in charge of whatever Federal prison Snowden would end up in. I would surmise he should expect the same treatment as any other civilian accused of a Federal felony.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by foobarbazqux on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:55PM (#5975237)
Maybe you don't know this, but there are tens of thousands of prisoners living in long-term solitary in supermax prisons in the US. Why wouldn't Snowden end up with them? What percentage chance is there that he might end up there? What percentage chance justifies an asylum request?

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/03/30/090330fa_fact_...

By the way you might have to click on "link" to reply; I think the thread nesting is too deep.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @10:26PM (#5975404)
I want to say first off, thanks for linking such an informative article (as if I needed more to be depressed about tonight).

I hope I haven't given the impression that I think prolonged solitary confinement is acceptable. But I will say that the idea of someone as infamous as Snowden being put in solitary without actually trying to shank someone is implausible IMHO. Manning's supporters managed to get him transferred out of a military brig, after all, and Snowden's is a much more sympathetic case (with much more international attention to boot).

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by foobarbazqux on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:48PM (#5975705)
Oh you're welcome. I always thought solitary was given for maybe two weeks for really bad behavior or something. I didn't get the impression you thought it was good. If anything, I thought perhaps you were a bit optimistic about our judicial system; on the other hand, perhaps I'm a bit cynical. Either way, if he ends up in the US, I certainly hope you're right.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by kpommerenke on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:36PM (#5974499)
It has nothing to do with torture. Snowden is, quite reasonably, afraid of going to prison for breaking the law.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by res0nat0r on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:35PM (#5974091)
Websters does not have any language of the sort relating to "imprisonment or death upon return". http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/exile

By the Wikipedia definition above every criminal who flees the country to avoid arrest is by definition in exile. Skipping town because you want to avoid a crime isn't being in exile, it is being on the run.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by EthanHeilman on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:02PM (#5974273)
Websters does not use this exact definition, being a more compact format than wikipedia, but if you look under the examples in Websters you will see "Many chose to live as exiles rather than face persecution." http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/exile
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by willvarfar on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:41PM (#5974145)
Fun that we reach for the wikipedia definition of a word; that definition is easily editable.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by fragsworth on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:28PM (#5974037)
What??? He is, very clearly by definition, exiled.

From Wikipedia: Exile means to be away from one's home (i.e. city, state or country), while either being explicitly refused permission to return and/or being threatened with imprisonment or death upon return.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lttlrck on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:35PM (#5974090)
So if I rob a bank and flee to South America to escape justice I am exiled? Give me a break.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by baddox on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:08PM (#5974312)
Yes, that absolutely means you're exiled. I'm not sure what the controversy is here.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by brown9-2 on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:49PM (#5974914)
It's a misappropriation of the meaning of forced exile as a punishment.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:39PM (#5974124)
Exile is indeed how it is generally described when the "bank" is a "country" and "you" are a "dictator".
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by thenewkid on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:48PM (#5974187)
Yes, except it would be self-exile.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by olefoo on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:27PM (#5974021)
If your alternatives are "Return to your home country and face torture." or "Accept that you will have to live out your days under the protection of a government not your own."; I would say that qualifies as being forced into exile.

And no, the use of the word "Torture" is not hyperbole in this case; no matter what technicalities you sugar coat it with; the US Government lacks all credibility on the issue of human rights at this time.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by thufry on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:41PM (#5974143)
Would you consider someone who murdered several children and then fled the country to be in exile? Because his choices would be to return and face the death penalty, or live in hiding abroad.

Whether you think he did a good thing or a bad thing, it's clear that Snowden is, by his own acknowledgment, guilty of multiple counts of serious felonies in the United States. The government is acting as expected, given this fact.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by olefoo on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:33PM (#5974474)
Your needlessly inflammatory hypothetical example is irrelevant in this case. Snowden did not; no matter whose rhetoric one accepts uncritically, perform an act of violence. And most people's moral calculus admits the concept of the balance of harms; whereby an acts benefits to the public at large or the victims of an evildoer outweigh the harms to the evildoer of having it's evil actions revealed to the world.

That the US government is acting as we might expect rather than allowing a congressional investigation into these clearly unconstitutional programs and the legal smokescreen that was designed to prevent any challenge to their legality; is not an advertisement for it's good faith towards the citizenry.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by thufry on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:49PM (#5974580)
The US government may or may not start a congressional investigation into these programs. PRISM may or may not be declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. But even if both things happen, the US will do everything they can to get Snowden, convict him, and put him in jail for the rest of his life.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by baddox on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:09PM (#5974321)
> Would you consider someone who murdered several children and then fled the country to be in exile?

Yes, absolutely. Are there any English speakers who wouldn't?

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:39PM (#5974863)
We would say "self-imposed exile". Or colloquially, that he was "on the lam". Exile is where someone else imposes it on you.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by baddox on Monday July 01, 2013 @10:05PM (#5975299)
The distinction seems vague to me. It's either "don't come back or we will throw you in jail for coming back" or "don't come back or we will throw you in jail for committing a previous crime."
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:11PM (#5975578)
For the latter, you could very well be judged not guilty and go off scot-free. Whereas with exile you get thrown in the slammer just for coming back.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by samstave on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:10PM (#5974331)
Wasn't roman Polanski living in exile in France after being wanted for sex with a minor?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:00PM (#5974636)
A quick google search confirms that yes, Polanski could be said to have been in "exile" in France, according to numerous news organizations. Great example.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:25PM (#5974424)
Thank you for an injection of sanity and reason into the thread.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by dmiladinov on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:29PM (#5974046)
According to Wikipedia:

Exile means to be away from one's home (i.e. city, state or country), while either being explicitly refused permission to return and/or being threatened with imprisonment or death upon return.

So he's probably not so much worried about whether or not he can return to the U.S., but rather what would happen to him when he did.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mpyne on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:53PM (#5974930)
Even so, the imprisonment would be because he returned per se. He may come back and the jury says "not guilty" and walk off a free man, after all.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by gfodor on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:35PM (#5974096)
I would never come back to the U.S. if I was due the punishment afforded to Bradley Manning.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by dreamfactory on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:09PM (#5974323)
And this is the problem of being too willing and too brutal when making examples of transgressors.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by runjake on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:26PM (#5974015)
You're parting hairs and completely missed Snowden's point: that the US government has slickly put him in limbo. He either turns himself in or ends up like the guy in the Tom Hanks movie, Terminal.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by michaelhoffman on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:28PM (#5974041)
Stretching the truth is wholly unnecessary to making such a point. Need I argue that the ends do not justify the means?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by EthanHeilman on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:36PM (#5974099)
But clearly he did not stretch the truth, you just failed to understand the full meaning of exile. An accident, but easily remedied. Why are you so insistent that he is stretching the truth?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:34PM (#5974079)
Your argument stems from an inability to check what "exile" is...

     "Exile means to be away from one's home (i.e. city, state
     or country), while either being explicitly refused
     permission to return and/or being threatened with
     imprisonment or death upon return." [0]
Hopefully that clears things up...

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by mbreese on Monday July 01, 2013 @08:15PM (#5974728)
Just to be clear - he hasn't been exiled by the US. He is in self-imposed exile to avoid prosecution.

They haven't revoked his citizenship... just his passport. That doesn't remove citizenship, just the ability to travel abroad.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by sneak on Monday July 01, 2013 @10:20PM (#5975376)
If he returns to the US he will be tortured, as Manning was, prior to trial for much the same charge.

It's not self-imposed exile if returning to the US is a non-option due to their DEMONSTRATED TENDENCY to deny prisoners their basic human rights.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by tome on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:52PM (#5974219)
My understanding is that the imprisonment/death would be a penalty for breaking the terms of the exile, which is something quite different.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:56PM (#5974239)
Fair enough, but at this point it's pretty close to exile without being a perfect example...

Still: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5974040

I think effectively it is a bad situation which has been created for him by the United States government. They are definitely manipulating his citizenship for their purposes whether you like the wording or not.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by tome on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:59PM (#5974258)
They revoked his passport because he's wanted for questioning about a crime. How is that different from any other criminal who flees abroad?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lhnz on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:09PM (#5974325)
They revoked his passport because they needed time to negotiate with other countries to refuse him the right to asylum.

And this isn't about just being questioned. If he is extradited back to the US, expect a lot worse to happen to him...

What he has done is no doubt illegal, but it also strikes me as a positive thing. I disagree with people that say he is a fugitive from justice - I think it's very clear that he is a fugitive from injustice. He has shown us injustices from the US government - and now they wish to have him stand trial in order that they can lock him up for life, sentence him to death or torture him.

Is there a difference between Snowden and other criminals? Yes, Snowden has done the right thing.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by jlgreco on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:24PM (#5973996)
The state in question may feel that he still "belongs" to them in some fashion, but it seems pretty likely to me that he does not believe that state is "his" anymore.

He is under no obligation to make concessions to them by adopting terminology which they control.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by knowknowledge on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:22PM (#5973974)
What does it even mean for a passport to be revoked?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by lawnchair_larry on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:43PM (#5974166)
I'm wondering about this question myself. It's not as if the facts of your identity change because a country revokes a document. Is it just a policy issue, that there are no countries that allow entry without showing a passport?

It certifies his identity, not his rights. I'm not sure how you can suddenly claim it's not valid, without claiming that the original certification was found to be incorrect.

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by dreamfactory on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:12PM (#5974356)
It sounds like the old Russian system where you couldn't leave the country without a passport (and it was made very hard to get one).
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by marshray on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:29PM (#5974048)
It means that it is made not valid by the issuing country.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by syjer on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:39PM (#5974119)
doesn't he fall in the "de facto" stateless person as defined by the unhcr http://www.refworld.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/rwmain?docid=4ca1a... ?

(just asking, IANAL, so maybe some technicalities elude me)

Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by corin_ on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:18PM (#5973948)
I wonder whether that choice of phrase was a genuine mistake, an exaggeration based on emotion, or a calculated lie. I like to think it was the middle one.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by famousactress on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:22PM (#5973981)
I don't buy that. So far we've seen nothing but pitch perfect and intentional language choices from him. I still can't believe how remarkably well thought out and savvy all of his answers to the AMA thing were. I suspect he'd argue he's stateless because his citizenship in the US has been compromised, that he wouldn't be afforded the ability to be treated fairly like a citizen, hence the asylum requests.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by corin_ on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:38PM (#5974116)
It's not really a valid argument, though. Even if there was a complete certainty that returning to the US would see him tortured and eventually executed, that still wouldn't change the fact that he is still a US citizen (unless he chooses not to be). That's why I'm hoping, all-be-it doubtfully, that it was innocent exaggeration rather than a lie - not that it really makes a huge difference I guess.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by famousactress on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:43PM (#5974160)
Doesn't leaving, refusing to return, and requesting asylum effectively fall under the "choosing not to be" category?
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by corin_ on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @02:38AM (#5976203)
By that logic I'm effectively banned from Africa, as I don't plan on going there. He said they "evoked my passport, leaving my stateless" not that he was effectively stateless due to his own decisions.
Re:Statement from Edward Snowden in Moscow by bmelton on Monday July 01, 2013 @07:12PM (#5974357)
For what it's worth, the department of state correspondent Matthew Lee in CSPAN interviews were using "stateless" to describe Snowden as well, and days before he released this release.

If Snowden is mistaken in using this terminology, he isn't the only one.