News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by msy on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:34AM (#5938950)
And this is why we all need to start encrypting everything. Every HTTP request, every email. There's strength in numbers and privacy in a crowd. They may have massive resources but they're not limitless, we have the technology available to render tools like PRISM unfeasible for the foreseeable future, the choice is ours.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by StavrosK on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:47AM (#5939022)
It's really chilling when you realize this is your government you're talking about. It sounds like some dystopian future where normal citizens have to hide from their government's eye, but it's here and now.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by cypherpunks01 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:22AM (#5939214)
Yep, scary. This is the cyberpunk future, after all.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:35AM (#5939698)
Encrypt your email. Help support jobs for mathnerdspooks. Seriously, the more people they have to hire to sort our garbage personal communications, the more likely future leaks will be about this invasive, wasteful, unnecessary threat to (life, the universe, everything).
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by enraged_camel on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:03PM (#5940415)
>>Seriously, the more people they have to hire to sort our garbage personal communications...

The more taxes we will all have to pay. :)

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by davidcuddeback on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:16PM (#5940493)
And nothing motivates voters more than their wallets.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:28PM (#5941041)
Yup, and that makes it harder to do in secret.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mindcrime on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:39AM (#5940227)
I forget who first said this, but...

"I used to wonder when the cyberpunk future was going to get here. Then I realized we're living in it"

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by LoganCale on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:15PM (#5941369)
We've had the technology of the cyberpunk future for a while, and now we have the dystopia as well.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by theboywho on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:38AM (#5939315)
NSA logic: Don't encrypt your data or we'll keep it until we decrypt it.

So, they will keep it until they can figure out its content ? Fine, so why make it easy on them by giving them plain content from minute 0 ?

I don't see why would anyone able to encrypt his/her data not to.

The problem is not about them keeping encrypted data but about them labeling you as a potential bad guy once you have encrypted data.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by antocv on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:50AM (#5939396)
Indeed that is the problem, we are now at the point where you are marked a target for trying to keep some privacy between you and your friends, when you try to keep a third-party, the government, at bay your citizenship rights are temporarily suspended.

"Deine papiere bitte" on the streets is not that far away. Actually what we have today is worse, self-censorship and suspension of rights.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:40AM (#5939741)
>"Deine papiere bitte" on the streets is not that far away.

Yup. It is practically here, license plate scanners, NSA metadata with location, constant surveillance. The only thing missing is automatic enforcement of the many petty crimes we commit each day (but you will be threatened with them if the gov't needs you to inform against someone, or simply wants you to plead guilty to some crime).

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by 77887 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:12PM (#5940922)
>>The only thing missing is automatic enforcement of the many petty crimes we commit each day

We already have this. Red light cameras.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by wahsd on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:35PM (#5940635)
As long as there is no default way of doing that for the majority of activity of the lowly user it will not succeed. If, e.g., Mozilla and Ubuntu built it in to all their assets by default with the ability to disable it, then you might have a working plan to overload and drain away the resources put towards decrypting data.

Does it dawn on anyone else that our government has and will continue to have turned on its own people. Let that sink in for a couple seconds. The the majority of the legislature instituted it and the executive has been executing it with impunity.

It is already bad enough just based on principle as to what is being done to the rest of the world, but our own government has turned on its own people. Just like Europe didn't quite understand what it was getting into, let's say late ~1910 and again in ~1930, because what was to come was so beyond their experience and comprehension; we are making the same mistake and not quite comprehending the ramifications and consequences that will wash over us.

No one wants to acknowledge it, but the enemy is within. Tyranny is spreading the way it does and will not be apparent until it is too late.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by Joeri on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:07PM (#5941317)
The irony is that reforming the U.S. so that it turned insular and tore itself apart was the very goal of the terrorists who this system is supposed to defend against. The remedy is becoming the disease itself.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mhandley on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:33AM (#5939284)
As a non-US citizen, they can keep all my communications forever anyway. It seems to me that my only redress is to encrypt as much as I can now so as to chaff that one time at some point in the future when I do have something to hide.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by phryk on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:41AM (#5939338)
Yep, and I think they can even keep all the communications of everyone in the US you communicate with.

Not encrypting to stay secure is just plain fucking stupid. If you don't encrypt they can read your shit anyways. Plus "reasonably believed to contain secret meaning" in all likelihood means "whatever the fuck we want".

As someone else already noted: There's strength in numbers. Let's just encrypt everything and have those fuckers deal with humongous amounts of data, most of which will be completely useless. Shit, if you're inclined to do so let some piece of software run all day that just produces encrypted gibberish and sends it off to random recipients.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by joering2 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:25AM (#5940101)
> As someone else already noted: There's strength in numbers. Let's just encrypt everything and have those fuckers deal with humongous amounts of data

Just so you know; the reasoning behind huge NSA camp they are building in Utah is not because huge camps are cool, but because someone at decisions level was presented with average number of data an average citizen of us soil digest per day, and that number was overwhelming.

So, if we all encrypt everything, 2 things gonna happen:

Either they will ask to quadruple their funding and build 10 more Utah-type camps "because we need more storage and CPU resources to catch those pesky terrorist", or

The problem will be so huge for the government that it will ban usage of PGP/encrypting. The light version of banning would be, for example: extra tax if you encrypt your data. I can see it easily reasoned: terrorist use PGP encryption so the government uses lots of resources (that equals to money) to crack those down so in order to keep their operation running they need extra money. Of course if you do not use PGP you don't have to pay that tax. If you do use PGP, you are required to pay it. Simple checkbox on your tax form. Now, if they every catch you with some encrypted files that they can reasonably say belongs to you (just like the can/cannot tell the child porn files belong to you [they can always upload them themselves]), you will be charge with a severe fine or imprisonment up to 25 years for aiding terrorist [by not supporting NSA Encryption Unit financially -- remember Bush motto? you not with us, you with terrorist].

So, long story short. Just pissing them off and encrypting everything will not fix the issue. It will just give them more reasons to ask for more funding. And they will get them.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:22AM (#5939598)
Nobody should believe that any encryption used today will be secure against attack from anyone after nnn days due to technological advance. Even if no weakness is ever found with which to attack the encryption, Moore's Law will eventually take care of it.

edit: yeah, I was talking out my ass, get over it. I still think it's imprudent to assume that encrypted files may never be compromised in the future.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:00AM (#5939906)
This is pretty crap, actually. http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2009/09/the_doghouse_c...

You couldn't even increment every position of a 256-bit key using the energy our Sun could provide, let alone brute force 256-bit AES.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by kamjam on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:58AM (#5940370)
I often TrueCrypt (http://www.truecrypt.org/) as containers to transport private documents on USB or in emails, and able to use multiple encryption algorithms for the containers (e.g. AES-Twofish-Serpent). Something like this will presumably slow them [NSA] down umpteen amounts of times?
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by josephg on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:22PM (#5941405)
Snowden:

> Encryption works. Properly implemented strong crypto systems are one of the few things that you can rely on. Unfortunately, endpoint security is so terrifically weak that NSA can frequently find ways around it.

You probably don't need to use 3 cyphers. Just make sure you're storing your private key somewhere safe.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:19PM (#5940517)
Not sure, I'm not a crypto wizard. My guess would be that "it depends". What you describe was more-or-less the basis for 3DES IIRC, but (knowing crypto) you could probably just as easily accidentally break the cryptosystem to the effectiveness of just the best scheme.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:46AM (#5940282)
Fine, scratch the last part.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by pyre on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:35AM (#5939708)
They are collection a ton of data. As time goes on, if a large portion of it is encrypted, then it may not be feasible to break it all, even with Moore's Law. They may just have to be selective with it. You can imagine that even in if the US becomes a new-age Nazi Germany / Stalin's Russia, it may still be prohibitively expensive to go spelunking through years old communications looking for people with possible subversive thoughts.

Edit: It would probably just be easier at that point to ban encryption going forward.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by endeavour on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:13AM (#5939998)
You've simultaneously managed to misinterpret both the way encryption works and Moore's Law.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:56AM (#5940359)
I should have known better than to paraphrase or quote "Moore's Law" out of context around here. I usually feel its safe to do so because I don't really consider Moore's Law to be Law, as much as "Moore's Quite Good Prediction"

s/Moore's Law/technological advance and\/or advances in cryptanalysis/

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by lifeformed on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:53AM (#5939411)
I wonder if you could tie up the NSA with honeypot spam? Just send tons of encrypted data from a bunch of different sources, 24/7. You could even hide your legitimate messages within it.

Does a system like that exist? A constant stream of random bytes, some of it real information, most of it not. Only those intended to be the recipient know where to look.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by daturkel on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:03AM (#5939474)
It's often possible to distinguish random data from encrypted data using something like a chi square test. However, if you just encrypted random bytes, then it would look just as encrypted as your real data (because it is). Alternatively, you could just encrypt spam emails (it'd be cute if a system like this encrypted and sent every spam email that you received).
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by ronaldx on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:34AM (#5940188)
Ideally, encrypted data should be indistinguishable from random.

I agree, this may not be true in practice.

[Presumably, NSA is not collecting all sources of random data?]

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by jessaustin on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:30PM (#5941454)
...system like this encrypted and sent every spam email that you received

I wanted to like this proposal, but then I realized these encrypted spams have to be sent somewhere. Any ethical target would be too easy for "the bad guys" to filter. Oh well.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by msy on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:49AM (#5939814)
I can't edit that now but actions speak louder than words - get your GPG key set up today: http://gpgtools.github.io/GPGTools_Homepage/keychain/ It takes 5 minutes, tops. If you've spent 5 minutes talking or worrying about this issue you owe it to yourself to do it. Set it up with your favorite email client and encourage your friends to do the same.

My public key is here: http://sho.ch/alexgraul.publickey and on the gpg keyserver, where's yours?

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by leephillips on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:53AM (#5939856)
I've had my public key available on my website for years. Nobody uses it. The problem is social: people are not in the habit of using encryption and only the technically adept have any idea how. Even my correspondents who know how to use gpg don't bother.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by acabal on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:08AM (#5939967)
That, and the fact that public/private key encryption is difficult to understand on a conceptual level, uses poor, inconsistent, or misleading terminology, and has a user-hostile interface with GPG or a buggy and error-prone interface with Enigmail. The problem is social in part because we've done such a poor job packaging and marketing the solution.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by unimpressive on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:15AM (#5940029)
This, a thousand times this. I could write an entire post on the key metaphor alone. I don't think anyone has ever had their conceptual understanding improved by calling the codes you use to encrypt and decrypt things 'keys'. If we insist on calling them that, can we at least make sure to explain why it's called a key, instead of giving people the impression that it somehow works like an actual key?
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by 6d0debc071 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:03PM (#5942441)
I wonder whether users need to know the difference.

Seriously, the are few situations where someone's actually going to want to post their private key to the internet - at least if they understand what it is - so what are we imaging that they're doing with it that they need to know about it in the first place?

You're probably going to want them to have a backup, but you can have them make a backup without having them understand the difference - you just have your program back up a folder structure that the private key is hidden somewhere in and only make the public one obvious. Make them aware that if they don't backup they won't be able to access their emails - should the worst happen - but don't tell them why. Someone with a push-button understanding of computer... they just don't really need to know why.

... -sigh-

I almost wonder whether it wouldn't be easier to market public-private key crypto as a packaged solution. Buy an encrypted email address kind of thing. Send people a physical token they mentally associate with that email address and tell them not to lose it.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by milfot on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:36AM (#5940210)
maybe the public key should be called a lock.. lock and key makes sense to me
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by jessaustin on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:21PM (#5941401)
Except in other contexts, the use of the public and private keys is reversed. I use my private key to generate signatures: does it aid understanding to tell someone to use my "lock" to verify such signatures?
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by ippisl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @07:19PM (#5943104)
Just tell the user he can't sign things without a profile, and make keys with each profile.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by milfot on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:16PM (#5943514)
good point

but maybe this is a different thing conceptually i think i would call that a stamp or a seal ..sort of like a wax imprint of a key

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by xradionut on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:24PM (#5941017)
I agree and disagree:

GPG has a sucky API and crazy CLI. It's a stack of eggs that everyone is scared to improve.

People don't even try to understand the bare basics of PKI or even security because they are fundamental lazy and not required too. No one expects them to understand the math, just the few processes required for basic usage. If you can understand the arcane rules of baseball, or how to drive a stick, or solder, or field strip a pistol or basic cooking, you can learn how to "use" encryption.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by cabalamat on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:06PM (#5941309)
> That, and the fact that public/private key encryption is difficult to understand on a conceptual level, uses poor, inconsistent, or misleading terminology

Consider https. That is very easy to use, because the user doesn't have to do anything to use it. The user doesn't need to know anything about encryption.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by DanBC on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:18PM (#5941379)
> Consider https. That is very easy to use, because the user doesn't have to do anything to use it. The user doesn't need to know anything about encryption.

Doesn't this mean that many users will just click through any errors, thus making https less secure than it could be?

Consider the evolution of warnings. Padlocks were shown in different states and colours, then pop-up dialogue boxes appeared, and now Chrome has an entire red screen with a suitably stern warning.

You're right that https is the easiest form of PKI for users to understand. And they still get it wrong. And that's for encryption that could make a difference to their lives - people could steal their money or their products or whatnot.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by leephillips on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:29PM (#5941447)
Well, mutt works seamlessly with gpg signatures and encryption, but that's probably not what you had in mind.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by kamjam on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @03:15PM (#5941726)
I remember reading about Hushmail a few years back, encryption was built in the web based email system with PGP, the use would never need to worry about encrypting the mail since it was baked in out of the box, esp between hushmail accounts.

The only problem was that the system was compromised in order to comply with US requests.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hushmail#Compromises_to_email_p...

Good concept, but anything you rely on someone else doing can always be compromised.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by davidcuddeback on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:13PM (#5940472)
> Nobody uses it.

Allow me to be the first. (Check your email.)

In all seriousness, I agree that it's a social problem. I think we (in the tech industry) can do a better job of making the tools easier to use. If we really want to make something like PGP take off, we'll have to provide easy tools that integrate with people's email clients and provide dead simple tutorials of how to get started.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by xtracto on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:18PM (#5943521)
The best way to make people use it is to make it seamless.

I am talking about something like a Chrome/Firefox extension, which creates a GPG key pair for you, uploads the public to some central server and encrypts stuff like the text in your hotmail, gmail, yahoo mail, etc, after you press "send" and before the text is sent to google.

Then, at the other side, the a user with the same extension opens the new message and as soon as it appears, the extension detects that it is an encrypted message, reads the id of the sender and decrypts the message.

There are lots of details which makes this difficult to implement... but that would be the only way to make the vast majority of people use public key encryption.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by randomdata on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:49PM (#5941572)
I think there is a certain level of distrust of the technology on top. I had a discussion about encryption with a group of non-technical peers a while back and every single one of them strongly believed that it could be circumvented with ease. If you come with that attitude, you'll find no reason to use encryption, as it is only as good as plain text at that point anyway.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by cabalamat on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:04PM (#5941295)
Yes, and that's why the software needs to be easier to use. In fact it should be effortless: once installed, it should automatically encrypt on the way out and decrypt on the way in.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by stephengillie on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:21PM (#5941400)
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:56AM (#5939876)
I've had a GPG key of some sort since 2001-09-05, in active use essentially throughout (though for signing, not encryption).

Someday I'll even meet someone real in person and be able to get it signed!

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by Sami_Lehtinen on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:38PM (#5941513)
I've been using PGP from early 90s and most of my friends use it actively too. Just set it up once and after that it's seamless.

Btw. It's time to upgrade the DSA signing key to longer RSA key. Soon GnuPG should have ECC support allowing much shorter keys.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @04:04PM (#5942064)
The was upgraded in 2009 to 4096-bit RSA. In fact I believe hearing of the vuln in DSA-based digital signatures was what led me to do the replacement.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by recursive on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:20PM (#5940524)
> My public key is here: http://sho.ch/alexgraul.publickey and on the gpg keyserver, where's yours?

I don't have one. I, a software developer, have no idea how to get one. And if that's the case, what hope does anyone else have?

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by umsm on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:34PM (#5941095)
It doesn't mean you can't learn. We are our own limit.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by recursive on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:22PM (#5941408)
I have no doubt in my ability to learn how to do it. What I do doubt is how useful it will be unless it's easy enough for a critical mass of users.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by devindotcom on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:24PM (#5941416)
What's the best option for Windows users? I know I could just search, but I trust the hivemind more.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by jlgaddis on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:17AM (#5944942)
Symantec PGP Desktop / Endpoint Encryption
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by ianstallings on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:24AM (#5939224)
Start by using HTTPS-Everywhere plug in: https://www.eff.org/https-everywhere
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by kamjam on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:00PM (#5940390)
Except it will make no difference when Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, Facebook etc just hand over your data anyway.

Nice plugin though, installed.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by sp332 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:39AM (#5939736)
I combine this with the HTTPS Finder https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/https-finder/ which detects when a HTTPS version of a site exists and redirects you. It also writes a rule for HTTPS Everywhere so you don't visit the HTTP version again.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by danbruc on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:38AM (#5938972)
The problem is that we are not enough - you have to get the other 95 % not really caring on the bandwagon...and this without causing the slightest bit of additional inconvenience.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by buro9 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:06AM (#5939105)
We own websites... make them SSL.

We affect the 95%.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by malloc2x on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:56AM (#5939424)
You must assume that the NSA already has master keys for all domestic CA root certificates, and given how many were hacked recently, foreign ones too. In which case SSL traffic is effectively the same as plaintext to them.

The solution could be a distributed CA system like http://convergence.io/

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by karlmdavis on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:55AM (#5939866)
Is this correct? Wouldn't they still need all of the leaf private keys to decrypt things?

My understanding was that having a CA's private key just enables someone to issue new child keys for that CA. That vulnerability could be addressed with certificate pinning.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by malloc2x on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:50AM (#5940318)
To decrypt after-the-handshake bytes I think you're right, they would need a leaf private key.

However, they absolutely can mount a MITM with the CA root.

EDIT: Further, if they can compel a master key then they can also compel a copy of all the private keys the CA generates.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by juhanima on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:06PM (#5941310)
Not quite sure what you mean, but for the record, as a general rule CAs do not generate keys. They just sign the public keys coming in as Certificate Signing Requests. Without ever seeing the accompanied private key.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by jeltz on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:17AM (#5939561)
Perfect forward security should prevent the master key from working.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mhandley on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:18AM (#5939570)
On the other hand, we do have the influence to get something like http://tcpcrypt.org standardized and deployed in commodity operating systems if we really care enough. Then the 95% won't need to care.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by eru on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:49AM (#5939027)
95% would be nice, but a few percent should be good enough, if there's enough traffic overall. (And even 100% would not be enough if there's almost no traffic, like in the beginning of the internet.) Absolute numbers matter more than shares, here.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by greyman on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:42AM (#5938994)
Or it is rather 99.995? ;-)
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by danbruc on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @08:51AM (#5939034)
True. 316 million US citizens and 117 thousands of them signing the Snowden petition yields a first approximation of 99.96 %.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by sixothree on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:06AM (#5939102)
The Direct Project as part of the ARRA stage 2 meaningful use is worth looking at since encrypted emails will be widely adopted by medical professionals. Maybe this project will be useful for the rest of America.

http://wiki.directproject.org/

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mikegreen on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:14AM (#5939160)
The challenge is if you encrypt every email, you're basically using your own email server and service. The gov't isn't decrypting your HTTPS gmail traffic - it is going to Google, saying "hey, give me msy's emails from 2007 to 2010. k?thnx buhbye!"

So you essentially have to go off the usual grid to run your own email service... then you have to get all your contacts onboard with using it.

I have a client that uses zixmail - webmail that is https and just sends notifications to your plain-old-text email, then you login and read and reply to your email over https. Ironically, it is a gov't agency that makes us use it.. I wonder if they snoop on their own encrypted, vendor-provided secure email?

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by prg318 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:27AM (#5939240)
Lavabit encrypts all of their stored email to the point that if you lose your password there is no way to recover your email. It might be worth checking out their service [1]. I've switched to lavabit from gmail and outside of a minor outage, I have had no complaints.

[1] http://lavabit.com/

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by fein on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:36AM (#5939302)
I loooove lavabit. Stumbled across it a year ago, and it's my primary account for all my freelance work.

The only problem is that a lavabit email is generally viewed as an anonymous (burner) email, so half the services I want to register to just kick the email back as not being "legitimate" enough.

For human to human emails it's great.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by prg318 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:55PM (#5941615)
If you want to use something other than "@lavabit.com" for your e-mail address, you can. If you have a domain name, you can point your MX records for your domain at the lavabit servers to have your mail forwarded to your lavabit inbox. For example, you could get "[email protected]" and direct it to your lavabit inbox. After setting the MX records, you would just need to send an e-mail to lavabit support to have them set it up on their side.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by q3k on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:24AM (#5939221)
Or you can use GPG or some other form of point-to-point encryption.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by darkarmani on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:41AM (#5939747)
> So you essentially have to go off the usual grid to run your own email service... then you have to get all your contacts onboard with using it.

Running a mail server is off-grid these days? Can't you just use pgp encryption and it doesn't matter where your email is stored.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by DanBC on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:46AM (#5939799)
> Running a mail server is off-grid these days?

The vast majority of people are not able to run a mail server. Of the ones that do some should not be doing it because they're not clueful enough to keep it secure and out of blocklists.

> Can't you just use pgp encryption and it doesn't matter where your email is stored.

Most people get freaked out by context menus and right-clicking. You're smart; you're surrounded by smart people; you're surrounded by people who know computers. I think you might be unaware of just how bad most people are with computers.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by EFruit on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:30AM (#5939653)
Woah, we don't want to go there.

If they can't get the data in transit, they'll go for the sources and destinations. Legally mandated keyloggers, anyone? An 'adversary' as markedly omnipresent as the NSA has had no problems [1][2][3] with intruding upon infrastructure, and I doubt your pesky little Win8 tablet or your pretty little Linux box would be able to withstand even a fraction of what the NSA could set up as a push-button intrusion system.

A click of a button, and you're compromised.

If you mess with the bull, you'll get the horns.

[1] http://rt.com/news/snowden-nsa-china-hack-120/ [2] http://venturebeat.com/2013/06/12/nsa-global-surveillance/ [3] http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/snowden-says-nsa-ha...

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by rwl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:29PM (#5941052)
> And this is why we all need to start encrypting everything. Every HTTP request, every email. There's strength in numbers and privacy in a crowd.

And strength in numbers is not the only reason to do this. The more people expect that their Internet communications are private by default, the more outrageous it will seem to the general public that encrypted data is an exception to whatever rules there are against storing and targeting data from U.S. citizens. "Encrypt everything by default" is a good policy for changing social attitudes, not just a technological measure to defeat an unconstitutional practice.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by LoganCale on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:17PM (#5941376)
Furthermore, it's a counter to the absurd argument that our emails are not private because we share them with third party servers. By encrypting them, we are clearly asserting our intent for them to remain private.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by nicholasjarnold on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:59AM (#5939452)
This is almost exactly what I logged in to say. If we all use strong encryption to secure our private communications then we'll quickly exhaust all available decryption resources possessed by any government or entity looking to do massive-scale dragnet surveillance.

We do have a choice here, and our collective decisions will be what shape our future and our future government. Without a concerted effort we're doomed to slip ever closer to a dystopian future of zero privacy and ever present suspicion of everyone.