News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by msy on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:49AM (#5939814)
I can't edit that now but actions speak louder than words - get your GPG key set up today: http://gpgtools.github.io/GPGTools_Homepage/keychain/ It takes 5 minutes, tops. If you've spent 5 minutes talking or worrying about this issue you owe it to yourself to do it. Set it up with your favorite email client and encourage your friends to do the same.

My public key is here: http://sho.ch/alexgraul.publickey and on the gpg keyserver, where's yours?

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by leephillips on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:53AM (#5939856)
I've had my public key available on my website for years. Nobody uses it. The problem is social: people are not in the habit of using encryption and only the technically adept have any idea how. Even my correspondents who know how to use gpg don't bother.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by acabal on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:08AM (#5939967)
That, and the fact that public/private key encryption is difficult to understand on a conceptual level, uses poor, inconsistent, or misleading terminology, and has a user-hostile interface with GPG or a buggy and error-prone interface with Enigmail. The problem is social in part because we've done such a poor job packaging and marketing the solution.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by unimpressive on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:15AM (#5940029)
This, a thousand times this. I could write an entire post on the key metaphor alone. I don't think anyone has ever had their conceptual understanding improved by calling the codes you use to encrypt and decrypt things 'keys'. If we insist on calling them that, can we at least make sure to explain why it's called a key, instead of giving people the impression that it somehow works like an actual key?
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by 6d0debc071 on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:03PM (#5942441)
I wonder whether users need to know the difference.

Seriously, the are few situations where someone's actually going to want to post their private key to the internet - at least if they understand what it is - so what are we imaging that they're doing with it that they need to know about it in the first place?

You're probably going to want them to have a backup, but you can have them make a backup without having them understand the difference - you just have your program back up a folder structure that the private key is hidden somewhere in and only make the public one obvious. Make them aware that if they don't backup they won't be able to access their emails - should the worst happen - but don't tell them why. Someone with a push-button understanding of computer... they just don't really need to know why.

... -sigh-

I almost wonder whether it wouldn't be easier to market public-private key crypto as a packaged solution. Buy an encrypted email address kind of thing. Send people a physical token they mentally associate with that email address and tell them not to lose it.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by milfot on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @11:36AM (#5940210)
maybe the public key should be called a lock.. lock and key makes sense to me
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by jessaustin on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:21PM (#5941401)
Except in other contexts, the use of the public and private keys is reversed. I use my private key to generate signatures: does it aid understanding to tell someone to use my "lock" to verify such signatures?
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by ippisl on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @07:19PM (#5943104)
Just tell the user he can't sign things without a profile, and make keys with each profile.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by milfot on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:16PM (#5943514)
good point

but maybe this is a different thing conceptually i think i would call that a stamp or a seal ..sort of like a wax imprint of a key

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by xradionut on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:24PM (#5941017)
I agree and disagree:

GPG has a sucky API and crazy CLI. It's a stack of eggs that everyone is scared to improve.

People don't even try to understand the bare basics of PKI or even security because they are fundamental lazy and not required too. No one expects them to understand the math, just the few processes required for basic usage. If you can understand the arcane rules of baseball, or how to drive a stick, or solder, or field strip a pistol or basic cooking, you can learn how to "use" encryption.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by cabalamat on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:06PM (#5941309)
> That, and the fact that public/private key encryption is difficult to understand on a conceptual level, uses poor, inconsistent, or misleading terminology

Consider https. That is very easy to use, because the user doesn't have to do anything to use it. The user doesn't need to know anything about encryption.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by DanBC on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:18PM (#5941379)
> Consider https. That is very easy to use, because the user doesn't have to do anything to use it. The user doesn't need to know anything about encryption.

Doesn't this mean that many users will just click through any errors, thus making https less secure than it could be?

Consider the evolution of warnings. Padlocks were shown in different states and colours, then pop-up dialogue boxes appeared, and now Chrome has an entire red screen with a suitably stern warning.

You're right that https is the easiest form of PKI for users to understand. And they still get it wrong. And that's for encryption that could make a difference to their lives - people could steal their money or their products or whatnot.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by leephillips on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:29PM (#5941447)
Well, mutt works seamlessly with gpg signatures and encryption, but that's probably not what you had in mind.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by kamjam on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @03:15PM (#5941726)
I remember reading about Hushmail a few years back, encryption was built in the web based email system with PGP, the use would never need to worry about encrypting the mail since it was baked in out of the box, esp between hushmail accounts.

The only problem was that the system was compromised in order to comply with US requests.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hushmail#Compromises_to_email_p...

Good concept, but anything you rely on someone else doing can always be compromised.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by davidcuddeback on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:13PM (#5940472)
> Nobody uses it.

Allow me to be the first. (Check your email.)

In all seriousness, I agree that it's a social problem. I think we (in the tech industry) can do a better job of making the tools easier to use. If we really want to make something like PGP take off, we'll have to provide easy tools that integrate with people's email clients and provide dead simple tutorials of how to get started.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by xtracto on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @09:18PM (#5943521)
The best way to make people use it is to make it seamless.

I am talking about something like a Chrome/Firefox extension, which creates a GPG key pair for you, uploads the public to some central server and encrypts stuff like the text in your hotmail, gmail, yahoo mail, etc, after you press "send" and before the text is sent to google.

Then, at the other side, the a user with the same extension opens the new message and as soon as it appears, the extension detects that it is an encrypted message, reads the id of the sender and decrypts the message.

There are lots of details which makes this difficult to implement... but that would be the only way to make the vast majority of people use public key encryption.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by randomdata on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:49PM (#5941572)
I think there is a certain level of distrust of the technology on top. I had a discussion about encryption with a group of non-technical peers a while back and every single one of them strongly believed that it could be circumvented with ease. If you come with that attitude, you'll find no reason to use encryption, as it is only as good as plain text at that point anyway.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by cabalamat on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:04PM (#5941295)
Yes, and that's why the software needs to be easier to use. In fact it should be effortless: once installed, it should automatically encrypt on the way out and decrypt on the way in.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by stephengillie on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:21PM (#5941400)
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @10:56AM (#5939876)
I've had a GPG key of some sort since 2001-09-05, in active use essentially throughout (though for signing, not encryption).

Someday I'll even meet someone real in person and be able to get it signed!

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by Sami_Lehtinen on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:38PM (#5941513)
I've been using PGP from early 90s and most of my friends use it actively too. Just set it up once and after that it's seamless.

Btw. It's time to upgrade the DSA signing key to longer RSA key. Soon GnuPG should have ECC support allowing much shorter keys.

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by mpyne on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @04:04PM (#5942064)
The was upgraded in 2009 to 4096-bit RSA. In fact I believe hearing of the vuln in DSA-based digital signatures was what led me to do the replacement.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by recursive on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:20PM (#5940524)
> My public key is here: http://sho.ch/alexgraul.publickey and on the gpg keyserver, where's yours?

I don't have one. I, a software developer, have no idea how to get one. And if that's the case, what hope does anyone else have?

Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by umsm on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @01:34PM (#5941095)
It doesn't mean you can't learn. We are our own limit.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by recursive on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:22PM (#5941408)
I have no doubt in my ability to learn how to do it. What I do doubt is how useful it will be unless it's easy enough for a critical mass of users.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by devindotcom on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @02:24PM (#5941416)
What's the best option for Windows users? I know I could just search, but I trust the hivemind more.
Re:Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape N... by jlgaddis on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @05:17AM (#5944942)
Symantec PGP Desktop / Endpoint Encryption