News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:22PM (#5929521)
There is a practical way to reduce terrorism and make the US and the world safer that won't cost a dime and doesn't require compromises on civil liberties.

Stop starting and getting involved in foreign wars, stop supporting the abusive policies of Israel, and stop supporting corrupt and abusive governments around the world.

You don't hear much about that option on TV, but it's by far the simplest and best course for all concerned save a handful of greedy and duplicitous folks at the top.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by Ihmahr on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:32PM (#5929574)
I agree. That is why I try to tell people around me exactly this.

US is a terrorizing and terror generating machine.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by personlurking on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:35PM (#5929595)
It's the difference of one letter. War oN Terror vs. War oF Terror, with the latter being by the gov't, on the people.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by joelrunyon on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:36PM (#5930047)
This is copy/paste the same exact response from the top thread on reddit[1]

Been seeing this a lot around here lately...Could be the same user, but I've seen it happening enough that I bet it's not.

[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/1gxehl/chomsky_sp...

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by discostrings on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:16PM (#5930184)
It looks like the reddit user "kaax" is taking insightful posts from HN and posting them on reddit [for karma?]. See the Bitcoin comments at http://www.reddit.com/user/kaax and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5929622 .
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:40PM (#5930254)
It's kind of sleazy but I guess given the topic that I'm just happy for the words to reach more eyes.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by olalonde on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:53PM (#5930709)
Might want to post this on http://www.reddit.com/r/karmaconspiracy.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:05PM (#5930148)
Whoa, weird. Nope, I didn't post this on reddit.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by mladenkovacevic on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:32PM (#5929573)
This.. This is the problem. Yes of course Americans are not safe and are under threat. When you are an occupying force you are bound to find a few enemies.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by patrickaljord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:13PM (#5929968)
> stop supporting the abusive policies of Israel

Really? You had to drag Israel into that? You're aware that the only "abuse" Arabs are actually angry about is the fact that Israel exists at all? I'm an Arab so let me tell you, any stupidity that is committed in the West Bank is overblown by Arabs to delegitimate Israel which is part of Arabs quest to get rid of Israel altogether. They consider the whole of Israel to be occupied territory, this is why whether Israel keeps on building in the West Bank or not is meaningless for peace. They would have to stop building everywhere in Israel, pack up and go somewhere else to end the conflict. This is why many in Israel see the West Bank settlement as a secondary issue when it comes to bringing real peace although they are aware that it's bad for their image...

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:35PM (#5930044)
There needs to be more good faith from both sides; until then it will be quite a mess. As a stable functioning democracy, the Israeli people really should decide to stop the settlements even though that won't bring about peace: it does them no real good while merely agitating an already volatile situation. The Palestinians (including Gaza and Hezbollah) should also develop their government into something not dysfunctional, and should recognize Israel's right to exist. Then we could move on to the next step, but they must start with baby steps.

America can't just exit from this or other worldwide situation. Isolationism will only make things worse. Ya, we do make mistakes and we could do better, but just disappearing won't bring about any meaningful peace. We can argue all day if its worse for civilians to be killed by drones or the Taliban, but they are still dead.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:37PM (#5930246)
The US can't prevent regional conflicts. Getting involved just helps them to spiral out of control and simultaneously puts America's own neck on the line.

If there were actually a situation where a so-called adversary presented a legitimate threat to the US if left alone, it might be a different debate, but that hasn't been the case for many years. None of the states that the US is currently fighting in could hope to threaten it militarily in their wildest dreams. Iran, for example, which we are supposed to be so frightened of, has 1/45th the gdp and roughy 1/100th the military budget of the US.

The US could cut its military budget by half and go into full defensive mode and still be completely untouchable by state actors, while removing the primary motivation for non-state attacks. True, the taliban might still kill people, just as plenty of regimes that the US supports like Saudi Arabia and Bahrain kill those it opposes. The US can't fix the world. It has enough problems of its own to worry about.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by Tloewald on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:53PM (#5930708)
The US could cut its military budget by more than half and not have to even become less offensive. It might need to stop building weapon systems to win a war against the Soviet Union though.

Setting aside the tanks that are built solely to keep congressmen in office, consider US carrier groups — around which the entire US surface fleet is built — it's an open scandal that military exercises with allies frequently result in US carriers being taken out by diesel subs and cruise missiles, but rather than realize that the carrier group is now just as obsolete as the battleship flotilla, the rules of the game get changed. It's like the Japanese planning for Midway all over again (where naval cadets did exactly what the US did and annihilated the Japanese forces so they changed the rules and ran the simulation again).

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by sneak on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:37PM (#5930250)
> We can argue all day if its worse for civilians to be killed by drones or the Taliban, but they are still dead.

Except in one situation it's not "us" killing them. Or our tax dollars paying for the flying killer robots that do the job.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:11PM (#5930588)
The killer robots are inevitable, at least they are an improvement on the more imprecise F-22 airstrikes (we now have precision to make real mistakes, before mistakes were inevitable because we lacked precision). On the other hand, we are just a few steps away from SkyNet.

But the issue is should we be in Pakistan, Afghanistan, or Iraq at all, or just let those countries go to hell by themselves? Civilians die either way given that peace is elusive. If you visit these countries, perhaps your perspectives shifts from "we should get out" to "we should at least try and do something!" Morality goes both ways.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by sneak on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:53AM (#5938406)
Sure, but "at least try and do something" seems to always result in the US military killing tens or hundreds of thousands of people.

I'm not saying isolationism/non-interventionism is the best way, but the US doesn't seem to be able to follow up "let's do something" with anything other than a big remote-controlled radar-invisible flying death party.

How about no.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by olalonde on Sunday June 23, 2013 @11:02PM (#5930742)
> Isolationism will only make things worse.

You are misusing "isolationism" here. The word you are looking for is "non-interventionism". What OP was suggesting was that the US should "stop supporting the abusive policies of Israel", not stop all trade, travel, etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isolationism

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by rbanffy on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:32PM (#5930037)
danenania's point remains valid if the Israel part is omitted.

I grew up under a military dictatorship endorsed by the US and I can tell you there are still lots of people very resentful of that support. Reducing foreign intervention is the cheapest way to demotivate potential terrorists.

Unfortunately, doing so now would risk making them believe they won something.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by ars on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:18PM (#5930188)
> danenania's point remains valid if the Israel part is omitted.

You mean "only if". The Muslims who hate Jews (and via extension Israel), are happy to hate America without any help from America's policies.

It makes no difference what Israel does - they will hate Jews and Israel without reservations and without end. The only thing Israel can do is make them scared, which will hopefully keep their hate in theory and not in practice.

Danenania: Are you really naive enough to believe that if Israel makes "peace", and/or gives up land it will help? Israel made peace with Egypt, and gave up tons of land - but the people there still hate Israel and wish for its destruction.

Israel made peace with Jordan and gave up land and water - but the people of Jordan still hate Israel.

You really think it's America's policies that cause the hate? It's not. It's what America stands for - primarily freedom of religion, and the acceptance of secularism.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:54PM (#5930308)
Regardless of one's perspective on the Israel-Palestine conflict, the fact remains that providing extensive military support to a nation that is a symbol of oppression in the region greatly increases the risk of terrorist attacks against the US. Save for a tiny elite, there is no corresponding benefit for the American people that justifies this risk, while the costs are many.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by ars on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:12PM (#5930382)
You mean a symbol of freedom not oppression.

I am aware of how jealous the Arabs are of Israel, and how they wish they could also have those freedoms. It's of course part of the reason that the Arab administrations demonize Israel so much - so that their own people don't complain about their own countries.

But that's exactly why the US should support them so strongly, this is what America was founded on. Even if there is no benefit.

> greatly increases the risk of terrorist attacks against the US.

No it doesn't. America is also a symbol of freedom, just like Israel and they hate America just fine, even without mentioning Israel.

But you are wrong about the benefits though, just for the consumer an enormous amount of technology comes out of Israel. And for America to turn away from Israel would be the same as renouncing the principles America was founded on. I hope to never see a day when America doesn't at least try to uphold these values (even if the actions aren't what they should, at least the ideal is there).

I'm sure you've head the saying about trading security for liberty. And the same is true for ideals. Sometimes you have to fight for your ideals. Even if there is a cost. The downsides of having no ideals at all is just not worth it.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:37PM (#5930052)
That would only demotivate terrorists against us. They still have plenty of other targets. I don't see how isolationism for the states will actually make the world better. We tried it before, it didn't work.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by rbanffy on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:51PM (#5930538)
> They still have plenty of other targets.

As long as they are internal affairs, it's their problem. If the problems cross borders, there are international organizations with proper authority do deal with them.

When one country decides to make a military intervention, the international bodies are further weakened.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by ars on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:14PM (#5930595)
> international organizations with proper authority do deal with them.

Are you kidding? The UN has no authority unless given to it by the country involved, which of course they won't. (Example: Syria and chemical weapons.)

Plus the UN lost most of it's moral authority by allowing jokes like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Commission_on_Hu... to exist for years.

It's cute how they tried to fix it by starting a new council to replace it (instead of simply fixing it) - and the new council appears to be "the UN council to criticize Israel and ignore everyone else".

The UN is a joke. They are not weakened by country's military intervention, they are weakened because they have no legitimacy in anyone's eyes because of their own policies.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:01PM (#5930564)
What international police force with proper authority are you talking about? NATO? The UN? I think most of the world is actually against a world-wide police force with any real authority.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by D9u on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:18PM (#5930189)
Isolationism and non intervention are two divergent ideals...
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by glurgh on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:30PM (#5929560)
That's about as practical as asking people to kindly stop flying planes into buildings or blowing up buildings with day-care centers in them.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:48PM (#5929657)
It may sound crazy to you, but yes you do actually stand a greater chance of making peace with enemies and therefore reducing attacks from them if you stop shooting at them and bombing them and ask them kindly why they are flying planes into your buildings and then make a good faith effort to address those issues.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by glurgh on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:03PM (#5929711)
You're right, it sounds completely crazy to me. Nobody really bombed or shot Timothy McVeigh. Or the RAF. Or the Brigate Rosse. They did all their shooting and bombing all by themselves, at the cost of hundreds upon hundreds of innocent lives. It's not that the questions of causes or morality of our own actions are illegitimate - they aren't. The idea that we're going to practically stop amoral nutjobs by just being ever so much nicer seems based on nothing but wishful thinking, though.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by foxylad on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:30PM (#5930639)
I think the point is that you can't stop the amoral nutjobs (awesome term BTW!) by killing them (and their family and friends) either, because that just embitters another generation. Your examples actually illustrate this perfectly - Timothy McVeigh justified his murdering in revenge for the murdering done at Waco; and both the RAF and Brigate Rosse were driven partly by the injustice of former Nazis (those nutjobs really took their amorality seriously!) returning to power. I accept that there are psychopaths who murder for no reason, but luckily for our species they are very rare. All the killing discussed above was triggered by severe injustice including murder - revenge. Our civilised societies are practically defined by their rejection of revenge as a reason for anything, replacing it with either rehabilitation or prevention. "An eye for an eye" is the mark of a primitive society (or person) that doesn't understand positive feedback loops.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by jicksta2 on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:15PM (#5929758)
Evolving beyond being amoral nutjobs ourselves is the first step to eliminating amoral nutjobbery elsewhere. There's a lot of extra work that needs to be done on top of that, such as good-faith social programs to help their society recover, etc.
[deleted]
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by tankenmate on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:12PM (#5929744)
Some people when oppressed, rightly or wrongly, feel that they are powerless to resolve their grievances, real or perceived, within the social norms around them, lash out. Some are better at lashing out than others.

The most dangerous person in the room is the one with nothing to lose. One way, quite possibly not the only way, to stop them being so dangerous is to give them something of worth, then they'll have something to lose. Social security, good healthcare, foreign aid, and taxes do serve some purpose for the greater good.

There is justice and pragmatism, the best solutions solve both.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by jes on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:11PM (#5929742)
What do you recommend when dealing with an enemy that isn't interested in your good-faith efforts?
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:38PM (#5930057)
Well, the Europeans would just send diplomats around until they could conveniently forget about the problems, as usual.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:24PM (#5929802)
Then you look at other options. But in this case a good faith effort could resolve the problem very quickly. The people attacking the US aren't really asking for that much. They just want the US to stop sponsoring violence and tyranny in their region.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by lttlrck on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:01PM (#5929935)
Unless 'other options' encompasses some yet undiscovered diplomacy tack it would escalate back to the status quo pretty damn quick.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by wslh on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:34PM (#5929585)
I don't think the solution is trivial. There are cases of terrorism that have nothing to do with foreign wars.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by Ihmahr on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:36PM (#5929599)
Perhaps, but what if those billions were spend on safer cars or medical advancement? Surely those billions could save a whole lot more lives than by terrorizing the rest of the world.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:41PM (#5929617)
So the way to deal with those outlying cases is to start wars and cause widespread violence that will generate 1000x more terrorism?
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by wslh on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:46PM (#5929639)
I am not saying that and don't want to enter into an infinite discussion about terrorism.

Just saying that the problem is complex. I don't live in US and my country was attacked twice, a hundred people killed, in the last 20 years.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:00PM (#5929697)
Well, the US has had 3k or so killed in the past 15 years. In response it killed hundreds of thousands and caused widespread devastation and misery in several foreign wars.

These wars created multiple large transnational extremist anti-US movements that now have advanced military equipment, are skilled veterans of war, and are spreading their influence to neighboring countries.

Not a great trade.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by wslh on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:08PM (#5929731)
My country was not involved in attacking other countries.

Imagine if a crazy guy in my country uses our nuclear capabilities as an answer? can I justify them?

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by TeMPOraL on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:41PM (#5929871)
No. But would you justify your government if it were to preemptively invade the crazy guy's homeland to stop him from potentially doing something bad?
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by wslh on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:58PM (#5929925)
Never said that. The main point of the thread is if there is a simple way to reduce terrorism or not.

Remember that Salman Rushdie didn't invade any country.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by PavlovsCat on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:45PM (#5929636)
From the perspective of people who peddle weapons and fear to those who have to pay for the weapons and act on the fear, yes. That is exactly the correct response.
[deleted]
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:52PM (#5929665)
Yeah, that's not exactly leading edge psychology. It's pretty well known. How does that invalidate my conclusions?