News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:35PM (#5930044)
There needs to be more good faith from both sides; until then it will be quite a mess. As a stable functioning democracy, the Israeli people really should decide to stop the settlements even though that won't bring about peace: it does them no real good while merely agitating an already volatile situation. The Palestinians (including Gaza and Hezbollah) should also develop their government into something not dysfunctional, and should recognize Israel's right to exist. Then we could move on to the next step, but they must start with baby steps.

America can't just exit from this or other worldwide situation. Isolationism will only make things worse. Ya, we do make mistakes and we could do better, but just disappearing won't bring about any meaningful peace. We can argue all day if its worse for civilians to be killed by drones or the Taliban, but they are still dead.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:37PM (#5930246)
The US can't prevent regional conflicts. Getting involved just helps them to spiral out of control and simultaneously puts America's own neck on the line.

If there were actually a situation where a so-called adversary presented a legitimate threat to the US if left alone, it might be a different debate, but that hasn't been the case for many years. None of the states that the US is currently fighting in could hope to threaten it militarily in their wildest dreams. Iran, for example, which we are supposed to be so frightened of, has 1/45th the gdp and roughy 1/100th the military budget of the US.

The US could cut its military budget by half and go into full defensive mode and still be completely untouchable by state actors, while removing the primary motivation for non-state attacks. True, the taliban might still kill people, just as plenty of regimes that the US supports like Saudi Arabia and Bahrain kill those it opposes. The US can't fix the world. It has enough problems of its own to worry about.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by Tloewald on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:53PM (#5930708)
The US could cut its military budget by more than half and not have to even become less offensive. It might need to stop building weapon systems to win a war against the Soviet Union though.

Setting aside the tanks that are built solely to keep congressmen in office, consider US carrier groups — around which the entire US surface fleet is built — it's an open scandal that military exercises with allies frequently result in US carriers being taken out by diesel subs and cruise missiles, but rather than realize that the carrier group is now just as obsolete as the battleship flotilla, the rules of the game get changed. It's like the Japanese planning for Midway all over again (where naval cadets did exactly what the US did and annihilated the Japanese forces so they changed the rules and ran the simulation again).

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by sneak on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:37PM (#5930250)
> We can argue all day if its worse for civilians to be killed by drones or the Taliban, but they are still dead.

Except in one situation it's not "us" killing them. Or our tax dollars paying for the flying killer robots that do the job.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:11PM (#5930588)
The killer robots are inevitable, at least they are an improvement on the more imprecise F-22 airstrikes (we now have precision to make real mistakes, before mistakes were inevitable because we lacked precision). On the other hand, we are just a few steps away from SkyNet.

But the issue is should we be in Pakistan, Afghanistan, or Iraq at all, or just let those countries go to hell by themselves? Civilians die either way given that peace is elusive. If you visit these countries, perhaps your perspectives shifts from "we should get out" to "we should at least try and do something!" Morality goes both ways.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by sneak on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:53AM (#5938406)
Sure, but "at least try and do something" seems to always result in the US military killing tens or hundreds of thousands of people.

I'm not saying isolationism/non-interventionism is the best way, but the US doesn't seem to be able to follow up "let's do something" with anything other than a big remote-controlled radar-invisible flying death party.

How about no.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by olalonde on Sunday June 23, 2013 @11:02PM (#5930742)
> Isolationism will only make things worse.

You are misusing "isolationism" here. The word you are looking for is "non-interventionism". What OP was suggesting was that the US should "stop supporting the abusive policies of Israel", not stop all trade, travel, etc.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isolationism